U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Cathy Tremonte' NYC — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 19:56:08 GMT

Here's the story.

He got drunk and shacked up with German Girl. Sorry, he would rather drink Hefewizen and dance at Club Europa im Berlin with his Fralien', than fight inBUSH/CHENEY'S debacle.

No one agrees with the stupid occupation of Iraq, but you have to do your duty.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Kevin L. Buesher Beaumont, TX — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:01:42 GMT

Hum maybe to much German nite life made him miss movement. Happened to me. I took my punishment and joined my brothers for the fun filled, all expenses paid Middle East Vacation, no big deal.

No one likes being here. But you gotta do what you signed up for.

Hope Obama will stop all this invading other countries thing.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Kathy Campione' Short Hills, NJ — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:02:52 GMT

He and the shoe thrower are hero's.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

JWD — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:14:19 GMT

The Germans should give him back and we should lock him up and throw away the key. He enlisted in the Military and no one made him sign up.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Joe F Las Vegas — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:15:25 GMT

I despise everything about the Iraq War and those that lied to us to get us into it but unfortunately as a soldier once you put on that uniform you are bound by a different set of rules. I joined the Army while Viet Nam was going on,I didn't support the war in Nam and requested duty in Europe,which I got,but at the same time I knew that if the Army ordered me into combat in Nam or elsewhere I was duty bound to go,that's part of being a soldier.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Michael Grant, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:17:47 GMT

Leavenworth would be a good place for him to think about his actions for about 20 years.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Marty Moline, IL — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:18:05 GMT

Good. He should be given a medal for standing up to the Bush administration and calling them out on it.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

JOE SNUFFY — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:18:26 GMT

grant him the asylm!!!if he wants to abandon his country..then let him.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Otis R. Needleman — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:18:39 GMT

Hope he is turned down for asylum. Apparently he was homeless before joining the Army. So now this guy runs off once given an actual job to do? His request for asylum is a slap in the face of every other soldier who does their duty.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Craig Rohan, Los Angeles, CA — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:19:19 GMT

War is an ugly thing, but not the ugliest of things. The decayed and degraded state of moral and patriotic feeling which thinks that nothing is worth war is much worse. The person who has nothing for which he is willing to fight, nothing which is more important than his own personal safety, is a miserable creature and has no chance of being free unless made and kept so by the exertions of better men than himself.
John Stuart Mill (1806 - 1873)

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Philip Eckstein, Cookeville, TN — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:19:55 GMT

I am a disabled US Army retiree who was honorably discharged. I see incidents like this and they make me sick and very disappointed in my fellow solidiers. If he felt so bad and determined that this war is illegal, he did not have to desert to satisfy his problem. He could have gone through the proper Army channels to solve his new problem. In my view this man is a coward and should be court martialed.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Brian — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:20:18 GMT

I dont understand Andre's reason for going awol. On one breath he speaks of all the good he did in Iraq and the other of all the bad he helped create for working on attack helicopters. In war you cant have it both ways. I feel this is really his copout from probably being redeployed to Iraq or Afghanistan.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Dee Brown — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:23:16 GMT

Do what you think is best for you and nothing comes before you but god. All the best.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

R. O. Davis, Downey, California — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:23:32 GMT

Allow these deserters to renounce their U. S. citizenship and stay there. It is better for everyone.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Mister Jimmy — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:25:24 GMT

Germany 'owes' mankind. I hope they will look deeply into their hearts and souls and do this brave man justice. He appears to be asking to only live a life of his own and not be forced to be a tool in the endless murder of civilians in an illegal war. Help him, you 'good Germans." It is a lead-pipe cinch his own country will not.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

America, love it or leave it — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:26:54 GMT

He wasn't drafted, it was and is a volunteer Army. I was in and I took my oath seriously. No matter were he was sent or what he was made to do, he chose to put himself into the service of our country. It's not up to him to choose which battles to fight. He should be tried as a desrter and face the consequences.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Methinks, Valdosta, GA — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:27:17 GMT

Hmmm, AWOL or Deserter...Should be shot.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

John Hawkins Upper Marlboro, Md — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:27:18 GMT

I understand, there is no draft, so I assume this person enlisted in the military voluntarly. With that said..did he not realize that just perhaps he would be sent into combat? Thats what our military is for, to defend and honor out country. Desertion is a crime and should not be looked upon as some soft hearted GI thinking he can crawl under some rock in another country. Do his job, whether he agrees with the job assigned or not. I hope the Germans tell him go pound salt, go back home and face what you have done, and be man enough to do the time in Levenworth.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Jerseygirl — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:29:41 GMT

I understand his discontent, many feel that way with the Iraq war and I can't blame them, however, when he enlisted he knew what he was doing, he wasn't drafted like so many in the Vietnam War era and forced to go. He volunteered. I dont think he is entitled to politcal asylum, because he wouldnt be going to jail for his political views, he would be going for deserting his unit. Yes it sucks that he was being sent back, and yes many have been killed civilian and otherwise,however, there has been much good done too. I think our soldiers need to come home, but what he did was wrong and he deserves to face the music.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Jerseygirl — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:29:42 GMT

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Andy Romero, Oxnard, Ca — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:31:33 GMT

First of all this pisses me off seeing this guy go AWOL for being a mechanic. You joined the service to FIGHT AND DEFEND your country and the CONSTITUTION. If you go AWOL during wartime you are punishable by death so I hope they get this coward.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Brian — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:32:38 GMT

Coward

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

US Soldier, Fort Benning, GA — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:32:45 GMT

This deserter swore an oath upon enlistment to protect and defend the Constitution. He's failed on that oath. The Uniform Code of Military Justice makes it quite clear the ramifications of opting out on that oath, including being an AWOL deserter. He's shamed himself, his fellow soldiers, the US Army and the United States, by deserting his post. He should be punished accordingly. I'm not interested in hearing his sob story about how he couldn't handle doing his job anymore. He knew what he was getting into when he enlisted.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Laura Brown, Valley, AL — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:35:52 GMT

This guy enlisted AFTER the war had started. That it came as a shock to him that he had to fight is an outrage...I am a veteran who enlisted BEFORE the war started. When my unit was called up, I disagreed. I was appalled. But I went, and I served. My opinion should not affect the job I do. He never objected to receiving that paycheck, now did he?

