ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



Lifting the veil on a North Korean obsession

Posted: Friday, April 10, 2009 8:22 AM
Filed Under:

BEIJING –North Korea has been in the news a lot lately, but for all the articles on its recent missile test or senior leader Kim Jong Il’s health, the isolated state remains a mystery – secretive and opaque.

But tucked away in a small residential compound here in central Beijing, a small exhibition of that rarest of pop culture media – North Korean film posters – helps demystify the country.

Image: Girl Barber poster
Courtesy of Koryo Tours
A poster for the North Korean film “A Girl Barber.”

“We wanted to do something that would teach people about the place,” said Nick Bonner, a co-founder of Koryo Tours, a group that leads tours of North Korea, who organized the exhibition.

The 25 posters on display were used to publicize overseas films released from the 1960s to the present. Accompanying almost all the artwork are detailed, informative notes – including excerpts from “Korea Film,” a book published by the Korea Film Export & Import Company in Pyongyang.

The medium is the message
Films, of course, have long been a keen interest of North Korea’s leader Kim Jong-Il. Although the medium was the preferred propaganda tool in North Korea even before he succeeded his father Kim Il-Sung, the younger Kim is widely credited with keeping the industry alive and thriving. 

He even went to the trouble of kidnapping a prominent South Korean director and his wife, a popular actress, in the late 1970s in an effort to revolutionize North Korea’s film industry.

What’s more, he has deftly used movies to justify his succession and grip on power. It was never a given that the younger Kim would become North Korea’s next head of state – film became the primary means he used to carry on his father’s legacy and solidify his own status, according to Suk-Young Kim, a scholar of North Korean arts and culture who teaches at the University of California-Santa Barbara.

The posters included in the exhibit represent films notable for both their political and cultural value.  

Such as “The Flower Girl,” a 1972 film based on a novel rumoured to have been conceived, and possibly written, by Kim Jong Il’s father. The movie – depicting the life of a poor, young flower-seller who endures a series of disasters before being rescued by the Revolutionary Army – was popular even here in China, shown widely back in its day.


Decades later, another film, “The Schoolgirl’s Diary,” telegraphs similar messages of patriotism but also of service to the fatherland. It’s the story of a rebellious young girl who struggles to cope with the absence of her father, a computer engineer who spends more time on his research than with his family. She finds redemption just as he achieves a scientific breakthrough for the country.

At least a third of North Korea’s population is believed to have seen “The Schoolgirl’s Diary,” which was released in 2006. It was also the first North Korean film ever to be shown in the West when it was picked up for distribution a year later in France. (It enjoyed a much poorer showing among the French.)

Iconic images
The posters themselves are quite noteworthy. Some of them, particularly those dating from the 1960s, exude the predictable kitsch – hand painted with vibrant colors, faces beaming expressive ardour. In comparison, the more recent posters are more subtle, relying on photography and computer-generated graphics.

“You can see a development in technique, because people started using computers,” said Simon Cockerell of Koryo Tours, who wrote up the film notes for the exhibit. “But [the posters] still look a bit out of time. Timelessness, it’s a unique skill the North Koreans have!”

Image: poster North Korea's "Titanic"
Adrienne Mong/NBC News
A poster for "Souls Protest," a film some have dubbed North Korea's "Titanic." 

The function of the artwork, however, isn’t confined to advertising movies.

“The images are so iconic,” said the scholar Suk-Young Kim.

Like those from post-revolutionary China, North Korean film posters “tend to emphasize the healthy, beautiful bodies of North Korean or Chinese people,” she said. “That’s quite important for their visual politics. These films are supposed to be cheerleaders of North Korean people, [showing they] are strong enough to stand up against foreign invaders and indignities.”

Moreover, the importance of the posters can outweigh that of the films they promote. “With films, when they end, it’s over, you come back to reality,” said Kim. “But what these posters do is extend that image of heroism and nationalism into everyday space and everyday life.”

