Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Martin Beveoze Basrah, Iraq — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 12:11:47 GMT

Working out of the Green Zone as a Contractor and having been too Dora several times (was there 3 days ago), yes, things are slightly better, tentatively, everything is dependent on security provided by US troops.

Abit taken back with and scratching my head over Mr Maceda comment "Keeping Al-Qaida at bay", if he kept track with figures trickling out of the Green Zone, you would know that less than 3 percent of all violent activity is attributed to Al-Qaida, the remainder is civil disputes into what has become a on going power struggle over which sect, clan or leader will control the real prize, and that is Iraq's huge Oil reserves in Kirkuk and Basrah.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Laura Campione' Boston, MA — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 12:18:27 GMT

Unbelieveable the huge amount of citizens, who are totally dependent on our security presence. What will happen to these people if our troops pull out?

We brought all this misery to the Iraqis, by invading their country (for what many feel were false reasons), we owe it to them to stay in there at least another 20 years until they can get back on their feet.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

satchel, tampa,florida — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 14:12:58 GMT

is it just me or does this story have a negative tone. even though they subject matter is positive , it seems like the reporter went out of their way to put a pessimistic spin on things. but anyhow good to be hearing good things about Iraq. keep up the good job over their guys, god bless you and be safe.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Robert G. Fairfield CT — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 14:42:01 GMT

I wonder what Nancy Pelosi, Harry Reid and yes, the beloved Barack Obama have to say about this story. On MSNBC's website no less.

Watch 'em bob and weave.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

K Wills, Austin, Texas — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 14:50:42 GMT

That's a good question and here's another: Why do Americans have to pay, in both blood and treasure, to police and rebuild their neighborhoods?

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

jack doyle — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 14:52:47 GMT

Isn't it nice we are patrolling the neighborhoods of Iraq while our Mexican border is wide open to invaders of all kinds year after year and our inner cities have five,six seven drive by shootings every day with no cops or troops to prevent the slaughter.
It's nice that we dump suitcases full of money on Iraqi chieftans and mini potentates to "calm them" and build blast proof walls to "protect them"
It is good to be kings of another country while they charge us $140 per barrel for oil.
We and our troops are dupes.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

jack doyle — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 14:53:12 GMT

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Ron New Port Richey FL — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 14:55:06 GMT

Wow, a positive story regarding the war in Iraq! I didn't think American news outlets were allowed to publish positive stories. Whats next, might we be able to win this war?

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

dsells chicago, il — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 14:55:42 GMT

These kind of stories are encouraging and I hope to see more of them as security improves. However, I have to chuckle whenever I see these positive stories and notice the absence of liberals and their comments. I'm still waiting to see a post condeming the Bush admin. and the "neocons", maybe its still too early...

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Liberty, Atlanta, GA — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 14:57:04 GMT

Nice to hear a positive story as it seems the mainstream liberal press and the Democrats have suddenly forgotten their Iraq agenda of failing miserably and now take up the economy issue. The only reason we lost in Vietnam was lack of backbone to get the job done. Let's not forget this time around what became a ralleying cry for our enemies around the world (Vietnam) and stick it out as a democracy emerges that may lead to long term stability in the region. Most people are too short sighted in their day to day lives to see the impact of a free democracy in the Mideast.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Dave, Sacramento, CA — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 14:57:35 GMT

Holy cr@p, positive news out of Iraq! Will wonders never cease?!

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

The Truth Hurts, Earth, Milky Way — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 14:58:53 GMT

not long i would guess. we don't want them to be to safe to fast or we have no present fake reason to be there. A rocket will sail over the wall in a few weeks and then periodically after that. Our top brass could let loose our troops, but they won't, not to fast anyway. Just like the current adminstration fooled us into the war, it will order the army politicians ( generals who's real mission is to keep control over red blooded american warriors so that they don't do the right thing all the way) which is all the officer corp is, they aren't necessary to actual combat and every grunt knows this. all the money all the time could have been used to erect a virtual fence of patrols and border walls But the repubs need insugency violence to make the cause to stay. If Iraquis wanted freedom they would have fought for it, but they didn't so they must have liked it. We like being puppets, controlled by corporations and Big "Sneeky" Govt. Govt. is the same as it's ever been, they want the money for themselves, while dem. big govt wants it for everyone. There's nothing more pitiful then a regular person who thinks because they register as a member of the republican party, that they are actually a member. Same goes for Dems. YOU DON"T COUNT!! not anymore, not like the Sons of Liberty did back in day, back in Boston.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

ZFR, Atlanta, GA — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:01:39 GMT

Dear Mr. Maceda:

Reporters like we listen to them. You are bringing the truth to the Americans from the boiling points of the world. I say to you keep safe and I thank you for your historic reporting.

For Lt. Justin Chalvko, the American army officer responsible at mid town Dora, I say to Lt. Justin, your work will never be forgettable to the Dorans people, you deserve to be called "Mr. Dorans" for all the good work and pationate heart you showed the people in that volatile area of Baghdad. Just couple of months ago no one can walk the streets. Keep continue the good work you are doing and enjoy your spare and relaxing time with the Iraqis, because once they know you are a man of dignity and peace, they will protect you with their lives. It is you and your friends that has changed the war picture in Iraq. At the begining of 2003 the Iraqis thought that they had a good chance to change to the better in their lives after 40 years of dictatorship. But soon they recognized that the plan of invation had many weaknesses and cap points which resulted the divsion, the killing and the lack of security in the Iraqi community. It is your work and the work of your friends is gardually changing this picture and winning the heart and mind of the Iraqis once again, and remember once they trust you, they will never want you to go away. Lt. Justin, you will see that some will cry when the time comes to say bye for you to come back home. Keep your self safe when you patrol the streets of Dora, because always there are bad boys. Keep your self in a high spirit and rememebr that your good work is not only serving your country but serving the entire world community and the peace process on earth.

I thank you and I salute you Lt. Justin Chalvko. I also thanks reporter Jim Maceda for his amazing reporting to bring the facts to the beautiful American people.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Susan Jones — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:02:11 GMT

It is a start, Hope and pray to God they can hold it together and we can come home. Which, we should have never been there in the first place.
But as the old saying is Somewhere in Texas they are missing their village idiiot George Bush

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

alan — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:05:49 GMT

it's good to hear a truthful story for once, it's good to hear about people going back in living in peace. it's good to read the truth about the hard work, our service people are doing and the friendships they are building, it's good to hear about different factions working together and living in relative harmony. why can't we see more success stories ,about the good in people,like this, i'm sure there are many.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Ed, Virginia Beach, VA — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:06:02 GMT

The very first line: "Dora, in Saddam’s time, had it all." Yes, life in Iraq was sunshine and candy canes! Everyone was happy - we should all have been priveleged to live under Saddam's golden rule! This article is emblematic of today's media m.o. - everything in Iraq was great until the mean ol' Americans showed up, spin positives into negatives, give no credit to the president or our military - and if you have do, do it cautiously and grudgingly. Heaven forbid you expose the real successes happening all over Iraq - that would blow the hate-Bush, hate-military, hate-America template out of the water!

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

PJ — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:10:38 GMT

What does "Winning the War" mean? Our president and many others are saying we are winning the war! What exacly does that mean? Who wins what?

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Ken Stovall,Orangeburg, SC — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:10:55 GMT

Maceda just had to put a negative comment at the end of his otherwise extremely positive report. I wonder why there can't be more positive reports coming out of Iraq and why any positive report isn't getting covered on the nightly news.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Doug Webster, Tulsa, OK — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:15:05 GMT

Nice job Jim, right up to the end, that is. Why can't a positive piece be positive throughout? I think your quip at the end regarding the bank was not only unnecessary, but underlies the pessimism that is pervasive throughout the mainstream media. I know death and destruction is more spectacular to report than happiness and prosperity, but anyone who has beaten the odds like the citizens of Dora should have their moment in the sun without speculating on their ultimate success or failure.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

tom mechenbier Columbus, ohio — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:17:10 GMT

thank god for a positive press release. Now, if the McCain camp isnt smart enough to capitalize on this press, dont come crying to me when Obama, as the new prez, surrenders in the midst of these successes. Wake up John, you aint that charismatic!! and not you're going to ride in on your looks!!

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

keith, NY — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:17:19 GMT

mission accomplished! call the troops home.

the only way iraq will stand on its feet is when we give everyone a gun and last man standing rules the country. seems to be whats going on now. how many hundreds of thousands are dead? shock and awe, too bad its we americans who are now shocked by the waste and awed at the number of dead.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Scotty T, Milford, Ohio — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:22:57 GMT

Well I think that it is great that we here something good for once. I enjoy hearing about improvements both here in our own country and around the world. I have been getting sick of the librals only allowing the negative news to filter through so that they can fulfill there own political agendas.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Paul, Ohio — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:23:23 GMT

"Now we are living in stability and security. It’s like a precious gem, something very fragile that you have to take care of." Tell Barack Obama, John Kerry, and every other soft democrat who whines about the US going to Iraq being unjustified to put that in their pipes and smoke it. While it is early, and Dora is not reflective of all of Iraq, this is very intriguing. And while we're on the subject tell the Iranian Ayatollah that the "presence of foreign occupiers" is clearly not the problem in Iraq, that clown. This is what we do here in America. We're not perfect, not even close, but we know a few things about personal freedoms, and no one in their right mind will argue that having them isn't a special thing. Now, if only ourselves as a country, can begin to act humanely towards one another and cut all the selfish BS out, there might be hope for the future of our kids. The economy is rough, costs of everything are going up, this is not a new occurence. What is scary though is when a man gets hit by a car (reference Hartford, Connecticut incident) and nobody makes a move to help him. I would have been in that street a quarter second after he got hit trying to do something, anything. Thats the level of citizenship and comraderie that we need to get back to as a country. Focus on the small things, the "hello's" and small acts of kindness - one at a time. Wake up American citizens, no one is going to do this for us, we must take action ourselves to create the type of environment that we want to live in. Now is a perfect time to start.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

dave smith — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:23:46 GMT

well by the looks of some of the above blogs , it seems to me that now all of a sudden conservatives think that georges revenge war is now a noble venture . they refuse to accept that they and most of us were dupped into this huge blunder by the current administration!

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Evans E. Pate Jr, Detroit, Mi — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:25:05 GMT

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Rob Harding, Longmont, Colorado — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:25:15 GMT

Those who critize, what are you doing for America's
freedom? Sunday morning quarterbacks will always have
comments after the fact. You have to deal with the hand your dealt and try to correct our mistakes and move forward. We are a better country if we deal with each other honestly, not always politically. The story is just one story told where there a hundreds not being told. God does bless America and all people willing to make the right choices in life.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Lonnie D Cross Facatativá, Cundinamarca — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:26:49 GMT

Thank God for some positive news for a change.

Lonnie D Cross
Colombia SA

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Howard Salem, Oregon — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:29:49 GMT

It is good that our troop can provide the Iragi people with safe and security. All those who reported news should be reporting good new like these.Instead pounding on the negavity issue all the time. I am a refugee from Asia and I know about war and suffering.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

dennis michael — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:30:05 GMT

It is encourging to see one spot,that christians for
the time being are safe and that that the people see
democracy,one time in their lives.That is what my nephew died for in this war.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Shorty,Tampa,Florida — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:30:14 GMT

It figures,this story has been out before 8:00 A.M. EST and there is not one comment about something good happening in Iraq.The Iraqi ppl need news like this to know it can and will happen if they work together with out the involvement of terrorist countries like Iran ans Syria trying to screw things up.Then again I guess it is hard to bash when your eating crow !!!

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Robert, St. Louis, MO — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:31:47 GMT

Just yesterday I filled out a survey where I basically said I had no faith whatsoever in anything related to NBC. With stories like this I may have to re-think my position a bit

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Bri — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:32:27 GMT

No WMD? Tell that to the hundreds of thousands that were killed by Saddam's WMD.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

J Kaswell — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:33:15 GMT

Life is so great as depicted--watched over by massive US troop presence.Any more of these showcases and we'll need several more surges.Guess it's all worth a shredded US economy,increasing populations of Jihaders and,reputation as SS-type torturers,billions of bucks disappearing into
Cheney's fraud factory and a generation of mutilated & PTS vets--Again,"Iraq--What For?"