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

John Davis, The Colony TX — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:36:26 GMT

This soldier enlisted, not drafted, and was stationed in Germany. It is a disgrace that he would desert while in Germany, or any other country. His obligation is to his country and not a political issue. I too have a son in Iraq and have a political view but am proud that his fellow soldiers are his concern not the politics.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

USMC, Retired — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:36:52 GMT

WOW!
He elisted in 2004 while the activity by US Military in Iraq was not a secret - Question: what did he think joining the miltary was about?

LOSER!!! Let him stay in Germany and never allow him to set foot in the United States.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

TI, Europe (ex-pat US) — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:38:04 GMT

Good luck Mr. Shepherd... hope it works out for you.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

MF, OR — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:39:23 GMT

If Germany accepts his request then Germany will likely get a very cold response from America. This man should not be granted asylum. He's a coward and should be sent to Afganistan not jail.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

dave danko anahiem ca — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:39:59 GMT

he's a courard let him stay in germany but no gi bennifets and never back in usa

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Harold Clark; Grover Hill,OHIO — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:41:01 GMT

Lets see he had to join voluntarily to get in, must be he wanted some kind of a bonus for joining? then decided he was not man enough to serve. Or is he a Muslim who has no character?

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Mike Edwards, Dallas, Texas — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:42:06 GMT

The guy is a coward who should have never enlisted in the first place. Every soldier is told in Basic Combat Training that they could one day actually have to be a SOLDIER and go to war. Heaven forbid you actually have to DO the job that you signed up for...

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

alan womack clackamas oregon — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:44:25 GMT

Andre Shepherd should go to military prison for twenty years period. He sighned up for it and he should abide by his contract with the U.S. ARMY.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

DEWITT BEELAND, SAVANNAH, GA — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:45:08 GMT

THIS MAN FREELY JOINED THE MILITARY. HE SWORE TO OBEY THE COMMANDS OF HIS SUPERIORS AND HIS COUNTRY. HE HAS TAKEN THE MONEY AND BENEFITS AS LONG AS IT WAS IN HIS BEST INTEREST. SOLDIERS DO NOT HAVE THE RIGHT TO DECIDE FOR THEMSELVES IN WHICH BATTLES THEY WILL PARTICIPATE AND WHICH THEY WILL NOT.THE MAN IS SCARED AND JUST WANTS OUT OF THE OBLIGATION HE FREELY MADE TO HIS COUNTRY. I SURELY HOPE THAT IF HE IS GRANTED ASYLUM THAT THE USA REVOKES HIS CITIZENSHIP PERMANENTLY.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

ruben, albuquerque, nm — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:45:47 GMT

unfortunately our soldiers are having to explore other methods of ending the irag war. when are we going to use common sense and stop this farce of a war. i don't blame this soldier, i blame congress for getting us into this mess.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

jims oklahoma city oklahoma — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:46:11 GMT

lets see; he was not drafted, he chose to enter the military; he was not a combat soldier; he was a mechanic; he has made a political move with political statements; a definite no no for a military
soldier of any rank; ouch! he is a deserter. Germany should leave this one alone. Send him back....

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

JonL, Bradenton, FL — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:47:58 GMT

Like a SC state patrol told me years ago after stopping me for speeding, "If you're gonna dance, you gotta pay the fiddler."

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

jose monterroso la ca 90042 — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:48:59 GMT

he is nothing but a cower iam very sure that he was fine when he was getting all of the army benefits, but dont this people know that once you joing the service at one point in time you are going to have to defend your country no matter where they send you and do what ever it takes its just common sence, why do they joing makes no sence to me

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Fort Worth, TX — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:49:54 GMT

Too bad he didn't think about the consequences when he signed up for the military. I am sure all the men/women sometimes think to themsevles - what have I gotten myself into. But, they stay and do their time and then get out with an Honorable Discharge. I for one could never ever think of not being a US citizen. I thank every service person out there for all you do and all you sacrifice each and every day. God bless you all and please know - we do appreciate your patronage. I know I don't agree with the war but I do respect what all service men do. They made a commitment even if it is not what they thought they signed up for. The proud daugheter of an Army Korean War veteran.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Matthew Wetherholt, Nelson Twp., Ohio — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:52:44 GMT

I know Lefties will think this guy is a hero, but every person who joins the military (myself included, 20 years ago) KNOWS that combat is a possibility, regardless of what justifications are made for whichever war may happen top break out during your enlistment. You are joining the UNITED STATES MILITARY; put in place to defend, at all costs, the American way of life. If going to a foreign land to fight with combat arms, and risking life and limb is something you are diametrically against, I would suggest you stroll right past the recruiter's office. This man stood in a room with however many other recruits at the MEPS in Downtown Cleveland, raised his right hand and swore to defend America against all enemies, foreign and domestic. He doesn't get to choose his war zone. I hope Germany doesn't set a dangerous precedent and allow this DESERTER, this back-turner, to be freed of his military obligations. I hope he is given an Article 15, discharged dishonorably from the Army, and flown to Leavenworth to serve a long sentence for dereliction of duty and desertion. He is every bit a traitor in my opinion. Prosecute and label him accordingly. To all the Soldiers, Marines, Airmen, and Navy personnel out there who have honored their committments to this great land, God bless you all, and may you return safely to the Hero's welcome you all so richly deserve. (3rd ID, 2/34 FA, Kitzingen, Germany, `88-`89)

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Mike Conner, Charlotte, NC — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 20:59:48 GMT

Sure....grant him political asylum. Then extradite him to the United States to face trail for desertion.