Often, film poster images end up as wall murals, large-scale billboards, on the covers of books or magazines, or even, as Kim pointed out in the case of “The Flower Girl,” on bank notes.

Evolution of film
Another aspect of North Korean film – also captured in the posters’ vivid imagery – is the government’s ability “to sustain an ongoing war spirit in peacetime,” according to the scholar Kim. The Korean War was the last major national conflict Pyongyang engaged in, and yet the leadership has managed to perpetuate a proud sense of isolationism amongst its citizenry.

A good example is the film “Souls Protest” – released in 2000, it is also known as the North Korean “Titanic.” The film dramatizes the mysterious sinking of a ship ferrying thousands of Koreans home from Japan in 1945 and fuels a conspiracy theory that the Japanese were behind the incident. As Cockerell noted, the movie reminds Korean viewers that Japan was “a cruel colonizer.”

Kim Jong Il
VIDEO: Kim Jong Il thinner, older
Many contemporary film themes are also quite topical. “Street of Love,” released in 2003, is a love story between a bus driver and a beer factory researcher. Although that might seem somewhat incongruous, the motive here is clear – to parade North Korea’s technological advances despite years of deprivation.

The film showcases the Taedonggang beer factory, which was once a brewery based in Towbridge, southwest England.  The brewery was dismantled and shipped over to the outskirts of Pyongyang in 2000 – components, equipment, everything but the hops. Relying on German brewing production technology, the Taedonggang brewery started up two years later. (Word is that the final product is a respectable version of a British bitter….) 

What’s next?  
On Thursday, Kim Jong Il made a rare appearance after a suspected stroke last year, looking worn and gaunt. Given his strong influence on the country’s film industry, one can only imagine what themes might emerge now that he seems to be ailing.

Koryo Tours are working on an exhibition catalogue on North Korean film posters.  For more information, www.koryogroup.com

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

The foreign film "industry" is always interesting, especially those films produced under dictatorships of the right or left anywhere.  No less so for North Korea, keeping in mind that South Korea has a larger and very interesting movie business.  In North Korea I think the movies are produced as part of that mighty effort to sustain the regime, whereas in South Korea they are used to present/reflect social problems.

With that said, I believe India produces more films than any other country to include tha U.S. I could be wrong about that.  Thanks for the article because many foreign films are really quite good.  I doubt many Americans care about foreign films.  I think the U.S. populace is looking for lots of sex and violence in films only for the purpose of being entertained.  And for the most part that is of course what we get.
I think the use of film as a propaganda tool is not uncommon....we did the same thing in the United States during WWII...has anyone forgotten the exploits of John Wayne, Robert Montgomery, Richard Attenberry, Jack Hawkins, Lee Marvin, Cary Grant, Glenn Ford, and hundreds more I can't name?  Film does more for a country than just entertain....it can, and has, created a lot of patriotism in a lot of countries....Nothing wrong with that according to my democratic upbringing....
Maybe if they were not so isolated from the rest of the world they could produce films thatthe world would actually want to see. Judging from the posters that were shown in this article it looks as though the director he kidnapped thinks it is still 1970! I dont know who the successor of Kim Jong Il will be, but I do hope he is much more moderate than his prdecessor. The entire country is starving to death and thier leader makes lame movies!
“tend to emphasize the healthy, beautiful bodies of North Korean or Chinese people,”
-- well, that is certainly true of US advertising, at least for most mainstream movies.
.....
“Souls Protest” – released in 2000, it is also known as the North Korean “Titanic.” The film dramatizes the mysterious sinking of a ship ferrying thousands of Koreans home from Japan in 1945....”