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Tim G, Perry, OH — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:37:40 GMT

So we Americans bring a few months of suspect peace to one neighborhood in Iraq and that is supposed to make up for 6 plus years of killing over a matter that was not our business in the first place? Hooray for Bushies/Clintonites (Bill Clinton’s Administration is just as much to blame for this failed policy as is Bush and Bush Sr. – Iraqi Liberation Act of 1998). You have to be kidding me.

The deflation of the US dollar and inflation of our prices by the Federal Reserve is what we have to pay for in order for the American taxpayer to rebuild what we have destroyed. The fact is our country is at stake because of these liberal spending programs and war mongering. Do you think the Iraqis will be there to bomb us and then help us when our currency goes the way of the Deutsch Mark did during the great world wars? All of you lemmings that think this is good news are just being fooled by the same mainstream media that fooled the American public to believe the war was just.

Let’s not also forget that the Democrats were brought in with a “mandate” from the American people to stop this war. In fact, Pelosi had a bill withdrawn that was dealing with the Iranian problem and was to be used to reaffirm the need for Congress to declare war and not a dictatorial President. Too bad Pelosi listened to our “friend” Israel and took down the bill. You all have been bilked for too long.

“We marched right in there and we can march right out.” – Ron Paul

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

mike hogan, philadelphia, pa — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:44:09 GMT

Winning the War refers to the fact that the United States Military, with support from Iraqi forces and Sunni militants who have turned against al-queda are kicking the terriorists butts. Even though this was also true in Vietnam (and before any liberal yahoos challenge that remark please google tet offensive) it was a combination of the msm and the democratic politicians who raised the white flag of surrender (kinda like the O man)with the liberal commentator and news icon walter cronkite pronouncing the war as unwinnable and boobus americanus meekly accepting (or simply too lazy or ill informed to challenge)this lie.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

dennis michael — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:44:25 GMT

It is encourging to see one spot,that christians for
the time being are safe and that that the people see
democracy,one time in their lives.That is what my nephew died for in this war.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Rex Harvey, California — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:44:41 GMT

I was always under the impression the a good, no a great reporter, reports the news with facts, “Invasion” I would think that MSNBC would prefer actual facts on the home page.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Tom, in PA — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:45:25 GMT

Oh, I agree with Paul from Ohio, it must be KILLING Harry Reid and Pelosi, and all of their ilk, especially Obama, that there is good news coming out of Iraq. My bet is on Obama never visiting Iraq. Know why? He'll have to state the obvious, i.e., there is stability and good news. He'll never do that! Why? He'll lose the election, pure and simple.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Mike — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:46:17 GMT

Great Story . >I'm proud of our President and our troops ! .

Liberals will try to downplay it . !

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Priscilla McDaniel Overton, Texas — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:47:17 GMT

I am so happy the Christians in Iraq are able to attend their churches ...It can't be easy struggling to maintain faith in an Infidel land. God Bless Bush and our troops...Doing the right thing is never the easy road..But God is watching all of this..God Bless America..and a President who did not blink...

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Kevin G. Roselle, IL. — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:51:08 GMT

Evans E,

What information do you have that factually states "we are less safe" since "the invasion"? What information do you have that factually states "the invasion" doubled the price of gas?

Make sure you can back up your "facts" before you start spewing your liberal, divisive, anti-conservative, blather.

Give it a rest. It's an encouraging story at a minimum.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Betsy — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:51:30 GMT

For all those LIberals who think that this is a BUSH war, look up on YouTube, Clinton/Iraq. In his on words, back in 98 talking about Saddam and WMD. Just Clinton didn't have the balls to do something about it.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

ken, Indianapolis — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:51:39 GMT

Why is there such a differing view between those Americans who have stood up and worn the uniform and served their country and those who have just sat back and taken all the freedoms that they have not protected?

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Chris, Omaha, NE — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:52:01 GMT

I think we can all agree that we hope this kind of security lasts. But that's the point isn't it? How many times before have we heard of improving security conditions only to be blindsided by how quickly and utterly they fall apart (Tal Afar anyone)? Bear in mind that the Sons of Iraq on our payroll, receiving $300 a month to not attack U.S. troops or ferment sectarian animosity and the increased troop presence. Couple that with with an uneasy cease-fire from the major Shiite factions and their militias and you still have a potentially combustible situation, kept at bay by a U.S. presence that, in essence, keeps a physical barrier between Sunni and Shiite belligerents. None of this security would be sustainable without that physical barrier, and U.S. troops cannot be expected to keep this up much longer. The strain on them has been too great and too unfair for too long (and don't get me started on the shoddy treatment so many receive when they come home). This situation for American troops is especially true if the Iraqi government and their military doesn't get their act together soon. Keep in mind also that the some or maybe most of the stories we've been hearing about Iraqi troops "taking the lead" in various security operations may be exaggerations perpetrated by a nervous American military and presidential administration, meant to paint a better picture than the one reality does (This was reported by Time magazine some two or three weeks ago). If something else doesn't rise up to replace the troop presence in places like Dora, then all we seem to be doing is delaying the inevitable. That said, I hope this takes, I really do. Iraq and the U.S. military has suffered an enormous amount of punishment at the hands of a war that Bush and his administration misled or outright lied the American people into and it needs to end. 4000+ troops dead and 600+ billion dollars wasted is probably enough for an erroneous war.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Kevin Johnson, Minneapolis, MN — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:52:10 GMT

I hope the liberal NBC news had this approved by the Obama campaign before it went to print. Otherwise, it will undermine his commitment to an immediate withdraw. NBC news surely wouldn't do that to its preferred candidate.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

MV, LBK, TX — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:52:28 GMT

As the mother of a future army solider, it is rather comforting to see positive things happening in Iraq. I am not naive to think that there is no danger. We are blessed to be the greatest nation in the world for we are not just one race but many who live in harmony. We are not a perfect nation but God has given us much and although we are critized here and abroad for this war and Afghanistan we are still a leader in this world who must show the other "older Nations" that this is what a true leader does with or without their approval. We must help those in need.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Todd Tracy — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:53:56 GMT

Keep Reporting the good news out of Iraq. There are more stories like this every day, but the news always wants to report bad news, because bad news people like reading.. Sad.. I would like to read more good new about the US and Iraq...

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Alex — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:55:54 GMT

OK, life is better in Dora when US troops are policing the area. It is interesting that some people appear to think that this fact alone is a proof that we should be there. Oh, we could also be fighting the crime in Johannesburg or Grozny and the life would improve in those places. So ?

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Tom in PA — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 15:57:54 GMT

Dear Dennis, sincere thanks and appreciation to your son for serving our country. I'll peel the layers off of this onion: Iraq will become the millstone around the neck of the Democratic Party. Their constant negativity and lies have come full circle; I state this in spite of the left-wing media that is an utterly corrupt vestige of their Party.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

L M Davidson Chandler AZ — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:02:02 GMT

It is the responsibility of everyone who takes a breath in freedom to do all that they can to provide that opprotunity to all of humanity. There are word in our history books that state "all that is necessary for evil to prevail is for good men(and women) to do nothing. is this a long road? YES is it worthwhile? YES is it costly? Yes is it necessary you will have to answer this yourself, but for this service connected disabled American Veteran I believe it is. We forget and disrespect the sacrafice of all who have fought and died for this principle in all the wars of history. Success come with perseverance and we can not walk away from this. I am thankful for this story and it's real message to the people of the world

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

MV, Lbk, TX — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:03:57 GMT

This is a good story. I am proud of our President, too. If being a world leader was so easy than everyone would be trying to get the job. I admire our President for sticking to his guns and what he felt was right at the time. I just wish everyone would quit calling him names because we all do the same thing with our jobs we have made good and bad decisions. He didn't do anything really. Congress had to approve the decision to invade Iraq. He cannot start a war by himself nor can he stop mother nature from doing harsh things to the world or stop the gas prices from going up. But then again if we don't blame President Bush then who do we blame? God perhaps?

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Sheky, Chicago IL — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:04:11 GMT

I expect Mr. Maceda, who dared write something positive about Iraq, will be banned from all Liberal coffee shops, cocktail lounges, and outhouses where the knee-jerk liberals imbibe. The unfortunate problem is that the liberal press' psycho-trauma machinery has 'positioned' Iraq as 'bad'. Few will want to go thru the mental exercise of revisiting their beliefs in light of new evidence. Instead of denigrating the piece, his editor, if interested in how many more Doras exist, if really interested in finding out if things are really changing... he can go or send more people back in to find out. Especially, he should send people who were there before.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Andy Bogart, Seattle, Washington — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:10:21 GMT

I'm put off by your placing of an image of a bunch of Iraqis entering a Christian church, plastered next to the banner "Life Returns . . ." the implication being that the more the Iraqis become like Christian Americans, the better off everyone will be. That kind of thinking is devisive and disrespectful and ethnocentric . . . and in my opinion, hopelessly wrong. Iraq is largely a Muslim nation, and its leaders and passion and hope for the future will come from their own culture, not the religion of an occupying force. Sure there are Christians there too - but if you think that Christians have some sort of monopoly on peace and love, you're crazy.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Jeff M, Stockton CA — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:10:59 GMT

I just played online chess with an Iraqi.I told him I am from the U.S. and he called me an occupationer. We should not have gone into Iraq. They believe we are the cause of their suffering. One of the framers of the constitution said that governments cannot rule without the consent of the people. Let's be real. This whole thing will collapse, and Iran, Russia, or China will fill in the power vaccum; because we do not have the popular consent of the people. Let's withdraw our troops rebuild our military and diplomatic relations and strengthen already existing strongholds.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Courtland, Muncie, IN — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:13:07 GMT

So Mr. Dave Smith, this is "this" administration's war huh. Well, this war started a long time ago even before the Clinton administration. But read just a few quotes:

Secretary of State Madeleine Albright was asked about the distinction while the operation was going on:

"I don't think we're pretending that we can get everything, so this is - I think - we are being very honest about what our ability is. We are lessening, degrading his ability to use this. The weapons of mass destruction are the threat of the future. I think the president explained very clearly to the American people that this is the threat of the 21st century. [. . .] [W]hat it means is that we know we can't get everything, but degrading is the right word."
Main targets of the bombing included weapons research and development installations, air defense systems, weapon and supply depots, and barracks and command headquarters of Saddam's elite Republican Guard. Also, one of Saddam's lavish presidential palaces came under attack.

And then this from President Clinton:

CLINTON: Good evening.

Earlier today, I ordered America's armed forces to strike military and security targets in Iraq. They are joined by British forces. Their mission is to attack Iraq's nuclear, chemical and biological weapons programs and its military capacity to threaten its neighbors.

Their purpose is to protect the national interest of the United States, and indeed the interests of people throughout the Middle East and around the world.

Saddam Hussein must not be allowed to threaten his neighbors or the world with nuclear arms, poison gas or biological weapons.

I want to explain why I have decided, with the unanimous recommendation of my national security team, to use force in Iraq; why we have acted now; and what we aim to accomplish.

Six weeks ago, Saddam Hussein announced that he would no longer cooperate with the United Nations weapons inspectors called UNSCOM.

Obviously, mistakes have been made by "this" administration in how the war was handled. But make no mistake, "this" administration didn't start this, it just inherited the problem as will the next administration.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Melissa, San Luis Obispo, California — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:15:18 GMT

While I am certainly glad that life is more safe in Dora today, Mr. Maceda's opening sentence says, "Dora in Sadam's time had it all...." - we caused this tragic mess and while I'm glad it's getting a little cleaned up in some places it is a global shame it ever had to happen in the first place.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Barbara, Hartford, CT — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:18:52 GMT

God Bless our Troops and keep them safe - they have done such a tremendous job under such difficult circumstances...we can continue to discuss the reasons why we went to war but we are there for as long as it takes so I love to see positive stories come out of Iraq and hope for more. Thanks to our Military!!