There are far better ways to deal with objectionable aspects of your chosen profession. Bringing dishonor to your comrades, the Army, and the United States was a poor choice.....likely just one of a long series of poor choices this gentleman has made.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

JD, Boise ID — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 21:01:52 GMT

Throw him in jail until he rots, he is a traitor to the United States and his fellow soldiers. I wish there was a way to strip him of his citizenship, he shouldn't ever be allowed to return to the United States and the military should file a civil suit against him in Germany and take back his sign-on bonus.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Remmy ,Tn — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 21:04:32 GMT

What ever happened to personal honor in this country? This guy should be prosecuted and sent to prison just like any other deserter. I hope he does realize that a military court can sentence him to be shot for desertion. Maybe the reality of that would stop these coardly worms from going "AWOL". I spent my time in a hell hole and I didn't whine and run away like a coward. I expect all servcemen to serve with honor.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Jim Reddoch Portland, TX — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 21:06:24 GMT

We have an all-volunteer military. He VOLUNTEERED! If he wants to refuse to fight on moral grounds, then do it the right way and face military justice. They would have slapped him on the wrist and discharged him. This is just attention seeking.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

J. Ainsworth — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 21:09:55 GMT

This is so rich! I knew you didn't have to be smart to join the army, but I didn't know they accepted people that had such a deep and profound respect for the plight of the people of Iraq. I hope the army has the nads to make an example out of this retard when they get him back.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Douglas V. Houghton — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 21:11:20 GMT

Men and women have put on the uniform and taken an oath to defend our nation. No war is ever a popular war. Viet nam was heavily critisized as was Korea. There were even those who felt we should have stayed out of World War I & II. But once you sign the papers and go in you are in until your contract is up. This is not an option. He has deserted and should be punished for his actions. To allow him to get away with this would set deadly precendence.
(U.S. Navy medical corps- '77-'82)

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Peter Gleits — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 21:11:51 GMT

It is and has been an ILLEGAL WAR, all bets (sign-up-promisses) are off. He is a curageous, and brave man and I admire him for his BRAVE actions. Have we had more like him, this country would be far better. We all know that Bush lied about the WMD and he (bush) got us into the war for the OIL. I say again WELL DONE Andre, and may God Bless You.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Ed Smith — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 21:12:10 GMT

He's so upset about the poor civilians? People need to realize that there has never been a war fought in human history in which civilians did not die. Then they can sign up for the military knowing before hand there will be poor civilians.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

reddog - Indiana — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 21:12:25 GMT

For all of you who think it's ok to quit, you must the ones who never finished a project, chore or anything...what have you every produced or provided to society except failure?

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Jim Ausel, Fountain Hills, AZ. — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 21:15:05 GMT

This person volunteered and took an Oath to defend the country and obay the orders of his superiors. When things got "tough", he bailed out i.e. read deserted, and now wants off the hook. You take the ggod with the bad.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

bill hetland, portland, ore — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 21:16:29 GMT

The guys is embarassing... i did my 10 years, you sign up, you are not forced by the way, you do your time... He should be made an example of and locked up, the the other candy butt's might think twice before us citizens spend money and time training for a prosperous future... he is a wuss..

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Scott, Nebraska — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 21:20:28 GMT

First off I proudly served my Country as a US Marine!!

As far as I am concern this Andre is a COWARD and should be thrown in the Brig for years to come!!! He signed the contract to be in the military and he new what he was getting into!!! Since he did join the military 3 years after 9/11 and has seen what was going on over in Iraq from all the media! First off you never ever question the orders that are givin to you by your commanding officer let alone the Commander in Cheif!!!!!! Second do you know why the Iraqi citizens are surprised to see you in this I am coward Please help me group is becasue American is the super power of the world and they know the American Troops are tougher than you are! They have not seen anyone quit like you have and it just shocks them to see that America is weak!!!

What is this guy thinking he joined in 2004 and was problably close to coming to his EAS (End of Active Service). Just should have sucked it up and finished what you started!!

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Pat, Edison, New Jersey — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 21:21:19 GMT

auf Wiedersehen, enjoy your new Country.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Pete Maccini, Nashua, NH — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 21:21:26 GMT

Shame on the US ARMY for not being able to collar this guy as he is having news conferences, and a good ol' time with the Frauleins. I served in Germany and returned home AFTER my enlistment ended. The UCMJ has a long reach for the military service members. Again shame on the JAG / MPs for not having him in the BRIG already.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

jorge — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 21:23:37 GMT

To all Americans,

It's really easy to support a war and the idiot who starts it but there's nothing more sobering than going there to fight in it and see up close what you're supporting. You'll be amazed how fast you will change your mind. Take the case of this man and say to yourselves, "There but for the grace of god go I."

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Alex, Germany — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 21:24:14 GMT

=) Americans already seeking asylum in Germany. Is it really that bad in the US already. Omg we are so awesome for having human rights here. we are like what you call civilised right.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Ron Speer — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 22:48:23 GMT

I wonder if all of you with negative comments have been in a situation like Sheperd's. One can become a concientious objector after being placed in a war zone. What was regular duty before, became a horrible
choice between sanity and freedom. I hope Germany does grant him status to stay there.

yes, I did my time, been to war and served 21 years but I completely understand what Sheperd is going through. For your armchair patriots that have nothing for your country just need to be quiet.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Barbara, Studio City, Ca. — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 22:49:47 GMT

The suicide rate among our soldiers last month was higher than the total killed in action. Something is dreadfully wrong.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

mary — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 22:51:21 GMT

This man signed up willingly to serve our country. He is a selfish individual. Many others have served 2 and 3 if not 4 tours already!
He is uses the the US monies just as those on welfare would do. Germany ship him out and let's court marshall him! He doesn't deserve to even receive monies or be in a foreign country that hides him away

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

P.R. Germany — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 22:51:36 GMT

With all due respect to the military guy’s who believe it’s the best to switch of your brain at the same moment you sign up at the army, history proved you’re wrong.
Millions and millions could have been saved if Soldiers in Nazi Germany would have had a critical though about what to hell they are doing! They also believed doing their job; they are guilty by closing their eyes and follow the Fuehrer.
It’s not harmful to think and especially in the military it should be your duty!

