ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



Civilians caught in the crossfire in Pakistan

Posted: Friday, May 08, 2009 5:37 PM
Filed Under:

MARDAN, Pakistan – Shaista, a terrified 11-year-old girl from the Swat Valley, was lying in a hospital bed in Mardan’s ill-equipped health center on Friday.

She suffered severe injuries to her legs when an artillery shell, reportedly fired by Pakistani troops, hit her family’s small house Thursday night in Mingora.

The traumatized Shaista said the mortar shell struck a room where she was sleeping. Her voice choking, Shaista said her mother, two sisters and brother were killed in the incident – and then she became lost in deep despair.

Image: Pakistan
Mushtaq Yusufzai / NBC
Shaista, 11, in her hospital bed in Marden.

A doctor treating the girl said she seems to lose her memory when speaking and starts to suddenly cry – apparently because of deep shock she suffered.

Children have proved to be some of the hardest-hit victims among the estimated 1 million people displaced by the ongoing fighting between Pakistan’s armed forces and Taliban militants in the northern districts of Buner and Swat.

Shaista said her father was worried about her family’s safety after the Pakistani military launched its operation against the Taliban in Swat and went to locate a house in a safer area for them to go to.

"He went to Dargai town on Thursday and said he would shift us to a safer place on Friday," she said, but the move didn’t happen soon enough. She said her neighbors recovered the bodies of her mother, sisters and brother from the rubble of the building and then took her to the hospital in the morning.

Ahmad Yar, a villager from Daggar who was taking care of his critically injured mother in the same ward of the hospital, said he had decided to take Shaista to his home once she is discharged. He said the neighbors who had taken her to the hospital left so that they could move their own families to a safer place.

‘We don’t know what our crime is’
In the same hospital, more than a dozen people had been admitted from Buner district with multiple injuries they received when they came under heavy artillery shelling by the security forces.

Image: Swat valley
Mushtaq Yusufzai / NBC News
Pakhtun Qamar, 12, was injured by an artillery shell in the Swat Valley. Doctors in the Marden hospital operated on his legs and had to amputate several of his fingers.

"We don’t know what our crime is that our own armed forces are targeting us. On one hand the government is asking us to vacate our houses and on the other they imposed curfew and blocked all roads in Buner," complained Sher Badshah, who came from the village of Suwarai. He said thousands of people are still trapped in Buner who cannot come out due to a government imposed curfew and the blockade of roads.

Badshah complained that he was taking his family to the apparent safety of Mardan when an artillery shell hit one of the trucks, killing five members of his family and injuring three others, including his aged father.

"Now tell me what crime this aged person had committed," his angry son asked.

He alleged that instead of eliminating Taliban militants, the troops have been targeting innocent people who wanted to flee for safer places.

He claimed several people who were moving to safer places via the mountains had been killed by indiscriminate military artillery shelling and their bodies were still lying there.


‘I don’t know what kind of people these Taliban are’

Shams-ul-Qamar’s story was no less tragic. He said he lost his eldest son in the cross-fire between Taliban and security forces.

"Qamar had just passed his matriculation examination and was looking forward to getting admission to college," he said.

But his family’s tragedy started months ago – when Pakistani troops set up a security post close to his house.

"Being a Pakhtuns, it’s our tradition to serve guests with whatever is available at home," Qamar said, referring to the tribal group in Pakistan’s North-West Frontier Province. "We were poor people but tried to serve the guest soldiers sometime with milk, tea and drinking water."

However, when the troops vacated their roadside post under a peace deal that was struck between the government and the Taliban last February, militants decided to settle their score with Qamar and his family.

"They entered our home and opened fire, killing my sister Zar Bibi, my niece Farzana, my 50-year-old sister-in-law Zareena, and kidnapping my nephew on charges of taking sides and helping the Pakistan Army troops. The Taliban also took [my nephew’s] 88 model Toyota car. They later released him when he paid 100,000 rupees to the Taliban," the terrified Qamar told me and then broke into tears.

He said the government has done nothing for him since he lost four of his family members for supporting their troops.

