ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



Taliban commander: We're fighting for 'independence'

Posted: Wednesday, November 18, 2009 9:08 AM
Filed Under:

SPIN BOLDAK, Afghanistan – Even as the Pakistani army steps up its offensive against the Taliban in Pakistan’s northern tribal region, there are increasing concerns about militants from Afghanistan seeking safe haven in a different part of the country: Quetta, the capital of Pakistan’s southwest Baluchistan Province.

American military and intelligence officials believe that the Taliban ruling council, or shura, which commands and controls jihad efforts in Afghanistan, have abandoned their historic base in the southern Afghan city of Kandahar and crossed the border into Quetta.

In Pakistan, the issue is raised every day in the press and on the streets: Have the Afghan Taliban moved their power base from Kandahar and set-up shop in Quetta? Quetta is my home – my family and friends live there – so I had a personal, as well as professional stake in finding out what’s been going on.

Some colleagues urged me to talk to Mullah Manan, a commander of 70 foot soldiers in Helmand province in Afghanistan, to try to get some answers.

‘Welcome to Spin Boldak’
It took weeks to arrange an interview with Manan, but finally the meeting point was set for Spin Boldak, a town in Afghanistan, near Kandahar.

Four of Manan’s men were waiting for me on motorbikes when I arrived by car in Spin Boldak. We exchanged greetings and then they blindfolded me and helped me onto the back of one of the bikes.

We drove for what seemed to be more than an hour, careening at breakneck speeds along narrow mountain roads. The driver zigzagged around rocks and potholes while the others seemed to follow closely behind. When we finally skidded to a halt, my blindfold was lifted.

I was led into a room in a modest house built of mud and sun-dried bricks and told to sit on the floor and wait. The room was mostly dark; there were no windows and no furniture, and the air smelled of damp wet mud. A dark green door of rotting wood was left ajar to let in some light.

After about 15 minutes, tea was served. Shortly afterwards, a young man with a thick, black beard entered, flanked by two others. "Welcome to Spin Boldak. I am Commander Mullah Manan," he said, "the second in command to Mullah Abdul Hakeem, the commander of Helmand Province."

Image: Mulla Manan
Mujeeb Ahmad/NBC News
Taliban commander Mulla Manan seen during a recent interview in Spin Boldak, Afghanistan.

He wrapped a white turban around his head as he began to speak. "I just returned from a council meeting in Kandahar," he said. Manan laughed as he explained that the U.S. and NATO forces think they can identify the Taliban by their black turbans – but they don’t understand that they only wear black at certain times. He seemed to enjoy pointing out that the Taliban are Afghans and dress like Afghans, which he said means they wear "baggy trousers, long loose-fitting shirts and white turbans." 

I was anxious to ask him about the rumors that the Taliban’s shura, or ruling council, had moved to Quetta. "This is Western propaganda," he said. "The only true Taliban shura is the one led by Mullah Omar. It has 29 members and is spread around Afghanistan – some of the members are even holding key government posts. Their identities are known only among the shura members," Manan explained.

He was referring to Mullah Muhammad Omar, a reclusive, one-eyed cleric who is regarded by all the Taliban as their supreme commander and the founder of the movement.

"Where is Mullah Omar?" I asked.  

"Very few know his whereabouts, but I am sure he is still in Afghanistan," Manan replied. "Mullah Omar’s orders are written down and then given to the shura members. They, in turn, pass them on to a chosen eight or nine others. Eventually everyone receives the orders. No one uses any form of telecommunications or electronic devices," Manan added with a smile.

Image: ullah Manan
NBC News
Taliban commander Mulla Manan, center, with reporter Mujeeb Ahmad on right with notebook and pen.

Peace proposal?
I pressed him with more questions about Taliban activities in Quetta, particularly because I’m worried about the threat of drones destroying my city and killing my family and friends.

"We are not safe in Quetta," Manan answered, referring to the Taliban forces. "These days, the Pakistani security forces are looking for us and it is no longer safe to even cross the border to visit friends. Besides," Manan added, "we control almost 80 percent of Afghanistan, why should we hide in Pakistan?"

Manan lectured me on the Taliban’s war against American and NATO troops, calling them occupiers who must be expelled from his country. He said he had personally killed 15 foreign troops.

"We don’t distinguish between American, British or other Europeans," he said. "They are all white people; they are all occupiers. We can never accept them and we will fight until we liberate our country."