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Ann Brimhall, Anza Ca — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 22:51:36 GMT

Signing up for miltary duty is an honorable thing. This war is not. He signed up to "defend our freedoms", not inflict horrendous injuries on civilians. I'm glad that there are people out there like Shepard who can tell the difference between miltary orders and war crimes. I hope this is the beginning of something huge!
A Brimhall

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Dave the British-American — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 22:51:47 GMT

I'm sorry....he knew what he was getting into when he joined the Military and that was to uphold the American Freedom Value and "OBEY" your Military and Civilian respectivley. There are many Military personel that put their life on the line on a daily basis and even with their objections they get the job done. I'm a brother and I think this type of citizen is not what America stands for. I say let him stay their and give citizenship to someone who "LOVES" what this country stands for.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Clark Gregory; Dallas, Texas — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 00:18:55 GMT

Never been in his shoes, hope I and my children never are. I have to take the experience of the retired soldier for education on this; perhaps there are ways inside the military to reconsider earlier decisions.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

TM Seattle Wash — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 00:21:12 GMT

I went to the sandbox the first time around and I admint it was completely different, but stuff happens send in a SEAL unit he's still US Government property send him to levenworth with all the rest of the usless trash that once called themselves US Servicemen

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

S Laney, Cherry Valley, CA — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 00:22:08 GMT

During this time of conflict, many have paid the ultimate sacrifice to defend and protect this great country of ours. Whether these brothers and sisters in arms agreed to the war or not, they stood, they fought, and they died. Their personal beliefs and convictions suddenly were immaterial; they were now part of something more. They were ordered to go, some leaving young children, husbands, wives, parents surely knowing that soon enough, they would return -
that day never came. Their families struggle to understand. The only solace is knowing they died for what they believed in, something more than their self. When you raise your right hand and swear to protect and defend the constitution of these United States, you are no longer an individual; you now are a part of something more. Soon, your life along with your fellow soldiers is intertwined, each depending on the other. There is no room for individuality, nor personal interest. This individual has done far more than just abandon his country, he has abandoned his fellow brothers in arms. During my 13 years in the Army, paying the ultimate sacrifice was always understood. This individual is a coward, and should never be allowed to step foot on American soil again!

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Austin Nelsen, Indianapolis, IN — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 00:22:13 GMT

I look at most of the comments on here saying "lock him up," "he's a coward," and my personal favorite "he signed up for it." I find it funny that most of these ignorant people haven't served in the military or the ones that have haven't properly looked at law concerning military personal. He signed up to be a US soldier because he believed it would be serving his country. However, when does serving your country cross the line and become killing innocent people, a clearly immoral thing that he believed he was contributing to? Clearly he thought it had crossed this line. To the people who say "this is what he signed up for," where on the contract does it say you will be killing civilians and you must sacrifice your principles? Read Civil Disobedience you mindless conformists! Society is not always right. I would also advise you to broaden your horizons and first read books about the military before you announce your brand of justice. For example, did you know that even though military contracts do not include a clause stating that soldiers can be used as test subjects for new medicine, such as vaccines, the military is allowed to test them on soldiers? And that this is backed by the FDA? Probably not. Kind of defeats the statement "he knew what he was signing up for." Some vets are already experiencing negative effects from medicinal testing, specifically from experimental vaccines for anthrax that incorporated oil based conjuvants which are known harmful substances? I'm aware this is a long winded response but I thought I would attempt to dispel some of the clearly ignorant comments previously made. I support the man who has the courage to stand up for what he believes in, especially in such a totalitarian society that believes they should dictate all appropriate actions.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

D From NY — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 00:22:17 GMT

What a bum I say draw and quarter him. No one likes war BUT he did sign up. Was he that stupid to think he won't go to either Iraq or Afgan?

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Jim Bob — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 00:22:19 GMT

A coward hiding behind bogus morality. Nobody likes the war. But he volunteered. Now he has deserted his comrades. I haope he has to face them someday. Phony, Punk, Quitter!

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

TSgt Jennings, USAF Retired, San Antonio, TX — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:19:14 GMT

I have the same feelings as the majority of military here. I did my 20 honorably, often away from family and friends in foreign lands. Time for this young fellow to grow up, do what's right, turn himself in, do his time and press on. Otherwise he is nothing but a coward, a disgrace to the United States and the military which he served.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

jose, connecticut — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:19:35 GMT

i believe that he has done what he should have done ! i praise him for doing what he feels is right, morally, the militry has the tradition of lieing in order to obtain conscripts and they use patriotism as a tool, it is only and once you are there that you learn the magnitude of what is actually doing that many times you have no choice or dare not make a stance. but only a few are brave enough to stand up and say this is enough.
i believe he loves this country just that he does not agree in becoming a murderer or an accomplice, after all since when did america become a country of blood thirsty murderers? jummm, bush era.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Joe Green, Denver, CO — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:20:25 GMT

Why is it all you people post comments during work hours? Does your employer allow such goofing off?

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

B Blake, Cleveland, Ohio — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:21:05 GMT

What happen to the term "Service To Your Country"!

My family and I have served our country for over four generations, yes that's right back to WWI. We did not sign up because of economic hardship like many of our current generation of soldiers, (thus leads to another issue of motivation and dedication) we did so because we believe in our country. I am an African American and veteran that has a graduate level degree, however if my country called me back to service.... I will drop my computer and coffee mug and return. Why? Because it helps my daughter and family sleep better at night knowing myself others are sworn to protect it!

So to my friend from Cleveland, I am ashamed for you and your love ones. Many have walked to conflict with doubts and questions why, however we finished the walk proudly with the American flag on our uniform!

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Chris, Dallas, PA — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:21:40 GMT

If he believes in something enough to go AWOL, then he has my support. At what point is a person allowed to do what they think is right even when others say it's wrong? Exactly how much of your moral fiber must you abandon in the name of what is right for someone else?