"I don’t know what kind of people these Taliban are – Pakhtuns never target women and children," he said.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Our poor people are the innocent victims of both the "random" US drone attacks, and the US forced Pakistani Army attacks.....I wonder who's to blame? Our country was always harmonious before we started catering to foreign interests  - sacrificing our women and children in the process,,,,,,are we being "liberated" as Iraq or afghanistan are??!
I wish I could do something for poor Shaista. I have two children and can't imagine what it would be like to lose one of them let alone live thru a war in my front yard that killed my family. Why is adoption so difficult when there are children in need of parents and GOOD people who would love to be parents?
This is all politics going on and so many innocent's people are suffering becuasue of that.. this is so unfair what type of government is our leaders running..
where is peace in our world.
Pakistani Govt. should take responsibility, Mush and Zia mess it up and Pakistani is one of the most dangerous countries to live in.It is interesting to note that former President Musharraf inherited a far more fledgling Pakistan in 1999, a Pakistan which was on the verge of being declared a terrorist, bankrupt and a failed state. Musharraf inherited a Pakistan which had less than a billion dollars as foreign reserves, with an economy the mere size of $75 billion, and with 65% of our GDP used for debt servicing. Although currently our economy is fast deteriorating due to the incompetency of the new regime (who looted Pakistan in the past), the situation in 1999 was FAR WORSE than what it is now.

And despite not receiving the above level of support and commitment from the international community, Musharraf and his team were still able to deliver, with Pakistan’s situation improving prior to September 11, 2001. For example:

Pakistan’s foreign reserves had risen up to $3.2 billion by September 10 2001. To quote Dr. Ishrat Husain:

   “In 1999, the ratio of foreign reserves held by India was 40 times that of Pakistan. By June 2002 this ratio has declined to 8 times while the size of Indian economy is about 6 to 7 times that of Pakistan.”
It's always the poor, less fortunate and the children who suffer for the sake of misdirected political/religious ideology that basically addresses the rich and the influential.
Like I said in my previous post. When you make a deal with the Devil, you always lose. I sure hope the Pakistanie government has learned that lesson now and they enilate the Taliban from the face of the earth. Really all they have to do is chase them across the border and let the U.S. Marines take care of them.
The taliban are same islamic extremist who run planes into buildings. Dare we use inhanest interregation methods. They are murdering thugs.
Ordinary people of Swat & other adjoining areas are innocent victims of Taliban's atrocities. I hold Musharraf, ex dictator responsible for tolerating mullahs for last 8-10 years.In the name of religion, these ruthless bandits will not stop unless whole nation unites against them. Pity that children are caught in the crossfire.
Wow, very nice coverage on an informative article!
It's obvious that Pakistans efforts to control the Taliban are failing; causing innocent people thier lives. I think the greater powers in this world need to unite, find out who allies with the Taliban, and exterminate them swiftly. The Taliban are no more than a parasite amongst the human race and need to be delt with as so. How do you ask? With a fine toothed comb!
The taliban say the fight in the name of God, but it is clear that with the evils they commit to further their goals, they do not follow God, but something akined to a devil.
These people need to understand that they are nothing to the taliban but human shields.  They should not harbour the taliban.
when will common people realize politicians only have one agenda and that is to surpress nonwealthy & control them in every way...(alittle bit at a time)until we come to the point we are all at today it used to be limited to countries , but now is global.to the powerful its a game which the people pay for in every way.they always take without giving
it will only end when it is taken from them(all of them)
Stop the bombing. Obama you are a war monger.
Wow, poor innocent children, I wonder what I would do if I were in there situation..
Human shields should stop protecting terrorists if they dont want to die.  Common-sense rite???? Wrong!!!
These ppl dont know the meaning of comon-sense.  They are happy living this way.  Kinda like the tailer trash jerry springer ppl in the U.S.A.  Some ppl are just bred that way.
Business as usual. Nothings changed. Man is desperately wicked. Get used to it for you haven't seen anything yet. Soon, all Hell is going to break loose. Have fun.....
It is sad when children are near such destruction. However the U.S. is in the regon because Pakistan people can't do anything right. The Pakistani people don't even do a good job taking care of themselves, and now you want to blame the U.S.If Pakistan is harmonious, then why do you have NUKES? And why so many poor people? Why????? Your foreign interest for your region was brought here. We have simply taken it back to where it belongs. So please do cry about us. We are only there after our tragic invite!
One of the problems is the United States has given Pakistans Government Billions of dollars over the last 20 years or so for their defense and internal needs however they used much of the money for reasons other than defense and it's people. In other words they put in their pockets. At first it was to support the war against the Soviets then later to help with the war on terrior and border security. Now that they have blown the money and are limited by their military means to fight off the Taliban. There is a lesson here for all of us in America. We can never let our military get weak. It will come back to bite us. The Taliban and it's supporters will stop at nothing to achieve their goal, that being a total control over the entire area. WE must step in with our military and pull no punches if there is to be any peace in that part of the world.  
I was thrilled when Pakistan stepped forward to try and help put a stop to the Taliban. But, it breaks my heart how many innocents get caught in the crossfire. Though I am not Muslim, and only understand a bit of the religion, I still send out my prayers to these innocents and those still fighting to survive through. That their deaths, anguish, and cry for their lost ones does not go unheard. By God, or by any of us with a heart, and a faith. How much evil man can do in the name of righteousness. How is anything mentioned in this article righteous, but the Taliban believe they are.
My heart goes out to these poor children. I'll pray for all of them but especially for Shaista who has lost her mother and sisters.