-- this actually sounds like an interesting subject that would be very compelling to watch, if the acting and special effects are decent.
North Korea would hardly be the only nation to make nationalistic movies about it's history!
I love North Korea...the underdog. Secretive? maybe if the West relaxed a little we would have more things from North Korea, are they secretive or have we closed the door? The reason that I do not go there is the same as George Washington's answer to the British, I want to saty here and convert you to communism. The same with Cuba, why is the USA so afraid to have info of Cuba come to the US public? Think about it. Thank you.
Propaganda is propaganda, is propaganda. . .  Its all lies. Not just Any lies, but the lies of a government with something to hide.
 It never changes, no matter who is doing it, it's always for the same ugly reason.  No matter how "Pretty" the posters are, or the makeup artiest style. . .  That only show the extreme shallowness of the viewer to buy into any part of it.
Kim's films are meant to "DIVIDE (separate his people from the rest of the world) and CONQUER (control them)".
....it seems to be working.
Since the gentleman from NYC mentioned Cuba, allow me to recommend to him a good little Cuban movie by the name of(2005) "Viva Cuba!"   Cuba is opening up but it probably won't be run by the Miami exile crowd or the Mafia again.  However, it will probably be much longer before North Korea opens up.  Both are dictatorships, but the cultures are radically different.  I think I would much rather visit Havana during the "cool season."  Anyway, take a look at "Viva Cuba!" to get a little glimpse of what Cuban artists are doing.  I'm sure there will be more to come from Cuba in the future.  On that note, we need to explore what the rest of the Spanish speaking film industry is doing.  Take a look at Argentina. Try "Red Bear" (2002).  For North Americans the most important film interface in the future (in my opinion) is going to come from south of the border near and far.  
I would have to agree with part of what Ray from Kansas said about foreign films being pretty good. I find that I tend to enjoy watching (some) foreign films more than American-made films. Why? Because the stories are real. The movies I've seen are about real people, people you could relate to. Instead of just being entertained, I find myself becoming involved with the characters in the film.
Recently watched a movie called "Let The Right One In", a Swedish film (I believe) dubbed into English. It was such a simple movie, but it was so smart, smarter than a lot of what is coming out of Hollywood. I could also imagine this film in the hands of a Hollywood producer and how the story would have gotten so overblown, that the simpleness of the story (which is what matters) would be lost.
Another very good movie was "Not One Less", about a young girl who was "recruited" to teach kids not much younger than herself, after their teacher leaves. Such a simple story but one that you would never see in a Hollywood film.  
Here, we are told what is entertainment. All the movies look the same, so much so that you could just about act the movie out scene for scene, before you ever saw the movie. Either that or they tell you the whole story during the commercial.
A great many foreign film producers say "Here is the story I want to tell" and let you decide if it's entertainment. Here in America, our film producers say, "Here is a film full of stuff. See if you can find a story in it."
It is unusual, at least to me, that Russia and China could put the "screws" on North Korea very easly. But for some reason, I think, that the U.S Russia and China don't want to get that involved, for some reason. What do you think?
Kim Jong Il is just trying to use these movies to show the outside world that everything is fine in NK when it really is not. People are starving, getting sent to prison camps for trying to be an individual, people are not even allowed to leave the country. If they do, their families are tortured and sent to prison camps or concentration camps. Don't think that NK is a country that is trying to preserve their culture by isolating themselves. They are just a communisitic, totalitarian nation that is cruel and heartless. How can a country not allow its citizens to have freedom? Watch "Crossing" it will show you what is really going on in North Korea.
Actually South Korea's films are designed to keep the confucian idea of family, friends firm. There are only two plots to them. 1) a triangle of love, where one man/woman is in love with who they think they love, and all the while their true love is secretly hoping for true love with the protaganist. 2) This involves when one person falls in love with someone from a different social class. I have never found any Korean film that is worth its salt. Not that Hollywood does any better. All films in most countries are to project some form of propaganda. Think of all those John Wayne movies. they were propaganda. But over all, Korean films and t.v. dramas try to hard, and end up lacking.
Films have different purposes, one of which is to communicate a message or story.  Even if North Korea uses the film industry to send propaganda messages, it would be very interesting to hear that message.  I'm assuming that message would be coming from a very different perception than that of my own.  To me, that always makes for an interesting film.
Kim Jong Il is a weird dude that barely says a word on camera.  I would pay big money to see that guy star in one of his own films.  His character could be a beach bum surfer, or a Kindergarten teacher, or as a high school football star like in Varsity Blues.  
The guy above who said he loves North Korea is either sadly misinformed, has never seen the country and how its people are forced to live, or is one of those people who I often wonder why he is not there. I am sure there would be many people who would be happy to contribute to a fund to send him there. His idea that he stays here to convert people to communism is ludicrous. I have never seen a line of people here anxious to embrace a system that thinks for them. Yes, he will recruit a few; there are always a few people who are always serching for something that will allow them to abdicate responsibility for their lives. Maybe he will eventually find enough to fill a plane and go! The sooner the better. I am a Veteran of Korean service. I saw how the people were literally fenced in, unable to enjoy such freedoms as the guy who posted here. Try doing the same thing in North Korea. He wouldn't last a day. He would be arrested for suspicious behavior. Of course, he would not have to worry about recruiting peope to communism. He would be surrounded by a society that has not had a breath of freedom in decades. If he thinks it is so great, he needs to take a trip to South Korea and see what response he gets to such silliness. If he really wishes to be a part of the system, he can go and hang out on the border. Just stand and wait, someone will happily escort him across. Just don't expect to be walking and smiling as you are dragged across and jailed. Maybe you can then convince them how much you love them. Then try to post your results. Sorry, no outside computer services available, no phone calls, no mail. Everythign will have to be first approved by your new father!!
I have traveled some among other countries in our world and to South Korea... in my travels I have always enjoyed the peoples and other countries cultures and found most people evrywhere to be basically the same... they want to enjoy life and long for peace, prosperity and freedom... as far as films in North Korea and other nations... as well as our own USA... media of any type is usually if not always used by those in the power positions of creating it and distribution with an agenda and message hidden... to manipulate and control power over the masses... yes, even in USA... and that is TRUTH and is not negotiable.
All things and ideas wear out in time. Sometimes it just takes a little longer.
i don't beleave the american film industry is trash and that foregin fims have all the right stuff, i bet you can count 10 american films you really enjoyed, and thats becuase there are good movies out there, its just such a big industry that alot of crap movies are made just to fill in the demand, by the same note i bet you can count 10 horrible american movies you've seen, the fact remains that movies get made and you go see them good or bad.