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

former marine texas — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:23:59 GMT

i agree with his man. the war in iraq was a war of terrorist attach by bushy boy & his terrorist asso.correct he did enlist but not to fight in a war quote" bushy he wanted to kill my daddy."i was proud of my service. but i would not fight in this war. they are not a threat to the usa.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Alan Wolin, Colorado Springs, CO — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:28:38 GMT

He gets no sympathy from me. The man has no character and took the path of least resistance.
I served a tour of duty in the U.S. Army during peacetime, and decided it was not the life I wanted.
I finished my three year enlistment,honorably, then did not re-enlist--I did not desert because I was un-happy.
Alan

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Jim — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:29:17 GMT

People have a point, its not like he was drafted, which wouldve been another story all together, the vietnam veterans had it so much worse, but we dont like to talk about it in todays society, its ignored, so as usual nobody seems to know anything, or even realize that the amout of casualties in this war isnt even on the same scale as others, that doesnt mean i think it was just in any way, but i have to admit when you've been misled in history class, by your president, and even your parents are blind enough to watch you go to the sandbox, i cant help but feel some pitty for these kids, they simply didnt realize when they grep up how messed up people really are, and how little thought is really put into military action when its coming from a simple minded cowboy. I read alot and have a vet father, luckily i had the advantage of knowing all this corruption at a very young age, unfortunately, alot of people get a different story....of course from people who werent there....i think he should be punished simply because its law, other then that i couldnt hold animosity towards people like him, thatd be even more cowardly.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

former marin texas — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:29:20 GMT

i think all of these people who belived in this war should volunteer to fight these wars. i bet they would not do it, all they do is running off at the mouth.if the usa was in damage of being attach,i would be the first to go.so loud mouths join for bushy boy fight and see how you like it.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Kristen, NC — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:31:18 GMT

I wonder if he thinks he can call himself an American after this mess he created is over with. When one hides out in another country, fears capture by his former comrades and considers apologizing for actions that are meant to secure the freedom of the US, he not only disgraces himself but every other man and woman that ever put on a uniform.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

ken Hardee — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:31:35 GMT

The guy is embarassing, I did my time in south east asia He should be locked up he is not an American.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Nora Mai, Dixon, CA — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:32:14 GMT

Did anyone think about the Germans wellfare system? My understanding from being stationed there a couple of years back, is that IF this guy gets the Asylum status he will get full medical and uneployment benifits from them(which you can be sure that he didn't pay into) He will get assistance finding employment(if he wants to work - but many German employers would avoid him like the plague due to his actions;he has shown already that he is not reliable)

And I would add that IF he is returned to the Army, he would get slapped with a Dishonorable discharge and have to pay back any wages/bonuses that he do not uurn, but I highly doute he would see Ft. Levenworth; the place is already full to capacity with worse offenders and has the real possiblity of getting much of the Guantanamo prisoners in the near future. He might get a couple months at the Base he would return to.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Ed M. SFC(R), US ARMY. Fort Hood, Texas — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:32:17 GMT

As a soldier you know you may some day have to go to war. The decision made by others matters not. If anyone has such a bad taste for the last administration then run for office yourself since you can obviously run the country so much better. STOP complaining! Cowardly acts such as desertion in a time of war should be met by a firing squad. I do not want my tax dollars wasted on long trials or prison sentances. I do not appologize if I have offended anyone...it's my first ammendment right that I can speak freely. Which reminds me, THANK YOU to every Soldier, Sailor, Marine, Airmen and to our Coast Guard for defending our constitutional rights!
Thanks to my son on his second tour and to my son-in-law getting ready to go.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

John, Arizona — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:34:46 GMT

Why didn't he desert and request asylum in IRAQ while he was there?

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Trish Schiesser — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:34:53 GMT

Have any of you heard of PTSD? (Post Traumatic Stress Disorder.) It seems to me that this man served his time in Iraq and then was re-deployed to Iraq - so he has served his country honorably. Many of the soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan are becoming ill with PTSD, something the news media doesn't advertise - they'd rather call this guy a deserter - yes he went AWOL and is branded a deserter - but think of the circumstances and be aware of PTSD. This may be what is wrong with him and the gov't is ignoring it, and so is the media, ready for another "ripe" and "juicy" story about our servicemen. He has not had any psychiatric tests or been considered he is suffering from PTSD - so cut him some slack because of the fact that at first he did serve his country and followed the oath of a serviceman. You people are so quick to jump to the conclusion that this man is a traitor and should be shot, but if he were your brother or son, or husband, would you not give him a break and perform psychiatric tests to ensure whether he is just another guy who has gone AWOL or that he is suffering, like many of our soldiers over there, from PTSD and other disorders. I am a patriot and love the United States of America and have raised a military family for 48 years and I believe in supporting our country in time of need, no matter what, but you are not considering all of the circumstances. Pretend it is you, and you are suffering from some ailment. What would you do if you were in your right mind? Give the guy the benefit of the doubt until such time as he is proven not guilty or guilty - that is justice speaking.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Ted , New York — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:35:42 GMT

Once you join the military, you can't just pick and choose. You follow the orders of your superiors. Period! You don't all of a sudden get righteous and try to change the game. You support your commander-in-chief and your constitution, whether you agree or not. Whether you like it or not, when you join the military (on your own free will) you agree to become a professional killer. You can't just quit when it doesn't suit you anymore. This guy is a coward and disgrace!

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Scott, Lexington KY — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:36:34 GMT

Illegal war....what a joke.

The US is a soveriegn nation with the right to declare war PERIOD!

The UN did pass over a dozen resolutions, the later ones threatening war. Did you all forget that? Did you think those threats were hollow?

All Saddam had to do was let the inspectors back in, stop killing his own people, and stop shooting at our planes.

IT IS SADDAMS FAULT!!!

Get a clue people! Its not that complicated.

All the BS was just that, but there were real reasons for the war, thats why Congress said OK.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

James Hahn, Fountain Valley, CA — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:39:58 GMT

Today's military is an all volunteer force. This guy was not forced to sign-up and he took the oath to follow all orders especially from the commander-in-chief (Bush). A soldier's duty is to go where he is told and do what he has been trained to do. This guy is a REMF and not even a combat soldier. He had a safe non-combat job in the rear. His actions are selfish and an embarassment to the country. Germany needs to give him back to the US so he can start making little rocks out of big ones in a place called Fort Leavenworth.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

E., Austin, Txeas — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:40:11 GMT

I'm currently joining the Army myself. If you enlist then you know you will be deployed. He needs to be held accountable for his choice and imprisoned in the US. He is a disgrace to our military.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Scott, Lexington KY formerly Darmstadt IN (ironically) — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:41:09 GMT

Alex,

Its better here than there, thats why we have MILLIONS of German immigrants.