May God bless all of the people of Swat and of Pakistan.
Pakistan a U.N. member since 1947 should get some relief from other members!  Where is our humanity?  We should never "Break The Chain"... - F.Ma.
Gee, I feel extremely outraged at pictures of innocent children (?) that have been injured/harmed becuase of conflicts because of cultural, religous, ideological differences. Then I am able to access a whole slew of pictures, videos, and instruction manuals on a whole different perspective of these poor victimized children.

Gee, I don't recall teaching my son how to use a fully automatic AK-47 or how to construct an IED.
Yes, I instructed my son on the proper handling and safe use and handling of firearms. This was instilled on me by my Father, as well as my GrandFather. Yes there was some instruction on how to use firearms for "Defense", though the majority was directed towards Safety and the Protection of Human Life (male sure of your target before you even put your finger on the trigger). However, the pictures and documentaries I have seen that show these same "Chidren" being trained on use of "Fully Automatic Weapons" (which, by the way, one can NOT legally puchase, own, buy in this country without goiung through wroitten Laws and the BATF, that is if someone would enforce Laws currently on the books) to continue, instructed on terrorist methods. How naive are those that accept what is presented as fact without question, though they be ignorant or have no knowledge or understanding of that which was put before them. (If you don't know, understand, or comprehend what the previous statement means, don't bother responding, as you have no concept of what what "Life, Liberty, and the persuit of Happiness" means. (Yeah, I know, your too busy with your I-Pod,text messageing, Guitar Hero...Yada Yada Yada...)
I almost cried reading this. Poor poor Shaista... I am 14 years old, and I can't imagine what I would do if I was the family survivor in such a horrible incident. That poor girl... Oh lord... :(
This story is very significant because it shows how the Taliban and militants have oppressed the people of Swat Valley just like the Afghans.  I beleive we  are making the necessary steps in the right direction to rid the world of these terrible people.  War is never good but sometimes necessary.  It was started in this region for a purpose and now it is time to finish it and put closure to the Taliban and Al Qaeda.
Pakistan is always on Fire due to its internal issues and politic unstability, I don't know when we will be able to stand on our feet and deny all USA and WORLD bank loans.
for years pakistan has supported the taliban against the innocent people of aghanistan particularly Musharaf the former dictator, now that the afghan people stood against the taliban and kick them out of afghanistan, the taliban found a new target, the corrupt government of pakistan. The pakistani people must stand up to these stupid wahabies in order to live in peace like they used to.
There is only one higher power that can stop all of this...GOD
Stop harboring the enemy, the cowards are using you as human shields.
And here liberals (Obama & Co.) want to pull out of the Middle East and the War on Terror.  Good job folks!  "It's all about getting Osama..."  B.S.  It's about T E R R O R--people who kill others because they don't believe they way they do.  This is a cancer, and if you don't take care of it then it spreads.

Terror In Middle East + Left Alone = More Attacks On Civilized Countries / People Who Don’t Believe The Way They Do  <How hard is this to understand?  Did Clinton keep to his one-year promise to get in and out of Bosnia?  FFS>

Please wake up the 56% of America who buried their head in the sand and encourage them to try and see a little bit further than the T.V. in front of them.  My gosh!