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Bohdan Szejner, Kraków, Poland — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:19:06 GMT

It is time for the millions of Iraqis that fled abroad to return. Many of those people are intellectuals, which is what Iraq needs. They are the necessary factor in rebuilding the infrastructure and institutions. As long as they fear to return the international contractors also fear to come. The sooner the Iraqis return, the sooner peace will come.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

St. Clair Barker, Port of Spain, Trinidad — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:19:11 GMT

It is refreshing to hear that good things are indeed happening in Iraq. It is sad that so many lives were lost in reaching this point. I wonder many times which would have been worst: Allow the former president to reward suicide bombers for killing young Israelis at will? Or stop him as the US and its allies have done? or allow the expansion of the siucide bombing to be brought to the streets of London and New York? Congratulations for a job well done and continues to be done.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Capt CRF — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:20:27 GMT

Well.....
Dora has never been safer than now. Our troops are doing a fine job, as we always do. The people there will devote much of thier daily free time, dinner, books, soccer, the free time for our troops will be great. When I left Fallujah, the heart felt tears were incredible. No matter what anyone says our presence there is appreciated more than any American citizen that has'nt been there.
God speed, Hooooah

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Brian, St. Paul, MN — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:20:50 GMT

I have heard and seen about a lot of positive progress in Iraq since the troop surge... but I'm really impressed that our own national news is actually carrying a positive story like this.

It drives home the point.... the troops must stay to stabilize and ensure that Iraq gets back on its feet. A troop withdrawl now would be disasterous.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Bill H. Boston, Mass — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:21:46 GMT

With oil prices so high, when will the american people see releif at the pumps? We are already sending billions of dollars to Iraq with no return on investment (ROI in the financial wordl). The only thing we are getting from Iraq is the lost of american lives. I'm a Viet Nam vet and not happy.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Wolfgang, Miami, Florida — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:22:20 GMT

When an extreme liberal outlet like MSNBC allows a success like this to be published you can count on the fact that things are going very well in Iraq.Watch more and more of this as things inevitably get better and better which will cause the liberal media to back away more and more from their anti-Bush and/or "anti-war" propaganda to later claim "hey we are not biased"...However they had been so blatantly and bitterly against the effort in Iraq that I know their attempt to "crawfish" out of their radical anti- war effort image will be impossible. Things are going well in Iraq NO THANKS to the liberals and their media.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Sgt K New York — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:27:10 GMT

I have to laugh at the ignorance of some people. Especially those who love to hear the bad news coming out of Iraq. Oh we lost more troops today, oh the green zone got bombed today. You people eat it up. Then when a little gem comes along about the good we military folks are doing over there, you come up with some crazy BS excuse why it's not good news. You know what, we sent that country back to prehistoric times and we are helping to rebuild it. Imagine if it was you over there with no running water, no electricity, and some sectarian militia threating to kill your family if you walk down the wrong street. Wouldn't you want somebody to do something about it? We're doing the right thing. Yes it is costly. Yes it may have been done under "false" pretenses. (I use the word false loosely cause everybody spins thing to suit thier side of the story). But it's somehting that must be done. If not by us then by who? Are you going to personally go to Iraq and settle all of their problems? Probably not. So until you folks decide to look at the big picture, and do something constructive about it instead of complain, be quiet.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Denise, Kelseyville, CA — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:27:37 GMT

I think that for far too many years the liberals have controlled the media. They've brainwashed generations into thinking that the U.S. is always the bad guy. As a PROUD American I'm disgusted by these tactics. It's time for PROUD Americans regardless of your politics to give America the benefit of the doubt first, not all other countries. America has made its mistakes but, we are by far the most generous, caring country in the world. So, I say Americans be PROUD of the fact that things in Iraq will get better if we stick together and help the Iraqis to build a better life.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

steve, san diego, ca — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:29:39 GMT

The fact is the surge has not worked; the main goal of the surge, national political reconciliation (yes that's what Bush said was the goal: http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2007/01/20070110-7.html ), has not happened. Keeping the peace by the point of a gun and paying off bribes is not reconciliation. Support our troops, vote for Obama, and bring them home!

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

oldfarte — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:30:33 GMT

I appreciated the story. I also appreciate that it was palpably difficult for an MSNBC correspondent to maintain a consistently positive tone, hence the numerous "however's" and "but's" in the narrative and the downbeat ending. Worse, those sad, little "snipes" weren't really necessary and simply justify the suspicion that MSNBC and its NBC parent have a viewpoint to sell, even when they concede the occasional victory.
You see, it is totally possible to give full credit to localized successes like Dora, without all the qualifications, and yet to still question the validity of the war and its outcome and cost. For the amount of money and effort poured into Iraq, we could have turned any number of places into decent locales in which to live. The question is, and ought to be, what does the USA get out of this, besides the endless diversion of resources and effort and the sacrifice of lives and money? Will a democratic, peaceful Iraq be to our advantage? How so? Will the cost of that be worth the benefit? Can anything we achieve in Iraq balance the loss of control over the Saudis and the Gulf States which removing Saddam cost us (how did the Saudis react to Pres. Bush's request for more oil - anyone care to answer)? Will it be worth the surrender of regional hegemony to the Iranians? We still do not know the ultimate cost of victory or the value to be realized should that victory be achieved. Indeed, we haven't even defined (as the Powell Doctrine insisted we must) the very meaning of "victory".
I applaud the success in Dora and the soldiers who made it happen, but it still doesn't excuse the war, not when we continue to pay to build (and rebuild, after they're bombed) schools or roads or infrastructure in Iraq, while our own schools and roads and infrastructure deteriorate.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Evans E. Pate Jr., Detroit, Mi — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:33:09 GMT

To Kevin G: go on the net and google the average prive of gas in the US in Jan 2003 then go out to your closet gas station and take a look at the current pump price. Go get a passport and take a trip to Europe and the Middle East and stand out on the streets and yell out how you're an American and you love the fact that that we invaded Iraq (see what that gets you). Would you like a few more "facts"? I'm not necessarily anti-conservative. In fact, I consider myself to be more conservative now than when I was younger, but I am anti-stupid. The story is encouraging, and I never said otherwise. It's the immediate jumping on the bandwagon to tout how this proves the administration was right all along that amazes me. Sure if we stay there another 5, 10, 20 (?) years we can pacify enough of the country to say "Yeah, we won!!"; are you willing to sacrifice your son or daughter to achive that long term goal? If so, go ask them (if they're old enough) how they feel about that. You fail to look at history back to the Crusades. Islamic people will NOT accept people they consider invaders occupying land they consider historically theirs no more than we would accept invaders occupying places we consider to be American. That is part of what has given that manic Bin Laden and others of his ilk so much sway over younger Muslims; if the jihadists hadn't been so uncaring about killing other Muslims who disagree with them, you might find your story about Dora quite a bit different. Be glad they make just as many mistakes as we have. Oh, and before it comes up I am a Christian, ex-Vietnam veteran who is exercising his right to speak just like you are.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

MAU, Bradenton,FL — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:35:44 GMT

Thanks for the very interesting and encouraging story. I wish the war was covered more fairly. Give us the good, bad and the ugly. For far too long we have gotten just the bad from the far left press and even the White House. I blame the President also for a lack of the communication to the American people. I blame the far left for putting their party before the good of our GREAT country. Durbin comparing our troops to "Nazi's" or Gore saying "he betrayed our country and played upon our fears" is treason. EVERY leading Democrat thought and said the EXACT same things as the President did before the war! 9/11 changed everything! We need to work together to win this war, we need to help grow a democratic and free Middle East. We need to do this for the future generations of this greatest country on God's green earth.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Paul Zom, Carldbad California — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:37:41 GMT

Dora was Predominately an Assyrian-Christian enclave and over the years, Arabs from the surrounding Baghdad neighborhoods had the intentions of taking over the Dora district, drive the Assyrian-Christians out. During the US liberation war of Iraq, they took advantages of the situtation and managed to drive all of the Assyrians out of Dora and illegally possess their houses and propety that was left behind when escaping for their lives.

It is time for the Iraqi government and the world community to look over the dire Assyrian situation and grant an autonomous region in their ancestral homeland of the Nineveh plains and the Assyrian triangle. Assyrian refugee situation in the neighboring countries of Iraq speak for itself about the plight of people who dwelled and created the worlds first civilization which the great musuems around the world attest to it and now are living on handouts from UN relief agencies.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Jay Morris, Jacksonville, Fl — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:38:31 GMT

"Dora has hit hard times since the coalition invasion". INVASION????!!! Gee, I just cant figure out why everyone always says MSNBC is liberally bias...hmmmm.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Korinkas — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:39:11 GMT

Let's not forget that there are those who don't want to see PEACE in the region, who stand to benefit from the conflict and chaos either financially, through power, or something. Terrorists are in this category - they do not want us or Iraq to succeed because they'd be "out of a job". Let's continue supporting the good citizens of Iraq and our service men/women who are working diligently for a peaceful Iraq (while we sit on our arse's and point fingers.) I agree that alot of the fighting is civil battles, not necessarily Al-Qaida. Thousands have given their very life and I hope that not one has died in vain.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

C Mack, Manning, SC — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:43:00 GMT

As a person who has three family members who have served in both Iraq and Afghanistan, this is refreshing. All 3 service personnel have told us that what we see on our news broadcasts is information that is fed to the media. It is not always the complete truth. All three of these young people have come back from their tours extremely proud of what was accomplished. They had a mission and a purpose, and it was achieved.

As far as rising gas prices are concerned, does anyone remember a little storm named "Katrina" and her sister, "Wilma"?

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Linda C Strain Tucson, AZ — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:49:30 GMT

Why has this wonderful story disintergrated into so many negative responses? And this isn't the only city (suburb) that this is going on in....we're just not hearing about the others. I want more of this type of reporting, and I don't care who is doing it. But the Iraqi people themselves need to be hearing about it too.

Am glad to see that many various types are getting along and cooperating in Dora. Too bad we can't do the same.....here at home and in Iraq.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

John, Scottsdale, AZ — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:51:06 GMT

Freedom is poison to extremist religion. Freedom turns extremist religion into moderate religion (as it did with Christian Europe). Extremist religion is the root cause of terrorism. There is no better weapon with which to fight the Global War on Terror than freedom.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

texasguy01 — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:54:05 GMT

How about some of those 12 foot walls by the Mexican Border? Mexican drug violence and gangs armed with military weapons are having daily gunfights. Check out the State Department warnings. Of course the media ignores a war on our border.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Pete Perez, San Diego, CA. — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:56:20 GMT

It takes the whole community to build a nation. This approached is a reminiscent of our historical facts that to rebuild a nation, it takes a lot sacrifices, trust, loving, respects and understanding of each other well being. It's a great news to all of us, especially the people of Iraq. Let's keep our fingers
cross, that this will be the stepping stone to move positively onwards on Iraqi people as a new rebuild nation. This reminds me of my old country (Philippines), getting rid of the dictatorship. A nation that was founded on freedom and democracy.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Dale, Colorado Springs, CO — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 16:56:46 GMT

When did it become our problem to go and help a country that didn't want our help? Why is it that so many people say that we are fighting this was to "defend our freedom"? How is fighting this war defending our freedom? We went in and invaded their country, killed their people, and decided what was best for them. If they want to kill themselves, let them. If we invaded their country for their oil why is gas so high? Why don't we take the oil for ourselves to help pay for the cost to the AMERICAN people for this war? I could care less about the lies that were told to get the public to agree on the war because it is too late for that now. Let's gain something not only for the Iraqi people but for the American people also. Through out history countries have been invaded and the spoils of war went to the winning side but where is ours? When a soldier is given an order, he/she follows it, no questions asked. I not only don't blame the soldiers but I support them and hope for a safe return but I also want a monetary return for the time and energy that our stupid President caused. He is an idiot just like his father was.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

R. Buchan, Orange, Califirnia — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:02:48 GMT

To K Wills of Austin Texas:
The reason we sacrifice blood and treasure to protect the neighborhoods of Iraq is that's what we
do and that's who we are. Thats what makes us Americans, what makes us special and what makes us the best in the world. Sacrificing for the liberty and freedom of others. We did it in World War II and we'll do it again tomorrow. We're Americans.
(sorry to offend any Obama loving liberals out there).

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Lee, Fresno, CA — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:03:23 GMT

Since Al-Qaida are responsible for 3% of the violence then why are we there? Iraq has nothing to do with 911. Bush wanted this war to cement his name into history are the dumbest president ever!!!

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Bob, Edison, NJ — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:05:00 GMT

A positive piece on Iraq who would have thought.
If I now see an article on how Rockefeller just wasted a year and countless tax payer dollars to prove that Bush lied, only to determine that based on all available Intel information, his decision was justified, I think I will fall off my chair.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Denise Montgomery San Deigo, CA — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:05:39 GMT

The only reason a trickle of good things are taking place in Iraq is because of our troops, which is the way it shold be, they are the ones who destroyed it and brought about over 100 thousand innocent Iraqi deaths thru collateral damage, and yes a few undisciplined tropps actually murdered the innocent- the Iraqi war is doomed to failure, because it started with a lie.