This guy had every opportunity for a great life after discharge, but when you desert, you go to jail.

Get over yourself dude!

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Weber, Bremerton, WA. — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:48:20 GMT

As a WWII, Korea, Viet Nam, Veteran plus a few more hot spots besides, I feel he knew that civilians as well as military personal would be killed doing his duty. Believe that the U.S. must deal with Germany and have him returned to stand trial for AWOL. At least for many years in prison. The war time death sentence would only cause protest from all over.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Weber, Bremerton, WA. — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:49:14 GMT

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

James, Aliso Viejo, CA — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:49:55 GMT

So he didn't want to work on Apaches anymore because of all the death and destruction they cause? What about the lives/ soldiers they support and save on the ground? I say if this dude doesn't want to be an American anymore, then kick him to the curb, take his citizanship and be done with it. As a former Marine and Army soldier this guy pisses me off.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

TSB, Nixa, MO — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:52:24 GMT

As the wife of a Green Beret, daughter of a MACVSOG (spelling?) soldier, and granddaughter of an Airborne soldier in WWII, I am sickened. The war was no secret when he enlisted - what did you think you were doing. I hope you get sentenced to a firing squad - I would gladly take ANYTHING out of our personal gun safe and do the job - simply for the fact that you endanger the lives of others around you with your attitude, complacency, cowardess, immaturity, and your traitor attitude! I also have seen both my brothers serve and stood at an airport fence waiting for my uncle to come home from Vietnam when his tour on the USS Ticonderoga was finished.

In fact - I would probably love to administer the firing squad shots with my sons air gun with pointed pellets - it might take a while, but it would give you lots of time to think about your own stupidity - after all, you are in it for the long fight, right? Fight me you traitor!

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Josh McGriff, sumner, Illinois — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:59:17 GMT

i am sick and tired of people whining and crying about the war in iraq. this guy wasnt even stationed in iraq so whats he complaining 4? tell him to suck it up and BE A MAN

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Katherine La Rocco — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 15:59:31 GMT

I was born into a military family. I worked for the militart almost all of my life. I lived in Germany for better than 20 years and understand very well that this young man wants ro stay there. I am a 60 year old woman that hates this war. But to those that say Leavenworth and death to a traitor in time of war - just let this guy go with a dishonorable. If you want a traitor get the people that in a time of war exposed a CIA undercover operative and caused untold danger to her network and herself for the horrendus crime of being married to an honest man. THERE ARE YOUR TRAITORS. Not this young man looking for a future in a country with 10% unemployment.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Jim Nashville TN — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:05:33 GMT

I believe he has a right to stand up against this war and what he feels is wrong.

Despite the fact he so called 'signed up' I wish alot of you people flipping out that statement where forced to serve in a war you do not beleive in.

Facts are these are different times and that war was illegal.

I hope in the end everyone does the right thing which is letting him out of the military.

The recruiters in this country CON young men and women still in high school every day to join and I think thats illegal as well.

Feeding them BS all the while just trying to meet their quota for the month.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Greg, Portsmouth NH — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:06:06 GMT

Brave man? more like a coward, all AWOL soldiers suddenly become objectors when they decide they want out.. send him to a military jail if he doesn't want to be part of the "illegal war" to finish up his time, when he signed up was he not reading the papers or watching the news? did he feel that he would be special and remain state side or on a safe base? when you join the military its not a free ride war could be declared at any time so man up you coward.. and yes I was in for 6 years.. you had what less than a year to go when you went AWOL.. LOSER..

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Nick, U.S. Navy (Retired) — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:06:48 GMT

For Peter Gleits, The President can send us into a conflict anytime he wants. There is NOTHING illegal about it. Try doing some research before you make an A$$ out of yourself in public.
As for André Shepherd, he is a COWARD and a disgrace to the country.
As with all deserters, military life is great when you are reaping the benefits, but they suddenly "Grow a Conscience" when they have to actually do the job that the taxpayers are paying them for.
He should do 20 years in Leavenworth.
For everyone that is considering joining the Military, YOU DON'T GET TO PICK YOUR WAR!

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Kelly C — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:06:52 GMT

Lets see he joined up in 04. If I am not mistaken that was when the worst of the fighting was going on.
So he didnt know?
Sound like a crock of poo to me. I was stationed in Korea for a year and saw many guys get involved with the cheap drink and girls. Then make some bad choices. You would be suprised all the stories that come out when they try to explain the stuff they did and why.
Time to ruck up punk. If you dont want to pull down on the bad guys. So be it. But you still have to get in the dirt with the rest of us and pull you own wheight.

How many soldiers do you think there would be if every time some policy maker made a mistake they quit? Not many, Policy makers are best at making mistakes. They have that down to a sience.
Read your history. not one war plan ever made it past the 1st mistake. Its our soldiers ability to over come and adapt that saves the day and protects you ass.
Throw this guy in the brig and move on.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Dana O Lawton, Oklahoma — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:11:14 GMT

This guy knew what he was getting into. I did 21 years in the US Army and initially joined while VietNam was still going hot and heavy. I knew there was a very good chance that I could be sent to VietNam and would have gone if that is what would have happened. For him to decry the uncivility of war is absolutely ludicrous. People die in war each and every day. Did we need to go into Iraq? Absolutely not. But that still does not excuse his actions in any way. Hell, he never even had a shot fired at him in anger. Give me a break, and him the death penalty for desertion!!

