Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

plloyd NC — Sun, 30 Dec 2007 18:47:17 GMT

Well written with depth of the people problems.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

wayne barker, elkhart, IN — Sun, 30 Dec 2007 19:20:58 GMT

Lets hope calm heads prevail. There is enough sorrow in this world, without bloodshed.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Richard Clepper — Sun, 30 Dec 2007 19:31:27 GMT

Many have reported on Benazir Bhutto being assassinated by a "suicide bomber". Should news media rather use the term "homicide bomber"? A suicide bomber would have blown himself (herself) up in the desert without killing anyone else. Bhutto was, unfortunately, killed by someone intent on taking her life and as many others as possible. Hardly suicide.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Akber A. Kassam, New-York City, New York. — Sun, 30 Dec 2007 19:41:13 GMT

Young and glamorous Ms. Benazir Bhutto, she successfuly portrayed herself as a refreshing contrast to the overwhelmingly male-dominated political estsblishment. I extend my heartfelt condolences to her family, friends and her party PPP. We pray to Almighty God to place her soul in high abode and grant her family solace to sustain this great loss.!!!!

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Peter Dunkerley, North Berwick ME — Sun, 30 Dec 2007 20:52:18 GMT

Sadness, obviously, for the tragic loss off such a strong political leader. She championed freedom and democracy in a very tough theater. One day, a hug and a "thank you" in response to a sarcastic "enjoy your visit to Pakistan.", will be enough to ease any tensions of that imediate situation. Am I a dreamer? Yes, I guess I am. More sad, is that in this "developed" state that the human race is in, we still have factions who believe force is the way to get a point made.I support miltary action where it is needed to stop oppresion and terrorism, but do not support force just to make a point. I condem the killing of Benzir Bhutto. And I appluad "Fakhar simply walked out of our car toward them, and in a few minutes came back unfazed. He had asked them to please stop throwing rocks and let us pass. They politely nodded as we drove on by." Clearly, people dont enjoy hurting one another. Clearly, those who do enjoy hurting another human being, are sick with hatred. I believe that world peace must begin at the individual level, and by that i mean that we, as individuals, must find peace in our own hearts and souls, before we can spread that peace unto our fellow human beings. We are indeed one race, the Human race, and we have got to start treating each other with respect, at the very least. Peace is a flower that will grow if nurtured, but it MUST be nurtured.
brightess blessings to my fellow beings on this small part of the creators map, Peter

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Mark St Denis — Sun, 30 Dec 2007 21:42:24 GMT

From the count of numbers on this blog, no body really cares about your article. You as a journalist are typical of the masses of psudeo-journalists. Were is the real story?

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Sharon,Seattle,Washington — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 00:20:05 GMT

I understand that the people of Pakistan are highly disturbed and angry at the horrific murder of Benazir Bhutto,however there is no need to consort to such violence on the streets.We personally find it absolutely undignified and tribal.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Lloyd Johnson Corning Ca. — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 00:51:18 GMT

To bad she should have been more carefull and had more security.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Abdul Khan — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 01:43:02 GMT

While I would like to give my condolences to the people of Pakistan for the loss of their political leader, I have some questions to bloggers from Pakistan. a)Was Benazir Begum really interested in restoring democracy in Pakistan or continuing with the family dynasty? b)Is Musharraf that bad? c)What bothers me is that 3 days after Benazir was assasinated, her 19 year old son was appointed as the Chairman of her party and her husband Mr.10% as Co Chairman. It gives us the westerners an impression that her husband is trying to make more bucks out of the image of his departed wife.

May be I am wrong. I would really like to hear from some outspoken Pakistanis.

Thank you

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

norm Blaisdell, zhengzhou China — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 01:53:22 GMT

sad but onder just how the people in this region will continue to live. It's hhard to believe that a potential leader will be assassinated but do think Bhutto knew this might take place. The question as to why the residents continue to be so violent.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Lisa McNeil,Alpharetta,Georgia — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 02:37:16 GMT

Dear Michelle, This region is certainly a troubled and tumultuous place and the people have been struggling to survive everyday for years and years. The people who were avid supporters of Bhutto feel a great loss because of her assassination and many just appear lost. The pictures you took show people who are mourning a leader who they felt could have helped Pakistan towards democracy and peace. I think the scene you described in Liaquat Park where the older men are praying and then one by one more people joined them was very sorrowful,yet with no violence occurring around them. I agree with your statement in this posting that "Most of Pakistan is not raging in the streets, but waiting, and watching. Worrying, and mourning." Time is so very precious to these people in this delicate process towards finding a leader for their country and making a peaceful nation. Very interesting posting Michelle. Peace to all.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Jane Doe — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 02:53:38 GMT

Why isn't anyone (including this media) commenting on the November 2, 2007 David Frost interview with Bhutto where she states that Osama Bin Laden was murdered? The David Frost video is posted on youtube:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_sxxv_R4uJ0

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Alfred Cushman — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 03:29:56 GMT

Now, here's the real story, "Where are the Nukes", let the Real War Games begin.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Hala Hashmi, Abu Dhabi, UAE — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 03:49:33 GMT

Well it is really sad to hear about Benazir Bhutto. Above all she was a mother and that's what i am more concerned. As far as democracy is concerned i do agree with Mr. Abdul Khan...i dont think so there would have been some change in the country as far as corruption is concerned...becoz we are aware of what her party has done previously. may God bless her soul. This is not the way...no one has right to kill other person....but now i have started beleiving...we have to pay for our deeds!!

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Connie Nawaz Waukesha WI USA — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 04:01:12 GMT

I am glad for once that the comments are not negative today. I was online last night and had some jerk that kept attacking me for saying that not all Muslims are violent. With that said, I am still mourning the death of Bhutto. I read a very angry blog on another news site by a Muslim woman that was bashing Bhutto really bad. While I will not say who I support(not Musharraf though), I think that just as the simple fact that Bhutto was human just like the rest of us. This girl that was attacking her was colloege educated and you would think she would have the common sense and enough respect for the recently murdered not to bash her so soon.

As for the question earlier, while I am not Pakistani, my husband and family are. They are currently in Rawalpindi and while I am a little more at ease, I still have not been able to sleep. And yes, Musharraf is that bad. I have been online for almost 4 nights and days now since I don't sleep and have been following link after link until I havreached many Pakistani sites. The general feeling is that Bhutto was their only hope at a democracy. Most of these boggers are young men who are trying to exspose the horrors that Musharraf is putting them through. I will give the link to my blog site, on there is a link to one of these sites that has blogs upon blogs and a 24 minute video clip on all the missing,torchered, and even killing of innocent citizens of that country. That is one reason I feel so worrysome about my family over there. It truly made me cry and I don't cry EVER. Let me explain why I do not tend to cry, I have been through much in my 34 years, as I was with a man who tried killing me almost every day. And yes, I could have left but I have two boys who were very young, babies then and no shelters had any room. So I had no choice. All of my so called "family" here would not let us stay with them. I even got so fed up with being beaten every day that I stayed in an abandoned house for a while in the middle of a very cold winter (I'm from Milwaukee WI). But yet, anything I have gone through does not compare with what the Pakistanis are going through. If you do watch the clip, you will see a 16 year old boy get ripped away from his mother and sister, only because he wanted his dad back. His father is a journalist and he was only reporting the truth. This boy was getting hit by the police, and thrown into the back of the police vehicle while they called him a spoiled brat. Oh, and the police, as far as I know locked him right up just like they did with his dad. All the while his mother and sister were pleading with them just to let him go. Then at the end, it shows the names of the known missing, I think it was a humdred at least. And that's just the ones that people have realized they were missing, there was probably many more.