I work in Iraq as a contractor and have heard many times, that things were better under Saddam.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Mary Ann Wiznewski Pittsburg, PA — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:08:31 GMT

Bush should be tried for war crimes (for lying and invading Iraq) and if we leave Iraq will become even worse- what a blunder by BUSH/CHENNEY/RICE.

Thank you to our wondeful trops for all you do

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Bob McClaren — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:09:05 GMT

We would not be a Free Nation if Leaders like George Washinton did not convince those figthing to stay the course. The question should be what will a free Iraq mean to us and the world. Our Goverment was not formed over night and came close to failure. I can not believe the majority of Iraqis do not want a save peaceful country to raise there families. The Congress should be figuring out how to be successful, leaving will only cause harm to us and the world. Peace is costly. BZ to the Troops

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Mackenzie R., Houston, TX — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:09:12 GMT

So funny that Engel says "People just don't care about Iraq" Sure, right when stories are positive and not as negative do people seem to "not care" according to him. How about it being more about all the mainstream liberal news outlets not "caring" enough to broadcast said stories. Seems like they wanted people to care immensely when it was going bad, but now that it's going good they're trying to insinuate and tell people "You don't care about this, move along now!" So predictable! What happened to that civil war? Why is it even called the Iraq "War" in the first place!? There's no war over there, it's terrorism or an insurgency at best, not a war. Think gas prices are bad now? Just let Barrack pull troops out of Iraq like he says, and see how soon you start riding a bicycle to work!

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

HStowell, Aurora, Colorado — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:10:34 GMT

It's hard to believe that a positive story regarding Iraq would show up on MSNBC. For those of you who seem so surprised about positive developements all you have to do is speak with people in the military who have been there and can see the progress that Barack Oblabba now wants to abandon. Just go to the military newspaper's web site (www.estripes.com) and you'll see these type of stories and photos often. Let's give the Iraqi people and victory a chance.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

lee — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:17:55 GMT

gee after five years and BILLIONS and BILLIONS we have a bank in Iraq!
Glad that the Iraqis have a place to put all that US money that we threw down the drain in Iraq.
any one who thinks that Iraq is a success are not asking the dead Iraqis the refugees and most importantly to me the american cost in lives .
It is also the greatest war profiteering that has ever taken place.

Liberals that so many have pounded here did not think that eventually Iraq would be quiet. we did we just did not like the price. we had no doubt that we could terrorize and bomb a country into submission
A war without cause and without end. what would Jesus think?

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Shorty,Tampa,Florida — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:18:10 GMT

Those of you that keep saying the President lied for this war to go forth need to do a little catching up on who said what about Hussein before we attacked.You have the same reports from Hillary,Pelosi,Kennedy,Biden,Reid,and many others that recieved the same reports Bush did and said Hussein must be stopped.So stop your finger pointing and blaming because you have the facts WRONG !!! If Billy Boy would have stopped playing golf long enough to make one phone call Binladen would never been a problem.......think about that one.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

marcus, Atlanta GA — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:19:23 GMT

The United States government only helps people who have what they need. They call it protecting their investments. If you think I am lying look it up for yourself and tell me. I bet there is a US representative in every country that has a good that we used. Bush used his executive powers to steer this country in the wrong direction. He has created many enemies and we can all blame high gas prices on him. If the soldiers wasn't fighting this so called war againts terrorist (muslims) then we would be living happier and enjoying ourselves instead of us burying our sons and daughters. God help America

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Justine Morongo Petoria, SA — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:19:50 GMT

What our country has done to the Iraqi people, is infinitesimally worse than what Saddam had ever done, there are way over (Green Zone stopped publishing the numbers, several months ago, to get a better grip on the whole negative picture thing), 100 thousand innocent woman, children and men murdered thru collateral damage by our troops (just folowing orders), why did BUSH have to Lie?

Our Government owes a heck of alot more than what we are giving Iraq, BUSH lied and invaded and now occupies Iraq-and has brought nothing but misery- he truly is a evil man-and our nation reflects this evilness and low moral standards,

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Lucy, Winston Salem, NC — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:22:48 GMT

I wish that there could be order and peace in the whole world. The article is one of hope and that is the only thing that is left when there is so much incertainty in everything else. So, I am proud of our troops and our country for doing what we have done that is looking out for ourselves and our safety. If that included liberating the iraqies then even better.
And I don't believe we should be attacking the people that come over from different countries. This country was founded on immigrants so that is not even an issue. Going to origin of the problem is what will solve our issues.
And these shootings are done by citizens, I dought an immigrant would put themselves in danger of being deported and seperated from their family. I'm sure there are a few but those are the one that should be deported anyway.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Kucher zakoly, Bridgeport, CT — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:24:28 GMT

There is always a positive report and truly calm place in Northern Iraq called KURDISTAN. It has been very peaceful since 90's and after Saddam's fall too. There has never been a single shooting,kidnapping or injury to US Army or any other foreigners. I'm an interpreter for the US Army and I did work in southern Iraq and now I'm in Kurdistan and I really do appreciate the security and the hard work that US Army and the kurds did and continue to do to keep it like this.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Mary Ann Searles, Albuquerque, NM 87109 — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:24:42 GMT

What about the terrorist, the American people know nothing about how many of them how been averted from striking. There's alot we don't know about, because the ones that have never gone to war take advantage of our Country, don't they? They do nothing but spout off about how ignorant they really are about war and it's consequences. Freedom is not free, remember? I am glad for Dora. Now I wish America would help it's own people.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

2-12th Infantry — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:29:33 GMT

I must admit that it sickens me that america has either forgotten, or just never was informed that it was 2-12 INF 2ID and 1 ID that actually made this place liveable from 2006-2008. This story is a joke.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Sam, Zionsville, IN — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:37:13 GMT

Uhm, so after 5 years we have physical barriers, paid off ex-insurgents, and many US soldiers providing enough security so that people can go to the bank and market? Well, at this rate we might be able leave in 20 years. And don't get me wrong, I'm not one of those that is all about a sudden withdrawal of our troops. And I can assure you no president regardless of party (D or R) would be stupid enough to let that country tear the whole region apart by withdrawing US forces early. Good to hear something positive though.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Denny — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:40:51 GMT

Maybe president Bush and V.P can afford to higher security forces for Iraq ,after we pull our troups out and bring them home?

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

lilly ch. Utah — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:42:39 GMT

I for one think we are doing a great job their.
yes we need are troops here at home, we need people to also wake up and learn about were are things are coming from like are oil and are prices on things is not all from are war and being over their. A lot of are problem is from not taking the time to get all the facts we have here. We have oil here in the USA. but some people do not want us to know and to get at it..
(It is said that a country is better controlled when it's ignorant...)

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

mczet, Kenosha WI — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:43:45 GMT

Aaaaaaaand their OFF.....A couple of disappointingly mild comments come out of the gate, this could be a short flame war folks..But Wait! Here comes Immigration Nation around the corner to take the lead followed closely by Backbone Revisionist. They are neck and neck coming out of the first turn, but coming on strong is Media Basher! Yes, this baby is fueled by pure ideology. Without the burden of understanding and context, this baby can really fly. Up the flagpole, saluted and back around the third turn and flaming pure liberal out the back end as the turbo kicks in.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Denny — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:46:41 GMT

Where were you right winger's the last couple month's.. You have all been very quiet. Until you get a bit of good news, so now you can all jump on the band wagon agian.. What kind of smear campain do you have in store for the Democratic party this week.. or until more bad news, and you can all hid in the corner again..

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Some Random Guy — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:49:42 GMT

I'm torn between what is the more compelling story here... The improvements being made in Iraq or the distress and anger those improvements trigger in liberals.

What does it say about the left that they want political power so badly they're more than willing to see the US lose and terrorists win?

And for the record... there are only a couple legitimate things the US government could do to reduce gasoline prices (build refineries and expand domestic production) and it's the left that's blocked them. Put your blame where it belongs.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

M M Congdon, Rochester, NY — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:49:42 GMT

It is encouraging to hear about a positive turn in one area after years of negitivity about what's happening over there. But to claim this as a point of which side is right or wrong as far as Democrats and Republicans about Iraq is just another example of Joe / Jane American closing their eyes to the bigger picture.

The war in Iraq should not have taken place at all. Post-war intelligence have come out time and time again to say that our reasons for starting the war was unfounded. Anybody disputing this claim is just another lemming. Now that we are in this mess the problem is what to do and both parties are in a lose / lose situation on this one.

The Republicans want to keep our troops there to finish the job, with no timetable to bring our troops home. While this is benifical to the Iraqis this leaves our nation wide open to attack. Our forces are stretched incredibly thin. Enlistment levels are way down because lets face it, who wants to join when it's almost asured your going to be rushed right into combat situation. Also when troops come back you don't get compensated in a way that they should for putting their life on the line. Keeping troops somewhere else means we don't have them to protect our own borders or other interests. So that plan actually makes us more vulnerable. Also we spend billions of dollars a month to supply our troops out there. That's money that could be used to help our horrible economy here.

On the flip side we have the Democrats wanting to bring people home. Now first don't believe the hype machine that's telling you if Obama gets elected he'll immediately pull all the troops out and Iraq will be in chaos. That's just the political machine grabing your votes. No leader is that irresponsible to do something like that. It will be a gradual process, but it does create an issue where it could be perceived as us being soft. Also there is the issue of would the Iraqis be stable enough to run on their own steam enough to not only take care of themselves but also keep any aggressors at bay.

There are many other points on both sides that could be covered but I'm trying to be breif. Also I won't kid myself and my points obviously have a Democratic bias as that's what I am. Regardless my point is that neither side is going to be able to come up with a solution where something else isn't going to suffer greatly for it. So as responsible voters who truly care what happens once this administration is gone we all need to step back from the politcal and media machines, do some research and some self reflection, and really think about which side is going to get through this with the least amount of damage done.

Our troops, our country, and the Iraqi people are all at stake here. It is us who will decide our fate and theirs in this election. We each have be given the right to truly decide for ourselves what is the right course of action. Whether you are a Republican, Democrat, or something else this election is too important to blindly follow any party.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

S Hayes Naperville, Illinois — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:53:04 GMT

I'm glad we finally had a President that did the right thing, then stuck to hi sguns and didn't WAFFLE underthe pressure and go with the mainstream. Great Job Bush and our troops who really mad ethe differnce in changing Iraq.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

TOM KUHNKE, CAMPBELLSPORT, WI — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:55:25 GMT

Like the republicans said, its great to hear a postive story about Iraq from the liberal media. If the story was negative, it must have been written by a liberal and the problem was surely created by Bill Clinton. Some of you people who want "feel good" stories must be desperate for good news!

I'd like to see more positive stories about the failing economy, sinking dollar, job outsourcing to foreign countries, rising gas prices, food shortages, rising crime rates, illegal aliens invasion, high health care costs, etc. etc. Next time, let write something positive about reality in the USA. Then we we can thank Mr Bush and all replublican flag wavers for being the only true patriots in the country. I wish all patriots had to send and lose their sons to Iraq. By the way...all of todays bad news is Clintons fault....lol. Amazing!!

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

R. S. Colorado Springs Colorado — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:55:28 GMT

Nice to see a mostly posative piece about Iraq- Suprised it took this long, as Dora started on the rebound almost a year ago actually- July-Aug 07 was when the Iraqi Security Volunteers emerged in the area and violent acts dropped by over 90% and common Iraqis started walking the streets on a regular basis once again. Hope the palce continues to get better day by day.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Irwin, Thousand Oaks, CA — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:57:02 GMT

This story is a little like looking at the trees, but missing the whole forest. I'm happy for Iraquis that they have a respite from the insanity. But we need more mention of the Status of Forces negotiations with the Iraquis to determine the relationship between the American troops and contractors and the Iraqis, namely whether the Americans will have permanent bases, be able to use (and abuse) their military unilaterally and with impunity, etc. This will really dictate how we move forward in Iraq, not little snapshots and acecdotes of tranquillity. Hopefully the media will do its job this time. Most of the Iraqis, even the most influential Grand Ayatollah Ali Sistani are dead set against the US occupation.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Kevin, somewhere, US — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 17:57:13 GMT

Susan Jones wrote:
"It is a start, Hope and pray to God they can hold it together and we can come home. Which, we should have never been there in the first place.
But as the old saying is Somewhere in Texas they are missing their village idiiot George Bush"

Funny, people who call others idiots can't even spell idiot or use proper grammar.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Melanie Couzens, MI — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:02:01 GMT

It pains me to even think about what is going on in the Middle East. My heart aches for the U.S. troops and equally for the men, women and children of Iraq. Don't we all, as human beings, deserve the right to raise our families in peace. Why does it always have to be "us" or "them". There is only one earth and we "all" share it. Why does it really matter so much were we are placed on this earth that we share. I know it is an impossible dream to think we will all line up and hold hands while singing "we are the world". But I don't see anyone "winning" this so called war. Everyone loses this time around.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Erich Graf, Turtle Lake, Wisconsin — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:02:05 GMT

my hope is that something good comes of the terrible loss of life and I hope the Mothers, fathers, brothers, sisters,sons & daughters of the men and women who gave their lives in the service of our country can be proud and someday realize that their sacrifice was for the good of mankind. I am proud of all of them. God Bless!