If this post knocks some sense into at least one person out there then there’s hope for our country.

Just like when you were growing up as a kid, people of all ages respect strength.  Terrorist are no different—how hard is this to see?  The Taliban saw our strength and resolve after 9/11 and they bailed…  Waiting for an opportunity to crawl out of the woodwork again when they thought we were weak.  <READ: Like today.>
I think all nations had paid a price for peace.. it is difficult to separate civilians from millitants in these regions. An well thought out and effetive vacation an rehabilitation starategy would help.. but in remote areas civilian evacuations are often stopped by millitants who tend to use them as collateral. I feel sorry for the children caught in this mess but hope the outcome of all this is a more peaceful pakistan with opportunities for education and jobs for everyone to better future generations.
The only cure for ills of our society is a total extermination of all Mullahs; their infestation cannot be overlooked. There are several thousand species of MULLAHS and Snakes around the world with one basic difference - not all snakes are poisonous but ALL MULLAHS are lethal, they must be destroyed.
Go back home MHL,NY,NY!!!  The American government has made mistakes as any Government does...  It's probably even corrupt; but, these attacks happened in a country were we have no foot-hold...  Don't blame the American Government for your own peoples immorality!!!  We don't need people leeching off our society who will, after pretending to be one of us, fight against us as you seem to be doing!!!  Live your own life in harmony with those around you in NY, NY and try to effect the world in positive ways rather than causing more hate and discontent:  There's enough hate in the world without you spreading it from your comfortable niche in the society you joined.
I feel so grief for shaista and all other families of pashtoonistan, oh God get us out from these creul and sold people, show them the right path so we are not suffering anymore because of these malicious politics.
We must pray for those who are the victims of the lost souls who are injurying and killing innocent people around the world and turn back to God and pray for world peace. Governments can create laws that throw prayer and God out of the country, but in the end, it's only God and prayers that matter.
It is not the USA's fault that these Islamic fundamentalist freaks think that Allah condones killing innocent women and children in his name. News flash!! There are no virgins waiting for you.  Maybe its time for moderate Muslims to take a stand.  Not going to happen.
The taliban is nothing but a bunch of religious fanatics, they are twisting and turning what they believe God is saying. It is all in the name of control. They want to keep the countries they try to take over, in the dark ages. No schooling for women, no rights for women. They basically want the women to be held in slavery. They can not show their faces. No medical care nothing. It is time the women of these countries take up arms to defend themselves against the abuses they have been suffering for centuries in the name of religion.
The pakistan army and the president are also targetting innocent civilian so that when they report the Taliban casualties figures to US Administration they can virtually jack it up, perhaps for a pat in the back and a tip in their pockets.
I am a Muslim and grew up in SWAT, I know the people of SWAT are not TALIBAN. Taliban came from across the border from Afghanistan and I am sure the people of SWAT hate them and the people of SWAT does not want those so called Shariah courts imposed by them and Govt. Both Govt and taliban have spread depression there and have done things against the will of SWAT people. And it is a shame that the ill equiped army is blindly shelling everywhere and affecting innocent people like Shaista, Qamar and thousands other. I hope and pray that these talibans be eliminated soon from the face of EARTH, they have disturbed the peace in this world and my heart and prayers goes to all those who are suffering (anywhere in the world). I pray that GOD (Allah) be mercyful on them! (Amin)
I love people, humanity and life and I wish I could spread peace and love in this world.
Mhl, you keep saying your country and talking about the US as though you are not sitting in New York criticizing the country that you are obviously trying to get everything you can out of with out giving anything back.  Why dont you go back to that crap hole of a country you call yours and fight for it.  instead of sitting in my country and criticizing it.  I am in the US army and we not only fight our battles but yours as well because like the rest of "your" country men are to week and cowardess to fight your on battles.  You disgust me.  get out of MY country and go back to yours.  But while your here do not bad mouth my country.  by the way "your" country was harmonious when is was being run by the British!! because people like you are incapable of running your own affairs! your like little children, you have know business running a country, let alone a country with nukes.  take a look in the mirror and realize just how ass backwards all you people are over there.  Thats why here here in MY country, getting a free ride and giving nothing back to it.  Once again you disgust me!!!!