"Will you guarantee to the Americans that if they leave [Afghanistan] there won't be another 9/11 attack against them?" I asked.

"Look, we want an Islamic state with Islamic laws," Manan replied quietly, while his eyes seemed to bore right through me. "If the Americans leave, then we will not concern ourselves with them any longer."

Manan paused and then asked: "Do you understand what I am telling you?" And then he put it this way. "That means we will never again allow our country to be used in the same way as it was used against America in the past."

"That sounds like a peace proposal," I said.

Manan laughed. He was quick to point out that this was the Taliban viewpoint, but since no one recognizes them as an international force, no one is asking them to abide by any international obligations.

"Look," he explained, "the Americans are offering huge sums of money to anyone who will lay down arms and join them. We are fighting for our independence and for our country. We believe in our cause and the Americans should stop trying to bribe us."

"Make no mistake," Manan added, "some of us will take their money, but none of us will ever give up our fight."

Mujeeb Ahmed is on the Executive Council of the Balouchistan Journalists Federation and is a reporter for AAj TV, the second leading news network in Pakistan. He is based in Quetta and is a contributor to NBC News in Pakistan.

INTERACTIVE MAP: Conflict in Pakistan
Power struggle threatens Pakistan's leader
Topics: More stories, videos, Web links on Pakistan

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

These people have long memories and will not forget out misguided adventure into Afghanistan.

The Taliban are merely women beaters who live in caves and only want to be left alone. We confuse them with Al Qaeda, who have more operatives in Europe and the States than in Afghanistan.
Of course he is defiant.  He realizes that his enemy (us) is led by emasculated, (pseudo) intellectual progressives.  The worst that can happen to him is that he will receive a nasty letter from Obama and the U.N.  
After reading this article about the Taliban perspective and their plans, I have realized that our U.S. eight-year war is suddenly useless and will never be "won". Time to bring the troops home!
Sell the place to the Chinese for the money we owe them.
I agree, we should KILL them rather than bribe them. Obama is a FOOL if he things we are going to buy our way out of this mess. The Taliban are TERRORISTS, plain and simple, send them to hell with swine!
Independance my foot, they've been known to kill barbers for giving shaves, beat and kill women for trying to get an education. They are monsters and a danger to the security of all free nations.
We leave Afghanistan, the Taliban establish their own system of government and law according to their local customs and preferences, and they won't allow jihadist activities against the U.S. to be conducted from Afghan soil.  Sounds reasonable to me.  Afghanistan has no real central(national) government,and we are trying to create one by dealing with the few choices we have (Malaki), who are all corrupt and untrustworthy.  Haven't we been here before?  Iraq, Viet Nam?  Why don't we just get out- we are looking for Al Queda and Bin Ladin, remember, not out to create democracies in Muslim countries with a tribal culture.  If anyone else attacks us and the Taliban was involved, we will just have to rain down cruise missles on them until they appear to have learned a lesson.  There is always a possibility we will have to "go back there"- we will never be able to create a functioning, stable democracy there.  Be we should never go back there with foot soldiers, just with really big hammers (bombs) that make our point.    
We are bribing people in Afghanistan so they can be our friends. Those who accept the money use it to their benefit only and persecute the population. The result is that the Afghan peole hates us. This reminds me of the US policy in the middle East. We give Egypt and Jordan a total of $2 billion dollars a year as bribe money so they can be the only Arab countries to have diplomatic relations with Israel. Israel then demolish and evicts Palestinians from their homes , steal their land and water, and the whole Arab world hates us. This answers the question why do they hate us? We spend billions a year to do exactly that.
independence bull, its overthrown and make their own state with no concern of the people. they are a group of thugs and criminals that want power and authority that they could not have in the real world.
WHERE DO THE TALIBAN GET ALL THEIR WEAPONS.

CUT OFF SUPPLY ;  WILL CRIPPLE THEM
UNTIL THEN THEY KEEP FIGHTING
With 9-11, the country reacted to a disaster.  With the wars, the country planned a disaster.  In the beginning many of us felt this country should punish the people who offended us and we were hot to trot.

Who can resist our technology and military force.  Who are these people to think they could defy the United States?

Lessons have not been learned.  No exit strategy, no way of a morally superior position, backing corrupt governments.  What were we thinking ?

Withdraw, come to what ever political solution which would allow us to get out with minimal risk to Americans.  Use our strengths through negotiations and political ties with other nations who's intersts align with ours to achieve some same solution.