I do agree that foregin films are out of the box, i don't think i've seen a foregin film that had the same predictablity you see in cookie cutter films. but my exposure to foregin films is such that i only hear about the interesting ones, i've never gone out of my way to find a truely random foregin film and test its quality.
North Korea wishes that America would return its national top secrets.
Every country and group has its own version of this type of thing.  If you think that there such a thing as a free people in a free country then you are as blind as a bat.  How free is free?  Where does freedom become anarchy?  I like law, and I do not like people mocking rule by law by various means including protests in the streets, destruction of property, etc.  But then again, I do not think that the U.S. Government people really care what its citizens want or think.  They just sail around us via various legal dodges and excuses.  That is not rule of law.
I served in South Korea in 1976-77 and have a deep love and respect for the Korean people.  At that time, there were curfews where one was subject to being shot, death penalty for marijuana, and other shocking laws and limits on speech.  What Americans would call police brutality, I witnessed several times.  One can only guess what North Korea is like.  I saw several American films, heavily edited, but I loved the artwork and murals at the theatres.  I took a Korean lady to see "Jaws" on an American base and she was completely terrified.  I'm sure she had nightmares for weeks.  Hollywood still is a propoganda machine.  Only now it is anti-American.  Resurrect McCarthyism.
To all of those arguing whether this is the same as the US governments propaganda, let me say that the  North Korean's propaganda movies are no different from the dribble coming out of Hollywood. I have seen more leftist slobber from the so called "enlightened artists" over the past 10 years then Kim could put out in 20. I keep giving them my money hoping that a real talent will produce something worth watching.
Kim would not be a beach bum or sports player. He would be Freddy Kruegar or Jason. He may control propoganda films,  Kim's favorite movies. Yes, the slasher genre. He love the summer camp and high school slasher movies

Maybe the one trying to prove the killer is on campus.