I did happen to come across an online petition in Bhutto's name that is going to be forwarded to Musharraf to end the violence. But for the life of me, I can't remember how I found it. Check on my site if you are interested in signing it, as I know it might not be much but at least it's a step in the right direction. I really don't know what to think about the whole her son getting put in charge thing, but I really don't think anybody in their party knows just what to do. And she did name her husband to gain control in her will, but he turned over control to their son.

I hope whatever you do, you at least check on my site for the Pakistani site and see just how terrible things are over there. I'm just glad that I have daily phone converstaions with my family there or I don't know what I'd do. All I know is I am praying constantly for the people of Pakistan and hope God above will put an end to it. The link is: http://cnawaz.blogspot.com and I also have another link but it doesn't have any links on it yet as I am in the process of building it up. It is: myspace.com/spybabe26
Well, enough outta me, thank you for reading this.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Connie Nawaz Waukesha WI USA — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 04:05:16 GMT

Check out my site http://cnawaz.blogspot.com it has a link to a Pakistani site that also has a very horrifying video clip on it that shows the injuststices they go through.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

ayeda — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 04:55:51 GMT

though we are tired and sick of games that are being played here in pakistan, but still we are hopeful that things would get better as they have always been. the players might play at their best but there is end to everything, is nt it?
i dont know about mr. 10% or 20% but it IS not wise to give bilawal a heavy responsibility at such an age. better to let him pay attention to his studies. such kind of actions have made our country a laughing stock in world. benazir is gone, no amends could be made better than to keep the dignity intact of the party and country as well.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Seid Amedie, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 05:03:15 GMT

My heartfelt condolences to the people of Pakistan for the tragic death of Benazir Bhutto. I wonder if the Muslim world would have a highly educated, secular woman Prime Minsiter again. The message is clear: a Muslim woman needs to know her role in society.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Mary — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 05:21:16 GMT

Thanks for the blog and the various comments. In one way it is very telling how the ordinary people cope with such political assasinations and unpredictablity. But this is no ordinary uncertainity. This time decisions PPP makes, and Musharaff makes (or his government), and the rest of Pakistan could make or break Pakistan. Is Pakistan the next Sudan - civil war, chaos, crisis after crisis? The international community must be vigilant and press on with the assasination investigation and better multi party electoral system. This is no joking matter - it is not just something for the late night news junkies! This is very very serious!

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Mel B. from onalaska WA — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 06:56:32 GMT

I wish that Benazir Bhutto rises to the esteem of a saint and that we can put this behind us...may she have eternal bliss and happiness in peace and that we shall learn from this tradgedy.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

NRecabo, Miami,Florida — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 07:39:50 GMT

I do not know much about the life of Ms. Bhutto prior to her death. However, one's life takes on a more significant meaning and prominence after a tragic death. I, along with the world, and the people of Pakistan mourn her loss. To her supporters, I am very sorry that you lost such a formidable leader who was willing to risk all for what she considered her mission to save Pakistan. To those who did not support her, can I candidly say, "well, you got what you wished for."
She was a Muslim woman who made a difference in a world where men supposedly know better with unyielding bravadura under the guise of religious fanaticism and tradition. She paved the way for many women to find the courage from within themselves to speak up when atrocities are being 'heaped' upon them, influencing them to not be afraid.
As I continue to learn about her these past few days, I am deeply saddened that she is no longer with us for she was the consummate woman, mother, wife, leader who transcended beyond expected gender roles in a country where women are seen but not heard.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Niel Josef — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 10:39:52 GMT

Democracy in countries like India,Pakistan,Bangladesh and Shri Lanka is on piece of paper.Muslim extrimists are running Pakistani Government and Hindu fundamentalists are in charge of Indian Government.
Poor and working class people are always undermined and exploited by so called high class mafias.Their basic rights are violated and live miserable life under this mob sponsored so called democratic countries.
Benzir Bhutto's death was unfortunate,but there are always Harward and Cambridge graduates available to run the well established family business that we westners fail to understand.

Niel Josef

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Steve R Boston, MA — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 10:45:21 GMT

A very terrible loss; for the People of Pakistan, People everywhere who hope for fairness, peace and free government and the World's governments.

We can all hope; each in our own way that the People of Pakistan will take their grief and find hope that will lead them to better lives and more just government.

Ms. Bhutto would have wanted her life to bring better days for the People; she would have demanded of herself that peaceful progress and better government be the goals.

I pray that the People of Pakistan forego their deserved anger and outrage and find their way to go forward to a peaceful better government.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Niel Josef — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 10:45:32 GMT

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Fazal — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 11:15:45 GMT

What had really happened to the Daughter of the east, the two times Lady Prime Minister of Islamic Republic of Pakistan, the Oxford and Harvard graduate. It was the most cowardly act that was carried out on her life. Those who had commited must be brought to justice, now that government knows who the bad guys are. She had taken steps so courageously and stops the madness of the current government's Emergency rule. Not even a single Male politician had the guts to put thier life on the line like her in Pakistan.
Especially, those who talked so badly about her corruption charges, please I have question for them, Give me the name of any Non Corrupted Leader. It is so easy to make Good person into evil down there. It is very hard to find the truth and what to believe. As far as Corruption goes, in Pakistan existed since the Assination of First Prime Minister Liaqat Ali Khan in Liaqat garden. The same Liaqat garden, now Pakistan's most favourable Lady former Prime Minister of Pakistan brutally assinated. It was the DARKEST DAY in the HISTORY of PAKISTAN. The people of Pakistan must take charge NOW, what she stood for THE ESTABLISHMENT OF DEMOCRATIC INSTITUTION IN PAKISTAN. Pakistan is deeply wounded and devasted with such a collasel loss of a GREAT LEADER.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Atomic Curry — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 13:34:41 GMT

A rapidly destabilising Pakistan must mean an increasingly insecure India. Two hot-head nations with nukes and no real mature systems to failsafe them....seriously scary.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Keith varden langley va — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 13:43:42 GMT

Its too bad that this country cannot accept an elected leader, and its very sad to think her son is the next to run. I sincerly hope that much more security considerations are taken with him! do the people as a whole, not realize that they truely would be better off with an elected govt?