The only way to cure Pakistani ills to eradicate the feudal system. This is like the landlord sytem of medieval times but still prevalant in Pakistan. India did away with it and can be now considered a Democratic state. Unless Pakistan abolishes the feudal lord system it can never be a democratic state no matter how much its politicians harp on the worh "Democracy". We hpoe Omaba will also assist the Pakistani people to freed from the clutches of the few landlords who dictate the the politics of the country and harbour such elements as the Taliban to covertly achieve their selfish goals.
Why does this kind of carnage occur primarily in countries that are muslim?  I want to know this.  What kind of culture allows a Taliban to exist, much less get this powerful?  There are fundamentalists in the U.S., in England, in Italy--but they do not overrun the country and kill thousands.  What is different about these people, these cultures, that this can happen with such regularity, while people in non-muslim countries live lives of freedom, relative prosperity and safety.  
The only way to cure Pakistani ills to eradicate the feudal system. This is like the landlord sytem of medieval times but still prevalant in Pakistan. India did away with it and can be now considered a Democratic state. Unless Pakistan abolishes the feudal lord system it can never be a democratic state no matter how much its politicians harp on the worh "Democracy". We hpoe Omaba will also assist the Pakistani people to freed from the clutches of the few landlords who dictate the the politics of the country and harbour such elements as the Taliban to covertly achieve their selfish goals.
Islam never allowed to kill women, children, innocent, older or someone who is not attacking. Islam always promoted peace. So called holly war is personal incentives. Talibans are the follower of Yazid the son of Mauwia. We condemn Yazidiat believes.
If we need to know what is Islam we have to refer to the family of Prophet Mohammed (Ahlulbait). The are the practicle of Islam. They have set the right example. There is a saying by Prophet Mohammed in Major Islamic books as "I am leaving you couple of important thing, you will never be misguided if connect to these two things; one is Quran and second is my Ahlulbait, these two will never be separated from each other untill they meet me at Hause Kausar on the day of Judgment". Secondly Talibans are not extremist because extremist means if someone practice the religeon more than needed but they are out of Islamic guidelines and in my eyes they are "Munafiq" and Munafiq are the wood of Hell according to Quran. Read this saying of Hazrat Ali a.s in Islamic believes or ELIJAH in Bible or Taurah and think about what Islam is; "respect another mankind, they are brother to you in religeon or creation" this one statement has guided us to respect regardless if someone is or not from your faith. This is what Islam is not what Taliban (malaoon) practicing. People if you want to understand Islam, the only way is to check out the islamic history, see how Prophet Mohammed live and how his Ahlulbait spent the life. That is the only way!!!
By targeting civilians also the Pakistan government and army can jack up the casualties figures when they report their “successes” to United Sates.
The only way to cure Pakistani ills is to eradicate the feudal system. This is like the landlord sytem of medieval times but still prevalant in Pakistan. India did away with it and can be now considered a Democratic state. Unless Pakistan abolishes the feudal lord system it can never be a democratic state no matter how much its politicians harp on the worh "Democracy". We hope Omaba will also assist the Pakistani people to be freed from the clutches of the few landlords who dictate the the politics of the country and harbor such elements as the Taliban to covertly achieve their selfish goals.
War can be very cruel especially in the impoverished villages where the children barely have enough to survive as is.  I am not sure whether a direct hit would be considered a reward or punishment in the poor childrens circumstances?
MhL don't start pointing the finger at the US. If you don't like this country then get the eff out. No-ones holding you here. It's Pakistan's fault for allowing the Taliban to get this organized in within their own borders. If the taliban ever get's hold of your govt or military resources and decides to us them against your neighbors or the US, you will see alot worse I'm sure.
I don't believe these Taliban really do believe in religion, rather I believe they just want to be in control. Since the Taliban use whatever means to hide themselves or weapon exchange troops will target civilian vehicals they believe contain Taliban or weapons for the Taliban. Until these northern region side with the military and weed out the Taliban then the military will continue targeting these areas and the Taliban will continue hiding there.
This is like a game of chess. The talibans are the pawns. Their is no way taliban would have survived this far without support of $ and help from rich nations. I hope who ever is helping them gets their head cut of.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1927039

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.