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

LOU, NewRochelle,N.Y. — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:12:52 GMT

I'm a Vetnam Veteran and proud of it! I enlisted prior
to that War. When I was sent there I served even though I didn't really agree with the baloney about the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution. President Kennedy would
not have sent us. I did my duty and was proud of it even though I was afraid plenty of times. I never killed anyone who didn't try to kill me. Andre Shepard
is simply a low life.The men in Irak are better off
without him. I have news for him the Germans don't have much love for him either.I know I spent a lot of
great times in Germany and they don't like cowards very much. They will be giving him his exit papers soon enough! His best bet is to find Binladin and collect the reward. He can kiss the U.S.A. goodbye
forever.Imagine if Germany drafted him. That's something for him to think about.If he stays he serves otherwise come back and be a man if he can!
He should be informed that the GESTOPO know his every
move. He would have had a better chance in France.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

60 Year old Grandmother, Green Valley, AZ — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:12:54 GMT

I do not agree with the war either; however, I joined the Army in 1966(right out of HS) and was stationed at Walter Reed. I have to admit I would do it over again; I was discharge honorably in 1967 due to pregnancy. I later joined the Florida National Guard in 73. From there I did two 2 year tours as a reservist and enjoyed every bit of it. Would I fight for my country? You bet I would. He knew when he joined that he could be deployed; however, it is sucha shame that these men and women have to deploy numerous times(I think due to a smaller military force). He needs to be returned to the US.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

craig rudder pasadena md — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:15:12 GMT

Mr Shepherd evidently enlisted for benefits,money school etc.Now that the taxpayers have provided him a service,he feels he no longer wants to pay us back by finishing his commitment.Although I don't always agree with our goverment decisions about going into war,ask the jewish where they would have been if we had not gotten involed in the war against Hitler.
I proudly served my country in the Vietnam era.I was fortunate to serve aboard the aircraft carrier Forrestal in 1967 along with john Mccain.And if I were not too old I would do it again.
The problem today our youth want everything given to them up front for free.nothing in life is free especially freedom.I think this man should be brought to justice,but a long term jail sentence would not do us justice ,Brand him a traitor and make him pay for all the school and benifits he recevied.or leave him in germany never to set foot on us soil again

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

K Spurgeon, Titusville,FL — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:17:10 GMT

I'm a veteran also, but I don't agree with what the Shrub did, illegally, in my name. If he goes to jail, he should share one with the Shrub and be sentenced to no more time than the Shrub gets for sending him, and the others like him, to Iraq.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

PK5 — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:18:29 GMT

Okay, just responding to these few thoughts and, then, I'll give my own, You joined the service to FIGHT AND DEFEND your country and the CONSTITUTION. If you go AWOL during wartime you are punishable by death so I hope they get this coward.
Andy Romero, Oxnard, Ca (Sent Thursday, February 05, 2009 3:31 PM)

Okay, Andy, does YOUR view extend to shooting former president "W"? Because whenever someone said something HE didn't "like" about his "job" to PROTECT AND DEFEND THE CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES, (a VOW he took as he was VOLUNTARILY SWORN INTO THE OFFICE OF PRESIDENT OF THESE UNITED STATES, a "long, hard fight to win his 'bid' for office"!), he would respond with such "cutesy" statements like, "Stop shoving the Constitution in my face - it's JUST A PIECE OF PAPER!"

Ahem - now then, one other thing - the ARMY, and ALL of the ARMED FORCES have been trolling high schools and utilizing "sales tactics" to get people to sign on the dotted line - at the time when most of these people signed up, I'm pretty sure that the financial outlooks they had were pretty bleak, and whatever arm of the forces they signed into probably "offered" them "training" they could "use" in the private sector - I don't know about you, but, I'm not so sure there's a lot of call for people who used to "kill" or helped same in the private sector - unless you're going into "special black ops" or some other thing that most knee-jerk liberals worry about.

Both sides have to weigh in - and it's going to take time. That said, there are a LOT of people who DIDN'T want to send their kids to the War - mostly Congressial Representatives and Senators - and again, CONGRESS didn't send anyone to war - that was Bush's "call" - remember all that flack over his "unilateral action" WITHOUT Congressional "approval"?

Just think of it - this war will be remembered as the war that "BUSH" "used" our kids as his "private army"!

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Travis R. Coleman — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:23:24 GMT

Let's face it the war we are waging in Iraq was for Bush and Chaney to line their pockets (Haliburton, Blackwater) and the pockets of their wealthy friends (Saudi's). We took out the stablizing power in the region being Sadam Hussien insane, and now we have mess on our hands. We knew where Binladen was and we failed to go there sending in a small amount of troops. Instead we went into Iraq,now after spending billions of dollars and the loss of life we are no safer.We are in the wrong country with the war on terror knowing Iraq had nothing to do with 911. I don't support the war in Iraq, but I do support the troops, because they go where they are told. That's what you do when you are a soldier. I can't support him deserting, he made the choice to join. He knew what was happening when he walked into the recruiters office. He is no better than any of the other service members who are doing their jobs and taking the risk.If he had reservations he should have never joined, now he needs to man up do his duty take his lumps and move on. We are wasting to much print on this deserter while others of much higher praise are serving.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

PATRICK HENRY, OREGON — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:32:58 GMT

WHAT DID THE TROOPS DIE FOR IN VIETNAM? WHAT ARE OUR TROOPS DIEING FOR IN IRAQ WHEN BUSH SR.HAD IRAQ SEWED UP BEFOR BUSH Jr. STARTED HIS TWO CRUSADES WHICH BOTH WILL FAIL IN DUE TIME? I CAN SEE BOMEING AFGANSTAN FOR 9/11 AND TELL THEM IF THEY DO IT AGAIN THAT THEIR ROCKS WILL GLOW NEXT TIME. I FEEL SORRY FOR OUR TROOPS FOR THIS TOTAL WASTE OF BUSH Jr. AND YOU NEVER SAW HIS GIRLS IN THE MILTARY.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Chris Martin — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:34:33 GMT

Why don't all you cowards instead of writing negative comments at the comfort of your homes join the army and go to Iraq. Lots of innocent people have lost their lives and it's not their wish to be born in a war torn country. Killing innocent people is not right, even if Americans think it is!!!!