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Dennis McCarthy, Marietta, Georgia — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 14:19:06 GMT

It amazes me how, if one truly understands the Koran, and Sharia, as the Prophet intended it to be understood, that a True Believer can take the life of another, who does not threaten him or his family, in such a senseless way. Also, how can True Believers grow the poppy and profit from the drug trade when they know the destruction it causes to the lives of others. What is going on is not Islam defending itself, it is all about power...a few corrupt individuals wanting power over the many, and, unfortunately, money. What amazes me is the way that learned Imams condone this.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

T. Hamilton Durango, Colorado — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 14:33:09 GMT

I find it amazing that we in the west are so shocked at, not only the assassination of Bhutto (who embarked upon a suicide mission driven by ego and avarice) but, by the response to that act of violence by an outpouring of more of the same. In Islam ( an absolutely savage and barbaric cult) revenge is not only important but commanded by the Koran. Violence, terror, misogyny, and death are the currency of Islam and its adherants. Bhutto is just another victim of a maliganat cancer that is spreading across the globe. Ignore it at your own peril.
T. Hamilton
Colorado

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Junaid, Dubai — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 14:47:22 GMT

Benazir the chain of four provinces, we lost benazir we lost the chain

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Philip F. Gallagher, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 15:26:22 GMT

Writing from Brazil. Most of the people here don´´t have any idea as to who was Ms. Bhutto or what she represented. Those who are up to date with the world
news know that she represented a hope of peace in a very troubled country, a country that has not seen peace since it´s founding more than 50 years ago. May God enlighten Pakistan´s people to realize that
violence does not accomplish anything as war does not
either. It all is a game of power. God have mercy on us all.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Concerned Citizen — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 15:48:18 GMT

What is wrong with people? We have recorded history going back almost 10,000 years at this point (I'm referring to the Sumarian's) and when something major happens to a community, it's almost always the same response. People loot, burn, pillage, and plunder. It doesn't matter whether it's Pakistan with Bhutto's assassination or racial trouble in LA.
What exactly do people think gives them the right to destroy property and lives that doesn't belong to them?

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

John Scully, Dublin, Ireland. — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 15:50:08 GMT

The problem in Pakistan seems to be the government headed by Musharraf. If he could be got rid of I'm sure the country would be much safer. It was a shame to allow such a good person like Ms Bhutto to lose her life. Bush didn't help Pakistan either by invaded two independent countries and it shows that violence does work. He should never have been allowed to use Pakistan to get at those countries.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Alam, Lahore. — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 16:07:31 GMT

I did like Ms.Benazir but not her hubby. I think his corrpution led to her downfall when she was the Prime Minister of Pakistan. The son is still very young and I do not think that this was a good nomination. Mr. Aitzaz Ahsan was an other good consideration for the party leader. Mr Fahim is so so.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Don Sebo — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 17:26:34 GMT

The death of Benzir Bhutto while tragic was inevitable. She was a remarkable and Charasmatic leader but she was stuck between western political interests and a country mired in traditional religious values that have little regard for women in powerful positions. This woman will serve as a martyr to the desire of many to bring about social and political change in Pakistan and the region but but the status quo will likely remain in effect long after her death is but a distant memory. Musharaf is but one in a long line of leaders with neither the intelligence or the resolve to make real progress preferring to rob the country's poor of their right to live a decent life dooming them to a life of misery and poverty. Though well-meaning, Bhutto probably wouldn't have done much better.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Fawad Ali - Atlanta — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 17:49:39 GMT

Shock, was my initial reaction. But the more I thought of it, the more I realized that the shock was over the killing of a prominent figure in broad daylight where the entire horrific episode was caught on camera. Looking at the broader picture, it’s history repeating itself. Bhutto was not the first political leader to be assassinated in the short history of Pakistan. The first prime minister was assassinated at exactly the same place, Bhutto's father was sentenced to death by a military tribunal in the seventies, the general that took over was himself killed in a plane crash in the 80's and the list goes on.
It is true that Pakistan in "its short modern history, has never seen a democratically elected head of state serve out his or her full term." Its political history has been a series of military dictatorships and corrupt civilian governments. But is democratically elected civilian government, no matter how incompetent and corrupt, better than a military dictatorship? Sadly in the context of Pakistan, the answer is not simple. I was never a supporter of Bhutto's party; not because of her, but because of other party members, especially her husband. He is one of the most corrupt individuals in Pakistan's political scene.
One of the blogger’s wrote, "Is Musharaf that bad?" Probably not, but the precedence he set is. Do ends justify the means? I say, No. Is he a better statesman than the rest of the political leaders? Probably not? Is he less corrupt than the rest of the political leaders? Maybe at the beginning, but now I am not so sure. Absolute power corrupts absolutely. There is a saying in Urdu that loosely translates, "In the land of the blind, one eyed man is king."
The violence in the aftermath of the assassination is another reflection of the turmoil at an individual level. Is the rage only the reaction to the killing of their leader, or does it involve general frustration over economic hardships, social injustice or just plain illiteracy? Civilized nations, whose people have the foresight to evaluate the results of their actions, who see the broader picture and just exhibit common courtesy do not react this way. But I am being unfair. Most of the populous are decent hard working people. It is just a small minority that does not realize that the best way to honor their slain leader is to continue the work she was doing.

Apologies for the long post!

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Muslima in Cleveland — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 18:29:41 GMT

Most Americans are ignorant of Pakistan's political past [as was I at one point], so there are a number of things that should be pointed out before anyone makes a sweeping judgement about the tragedy of Benazir Bhutto's assassination.

Yes, it was a tragedy - as any murder is. The murder of Ms. Bhutto, members of her security detail, and people in the crowd surrounding her were senseless and horrific. But tragedy as far as the death of democracy in Pakistan? Tragedy as far as the death of a great leader? Tragedy as far as the death of a champion of human rights, of women's rights? No...

The media have portrayed Benazir Bhutto as "the only popularly elected leader Pakistan has ever known." Not true. In a system not unlike our own electoral college, she was elected Prime Minister by the legislature that was packed with her party members. The population of Pakistan did not select her to lead the country.

Her administrations were two of the most corrupt in Pakistan's history - and that is saying something. Both of her terms in office were rife with charges of corruption and money laundering. During her first term [1988-1990], millions of dollars were stripped from the public education fund and put into personal accounts. Thousands of "ghost schools" were established - schools that only existed on paper, with the money for books and salaries going into the pockets of Ms. Bhutto, her husband and her top officials. This bankrupting of Pakistan's public education system opened the door to privately funded Madrassas, many of which are nothing but thinly-disguised recruiting centers for terrorists.

During her second term [1993-1996], the Taliban gained ascendancy in Afghanistan with her approval. Her administration provided military and financial support for the Taliban, and was instrumental in their victory in Kabul in September of 1996, which gave the Taliban almost complete control of Afghanistan.