In the end  only energy independance will allow us to leave the Afgans to the Afgans, Iraq to Iraq to be the best they can be and good luck to them.
If the Taliban controls 80% of Afghanastan, then they should be easy to find and kill.  What are we waiting for?  
If this is straight talk, maybe - just this once - we take the Taliban at their word and just get out. We can monitor for insurgent activities including training of Al Queida operatives.
Taliban can do what they want; and if they observed human rights with their own people (women and children) I doubt America would have much of an interst in the Taliban.  But, they have a horrendous track record with women, and it is hard to be able to tell te world, "The Taliban only want to be left alone."
What a waste of perfectly good web resources. MSNBC - who cares what a bunch of terrorists want or believe.  
You know, I'm all about defending our country and killing the bad guys, but I sure can't wait for us to get the hell OUT of the middle east.
Taliban can do what they want; and if they observed human rights with their own people (women and children) I doubt America would have much of an interst in the Taliban.  But, they have a horrendous track record with women, and it is hard to be able to tell te world, "The Taliban only want to be left alone."
Thank you so much for this article, Mr Ahmed.  I have believed all along that people in Afghanistan and other countries near there would love to have all the foreigners gone from their country.  It is a big part of the killing still going on.  I hope we can trust this man's comments. I wish the women in his country would be treated better.  Education of women would go a long way to improve their situation politically, monetarily and healthwise.  
He looks cold in that picture.  Is he wearing a Snuggie?
As far as I am concerned these people are the worst form of human life.
The article is brief abd to the point, and, the reporter's spin on it overall, was quite factual. Whar astounds me, is these guys get tio met wioth the Taliban top brass,with no problem, whzy don't the Afgan intelligence forces (and I use that preceding words loosely) send one of thier own in with some inte-tech gadgetry and get a fix on thse guys and take out the top brass as well! This "Mana" commander "§nesd a little "comeuppance", re his atitude for sure! His commnet abou the "gov#t big-shots being on his Suira council, was very true, "I for one, beleive him"! Why don'Ät NATO and we American Chiefs, "put the grip on "Karzi" to clean houe NOW, or get replaced immediately. This whole charde sems like a great waste of US taxpayer's monies for SURE.

the talib are cool. they will win. but i think they should take a fashion risk, and wear camoflaged turbans.
Time to get out of that area of the world and let them fight amongst themselves.  Stop giving bribes to people who accept money and then just laugh at us.  It makes us as dishonest, ignorant and low life as them.
Yes.  We can stop the war in Afghanistan.  Why we're killing our own people and others and at the same time making anermies all over the world including in the USA?  All citizens of USA loves America but also they love their mother land and their heritage of culture.  We need 'PEACE' only in the whole wide world.  we do live all over the nations and we all are brothers and sisters each other. Instead of killing each other let's help each other to improve our human well being.
Maybe all he really wants is a hug!
As a former Counter-Intelligence Agent for the 75th Ranger Regiment, I can honestly say American forces are not accomplishing anything in Afghanistan other than making alot more enemies. Understanding the anger, fear and frustrations of the 9/11 attack (part of the reason I signed up for active duty), I must admit today I feel it was a mistake to start a "War on Terror"; Hindsight is always better than foresight. One of the points of a terrorist act is bait and boy did they catch a big mouth bass. The majority of the locals in Afghanistan hold a very simplistic view, which is for the US and every other foreign nation to leave them alone and I agree. The irony in this is, Al Qaeda for the most part is not even in Afghanistan anymore, we as a military force couldn't control the border...hell we can't even control the border between Mexico. Which shouldn't be an issue b/c America was founded on immigration but I guess we no longer want "certain" immigrants.
The article is brief abd to the point, and, the reporter's spin on it overall, was quite factual. Whar astounds me, is these guys get tio met wioth the Taliban top brass,with no problem, whzy don't the Afgan intelligence forces (and I use that preceding words loosely) send one of thier own in with some inte-tech gadgetry and get a fix on thse guys and take out the top brass as well! This "Mana" commander "§nesd a little "comeuppance", re his atitude for sure! His commnet abou the "gov#t big-shots being on his Suira council, was very true, "I for one, beleive him"! Why don'Ät NATO and we American Chiefs, "put the grip on "Karzi" to clean houe NOW, or get replaced immediately. This whole charde sems like a great waste of US taxpayer's monies for SURE.