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Flip Turner, USN(ret) — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:35:19 GMT

This soldier changed his mind about his obligations for reasons I find totally unjustified. He should be handed over to the military, awarded a court-martial and if found guilty given a dishonorable discharge, all benefits and pay removed coupled with an appropriate time to be served in a military prison. He volunteered having full knowledge of his responsibilites to his nation, his family and his self-pride. He has failed them all.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

gabriel lujan, austin, texas — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:40:53 GMT

You sign up, put on the uniform and give an oath. You just dont desert your country and duty, because you dont like the war...this is pathetic. but i have to give this man his due. he is very brave. and he is standing up for what he believes in. so i wish him well.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

ajs — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:41:53 GMT

The invasion of Iraq may not be right and many may not agree w/ it. But he did voluntarily join the Army and he knew he would probably end up in Iraq. He needs to just carry out his duties that he swore to follow, after that then he can do whatever he pleases. As for calling him a hero Kathy Campione' I dont think so. It seems that word gts thrown around way too much these days. He isnt a hero hes a deserter.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

30 year Retired Army, — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:41:54 GMT

This coward thinks he is more special than the 800,000 other troops over in Iraq and Afganistan? Sounds like he signed up got the bonus now he don't want to play anymore. Right or wrong he signed a contract. Snivel waaa, the military or the USA don't need candy asses like him!!! This guy didn't even have a combat job!!! He was a mechanic for goodness sake!!!

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Jeanne Danner, Bowie, Maryland — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:42:25 GMT

He's a deserter and should be treated as such

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Norm Sam — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:42:31 GMT

I have heard on radio some folks who call themselves conscientious objector rather than deserters.
per chance he can formally become one after his service rather than be a deserter

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Glen Scutt — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:42:43 GMT

34 years in the army. Most people did not read carefully. The young man served honorably in Iraq. He matured. He did not want to go back to what he came to believe a bad war. He will pay a price for his beliefs. Our entire country is paying such a price now. That doesn't mean he is a bad man or that the United States is a bad country. We just acted immaturely.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

SrA Snuffy — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:42:44 GMT

This guy is a disgrace to anyone in ANY country who wears a uniform, much less to his own. At least in America it's volunteer to join the military, not forced. He should be glad he is getting the right to fight back against his boss, even if it is Uncle Sam. I joined in 2004 too, I knew what was going on, I knew what I was getting into, and I didn't agree with it all, but at the same time, I agreed with the fact that someone has to be out there to defend the states. And for all of you counting him as brave, or smart or whatever, think about it. Would you really want this guy watching your back in anything? If he doesn't agree with everything, your back is gonna get stabbed.

If you don't stand behind the troops, please, feel free to stand in front of us!!!

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Jenny, S.C. — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:46:10 GMT

Good for him! This war is highly Un-Constitutional, so this whole "he took an oath to defend our country and constitution" pretty much goes out the window. Yes, he enlisted after 9/11, but like many soldiers, he didn't realize the WHOLE situation and start to question things until he saw it with his own eyes. Is he not allowed to question things and come to a different conclusion? I applaud this young man, for standing up for something and trusting his instincts. There are plenty of other soldiers out there who 100% believe in what they're doing and fighting for, so why make this man continue? Everyone knows this war is wrong. Over 1 million innocent Iraqi's have lost thier lives since we invaded. It almost seems inhumane in a way to make someone go out there and do something that they believe is comepletely wrong.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

20-yr airman — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:52:24 GMT

I agree that he signed up for this gig, and should expect to see deployment to a war zone when he did. But the war is illegal, official investigations have determined America was lied to by Bush et al to get us in it and if he doesn't have to play by the rules, why should the average soldier? We are taught to lead by example in the military and the example he was shown by the administration and those military leaders above him blindly towing the company line certainly didn't teach him to do the right thing as they didn't. The whole thing is bad and in the big picture, this soldier's screw up is NOTHING compared to the lies, cheating and manipulation of those above him.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Timmeh — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:52:42 GMT

Punk. I'm a veteran and these gutless punks who join the military after the "Illegal" war (which it isn't) then complain that they don't believe in it. Throw the punk in Leavenworth!

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Mad coyote — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:54:56 GMT

AHEM......
as for you folks that say you are "proud" of this individual for deserting his post , running away, protesting .. whatever you want to call it. it does not matter.

anyone can quite easily see that your thoughts and comments are politically motivated and unfortunately at the most base level, simply just self serving.

For anyone to abandon their friends, team mates, family, fellow soldiers or their country speaks clearly about the worth of that individual.

as far as what will happen to him, i will be very curious to see. i hope that justice is done in the eyes of all the brave men and women who defend our rights , our freedom and our country.

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Scazar, Saint Louis, MO — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:58:09 GMT

I love the silly mentality than an oath that you willingly makes it ok for you to do things that are unethical. Amusingly enough that is the same argument that the SS used during Nuremberg. "I took an oath to follow orders, and I was just following orders as I ordered my einsatzgruppen to roll through those occupied russian exterminating jews"

If you were in the military and your CO ordered you to shoot an innocent civilian, would you follow it? Now if your answer is yes, well you are a piece of **** human being. If your answer is no, how far is being ordered to repair a chopper that kills civilians from being ordered to kill that civilian yourself?

I'm not saying the man is right or wrong, i'm not him, i've never been in his situation. But I will say that the man is not a coward as it takes far more courage to stand up for what you believe in the face of adversity, knowing that you will be **** upon by the ignorant masses who know nothing of your life, than it does to blindly follow orders.

The true fault of this situation lies upon the Bush Administration for creating a situation where this man has to choose between his moral/ethical obligations as a human being and his oath as a soldier. When you send men to fight, kill, and die you had best be certain beyond a shadow of a doubt that you are in the right. Of course that is something I doubt most of the fools here can grasp.

Hermann Goering (head of the Luftwaffe, german air force in WWII for the ignorant amongst us) once said (at Nuremberg) "of course the people don't want war. But after all, it's the leaders of the country who determine the policy, and it's always a simple matter to drage the people along whether it's a democracy, a fascist dictatorship, or a parliament, or a communist dictatorship. Voice or no voice, the people can always be brought to the bidding of the leaders. That is easy. All you have to do is tell them they are being attacked, and denounce the pacifists for lack of patriotism, and exposing the country to greater danger"

U.S. deserter seeks asylum in Germany

Scott, Lexington KY — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:59:48 GMT

Jenny in SC,

You have no clue. 1 million Iraqis dead? Wrong, where are the graves?

All innocent? Wrong, if they dont shoot, they dont get shot!

Unconstitutional? How so? You cant answer because congress approved according to the law.

And NO, soldiers have no right to question the mission, none at all. Ever read the oath?