She is hailed in the Western media as a symbol of what women can be in a democratic Islamic state. However, during her terms in office, nothing was done to better the plight of women in Pakistan. At the end of her term[s], as at the beginning, there were still laws on the books requiring a woman to produce four male witnesses before she could bring charges of rape [if not, SHE would be jailed], a woman was still considered the property of her male relatives, and a woman could not file for divorce. [NOTE - These are not Islamic laws, they are tribal laws]. During over five years [total] in office, she did nothing to improve the lives of the women of Pakistan.

Much as also been said about her triumphant "return from exile", but very little has been said about the fact that the exile was voluntary. She could have returned to Pakistan at any time she wanted, as long as she addressed the charges of corruption, and repaid the laundered $11 million that the Swiss judicial system had determined she and her husband had stolen from the Pakistani people.

Her death was tragic, as any murder is. But she was not "the last, greatest hope for a democratic Pakistan" - she was another link in a corrupt tribal chain of command, a legacy that has now apparently been passed on to her son. From corrupt father, to corrupt daughter, to corruptable son - this is not democracy, this is a dynasty. And not a very good one at that.

Please, learn the facts before forming opinions. Read, learn, ask - do not just take what the media says at face value.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Curtis, Columbia, MD — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 18:36:16 GMT

The problem is that the U.S. needs to stay out of the affairs and beliefs of other nations. Whatever happened to when in Rome do as the Romans do? The United States should honor other people’s beliefs and cultures without interfering by trying to insert puppet governments for self fulfilling purposes. Bhutto is a victim of U.S. manipulation on false beliefs of democracy. It's sad that Bhutto died for the beliefs of people who don't even care about a segment of their own population. As long as Pakistan secures its nuclear arsenal and has control over its population, I don't care what system of governance they select for themselves. If someone doesn't want to live there, then let them immigrate to the U.S. or any other country that doesn't agree with Pakistan.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Patrick — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 18:42:32 GMT

I have read alot about Benzir Bhutto's death.
I don't think they should worry about who killed
her,because no one will really know what group
is responsible. It is a horrible thing to have happen
to anybody and i hope they can get passed there anger.
I think they have a great country that is try it's best to go forward with a better future. :) Cya

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Javid — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 20:18:40 GMT

Why are the Pakistani people so ignorant, unethical and animal like, savage like as portrayed after the death of Bhutto. These people wanted someone with a corruption and murderous background to be their leader and run the county?? These people are sick and need to be rooted out of civil society and brought to justice and given the respective punishment of death. So many innocent people have died and will contnue to die if the government does not stop this virus from spreading. Our founding fathers and so many innocent people died for this country.. for what portral of this barbarism and looting of the innocent people.. destroy the limited resources Pakistan has..They have brought nothing but shame and embarrassement to the country. These people need to be corraled and rooted out of the Pakistani society.....All Pakstani should be ashamed of how they are viewed by the rest of the world.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Javid — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 20:37:27 GMT

Bhutto was no leader.. She brought nothing but same and embarrassment to the country and said the right things to woo the western countries to rally behind her. She would have been bad for the country. Whatever has happened has happened for a reason and better of the country. Westerners really dont know anything about her except what the media portrays her as. and we know how the media is.. Now they have elected her 19 old son to be the leader of the party and lead the country.. what kind of sick people are these and the question is, is that for the better of the country or the interest of a select group of people.. Pakistanis Wake up for god sake and realize what shame and embarrassement you people have brought to your country!!!!!

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Angel, VA — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 21:00:34 GMT

Sorry, but it was written all over the wall, ans she knew it. It was obvious, since she went back to Pakistan, that she was not going to make it. Why she continued to go at it? It is hard to say, but her end of days was crystal clear.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Joe — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 21:31:06 GMT

I have to say that they are a bunch of hot heads. Look at how many of our leaders have been murdered over the years and yet we remain calm. Is this because we are more civilized? This should be a time for them to unite. Not riot. Grow up Middle East. The time has come to get with it.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

james Overland Park Ks. — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 21:54:50 GMT

The one thing I would like to know is who killed Bhutto and why.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Angry Pakistani, Cleveland — Mon, 31 Dec 2007 22:22:17 GMT

When Benazir Bhutto returned to Pakistan in October, President Musharaff TOLD HER he could not guarantee her safety, and yet she continued to attend public rallies and gatherings. She knew what she was risking. If she had been the only one hurt, it would be a personal tragedy for her family, friends and supporters. However, she knew knew that she was a target; she knew the preferred methods of those targeting her [bombs]; and yet she continued to go into the midst of crowds of innocent people. In October, her actions were responsible for the deaths of 147 people in Karachi, last week, she was responsible for the deaths of another 22 people near Rawalpindi, and in the aftermath of her assassination, another 44 people were killed across the nation, with hundreds more injured since her return. That does not make her a martyr, a hero or a symbol of democracy. It makes her an accomplice to terrorism and mass murder.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Naureen Bokhari, Ashburn,Va — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 00:44:56 GMT

It is very unfortunate that the people of Pakistan have taken to the streets to vent their anger at the assassination of Benazir. You have to remember that there is no other way for them to be heard. There is no law in the land, there is a dictator who speaks and hears only what he wants to hear. The media was banned from speaking against the govt so that makes it very hard for the voice of the people to be heard. There is no justice system, so where do you go to find justice?
I think she was a brave woman and a people’s person. She reached out to the masses. But we also cannot forget the corruption charges and the way she looted our country. The PPP the so called people’s party is run by her family, making it a dynasty, there is nothing democratic about that. The last time the PPP was in power they managed to empty all the banks of Pakistan.
I feel for her children, they have just lost their mother, but I also don’t trust her husband, he is the one who pulled her credibility into the dirt when she was the prime minister…he gets another shot at making some more millions now, while the real people in the street struggle to find food.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Paul Peters, Bronx, New York — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 01:53:31 GMT

Michelle Kosinski has given us a sensitive and probing look into the deep feelings of the Pakistani people. It make you feel the oneness of people everywhere who grieve for Benazir Bhutto.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Dewey Shpag — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 02:29:14 GMT

The Pakistan people should unit and rally up against the terrorists that think they own your country. The terrorists are cowards and they know it deep down inside. Show them who's the boss and take steps to remove them or force them into tthe hands of the US Army in Afphanistan. Now is the tie.. you have the support.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Hassan Aslam, Baltimore, Maryland — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 03:18:49 GMT

Bhutto would have been unhurt, only if she was a little more careful. She knew that odds were against her, and intelligence reports that there will be assasination attempts on her life. Knowing she survived the first attack, she should not be waving to people from the sunroof of her truck. The Pakistan she left in 1999 is a lot differnt than what it has become right now.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Sandun, Las Vegas — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 03:26:46 GMT

There is one thing that Benazir said some 15-2o years ago that I never forgot and think often because of the twists and turns happend in my life.
She said answering a reporters question "What is fated will apply".