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

James Mathews — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:04:14 GMT

I appreciate the story. I would appreciate even more a follow up to your questions at the end of your article. However, I doubt very seriously if we will get those answers. What I believe we will get is more of the same about how the war is wrong how we were lied to by President Busch and other politicians. When in fact in my opinion we need to figure out how how to get the job done. Here is an idea why don't we put this issue on the ballot this fall and let the people decide since what we here from the press is that our elected officials haven't gotten it right and the fact that they are so out of touch with mainstream America then put it to a vote and be done with it.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Deebee, Clearwater, FL — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:04:48 GMT

This is good news. Finally. And inevitable, thank goodness. We have finally started learning, albeit so, so late. But this does not vindicate our going into Iraq in the first place. It just is a sign that we are finally taking the Iraqi people into account in this adventure. Americans, get ready to continue paying big bucks for many years to come to fix what we destroyed through our incompetence.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Clark Jensen — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:06:16 GMT

George Bush and the big oil co. raised the price of gasoline so when Obama becomes president he can tell them to bring the price of oil down or else. When he pulls the troops out of all muslim countries they will like us again and cut the price of oil way down. Happy days will be here again

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Rich, Riverside, CA — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:17:22 GMT

My Son-n-Law went over to Iraq for his 13 month tour and when he returned I asked him if it was worth it.
He look me straight in the eye and without hesitation said "Oh yes" they want to live normal lives like we do and we are helping get there. A few weeks later he told me that he couldn't watch the news about Iraq because is was so political and flat wrong. He since reenlisted and will be going back in October.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Camille Terry, Mobile, Alabama — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:17:30 GMT

Not to be redundant but Finally a positive report about Iraq. And to the neysayers that continue to eroneouslly state that it is FACT that there were no WMDs and no Saddam connection to AL Quada --- there was. According to the media there were WMDs they just weren't "the WMDs" that President Bush referred to in his justification for invading Iraq. So they weren't "the WMDs" he was referring to, WMDs are WMDs in my book and I'm glad Iraq no longer has them! And, there is documentation of the Iraqi government supporting AlQuada ???sp??? training facilities.

This war was very justified. It has been very hard to win but it will be worth it. The people of Iraq have NEVER known freedom/democracy and it truly may take an entire generation for them to know the value of living in freedom and love it enough to fight for it. When they do, we will all be better off for it.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Don't Believe The Liberal Lies. Colorado Springs Colorado — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:19:50 GMT

What FACT? How are we less safe? What FACT are you talking about? Sounds like the typical liberal talking point. How do you determine that we are less safe and then state that it is a FACT?

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

A US citizen, Dallas, Texas — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:21:23 GMT

Democracy in Iraq! Are all americans heavily drugged or what. Democracy will fail, the day after US pulls out of Iraq. Their mind-set, culture, traditions, society, religion everything is against democracy.
Yes, who is paying for the false, unjustified war and its repercussions ? The hard-working middle and lower classes. Who is actually benefitting out of the oil prices ? Believe it or not, our own politicians and politically connected. Democrats and Republican higher-ups both know the real behind the curtain manipulations.
All,in the name of "protecting Israel"! Stupid people, if Isael was really so fearful of Iran's nuclear advances, why would the Israel Premier be shown in the US news-media laughing and joking with Iran's Ayatollah in Iran? And here, the US administration is going around the world raising public opinion against Iran, that too on another bogus pretext. The muslim mind-set is such that they would rather set fire to the oil wells, than let us "infidels" benefit out of it, in any way.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Glenn Silver Spring Md — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:23:28 GMT

Robert in CT. What do you mean by your statement? I have a neighbor that has been to Iraq four times since the start of the war (he's a doctor) and he has told me that, they talk big time about different things such as this writting and most of it is blown-up just to make it look good over there. He has told me don't beleive it one bit because, it all show and not real. They will be hurting real soon and be back were they were three years ago.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Bobby Boy St. Louis, MO — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:23:31 GMT

You people better pay attention. Jack Doyle is right! Keep rooting for America to take care of Iraq and thier problems, while the US crumbles. Some of you America people are dumb! What does this have to do with Obama? The truth of the matter is, go to a inner city neighborhood and you will see a many Iraq! Maybe not bombs, but guns galore. I know what Obama has to do with this now.....he will CHANGE the way AMERICA thinks and reacts...to the WORLD! Obama 08...we can't have the same America!

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Irwin, Thousand Oaks, CA — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:25:14 GMT

I'm just amazed what amnesia some of the comments here reveal. SO there's no accountablity for past actions, right? God knows how many innocent civilians were killed - 100,000, 600,000? 4000+ American soldiers! Millions of refugees, a devastated infrastructure, and yet, well there's relative peace now, what a wonderful policy and president!! Is it any wonder why we're detested around the world? The Germans consider our country the greatest threat to the peace of the world! Get real, people! Get out of your cocoons!

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

K.D. Meagans Camp Victory, Iraq — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:25:37 GMT

In Iraq there are only a few happy stories, I know I'm here at Camp Victory, I don't feel good about my mission (what constitues winning, give me a objective). Morale is very low-no clear cut mission, and I'm higher in the rank structure-imagine what that lowley PFC feels like.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Ryan Dundon Chardon Ohio — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:27:00 GMT

For all of you who are happy to see a good story out of Iraq and are so ready to jump up and say the President and his cronies in the administration were/are right and the Dems and Mr. Obama are wrong: is it that easy for you to ignore the FACT that the invasion was based on fault info, propaganda, and lies; the FACT that Saddem Hussein had no Al-Queda connections, no WMD, and no way to reach out and touch this country with any kind of terriost attack; the FACT that 4000 dead and tens of thousands of wounded American military have been wasted for NOTHING; the FACT that we as Americans are less safe in this world than before the invasion; the FACT that before the invasion gasoline cost no more than half what it costs today; the FACT that we are more disliked by the rest of the world today than before the invasion??? It seems that you who justify this 5 plus year abortion we are involved in conveniently forget the above mentioned facts so try to remember this cliche: those who forget the mistakes of the past are doomed to repeat them (with the same stupid and unnecessary consequences).
In response to the above

Wow you would call people being able to live in freedom a waste of lives. FACT we have not been attacked since 911 so obviously Bush is doing something right. FACT Saddam perposefully led people on that he had wmds so he could act like he had more power in the region. FACT Congress isnt doing anything to get us off foreign oil sooo blame them for sky rocketing oil. And to mistake of the past comment Vietnam anyone, or how about Blackhawk down we have already made these mistakes and if we pull out of Iraq we will be repeating them, so i think its time we learned our history lesson. I'm only 16 and i know more than you so keep your mouth shut next time

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

BP, Seattle, WA — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:29:44 GMT

Interesting how the people who have not been involved in our efforts in Iraq--who have sat home, enjoyed their freedoms, villainized their own troops and have remained safe--are so quick to denounce that which they have not had any involvement with. They get their information about Iraq from American media, from self-serving politicians hoping to use popular opinion (regardless of whether that popular opinion is based on reality) to gain office. Yet when actual veterans of this war come home and tell them they're full of hogwash, tell them about all the positive gains we've made, what Iraq is really like, what the enemy is really like, and so forth... we get mocked for it, ridiculed, and our opinions/expertise/experience dismissed. I LIVED in Dora (more properly called "al Dora" or "al Dura" locally, which is basically a suburb of al Rashid in southern Baghdad) for three months, in early 2004. It was one of the most volatile and dangerous neighborhoods at the time and had a reputation as being a stronghold of Sunni terrorism. It was also the hometown of Saddam's old vice president. The fact that Sunnis, Shi'a, and Christian Iraqis are walking around in safety, going to markets and running banks... is simply amazing to me. Yet this story still has a pessimistic spin on it (ie, "Saddam's glory days"... oh, please), and you won't see much mention of it on any headlines or breaking news reports. It would go against liberal agenda to have ANY positive news coming from Iraq, particularly in an election year; and there has been a LOT of good work done and a LOT of positive things accomplished during the entire five years we've been there. The fact that we so rarely--if ever--hear about it doesn't mean it's not happening... it means that there is a media bias and political bias to write the entire mission off simply because of its association with George Bush, the mistaken notion that we didn't find WMD's (guess what--we did), and that Iraq has something to do with an oil market that is, and always has been, volatile to begin with (most of our oil does NOT come from the Middle East, much less Iraq).

I guess facts are a major inconvenience to those who stand to gain from a prolonged negative spin. Too bad we've "progressed" to the point of villifying our own troops and our own government over actual enemies who openly state they want to kill us.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Todd Dallas TX — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:30:41 GMT

I love articles like these I was in Iraq in 03. Even when things were getting bad Iraq standard of living was going up. Health Care went from $0.50 per person to $20 in a single year. I don't know were it is now. The first year after going in nothing much was accomplished and yes I do blam Rumsfeild and Bush but I blam the doom sayers a whole lot more.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Bill D. Marysville, Washington — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:33:11 GMT

It is too bad this is one of the few positive articles coming out of Iraq, as there are many. While I did not agree with the invasion at the time and I admit many many mistakes were made and I can agree with many issues both liberals and conservatives bring up, I am sick of the blame game. Bush made a mistake going into Iraq but we are there. Fix the problems that led to the mistakes we made but beating each other up constantly is garbage. We need to come together and work to find a winnable solution for all of us and the Iraqi's. Why did we thrive on negative things and finger pointing, why cant we work to solve issues instead of being the king of blame?

Many of the people blogging here and ranting and raving have not been to Iraq. I have spent the last two years in Baghdad and things are getting better. I have had the priviledge of making many Iraqi friends and they hope for the things we take for granted. If you took the time to meet with individual Iraqi's you would find they are glad Saddam is gone and they really want to make things work. Iraq is going through a huge change that they have never experienced and it will take a number of years for them to get things together. They are tired of the violence and killings.

The job our fantastic troops are doing along with the improving Iraqi army will make things better (although slowly) and in time Iraq will turn the corner. We Americans are so impatient we think things should happen over night and that is not realistic in Iraq or many other countries.

So for those who want to spit their facts from one side or the other remember facts are one person interpretation of issues and until on actually see's with their own eyes how things are facts can be misconstrued. It is a shame our media has not taken the time to really report the good things, but then we have become so negative as a society that only bad news is worthy of print or television coverage.

We have made many mistakes in Iraq and elsewhere in the world (both Democrat and Republican) but we cannot just up and leave the Iraqi's. I hear all the time how we are not liked by the rest of the world but if we cut and run like Obama is saying then we will show our allies that we cannot be counted on when things are difficult to stay and help. We are in Iraq right or wrong and it would be a disgrace to those troops who have paid the ultimate price and the thousands wounded who gave their all to run when the job is not finished and we also need to help the Iraqis get this done. Iraq may never be the democracy we are but it will be much better then it was under its former leader.

We need to figure out the best course to get our troops out as soon as we can but also without losing what they and the Iraqi's have fought so hard to gain.

If we cut and run then we have truely learned nothing from Vietnam and the sacrifices of those who served there.