Just build them a theme park, a NASCAR track, a soccer field and a casino.   Introduce alcohol and prostitution and they'll all have something to do rather than run around like idiots.
Read "Three Cups of Tea" ~ there is another way...
Seems to me many people have memory problems.  The Taliban ran the country and allowed Al Qaeda to base their operations there, amongst other terrorist organizations.  While in charge they inflicted severe draconian laws with equally harsh penalties for violating them to the people.  You think it will be any different if we pull out and let them take over again?

The reason this war is not going well is because Americans are not showing a unified front to defeat them.  All this whining and complaining that we should quit is what is allowing the Taliban to keep on going.  Because we are showing doubt and weakness for war all they have to do is hang on until we give up.  Wars can not be won without the support of the people, if we do not support our government and military they can not win no matter what they do.
That sounds fantastic for Americans, but this leader doesn't say anything about what the Taliban's plan will be toward the Afghanistan Government except he wants to set up "Islamic state with Islamic laws".  Does that mean they will try and overthrow the current government where everybody has (or is supposed to have) a voice?  Will the Taliban's rule be like it was before we kicked them out of Government, where the other minority ethnic groups lived in fear or fled to neighboring countries?  I am glad this journalist asked the pressing questions.
"they are all white people" ? This man is a religious zealot who is ignorant by choice. He and his ilk will  not stop. Afganistan is and has been a backwater quagmire for any nation who trespassed that wasteland for centuries. Afhganistan is not a nation-state, it is a collection of rural tribes. In hindsight, the nations of the world who could have helped this motley collection of ignored people should have done so long ago. As what's his name said, some of them will take our money, but they will still fight us. This is an area of the world where part of the rite of passage to manhood involves manufacturing your own firearm. I have no answer to this situation. I fear we will leave Afhganistan just as the Russians and British did, basically with our "tails between our legs". By the way, I am a "white "person.
He's saying the same thing that Jews said, Irish said, and everybody else said, who was fighting for independence and a homeland. Religion is a short-hand way of identifying supporters. Once the occupier is gone it becomes less important over-time. It sounds like the Taliban might agree to some rules -- like not harboring any body who attacks us, and maybe we can get them to respect world cultural sites and basic international rules.  They want to belong to something bigger than themselves which is fundamental Islam. Maybe we can substitute the bigger world community to some degree.
Here is the scoup give them a homeland if they give us binladden then we can worry about keeping them isolated. We don't want te kill them now just binladden. It is their back yard they have a right to NIMBY
Well having talban in quetta this is the beggest joke i am listinning now a days from western media.Why dont america just speaks up clearly that it wants free balauchistan so it can come and control the waters of indian ocean through Gawadar deep sea port which is underconstruction with the help of china.I am sure Washington will not be happy with the presence of china in that area.AS far as i know from the ground realities the talban in Pakistan and talban in Afghanistan are 2 different organizations so dont mix them up with each other.Talban in Pakistan are highly funded by foreign source and they are using high technologies and weapons in pakistan even few of the talbans who were killed in pakistan were not even muslims.I dont wonder Indians are pretty active in afghanistan but the bad part is Washington is supporting india in this cold war.Washington and New Delhi dont like a nuclear armed pakistan so they are making these kinds of grounds to disarm Pakistan from nuclear weapons.If pakistan give up its nuclear weapons everyone see the next day u will not find any single talban inside pakistan.
This proves to me that we are wasting time, money and most importantly lives in Afgan. We need to let them have their worthless country back and just keep an eye on Al Queda. Who cares if the Taliban return? The current puppet Afgan govement is just as bad.
Seems to me like a dog and pony show over there, lets let them have there dirt and caves, etc, get out NATO Forces out and see what happens.
The Afgan people cry out to us, "save us from the Taliban".  When we then send them help, they then say we are occupying their country and must leave. There is nothing anyone can do to help such people.  They get the rulers they deserve. There is not one american life worth giving for these people.  We need to pull out of the middle east, all our troops, our bases and our foreign aid and let them live as they say they want, with no help from America.  If their women die from lack of medical care, if they are beaten and killed for not wearing a burka, if their daughters have no education and are treated as slaves, it is no concern of ours, it is the life they choose.
The Taliban are thugs and cannot be trusted, ever. As for this becoming another Vietnam, that is because Americans don't have a backbone anymore. We create rules to war and be damned if we mess up. The enemy can behead your family member in the name of God, but we have to act like playground monitors.