Rest in peace Benazir.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Ahmad F, Anaheim, California, USA — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 03:38:25 GMT

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

saeed — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 04:08:33 GMT

While the loss to the cause of democracy in Pakistan is undeniable in a peculiar way(A nineteen year old boy is nominated,to head the sole family heirarchy,the "DEMOCRATIC PAKISTAN PEOPLES PARTY"without any elections in the "STRONGLY DEMOCRATIC"party),the people probing the assassination should also probe a third dimension.That is apart from the two generally accused;the Alqaida and Pervez Musharaf.Couldnt it be the same peoplle who killed her brother Murtaza BHUTTO and who had maximum to gain from her assasination.Also there are many pertinent questions in addition to those asked by Mr Abdul Khan in her comments.However her assasination is highly deplorable and strogly condemnable.God bless the departed soul,God bless Pakistan.AAmeen

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Josh Richard — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 04:37:41 GMT

I am saddened and grieved by the assassination of Ms Bhutto.

However , what bothers me is the looting of more than 200 Banks by Ms Bhutto's supporters.

When PM Liaqat was shot nothing like this happened.When ZA Bhutto was hanged for committing murder of Qasuri ..nothing like this happened .

Why the bank looting in grief ..can someone pls explain ..Thanks

Josh

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Elle Olsson — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 05:32:43 GMT

It seems that the best of leaders in this world are shot and murdered. When will we learn that once someone is truly dynamic and destined to be a true leader, they should be protected. Her death was preventable and is truly sad for Pakistan as well as the world.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Abhi Buch, San Diego, California — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 06:14:17 GMT

Michelle Kosinski beautifully captured the delicate flavor of a region in such internal torment. Her writing was a snap-shot, a passing moment in time, yet conveyed the sense of a forlorn scene rife with doubt and anger, yet muted and still. There is always self-doubt in the aftermath of such tragedy, and it is in the streets that one best hears the beating of the national heart and feels the pulse of a changeing nation. A great piece of work; thank you.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Manaal,Lahore,Pakistan — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 06:17:27 GMT

I would like to reply to the questions of Mr.Abdul Khan,a) was BB really for democracy? well i am sure she must have had a lot of her own personal intrests but alongwith that democracy would have been restored,as she was not going to become a DUMMY Prime minister in the hands of President Musharaf,you would probably not know that the Prime minister in Pakistan hold more power than the President constitutionly. But with our President Musharaf...he just wants to contain his power at every cost...no matter what the people of Pakistan want...he doesnt care!! he is that BAD !!!he would let the country go to hell but still remain in power and lastly i feel that the son of BB should not have been made the PPP chairman...he is too young to handle these issues and besides he knows nothing about the politics of Pakistan,,,someone who is just 19 and lived for the past 8 yrs outside of Pakistan,,should not be allowed to decide the fate of the biggest political party of the country,,but thats INHERITANCE !!! what can we do about it!!!! as for Zardari...he is undoubtly a very corrupt guy and he did keep his 10% in this deal as well by making himself as the Co-chairman!!!

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Jackie, Enid, OK — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 06:26:11 GMT

In response to Sharon, you have never had to deal with this type of society. These are tribal peoples, and to condemn them is ludicrous. This is they way they have lived for centuries. Shame on you for casting judgement. Instead, try to understand the futility they now seem to feel. The one person who could possibly bring them towards a democratic government and ideology is now dead. Their hopes have been shattered. How would you react at such a horrible conclusion?

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

A Khan, Houston ,Texas — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 06:41:50 GMT

It took me days to come out of the shock of MS Bhutto's Death. Even though I never had any likeness for her and her political party. But I started respecting her Because of her bravery.
She has been so out spoken on the biggest threat and the issue Pakistan has i.e Religious Extremism and Fundamentalism. And its shame on all of our other political leaders that none of them have ever brought up that as an issue.
But still Bilawal becoming the Chairman of that party gave me another Shock. Like there is nobody else left in the country of 160 Million people. Means there is no Democracy even inside our political parties.
Then what was wrong when Musharraf Imported Shaukat Aziz as our Prime Minister. And what is wrong in Musharraf being our President.
If we talk about democracy we have to start it from ourselves.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Rose Gill, Multan, Pakistan — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 07:01:37 GMT

Benazir,the women leader from Sindh, was the bond that was holding the country together. One can understand from the reactions of the Sindhis screaming Anti-Pakistan, anti Punjab slogans because Ms. Bhutto is the second Sindhi prime minister to be assasinated in Punjab, after her father Z.A Bhutto. The question raised by one of the bloggers who want to hear views of out-spoken Pakistanis is lso very crucial. Was Bhutto really interested in restoring the democracy? In my opinion, she was the key to restoring the electoral process and looking at her popularity, had definitely managed to trouble the militiary administration of Pakistan. This is in itself an answer to wheather Bhutto will be interested in restoring anything. Things cannot go from worse to good overnight but it would have triggered the process at least. The reason that we do not have a second line of 'prepared' leaders is a drawback so the main icons in Pakistan democracy restoration were Nawaz Sharif and Benazir, of them, Benazir as the most popular and likely to have won with massive majority.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

sam newman washington dc — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 08:27:37 GMT

It's so tragic that a small glimmer of hope for peace and democratic rule suddenly ends by blind hatred and religious zealotry (santioned by SIS), even in a politically shaky region such as Pakistan. The most striking aspect of this sad tale is that moslem moderates here did not push their leaders to marginalize and destroy radical islamists; hence, in this regards, they share some of the blame for the bad turn of events as well as fate of endless bloodsheds.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Erum Mehfooz, Islamabad, Pakistan — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 11:04:19 GMT

I totally agree that Benazir Bhutto's loss is great, but there are so many other innocent people who died for nothing, no one even thinks about them.
In this state of chaos, Pakistani's should stay calm and try to prevail peace. "grace under pressure" proves a nation to be educated. Have ur faith and strength intact and hope for the best.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Abdur Rehman — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 13:25:31 GMT

It is time that Pakistan develops its democratic institutions and tries to be tolerant. Successive governments in Pakistan have used suppressive tactics against their own people. They are used to enforce their agenda and do not care about the opponent.

Tolerance and not force is the solution. Peace and not wars/fighting is what this country needs. It is time that they learn to respect the opinion of the adversary.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

George D'Souza — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 14:31:29 GMT

You all are forgetting that Musharaf is a ruthless dictator, probably one of the worst in the history of Pakistan and the world. To come into her own country after an exile to contest an election speaks volumes for Benazir. Even in India after the death of Mrs Gandhi her son took over the reigns of the Congress Party and paid the price with his life. These people have put their lives on the line for that. I am sure Benazir cared for a democratic Pakistan. Musharaf is a puppet of the US foreign policy. He is the most dangerous ruler of our times. Without his support the Taliban will not exist even for a few months. Does anyone even care to think about how Taliban is existing and becoming more and more powerful? Well, there is more to it than this. But, to say the tne Bhutto family is trying to make money out of this is outrageous and childish. What would they gain if their life itself in not guaranteed? Wake up!!!