Thanks for letting me say my two cents worth.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Joe Blow in Chi-ca-go — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:33:21 GMT

Some of the posters here are retarded. Why don't you hear more stories like this? Because there aren't any!!! I assure you this administration does everything in its power to spoon-feed every such story to the media. Haven't you heard about the american serviceman and the soccer balls? There are a few such stories out there. For the most part, however, Iraq is still in chaos. These days, "we're winning" means we didn't lost a hundred troops last month.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

K. Lucero, El Paso, TX — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:34:34 GMT

Thanks for good news from Iraq!! Thank you, our brave troops, our brave allies, our brave veterans. Thank you President Bush, for keeping us safe since 9/11. You took the fight to the enemy and I think it was the best plan. Keep the good news coming. Best wishes to freedom-loving people in Iraq, Afghanistan, and all over the world.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Lorraine Taube Brockwaqy Township, Michigan — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:44:47 GMT

I have only one thing to say to all those who never have anything good to say about this wonderful country we call the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,LEAVE!!! Go!! We don't need you!! Go to the country of your choice. We don't want you to be unhappy! If you can find a better place, go!! Thank God I am an American..

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Chuck, Long Island, NY — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:52:25 GMT

Great, all this for only what.......$2 million per day? We ought to dump these losers, let them work out their own problems, and take care of our own people!

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

W J Sanders — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:54:22 GMT

So I guess we are going all over the world to MAKE everyone be free. I served in Desert Storm and Afghanistan. I am disgusted by this sit at home partiotism. None of you would leave your suburban homes, soccer practices, $50K+ income, etc to fight a war for a country that now TOTALLY depends on us. We leave a town, what they call insurgents come back. The thing is, a guy who warns you of an attack today can be an insurgent tomorrow. One bomb shatters what they call being secure. Just ONE. And meanwhile the Iraqi gov. drags their feet on everything from their constitution to training their OWN troops. Why train them, why take responsibility when those US troops are so ready to DIE! If there's a fire, the OWNER of the house BETTER be working the hardest to extinguish the flames. Not sitting on across the street out of harm's way. If so, I say pack it up and go home. North Korea, Somalia, Sudan, China, Tibet,Ghana,Myanmar, Burma, Iran, Azerbaijan, Zimbabwe, here we come, right? We will lose thousand of lives, spend billions of dollars while you invest zero, right? The people of these countries face gruesome atrocities just like the Iraqis, right? BTW, there still is that minor matter of that 6'5" Al-Qaeda guy who planned and executed thousands of Americans. 100K troops in Pakistan would definitely find him, right? It's just us crippled vets and liberals talking, right?

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Bill D. Marysville, Washington — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:55:20 GMT

Joe Blow in Chicago,

You have been to Iraq and seen all of the bad things and the fact there is nothing positive?

and you say some of the poster here are retarded?

Seems like there may be one in Chicago

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Max E. Borges II Miami Florida — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 19:01:19 GMT

Good and rare article from the liberal media. Why did you have to ended with a negative remark ?. Shame on you

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Phyreblade, Fort Polk, LA. — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 19:12:13 GMT

It's unfortunate, only, that this is just one news report, and doesn't allow for a true breadth into the tremendous number of similar instances all over the country of Iraq. I'm gratified to see this story told, surely. But I'd like it, more, if the multitude of similar tales were being told as easily as this one.

To my own soldier, who tells me his stories every chance he gets, I can never express my pride enough. Keep doing what you're doing, we're missing you, but know you'll be home soon enough.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

R Ries, Junction City, KS — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 19:12:18 GMT

I have look at a lot of the responses about our troops success in Iraq. People can debate from now to when hell freezes over about whether we should be there or not. What's the point! We are there and the important thing is to support our troops, support our government, get the job done and come home with honor. All this disention, bickering, and bad mouthing the administration only prolongs the conflict. As long as our enemies think there is a chance that politics will win the war for them they will hang on regardless of the cost. Human lives means nothing to them. A win in Iraq is essential to the freedom of the West. If you think for a minute that you can negotiate with or appease the Islamic militants you need to go back and read the history books. It is full of stories of those who thought they could and ended with tragic results. People that do not learn from history will repeat the mistakes of history.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Brett, Classified — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 19:14:33 GMT

Life is better in Baghdad. The IA (Iraqi Army) have been doing a great job. They are working with us(USA), SOI (Sons of Iraq), and the IP (Iraq Police) to accomplish missions. I see more of them on the streets than the Coalition forces. They have set up checkpoints thoughout Baghdad and the surrounding areas. Yeah, the SOI used to be confused on who was good and who was bad. But now they are protecting there communities with their Ak47s and thats about it. Some dont even get paid. The IZ (green zone) and the VBC havent had any significant mortar/rocket attacks in 2-3 weeks due to the IA. We quardened off Sadr city and they rolled though it. Now we do joint patrols there. If only they could release CIGX reports to everyone you would see the difference. What I really hate here are EFP's. If we could go ahead and get those taken care of that would be great. It went though our humvee like it wasnt even there. America get on that!
News stories are just that storys. Take what you will from them, be it positive or negitive. The only way to truly get an unbias view, is to see it yourself.
Americans aren't the only ones responsible for the way this country is. Its hard to separate the destruction of this country. Personally, it really doesnt matter at this point. It just needs to get fixed. There are people living in garbage made houses in landfills here. There are women and children shopping in dumps. I've got pictures to prove it. Thats not the worst of it either. I have also seen really nice houses with BMWs in the driveway. Baghdad is weird like that. I dare anyone to come over here and lend a helping hand to someone that actually needs it. I would rather give a US dollar to an Iraqi mother, then an American bum.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Tatyana Galperin,Glenview,ILL — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 19:15:11 GMT

Greate story,I would like to hear more about positive things in Iraq.Freedom and democracy is growing in this country.This is a long way,but right way.Thanks our troops.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Jim Beaton,Shelby Township,Michigan — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 19:21:29 GMT

If we had not taken out Saddam Hussein,when we did,
he still would be a menance in the Middle East.It would never end,because his evil sons would replace
him when he passed on. How can anyone be so stupid
to think that he did not work hand in hand with Al-Qaida or soon would be doing so
Furthermore,the president must be doing something
right because there have been no terrorist acts by
Al-Quaidi since the World Trade Center horror.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

John Smith CPL Louisiana — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 19:29:09 GMT

I find it intresting that so many people who arent in the military and have done nothing in iraq have so much to say about the suffering us soldiers has endured. If and when we (american soldiers) cant take it anymore and feel we are being abused we will say it.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

N M, Wisconsin — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 19:42:06 GMT

So many posters here should be ashamed of yourselves. We Americans have it so good, yet we complain about us spending money on others in the world. Yes we started this war, yes we need to stay until they are safe. You can sit in your suburban house and never worry about your loved ones on the way home from their school or market. This is the least we can do for these people is to try to give them some security. The next time you hug your child remember what some in the world have to go thru each day and money will not matter anymore. Thank you so much to our men and women in the forces, God bless and we are praying for you each day.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Registered Investment Advisor, Bethesda, MD — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 19:50:31 GMT

I am glad this is happening. It doesn't justify the war though.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Debbie, Memphis, TN — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 20:06:11 GMT

No matter how we came to be in Iraq, we have an obligation to see this through. We cannot tuck our tails and run away again if we want to remain a superpower. We cannot afford another failure like Vietnam. The WWII generation would NEVER have considered quitting, while their sacrafice was much greater than we have experienced thus far. God bless the men and women of our military that put their lives on the line every day. I have no doubt that through the efforts of men & women like Lt. Justin Chalvko we can be successful. America became great through our strength, determination and sacrifice and we will remain great through the same.

Proud to be an American

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Aadil Spokane, Washington — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 20:14:32 GMT

Tell me how change people minds. There are generations and generations of anti-western hate. Just as Americans have suicide-bomber, hatred, Islamic jihad, nontrust idea of many middle easterners (and you HAVE free press), many of us think of Americans as bullies who will do whatever to whomever to protect thier interests (oil). Yes, anyone with more guns and better weapons can be in charge for a while. Your precious saudis told Bush absolutely that they would NOT increase their oil output. The American press does not show the celebrations they have at their record gains. The American press refuses to follow the blood/money trail of Saudi payments to al-Queda and other factions. The American press refuses to disclose just how many Iraqis have dying. I see reports of 2 or 3 American soldier killed when we were lose 75-100 civilians a day. Just as no one dared speak against Sadaam, now no one dare speak out against the police or US troops. The same people who killed our fathers and daughters, teachers and doctors, mothers and brothers now have police uniform. And this is called progress? Kill, rape, maim, then put down your old guns for new ones. Do you think they have changed or are waiting? Do you think their sons have changed?

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Maggie Kennedy, North Pole, Alaska — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 20:30:42 GMT

Were things really all that great in Dora during Sadam's rule? Only if he allowed it. What about the millions who died because he didn't want them there? That area finally has some real freedom and democracy. It's great to see the Shiites, Sunnis, and Christians all working and living together in harmony. We need to teach ALL middle easterners that the rest of the Middle East can be like Dora is right now.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

David Mahone — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 20:30:47 GMT

its nice that the US going bankrupt is on a War that isn't suposed to be a War and the country of Iraq is bankrolling their money from the overinflated price of their crude oil if they are happy with what we are doing there start filling out tankers and paying off their debt.....come on America do some research on Ron Paul his views aren't new and he has been saying for years about what is happening to us today want america fixed get a true conservative Ron Paul kinda funny but if Ron Regan was around he would endorce him

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Jennifer K., Indianapolis — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 20:46:08 GMT

I could almost feel an unrestrained grin in the words of Alladin Hussein... "Now we are living in stability and security. It’s like a precious gem..." I earnestly hope that the rest of Iraq experiences the same thing sometime very soon and that the rest of our men and women can come home safely. May we all be at peace a year from now.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

srs, pine grove, ca — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 20:54:08 GMT

While I am not blind to the fact that we entered this war (actually occupation) on unsubstiated data, lies in fact, I do believe it necessary to protect and rebuild a country that we totally destroyed. Life in Iraq was not perfect, and neither is it in the US. But now that we are responsible for so much destruction, it IS our duty to help the ordinary people that suffered and are still suffering from our unbridled hubris. One day, maybe soon, we may need help from Iraq.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Iraqi Liberation/Surge Worked USA — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 21:18:46 GMT

I feel so bad for the people who see the good news coming out of Iraq, and they have to throw in negative comments. It's like they relish the bad news and the deaths so their views can be considered right. I guess I'm not surprised by the failure to acknowledge that we are achieving successes in Iraq. These are obviously the same people that were screaming the surge is just drawing us further into the war and this was becoming another Vietnam. Life is obviously getting better for the Iraqi people. I challenge those who bashed the surge on this board to admit this. In writing, maybe even a sorry, I was rude and obviously there are others who know more about this stuff than me. There must be at least one... right? Stop relishing in the death and violence for the simple reason of refusing to admit you could have been wrong, thats all I'm saying. And those that refuse to see that things are getting better are whats wrong with this country. Don't blind yourselves to an opinion or an idea when you're clearly wrong, and the smugness and rudeness are the worst.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Jim Tello, Ft Worth TX — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 21:21:58 GMT

As long as we keep up the finger pointing and blaming within our own country (how many times in all these posts did I read something about the 'liberals' did this or 'right wing' did that) then we won't solve anything.

We are where we are so let's work together and come up with clear exit critera and get our brave men and women home to their families.
The Iraqis need to take responsibility for their own destiny at some point, and soon. We have billions that need to be spent on improving our infrastructure here at home or we'll all end up walking to the office sooner rather than later.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Hopes for Freedom in Iraq — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 21:24:08 GMT

The war has been costly in both lives lost and money spent, but we've reached a turning point or lull at the very minimum so I say to every American Let us finish and win!!!! Those that wish to cut and run say there were no W.M.D's It doesnt take away from the obligation of rebuilding what we've destroyed. Whether there were or not. You cry out that 4,000 soldiers have died, do not.... I repeat DO NOT LET A SINGLE ONE OF THEIR LIVES GO IN VAIN! THEY HAD A BELIEF AND AN IDEAL. DO NOT ROB THESE YOUNG MEN OF A VICTORY, BECAUSE THIS IS WHAT THEY DIED FOR. YOU FLAUNT NUMBERS. THESE MEN DIED FOR A CAUSE. YOU'RE SITTING THERE 8,000 MILES AWAY AT YOUR DESK. OUR MEN AND WOMEN IN UNIFORM FEEL STRONGLY THAT WE HAVE A REASON TO BE HERE AND A CHANCE TO WIN. TO CALL THEM AWAY FROM THIS IS COWARDLY AND IGNOBLE TO THE MEN AND WOMEN WHO DIED FOR THE FREEDOM OF THE IRAQI PEOPLE!!!!!