We keep letting our media dictate the results, then we'll become another France.
Al Qaeda attacked us and the taliban drove the get away car.  That makes both just as guilty and both must pay the same price.  Neither deserve to exist.  Once the Afgan people submit then the US will get out, eventually.  
While we dither they control 80% of the country?  Are we showing the Muslim world who is really the strong horse?  
That leader is full of bull, I like how he says he has killed 15 foreign soldiers personally, in excution style! This guy is to scared to leave his cave to fight Coalition forces.
These so called Taliban are Expansionists as exhibited in Pakistan.If we give them Afghanistan they will take another country like Pakistan. The Taliban want an Islamic state which takes in all of Europe. Look at the terriost attacks in Spain, UK and the US. These people will not learn until the ground they stand on turns to glass. We have the means but lack the will to end this battle in a matter of hours. What is wrong with our decision makers? One Nuke in Baghdad and then tell them one major city goes until the brick throwing stops. That is the only thing they understand. We leave they accelerate. No choice in my view.
The big losers in these mideast wars are Iraq, Afganistan, Pakistan, and America. The big winner is Israel. They got big dumb Uncle Sam to fight their wars for them. They cleverly used our foreign aid dollers to pack Congress and the media with Israel supporters, then ordered us to war. Very clever
This whole Taliban issue is about control and more than that, most conflicts are about control.

Living in America, I only know what I see and hear through news and military reports.  Having said that, from what I see, the Taliban wishes to control not just their women, but anybody who doesn't agree with their ideology.

Why should their own countrymen and women be forced to accept these strict edicts if they don't agree with them?  

Its simple.  These Taliban members wish to control their own people because the majority of the Afghans don't agree with them and so they use force in the way of murders, decapitations, and threats against their citizens.

Like most conflicts throughout history, it is a few that try to make the majority submit in order to maintain their own jilted way of looking at life.
Nothing we can do will ever change the way the Taliban and Afghans tribal councils think and believe.  They have been doing things the same way for thousands of years. Those Afghans who do not believe the same way should have left ages ago.
We need to totally leave the middle east, europe, asia and all other countrys alone.  We need to remove all American troops from foreign soil.  Let's worry about America for a while.
WHY ARE WE STILL IN AFGHANISTAN? AFTER 9/11 WE WERE GOING AFTER THE TERRORISTS HOME BASE. WE SCREWED THAT UP WHEN WE DECIDED TO GO AFTER SADAM IN IRAQ, INSTEAD OF FINISIING IN AFGHANISTAN.
WE AREN'T GOING TO CHANGE THE TRIBAL CULTURE THAT EXISTS THERE AND TO SUGGEST THAT WE ARE, IS JUST ARROGANT AND STUPID.
WE CERTAINLY WON'T MAKE OURSELVES SAFER BY A CONTINUATION OF WHAT CERATINLY SEEMS AN OCCUPATION BY THE LOCALS.
WE SHOULDN'T ALLOW ONE MORE OF OUR HEROIC SOLDIERS TO DIE IN EITHER AFGHANISTAN OR IRAQ. OUR STRATEGY IN BOTH CASES WAS AND IS FLAWED.
TO THOSE WHO SUGGEST WE SHOULD STAY UNTIL WE ARE "VICTORIOUS", I CAN ONLY SAY YOU ARE DELUSIONAL , ARROGANT AND YOU MUST HAVE MISSED A LOT OF HISTORY AND GEOGRAPHY CLASSES.
Really Strange Ideals!! Win their Independence,To do what?,Kill and ravage others with their miss treatment of Woman,and Children. There is NO Moral Fiber in those People whatsoever,They can Pray to their so called god,which is just a misinformed Human all they want, But our real God will have the last laugh,and  so will we,( The US )
as long as Iran is supplying arms to extremists
thru out the region there will never be peace in
the middle east, Iran must be dealth with,
USA and westerns never learn a lesson..... Ask yourself a question.... what makes you to be hated so much around the world? when you get into other's affairs with your hand.... why Westerns care Daliban's killing women and doing such... better you look how many women killd and abused in western country with a liberal and free.... Im not supporting Daliban's killing women...
Westerns, mind your business and deal with your problems... dont try to solve other's problem when u have so much trouble in ur hands....

when you invade other's homes, demolish, and kill expect they will not only hate you but will be against you till they die....

All I say... America learn your lessons and know what u want to do for your ppl.......


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=2130311

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.