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Muna New York — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 14:45:11 GMT

I agree with Mr. Khan. If something happened to George Bush, would we give the reins to Jena Bush? Making your 19 year old son the head of a leading political party means only one thing: You are not concerned about the future of your country but rather about keeping it ALL IN THE FAMILY.

This is a grave period for the future of Pakistan.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Geoffrey Lipman — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 15:26:11 GMT

There is sadly nothing that any of us can do about the regretable combination of tragic loss of life, blow to democracy,encouragement to Al Quaida and the sad but inevitable death of a politician who ignored basic security advice. There is one small thing that NBC and the world media could do and that is, as Richard Klepper suggests refer only to homicide bombers in your reports. Over time this would properly categorize this crime with murder which mankind everywhere recognizes as outside the bounds of civilized society. Is there any case for not doing so?

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Daoud, Falls Church, VA — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 18:09:19 GMT

Pakistan is another failed Islamic state that is a) extremely jealous of its technically and economically superior democratic neighbor India and b) funded by the corrupt Saudis to spread fundamentalist Islam throughout the region. Unfortunately, the US has been supporting the Musharraf govt. in the hopes of stemming Islamic fundamentalism. I think time will tell that he (Musharraf) is as complicit as the Taliban for the woes of the region.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Malcom_Usama, Waziristan, Arabia. — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 19:39:26 GMT

Democracy is institutionalised freedom given to individuals or coorporations to manipulate public opinion into trusting them n give them positions of power.The aim is always selfinterests and the slogan of caring for the people n acting with justice n equal rights is just a big farce.
The noble n truthful ones r those who sacrifice their own sefinterests to help mankind n establish true justice.No man can act as a lord over another man.Freedom is a God-given right and we should not let the strong impose their will upon us.Many times political n ideological enslavement r worse than physical enslavement.At least those oppressed around the world be it in iraq, afganistan, somalia, saudi arabia, palestine, pakistan or kashmir, possess intellectual freedom to differentiate between occupation n resistance.
Let not this western egocentric mentality , racism, nationalism or patriotism , affect us...It brought darkness n confusion to every nation who tried to taste its fruits.Glitter, glamour, boastfulness, arrogance will not be able to seduce the inner state of man more than , truthfulness,sacrifice, sincerity, humility , humbleness , honesty and true justice.
Its hard to accept, but the west together with its corrupt puppet agents r losing the ideological war against islam.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Mohsin, Nwfp, PK — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 21:14:51 GMT

about your first Q: i wud like to say that here in pakistan you cant trust anyone, so cant say anything was she or not, but the way she was assassinated put every pakistani into deep grief n sorrow, Q: Musharraf is not That bad, but financial problems are increasing day by day for the common person, lets see where he takes us, and Yup! you are right about her husband.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Jean Wilson — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 21:46:22 GMT

In answer to Abdul Khan's blog message, yes, Benazir Begum was in earnest to have a democratic society in Pakistan, but at the last, she let down her guard too often and forgot sense of reasoning against the politicians and terrorists, taking ever more risks than before; she was willing to risk her own life, having already set the future of her own party stated in her will for her own son to take her place. She well knew what the consequenses could be but many have died to get and preserve democracy. Please, don't anyone ever forget that....

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Ahmad — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 23:35:53 GMT

Finally some one speaking the truth about the ground reality of Pakistan. Bennazir for all her glamour was seen as some one who had cut deal with a dictator , clining on to power due to the blessing of his American and EU overlords. Pakistanies rather than uncertain, fell more helpless. But thank you again gret artical

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

ahmad — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 23:41:52 GMT

This is to answer Abdul Khan, First answer a)NO, c)third answer that is the PPP perception of democracy. And as for Mushraff, An army bombing its own citizens, the secret services suping on its own people, ban on media, and freedom of expression, the ripping apart of the countries constitution, challanging and muzzling the voice of the judiciary, holding people with out trial. Dare i say more about what mushraff is, i hope this answers your question Mr Addul Khan

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Fahad, Poughkeepsie, NY — Tue, 01 Jan 2008 23:45:10 GMT

Broad thinking and knowing their rights is very important for the people of pakistan. Turning to streets and spreading violence is not going to improve anything. What pakistan needs is the best quality of education and values. Destroying each others property and throwing stones on each other will not improve anything but it shows lack of knowledge, values and education. People of pakistan have potential to make a difference and they should use it in a positive way not by looting each other's property. I believe that the people that were involved in destroying shops and looting banks were not mourning they were in fact taking advantage of the grave situation and were looting money and items for their own benefit. They were not mourning. Again, What Pakistan needs is Education, values knowledge and sincere politicians. Army's job is to protect pakistan and they shouldn't become politicians. If army claims they are saving pakistan they can leave the policical offices and still do their job. The only problem is everybody is power and money hungry. Army wants to be in power so they can enjoy all the luxuries of life and leave the poor people rot. All this violence started when army started ruling the country. Army should go back to the Barracks and let people choose their political leaders.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Eric Smith, Fairfield, CA — Wed, 02 Jan 2008 01:02:09 GMT

Unfortunately, politcal progress is always preceded by violence - assassinations, angry and unruly mobs, military actions and the like. History has shown that people must pay the ultimate price (whether leaders or innocent bystanders) before the ultimate, best civilization is manifested (Are we there yet?). I wish there was another way.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Rohail Khan, Chicago, IL — Wed, 02 Jan 2008 01:22:46 GMT

Good article, but no real story here...

It is sad to see such one-sided reports in the media based on the events that have transpired in Pakistan over the last few weeks. It is also regretfull when anyone's life is lost and we should all be saddened by that. What disturbs me as someone of Pakistani heritage however, is that the media plays sound bites that make it seem that Bhutto was an angel during both of her leadership stints as PM. Lest we forget that she was convicted - as was Nawaz Sharif - for stealing money from the country's poor. By all factual accounts the thefts in both cases were well above several billion dollars - yes that is with a "B" - but you don't hear anything about that in the media. She had pending cases of corruption in several EU countries as well. Why the media chooses to glamorize her as a "martyr" or "savior" is perplexing to me - Nelson Mandella was/is worthy of that status, not Benazir. A review of the facts involved would make that clear to anyone who cares about the facts.

Here was a woman who was very well educated, had the ability to lead a Muslim country as the first female PM several years back and make a real statement on te world stage, but instead of building any social, educational and industrial infrastructure, she did what most other's before her did and that was steal foreign aid and pilage from inside the country when she had a chance, with good ol' Mr. 10% ensuring that he didn't miss a trick by her side. What a disgrace to every educated Pakistani the world over.

Is Musharif the answer long term - maybe / maybe not -that is for Allah to ultimately decide, but when you have a lunatic fringe inside the country (fanatics who use religion as a cover, but who could care less about the country), tribal lords in the Frontier province to the north who have never really been governed and additional lunatics in Afganistan that also use religion as an execuse to further their own personl goals and wealth, coupled with the constant threat of India to the East, I remain amazed at how he has navigated through the last several years without getting killed himself (eight attempts on his life and counting) while balancing the "lose/lose" scenario he was thrust into post 9/11.