Iraq Vet

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

positivity brings more positivity — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 21:35:23 GMT

I love the comments like... (FACT that we are more disliked by the rest of the world today than before the invasion)

What the hell do you think this is a popularity contest??? We're possibly on the brink of a democratic Middle Eastern country. And, you're worried about what a bunch of people in other countries that refuse to lift a finger to help these people think?

That's why many of these views are laughable at best. Quit blinding yourself and binding yourself to an opinion because you refuse to be wrong or admit that someone somewhere in this administration is doing something right. I guess it really does leave a bad taste in your mouth especially if Democracy works out for the people... Democracy in the Middle East brought by Bush.... ouch oh wait i just had a flash back to Ronald Reagan... double ouch....

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

david M. Austin, Tx — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 21:38:24 GMT

I support the US troops all over the world and if you do also look at that facts more in the military gave
money to Ron Paul for his campain than the troops
gave to all the others running put together for Pres. ck out the facts this is a true statement

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

BCD Milwaukee WI — Wed, 11 Jun 2008 22:22:48 GMT

Even Richard Pearle, a neoconservative instrumental in forming much of Bush's Middle East foreign policy, conceded our invasion of Iraq was preemptive and therefore illegal. The inconvenient truth too often ignored is that UNMOVIC investigated the supposedly "foolproof" intelligence the Bush administration supplied (the same intel forming the basis of Bush's rationale to wage war) for three months prior to their being arbitrarily forced--despite good progress and over their objections--to leave by the U.S. All of the allegedly "solid" intelligence supplied by the Bush administration, in addition to other intelligence and their own independent investigations, turned up nothing indicating Iraq possessed, or was seeking to possess, WMD's. There is no reasonable explanation that explains why UNMOVIC wasn't allowed more time to confirm the suppositions advanced by the Bush administration as cause for waging war against another sovereign nation were wrong, given the enormity of the consequences and the results they had thus far obtained. This is especially inexplicable considering that Iraq had at the time been giving the U.N. inspectors unprecedented access and cooperation.

A patriot would accept the ample evidence showing that the Bush administration manipulated and withheld critical intelligence from the American people, engaging in fear- and war-mongering to lead us into a costly, counter-productive war; a partisan apparently cannot--they prefer to put party ahead of country.

These same partisans keep whining about the so-called "liberal" media, simply because the news isn't what they want it to be, or doesn’t reflect their own radical extremism. Newsflash: independent studies of our media show that our media is not liberal, but slightly to the right. Independent studies of the coverage in Iraq also show that "good" news is fairly reported and the "bad" news has been underreported. Remember Judith Miller of the NY Times? Studies also indicate that after 9/11, our media lost much of its backbone, becoming more of a cheerleader for government policy, however suspect, and failed to adequately perform the tasks expected by itself and the American people. I suppose these partisans are like some sports coaches, who by disparaging the ref's and attacking their calls hope to unfairly gain advantage. This is troubling because such propaganda can and does unduly influence the media, becoming detrimental to good journalism, while our citizens become misinformed, all of which ill-serves our nation.

Despite the numerous comments protesting otherwise here, it's obvious this reporter is being objective: the good news should be rejoiced, but the situation in Iraq is still extremely tenuous and volatile, and therefore susceptible to reversals at anytime. Basically, the reporter is saying that given the track record, he's going to take a wait-and-see attitude before drawing any firm conclusions. That isn't a negative approach--it's a realistic one. The partisans may want the media to paste a big "Mission Accomplished" headline over this whole fiasco so they can feel better about themselves, but how will fooling ourselves accomplish anything good? Isn't that partly how we got into this mess in the first place?

Folks, this isn't just some minor little boo-boo. Our nation engaged in an illegal, immoral, preemptive attack on another sovereign nation without adequate justification. This may not rank with some of the very worst atrocities, but we have still committed a grievous wrong. For some, I believe the inability to accept this is not so much about partisanship as about a false sense of patriotism; a form of hubris where they don't want to believe their country can be in the wrong. A great patriot, Carl Shurtz, once said, "'Tis not, My country, right or wrong; 'tis, My country, that which is right to be kept right, that which is wrong to be set right." Whatever qualities our country possesses, can we truly be a great nation if we can't admit our own mistakes? Personally, I don't see how. Yes, it is important to remember and commemorate what is right, but if we can’t even collectively acknowledge--much less remember--where we have gone wrong, how do we progress? How do we keep from repeating those same disastrous mistakes?

According to the polls, there is a significant majority of Americans who want our troops out of Iraq, who feel, as do I, that far too much blood and treasure has already been wasted on this erroneous war. While rightly we should be concerned about the ramifications and mechanics of doing that, there are nevertheless sound reasons why removing our presence from Iraq would be best for both countries.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Dan Harris — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 00:42:13 GMT

Great post. For or against our troops being in Iraq, it is important we get good on the ground reporting.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Soldier for a cause — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 00:50:00 GMT

It's very interesting to watch the psotings in here. Liberals want to bash the President because they don't know and don't want to know the real reason we are in Iraq. To all liberals. I met with a 12 year old girl, in Greece, that was Kurdish. Her family was killed by Saddam's forces had gased. Get that? He gased them. Then there are you liberals that want to say, "Oh, we don't belong there. Our President lied to us" Think about having a tyrant like Saddam sending his peopel to your house.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Tracy, La Mirada, CA — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 01:34:10 GMT

Gosh, it's sure depressing to see all of the "liberal", "conservative" comments about this story. Anyone who calls Mr. Bush a conservative has no clue of what a real conservative is. The Bush gang and thier corporate owners love to bash those evil "tax and spend" liberals. I would agree with that sentiment 100%. They neglect to mention that they are "borrow and spend" liberals, which is MUCH worse. One of the main tenants of conservatism is smaller and less intrusive government. Mr. Bush and his handlers have overseen the largest increase in government power and spending since WWII. They also have declared that since the president is Republican and we're at war, (how convenient, since he's the one that started the war), the constitution no longer applies, and the executive branch has absolute power to read our emails, listen to our phone calls, read our mail, "DETAIN" US INDEFINETLY WITHOUT RECOURSE TO THE COURT SYSTEM, and who knows what else we haven't learned about yet. The "war on terror" is worse than the the "war on drugs" and the "war on poverty" foisted on us by admitted liberals, but similar in that there is no end, and it justifies whatever taking of our freedoms the war declarer thinks is justified. Reading some of the "God bless our country, and whoop on those evil ragheads" comments is like reading some of the news from Germany in 1934-1940. We all know what happened there. Please wake up and tell our government that we want them out of our business before it's too late.

Thanks

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Army Mom — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 02:02:19 GMT

Reading the previous blogs makes me realize how great we have it here. No one will be executed by speaking his or her own opinion, we can get up in the morning with the security of thinking that we can pretty much can still live the way we want. Other nationalities still want to come here because we have it better here than they do in their own countries. I fear that the more we fight among ourselves that we will become like the countries that others have left. I don't see any reference to anyone stating that they have a child now serving or having served, nor do I see a reference to anyone having lost a loved one in 911. Perhaps I have not read enough of he blogs and if that is the case I apologize. For the rest of you - thank a soldier for keeping us one of the greatest nations on earth. And pray that we don't ever lose it.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Tracy, La Mirada, CA — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 02:11:39 GMT

A few more thoughts.

How many people in Iraq were killing Americans in 2002?

Funny that we have an oil family president, and in Dec 2001 I bought gas for $.99.9.

Odd that according to the Federal government, "inflation", which in newspeak means rising prices, was 4% last year, when gas went from $2.49 to $4.39 and rising daily, bread went from $.79 to at least $1.29, and an 8' 2x4 went from $1.19 to $1.89. Must be that new math thing.

If Thomas Jefferson, George Washington and the rest of the founding fathers came back today, they'd be planning revolution tomorrow. Remember, they went to war over a 2% tea tax.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Laura, Maryland — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 02:44:47 GMT

To those of you that think we shouldn't have "invaded" Iraq, let's turn back the clock to the days of Saddam and give you and all of your family a one way ticket to Iraq and see how you would have liked living under Saddam's rule.(He idealized Hitler so maybe you think no one should have stopped him either) You would probably have "disappeared" by now if you made public comments against Saddam's government. Would you want someone to come and help you have freedom????? Our country lost many lives as it gained it's freedom but it was worth the cost. IF YOU WANT TO EDUCATE YOURSELVES there is plenty of information out there that supports why it was the right thing to do to go there, including MANY more positive stories like this one that the main stream media don't want to talk about. What a disservice to our troops not to be telling every good thing that is happening. Anyway, watch the History Channel special on Saddam and see the weapons makers talking and see the bodies hanging from gallows around town squares where Saddam heard people were talking against him, so he killed all those involved. Look at all of the people holding up photos of family members "missing" because of Saddam's thugs. Read George Sada's book "Saddam's Secrets". He was a top pilot for Saddam and was told by Saddam to fly a mission to drop CHEMICAL WEOPONS on Isreal. The planes were to fly over Jordan and Syria and probably would have been intercepted and shot down over those countries. Can you imagine??? Read Nonie Darwish's book "Now They Call Me Infidel" that talks about her first hand accounts of growing up under Islamist extremist and how they are not "going away" and will not just "play nicely" if Obama sweet talks them and rolls over instead of sticking with the hard mission ahead. Not giving a firm response over the years, as with the bombing of the USS Cole, the embasies and other events that clearly led up to the 9/11 tragedies, will no longer work. We need to stand up for freedom for all and in the long run that is what will also make us more secure. When the terrorist networks and websites were all thrilled when more democrats were elected, what does that tell you??? Do we want the same people elected that our sworn enemies want to see elected? The politicians they know will appease them and then let them get away with more terrorism? We should all say a thank you prayer every night for our freedoms and thank the military for helping us keep our freedom! Don't take it for granted!

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Jack Daniel, Yellowknife, NWT, Canada — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 03:23:32 GMT

If we all got along, none of the young people who we have trained (and brainwashed that it's for our country that you protect) from the coalition would be getting killed, neither would the citizens in our home country's that kill each other. It's not just the Americans that they think are the bad guys, the bad guys come from Canada, Europe, Australia...etc...as well.
Good news or bad news.....we all know it's about love thy neighbor.....never mind what faith YOU BELIEVE IN.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Kelly, MO — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 03:23:50 GMT

Our family is very proud of our military member, he is doing the job he was trained for. I wish he didn't have to go but since he and many others will be sent overseas I think we can do nothing less than give them and our President our complete support. You may not agree what the President has done but you should still support him. Would you want to be responsible for making the decision to send so many so far away, I doubt it. God Bless our Troops.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

greg wilson , White Plains,NY — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 04:48:20 GMT

Fact Tenet was an appointee of Clinton
Fact Tenet stated publicly he stands by the intelligence assesment he provide to Bush

So all this Bush lied stuff is crap Tenet provided
the assesment,and looking back he still stands by
the assesment based on the CIA evidence at THE TIME.

In addition Iraqi have come forward to join police
and army the death toll in the past 4.5 years has always been

1) Iraqi Civilians
2) Iraqi Police and military
3) Amecican Military

The sectarian nature of the police is slowly fading,
as Iraqi Army grows stronger they can eliminate
extremist elements on both sides and all evidence points to an improving Iraqi Army.

American soldiers will probably continue to be
withdrawn at about 3000/month again in October
with new Petreus analysis.

Then provided Obama if he wins does not Pander
to his left wing support he will realize
a slow steady withdrawal which will guarantee
a stable self governing Iraq is better then
artificial timelines he states in order to get
money from George Soros so he can push his socialist
agenda in USA .... That is Obamas main goal

Socialism in USA he he does not care about Iraqi civilians and the furture of Middle East ....

He wants one thing massive wealth redistribution in USA

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Emil Cipolla, Poughkeepsie, NY (Capt USAF - Ret). — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 05:34:21 GMT

The Leftist anti-war Dems confuse the near universally held intelligence (beginning with the Clinton Admin in 1998)and ALL western Intel services with wrong and incoplete data. Saddam DID have, and DID use WMD on his people, and there was reason to believe that he still had WMD in 2003.