I would encourage the TV networks to ensure that they screen everyone who they position as an "Indo-Pak expert" to ensure that they have read a few history books about that part of the world to understand what has transpired there - spend time talking to the educated class who lives there - before they share their "expert" opinions and confirm that they have no basis for being an "expert".

We need stability in Pakistan and that requires the educated class to come forward and take a stand - something that has not been the case from what I have seen and experienced. Why is it that we only see the mob-type gatherings in all the media coverage ... that is not what is going on in the bulk of the country - only where it makes good TV play. It is no wonder that the best a brightest of Pakistan's educated class choose to leave or remain silent...

...how sad this is indeed ;-(

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

sohail Dallas — Wed, 02 Jan 2008 01:35:54 GMT

Amazing that mob mentality transcends so strongly and
can be so violent.It is disturbing to see so many innocent people lose their lives,businesses for the so called "loss".Though immensely popular,Benazir Bhutto never educated the masses about peace and brotherhood.Is Pakistan really ready for Democracy?Power without constraints always creates aftermaths like these.People of Pakistan are hurting no one other than themselves by these inexplicable actions.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

zara shah — Wed, 02 Jan 2008 05:08:02 GMT

I totaly agree with the Abdul Khan, her son and the husband (Mr 10%) taking over PPP, seems like taking over a piece of their property. I feel sorry for her kids who lost their mother at this early age, but she was not that innocent we all know that from her previous two terms as the PM of Pakistan.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Akber Khan — Wed, 02 Jan 2008 05:17:39 GMT

"May be I am wrong. I would really like to hear from some outspoken Pakistanis."

NO, Abdul Khan you have exercised modesty in expressing what I hear or read in your post.
Its not an easy task to cover all the improprieties of the Bhutto regime in power. The countless wealth stolen from Pakistan & numerous lives taken by those who were in her cabinet and all the way down cannot be adequately covered in a blog post however you can read brief description of their rule on the following links.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benazir_Bhutto

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asif_Zardari

The brother & nephew of the MQM leader Altaf Hussain was killed along with his son in the Govt. assigned residence of the then chief minister of Sindh province and their bodies were then sacked and laid at some corner. This is only one example of the brutal rule of PPP back then under BB. I do not like to say anything about her because she is now in the custody of the most supreme judge Allah the Almighty, above & beyond our scrutiny and I would surpass my limits as a humble human should I say anything to add to her account.
Yes she had the qualities and properties that hypnotized the less than literate majority of Pakistan, she new how to address the nervous system of Pakistanis, those Pakistanis that paid attention to her speeches, but politics and leadership goes beyond speeches and is not fulfilled unless it is supported by some action.
The recent unrest created by her supporters & party members of the PPP is self-explanatory, where in only one instance they burned down a garment factory in Karachi with 27 workers who died in that factory fire.
Asif as known to the entire world by now is Mr. 10%+.
People during her after burial ceremony raised slogans against the country which equals to treason. Sherry Rehman the information secretary of PPP in an interview with an independent Pakistani TV channel when asked by the interviewer about the unrest responded by clearly indicating that it would not stop unless PPP supporters did not hear what they want to by the Govt. spokesperson and indicated that the unrest would increase.
Over a thousand cars were burned down, super-highway from Karachi to interior destinations is littered with burnt down truck, trailers & other vehicles of all types.
Most violence was inflicted in the areas that are populated by those who are known to be majority supporters of political parties other than PPP.
As many may have heard Asif speaking after burial formalities that, even he uses the term "revenge" as he goes to say that we will take revenge of this blood by winning this election in a very nice fashion. While many people outside the country may not comprehend this fancy method of conveying that PPP & it's leadership in real sense is counting on taking revenge of this unfortunate and sad killing of BB, but paranoids like me who have observed the character of these thugs and hoodlums over decades do understand that it is not how it is capsuled together to come out as a fancy statement but goes much deeper.
By this time everyone interested in Pakistan & it's politics knows that before this last rally of BB+PPP in the same Liaquat Bagh the govt. has assured that BB does not go for the public meeting that she intended back in November and was blocked off by thousands of policemen from leaving her residence there disabling her from going to speak and it was done by the govt. to protect from the dangers that the intelligence may have known were present to BB while, the PPP leadership was outraged and took the opportunity to call it an attempt to blocking PPP & BB from holding meetings and rallies.
Most politicians in Pakistan refer to west when they talk about democracy & politics, however they fail to convey to the public that how disciplined those rallies, meetings & processions are that are held in the west. The organizers are required to apply for permits in advance giving complete details of their event, the places that they will be using and the routes they will take etc. however the politicians don't discuss discipline of western political events with the people of Pakistan because they use such opportunities to provoke & inflame people and lure them to streets to cause unrest which is very common.
To conclude if the politicians don't adopt the path of sincerity to the nation there is no light of democracy seen and it appears to be a long dark tunnel leading no where, because the major supporters of almost all candidates and politicians support them only for one reason and that is to know someone who can help them in their endeavors by using their undue pressure, and the politicians are willing and ready to reciprocate to their cronies in any manner they wish as long as they are elected with the help of such accomplices.
May God the Almighty protect our homeland from the wrath of our very own "politicians" aspiring to fulfill their pockets and robbing the poor nation of Pakistan when and if they gain power.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Shyle Gautama, Hong Kong — Wed, 02 Jan 2008 08:34:38 GMT

I deplore the death of anyone, especially by such means and methods. The perpetrators are fundamentally evil, and they mask their Satanic perfidity in those time-tested disguises: "Religiousness" and "Patriotism"; the former using God as its cover, the latter being "the last refuge of the scoundrel".

Still, I am completely appalled that Benazir Bhutto, a proven criminal, corruptor and pillager of her nation has, in her demise, drawn such accolades and, indeed, absolution. Despite her brutal and barbaric murder, my initial reaction was: "Ding-dong, the witch is dead....".

Poor Pakistan. A nation that has been robbed of so much potential, has had to fall back on the likes of Benazir Bhutto and Nawaz Sharif. While it is easy to criticize the U.S. for its support of Musharraf, what other options did they have ? The murderous, Taliban-thinking Gulbuddin Hekmatyar ? The impotent Imran Khan ? Whom else, the Chief Justice ?

Thus, it goes to the heart of the matter: The "silent majority" in Pakistan must forget its regionalism, its tribalism and its preoccupation with building a religious state, and focus on building a proper nation -- with all the appendages and built-in checks and balances against unbridled power and corruption.

Like it or not, the future of Pakistan rests, at least in the short-term, on the stability of its military, politicized or not. Without that, there is a long, slippery slope which is the descent into the medieval barbarism of the Tribal Concessions in North and South Waziristan -- which is where Al-Qaeda and the Taliban wish to lead us all -- starting with their Muslim bretheren, then the rest of us, including Buddhists, Hindus, Christians, Bahais, atheists, agnostics ad nauseum.

Surely, in a nation of 160-odd million people, there must be several thousand decent, uncorrupted and competent people ?

Now, to hear everyone from Mike Huckabee to Hilary Clinton (and all others in between) trying to exploit the situation and circumstances to their own gain is even more sickening.

Poor America ! You seem to have the same problem as Pakistan.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Karachi — Wed, 02 Jan 2008 09:47:36 GMT

Well.The assasination of Benazir is indeed a big tragedy. It could have been carried out for several reasons. Lack of transparency in investigation is giving birth to conspiracy theories. It will be better if an independent agency is commissioned to probe the gruesome murder.However i would like to state that Benazir wasnt a messiah or angel who came back to save the day for Pakistan. She had a feudal background and the appointment of her juvenile son as the chairman of Pakistan's most popular party shows that the party which professes demcoracy dosent infact apply the same concept for its internal workings. Benazir is a big loss to us because she managed to forge good relations with the West and would have played a major role in moderating our image.As far as doing something for the country was concerened. I really doubt if she had fared better than Musharraf.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Ali Azmat — Wed, 02 Jan 2008 12:07:58 GMT

Mr. Abdul Khan. by your name and comments it seems you might be better aware of politics and history of our region. But for your and for sake rest of readers here is a reply.
Ofcourse she was interested in restoring democracy, even if it was just for her own sake.A family dynasty is no forgone conclusion, despite what it may look like to "westerners". Her son won`t be eligible for any public office for many years to come and even then who knows what he may turn up like, after all law of primogeniture does not apply in a constitutional democracy. Bilawal bhutto/zardari is of no more value than perhaps prince williams and Harry`s or kennedys of this world, who will have little impact but do command a certain respect and public affection, no more than a symbol.
Let me add further to that, to even half intelligent pakistani it seems like a sham, but we accept it as a neccessary evil for the sake and unity of our country. for people`s party is the single largest party with represntation in all parts of ethinically unique provinces.
Her husband was and remains a highly unpopular figure here and the party is not letting him run for parliament anyway( as forbidden by BB).
I wonder how do westerners look down upon about " family dynasty" while the leader of the western countries or for the world for that matter has had a Father and son as presidents of US of A within 8 years of each other( with another son as a governer for good measure).
Democracy is never perfect nor the only way of governance, but it remains the best option to empower people. IT does`nt happen in one day, or even one tenure, it is the attitude of people that deveops it and makes it as good as it can be, as it is in some countries of the world. So please let us have it let us fail or succed at it, we don`t want ur puppets like musharaff who kills our countrymen at whim of powers that be. we son`t want a ruffian who throws out his own supreme court because it questiuoned his governemnts methods, we don`t want a dictator who is surely destained for same conclusion as Polpot. Let us be, we are a great nation too, and we will not be used by your world for your gain.
No hard feelings.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Rolando Villanueva, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia — Wed, 02 Jan 2008 13:02:45 GMT

A bomber, whether he/she died with their victims, is a plain murderer (except during real wars where desperate soldiers will sacrifice themselves to kill their enemies). There is no such thing as a homicide bombers but plain cowardly (or paid professional) bombers who do it remotely. Suicide bombers are those who are willing to die with their victims because of their false beliefs and convictions. If the person blows himself/herself alone with no intention of harming anybody else, that is plain suicide with a lot 'fireworks'.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

MJavaid Shervani, Jeddah, KSA. — Wed, 02 Jan 2008 13:52:43 GMT

What ails you Oh! Pakistan,
Only...FEUDALISM.. feudalism..
Those who struggle,
the darkness of feudal nights,
Bring the golden ray of dawn:
the SUN of freedom ...
Yes- I once, also, read :
“ I saw a child carrying a light,
I asked him where he had brought it from,
He put it out and said ;
Now u tell me where it is gone.”
Hazrat Hasan Basri(Iraq)

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

one song — Wed, 02 Jan 2008 14:33:38 GMT

Benazir Bhutto now does her work from another place.
May her life have meaning and her legacy of hope live on. She lived and died breathing for her people. An honourable woman with a dream of a better world for Pakistani and all children-what all mothers should dream. Instead, many watch as our men kill each other and children are poisoned with hatred for others they do not understand.
Attributed to Muhammad," Shall I not inform you of a better act than fasting, alms, and prayers? Making peace between one another: enmity and malice tear up heavenly rewards by the roots."
Islam (Hadith)"No one of you is a believer until he desires for his brother that which he desires for himself."
Benazir was clear in her belief and her desire was a peaceful democratic Pakistan. May people everywhere learn another way. May women everywhere stand in peaceful unison that we no longer accept a world of violence and must find a better way. We must teach peace in the smallest corners and the simplest moments to invoke peace for the preservation of all upon this planet. Do you love your Creator? Love your fellow beings first.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Salman Karachi — Wed, 02 Jan 2008 15:47:44 GMT

All things said and done, what does the future hold,
I'd my self support Benazir but not her leftover party so to speak but now what does the future hold for the Paki Populace

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Muneeb, Princeton, NJ — Wed, 02 Jan 2008 16:13:36 GMT

Benazir was in power twice and the performance was terrible. Corruption was all time high, history speask for itself. It was a mistake to allow her back, she did not pay her dues. Justice was not done. It is sad how she was killed. But during her time the country has taken many steps behind..its a shame. People of Pakistan must speak up for the right thing. Bhutto and Sharif are not the right thing.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

Sheikhu — Wed, 02 Jan 2008 16:20:15 GMT

Although the loss of a human life should never be condoned or excused, Bibi ji put herself in harms's way. After all, what is the use of a bomb proof and bullet proof if one is going to hang outside the car via a sun roof anyways. Kind of defeats the purpose of having a proofed car. As a pakistani myself, I find it amusing that many people have labeled her death as the death of democracy and the death of a great leader in Pakistan. Her administration was corrupt from day 1 during both terms and was forced out as a result. Why then would we have expected anything different were she to have come to office again. I say, stop looking at her with rose tinted glasses. Mourn for the loss of a person, a mother and a daughter; however, do not tell me to mourn the loss of the last bastion of hope for Pakistan. Neither her nor any of the other cronies who double as politicians in Pakistan qualify as that.

Pakistan's sense of loss and uncertainty

jdt seattle wa — Wed, 02 Jan 2008 16:24:36 GMT

Really sad what happened. Horrible too, what happened to the educational system of Pakistan on her watch. Perhaps one of the motives driving Ms. Bhutto was a sense of remorse? A willingness to take the extra risks and "hang it all out" for a chance to fix the mistakes of the past? Don't really expect the leopard to change it's spots, but who will ever know now? The nomination of the son, how pathetic a telegraphing of motive on the father's part is that?