The invasion was justified in light of 9/11 - The US could not take the risk of another attack on our interests. Recall that there were at least 12 terrorist attacks during the Clinton Admin (first WTC attack in 1993, the two African Embassy bombings, the attack on the USS Cole, etc. (see the book 'The Cell')for which Clinton took tepiod and ineffective actions that only furhter embolded the terrorists.

The invasion was a miltary success, and the CPA actions wrt removing the Baathists from power and disbanding the Sunni-led and incomptent Iraqi army were sound judgements at the time (but had negative consequences).

McCain was correct; we should have had more troops from during the occupation in 2004 - 2006. Despite the denials of the Dems, and the lack of positive reporting from the MSM, security, political, and economic progress is occurring.

Any and all US casualties are unfortunate, but more US troops died in a single day's Pacific island battle in WW2 or in a single month in the Hurtgen Forest than in five years in Iraq.

One final point - for those who think it is taking too long to achieve political stability, recall that after the US revolution, it took seven years before our Constitution and present form of government was developed.

The Leftist Dems either have little knowledge of history or ignores facts that do not fit their anti-US bias.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Tommy Springfield MO — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 05:37:05 GMT

Thanks for shareing a little truth for once ,it's refreshing

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

BBrooks, Portland, Oregon — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 05:43:35 GMT

Everone knows when and what winning the war means. After the winning takes place then the special unmentionable race comes in and proceeds to salvage all the scrap steel, surplus tanks and other war machinery, amunitions and all the rest.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Karl Bratcher, Florence, Oregon — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 05:53:08 GMT

<It is the responsibility of everyone who takes a breath in freedom to do all that they can to provide that opprotunity to all of humanity. There are word in our history books that state "all that is necessary for evil to prevail is for good men(and women) to do nothing. is this a long road? YES is it worthwhile? YES is it costly? Yes is it necessary you will have to answer this yourself, but for this service connected disabled American Veteran I believe it is. We forget and disrespect the sacrafice of all who have fought and died for this principle in all the wars of history. Success come with perseverance and we can not walk away from this. I am thankful for this story and it's real message to the people of the world>
I too am a Service Connected Disabled Veteran and feel the above remarks somewhat misleading. I look back at my forefathers knowing they too gave all that was asked of them, most of them gladly doing so knowing their children wouldn't have to do the same. Herein come the truth that every group of children that comes along sooner or later pays the same price over and over again. Seems to me if I follow this line my kids shall be domed to pay the same price again. I gave and I'm ready again but surely, there must be a better way

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Brad, San Diego, CA — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 06:18:49 GMT

I see a lot of comments here from people who already seem to have made up their minds - that the press is either subject to liberal bias, or that we don't belong there and we should just leave. When something bad happens in Iraq and the media reports it, why does that make them "liberal media?" On the contrary, have we become so morally corrupt as a nation that we would invade another country and promise their people freedom and Democracy, only to leave when things do not go as planned? There are good reporters and bad ones, just like politicians. I went on some pretty hairy missions and there were some brave reporters who volunteered to go with us. The stories they reported were fair and accurate. They were from media outlets like MSNBC and the Washington Post - funny, I don't recall seeing any FOX news analysts (you know, the "Fair and Balanced" news people) out on any missions other than reporting from safe inside the camp at the cafeteria interviewing guys who never left the 'wire.' I went on a lot of missions in places like Fallujah, Ramadi, Haditha, Baghdad, Sadr City, and Basra. We did a lot of good things that did not get reported in the news - mostly because it was too dangerous to bring media with us. But the real reason is because the American public does not think Iraq is front page news anymore, and therefore, fewer reporters being sent into the field. If you want to believe there are mostly good things happening in Iraq, nothing you see in the news is going to change your mind. If you believe it was all a big waste of time, likewise anything you read won't have much affect, either. The truth is, there are no simple answers, Republican or Democrat. Bullets and bombs don't care which political party you belong to. We build schools - insurgents blow them up. We build police stations - militias kill the police men. Insurgents attack passing patrols and sometimes women and children die in the crossfire. Sometimes civilian cars approach checkpoints too fast and we kill the people inside thinking they are suicide bombers. Sometimes the Iraqi security forces attack us - and we kill them in return. Meanwhile, some Iraqis are willing to die for us and fight alongside us like brothers. I owe my life to some of these men - to suggest abandoning them is like abandoning my own family. One man named Jamal took a bullet from an AK-47 point blank in the chest for me - because he said I was his friend and he would always protect me. He kept his word as though I was his brother. He will always be mine. Early in the war his home had been bombed by American planes and his mother and brother killed by US forces who mistook them for insurgents. The police in his neighborhood were armed and trained by the US - and then systematically rooted out all of the Sunni's, including Jamal's family. But no matter what, Jamal believed the US was there to help Iraq. How could we make so many promises and mistakes, and yet how could we consider abandoning people like him? Shame on all of us! We have become a nation of the weak - when we see images of the dead and wounded on TV we claim liberal bias. We have government policies prohibit the showing of pictures of flag draped coffins of American servicemen and women being brought home (over 4,000) - we don't have the guts to live with the consquences of the actions brought about by the government we elect. Wow - I could go on and on....I guess after a couple of tours of serving my country, maybe I have become a little bit cynical. Maybe it has something to do with people asking what it is really like over there in Iraq when I know they have already made up their mind before they even ask.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Rocky — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 07:06:14 GMT

I Agree In God We Trust, AND That It is the responsibility of everyone who takes that breath of freedom to do all that they can, to provide that opportunity the other nations, to breath also & to all of humanity. Freedom Liberty is a God giin right. Now Lets go after the real terrrorists. Iran & there cronie groups. Then, Give it back to the people of IRAN then & only then will the mission will be totally accomplished. As the Beach Boys sing Bomb Bomb Bomb Bomb Bomb IRAN, not the good people they are good, only the idiots that run Iran & most of the middle east Africa & asia. Then & only then, there will be peace. That we as Americians want Peace With Honor. Along with cheap gas, food, housing, healthcare, ect. Or we could turn our heads & be the United States of Iran........ Wise............. up .........people ........... & smell the coffee.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

riddler — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 07:27:24 GMT

dont mistake this positive story from the "US" media for anything except what it is. This is direct communication from our media to their terrorist buddies, who signs the paychecks, to update their target list because this example of the U S military success cannot be allowed to stand....

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Ben,Omaha,NE — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 08:04:09 GMT

What an interesting story! i hope it continues. I wonder what will happen to the people of iraq if the American forces are pulled out. And what type of story that will come thereafter

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Andrew Bradford, Desert Operations — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 08:11:32 GMT

Let me ask you readers this, how is it all of a sudden, any type of news with the word "Iraq" has been put on the back burner....No longer on the front page of MSN.com or on the scrolling headline displays on the major propaganda media broadcast stations. I had to input the word IRAQ into te search field, to find the above article. Did the grim 4000+ combat deaths triggered this shift in not glamourizing the fallen, or since a few provinces are reaping the benefits of our security assests there is no violence to talk about?

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Bob Roberts — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 09:10:04 GMT

Yes, haven't you heard? The left demands that all stories about Iraq have clear negative spin throughout. We must remain convinced Iraq was a mistake and will be a failure. Else how can it become that?

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Al. Orlando FL — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 10:05:23 GMT

we need to considere the fact that security which is being provided behind a wall cannot be considered as golden until it can be provided in a walless area where everyone can leave together. It is not our young people's fault if things are not better in the middle of Iraq. It is the Iraqi's people's responsibity to know every single one of them is humain they need to protect their own live and stop killing each other. I do not know how and see how we are going to get out to leave this part of the world with that miss. whom ever is the next president it will be a big mistake leave that country the way it is now.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Sharon Betts, Turner, ME — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 10:38:42 GMT

The comments on this article still show the divide here on our own soil. I find this to not be positive, but sad. Security is only due to military power and tall walls - we continue to build walls, not tear them down. To me this was anything except progress.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

jorge — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 12:00:58 GMT

It's hard to believe the Bush-lovers are treating this like some kind of vindication. You're cheering over us trying to get Iraq back to some semblance of the way it was before we invaded it. That's a far cry from declaring victory even in the short term. It's not not even approaching bringing them "democracy." And we've wasted only 4100+ American lives to do it. Wow, that's really good news, folks!

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Veli Albert Kallio — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 12:13:46 GMT

I was at London peace rally before the war was started because all the evidence were against Weapons of Mass Destruction and current genocide claimed.

However, once started the "Operation Removal Saddam", it is important that the mission is accomplished. The United States and the United Kingdom has a strong relationship. The only danger being the US becomes a roaming army of the Alexander the Great who went to Afghanistan, Iraq, and Iran... Where are Al-Qaeda in Iran? Veli Albert Kallio, London, the United Kingdom.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Mo, Flemington, NJ — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 12:21:01 GMT

Many people here are talking about how this is a good story and asking why "liberals" are not commenting on this one.

The fact of the matter is that hundreds of people are dying daily, both Americans and Iraqi's. For every Dora there is there is 50 still-dangerous neighborhoods. I'm just saying I still would not want to be walking around Sadr City or Ramadi now adays

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

MAJ BTR Camp Anaconda, Iraq — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 12:29:42 GMT

Bill D, I am a Soldier, not a 100K plus American Contractor, who came to Iraq to cash in on the Bloodshed-your other choice was saying goodmorning to people as they walked thru the doors at Walmart.

There are some good Iraqis, but they are your friend, for one thing, that is to try and get something from you, we destroyed their country, predicated on lies, killed countless innocent Iraqi men, women, children were murdered by colateral damage, all of us here are hoping Obama wins so we can get the hell out of here, all of us except the retired Military Contractors who are making way too much money for what they do, who hope it never ends, even Iraq beats Walmart.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Concerned at Camp Victory — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 14:12:57 GMT

After spending over 2 years here working in Iraq for Blackwater (making money), while I appreciate the big check for doing very little, except riding around with our principles, I am saddend that so many have a negative view of all that happens on a daily basis much good is being done to help the Iraqis, our troops are doing a good job (but more could be done, if they would just stop complaining so much and get with the program). I to do not feel good how BUSH lied about Iraq to invade, all to further our American Empire, which is not looking to Imperial to the rest of the world. I can not publish my name for fear of losing my job.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Tom Macon Kuwait City — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 14:23:03 GMT

Aadil from Spokane- while I agree with alot of what of your saying as I work in the Middle East and know you are speaking the truth. I am slightly vexed at Saudi intentions not to raise production, they would not even have a country if it wasn't for US Military Might, are we so naive, as to think that Saddam would have stopped at Kuwait's border after successfully invading, had we not crushed him in Kuwait City (along Arabian Gulf Road), no!, he would have pushed over into the Kingdom of Saud, had it not been for United States intervention. So I'm preplexed-but agree, we need to cut away from the, "Big Bully" foriegn policy, it makes our enemy look good and the BUSH Whitehouse look bad.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Lori, Oregon — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 14:51:56 GMT

If you talk to the troops who have been or are in Iraq they will all tell you the same thing, that they are glad to have been in Iraq because they can SEE the changes and they can SEE all the people sho are being helped. My husband went to Iraq, he was a medic and he saved the Iraqis as well as our own men. He tells me all the time that he would go back again if he could because he belives in the cause. If we pull out of Iraq their new found growth and their upturning economy will all crumble. The new formed government will likely fall and the terorists will take over. We really need to THINK this thru before we decide to pull out of Iraq and abandon those people.

Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Mac Bare, Durham NC — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 15:00:33 GMT

Someone somewhere has been struck by the truth virus. Amazing. Still, Mr. Reporter, you couldn't resist the snide comment at the end, could you? This reflects what the liberal mind set says to conservatives: you seem to WANT our soldiers to fail and Iraq to go up in flames. Apparently all that matters is proving that George Bush is the "village idiot." I think if you survey people who actually LIVED under Saddam, or whose families did so, you'll get a different view (see comments in this thread for examples).

Was Saddam a threat to the U.S.? Well, let's see...he hated the U.S. with a white hot hatred. He had the means to support and succor our enemies. He would have done all in his power to provide shelter and support to Al Qaeda, and would have done so. But more to the point, are we going to abandon the process of creating a genuine democracy in Iraq now that we have already invested so much?

World War II ended 63 years ago. We still have troops in Western Europe. The Korean 'conflict' ended 55 years ago. We still have troops in S. Korea. Europe and South Korea are today the site of stable democracies. This would not have been the case had the United States not invested plenty of time, blood and treasure to make it so.