I am not making this up,he has big collection of horror movies
Pat,
Lee Marvin was a Marine who fought in the Pacific
during WWII. His film career did not start until after the war.
If only they had Chuck Norris..
FILMS FROM NORTH FOREA. LET THEM FOOD THEIR OWN PEOPLE FILMS AND NOT FOOD. THE BEST THING THAT COULD COME OUT OF THESE FILMS IS ONE FILM SHOWING CHINA FINALLY REALIZING THAT THEIR NEIGHBOR HAS TO BE TAKEN DOWN AND WATCH A FILM WITH CHINA LEVELING THAT ENTIRE CESPOOL.
In response to Mr. Pinot, from NYC, and his hopes for the "Underdog" :

You may notice, if you open your eyes, that many things imported to the US from South Korea no longer show "South Korea" as the origin of their parts content, or assembly location, simply "Korea."

The easiest products to check would of course be automobiles and intermodal cargo containers, which have permanent metal tags (in the door sill for autos, and on the doors for the containers). Of course the vague Statement of Origin can also be found amoung the quickly discarded instructions and packaging for many consumer products as well (computers, tv's, etc...)

The reason for "Korea" and not "South Korea" being listed is that while the business may have a S. Korea location, much has been produced in N. Korea, under cooperative arrangements which have grown ever steadily since the 1980's. These cooperative arrangements are mainly to help establish better relations between the two Korea's as well as to provide income for the starving county to the North.

The US is fully aware of the "enemy produced" content of the products, but turns a humanitarian blind eye to the imports.  

You may recall the recent story of the S. Koreans detained in the free enterprise zone recently as N. Korea stepped up security in the period leading up to the missile test... this, and the "fuzzy" Statement of Origin on imported products are just about the only thing the US public will ever see as evidence.

Of course the 'free trade' between the two Korea's is really good propaganda for both sides, but the South is still getting richer, and the North is still getting poorer and more desperate. And the US is paying for quite a bit of the product and the never ending NK "bail-out."  The public just isn't aware of it.

Korea was known as the "Hermit Kingdom" long before the birth of the Kims, and even before the birth of Communism.  This reclusive attitude still permeates the cultures on both sides of the DMZ, but manifests differently under the opposing ideologies established after the division of the country.  Nearly crippling paranoia to the North, and a unique hyper active, disassociative disorder to the South, where many can't quite come to terms with their enormous success being mostly attributable to outside influence and assistance (the US), and therefore strive even harder to make their further success appear strictly Korean...

George Washington wanted to convert us to Communism? Wow. (Read 5th comment from top)
What is interesting to me is you can almost predict the above commemtary by looking at the persons name and/or address.
North Korea is now producing a decent British Bitter Beer!

North Korea and other regimes of their ilk MUST use any and all means to preserve their totalitarian rule and movies are just one more way to glorify the leader's status while keeping the people in the dark! If and when the North Korean people ever are allowed to view the outside world they will have a different viewpoint! This must be prevented by the regime evan as they glorify themselves to their subjects.
I think N. Korea is a mystery wrapped in an enigma, thanks to the failure of our Western press to unearth the true facts about it.  
North Korea and Iran = Hitler and Mussolini , The world is in the midst of a serious crisis and history is repeating itself right before our eyes .
Time is running out , by turning a blind eye , the free world will not be free for much longer .
Let it be no mistake there is no chance in hell that we could successfully negotiate a satisfactory agreement with either North Korea or Iran .
       
If you want to know the purposes and propaganda that the North Korea leader uses in it's films look at Diana Kim's comment. I recently lived in South Korea and visited the DMZ, the area of neutral UN owned land between North & South Korea. While I was there a South Korean who has visited North Korea many time informed me how their leader does everything in his power to keep his people poor and ignorant in order to keep them from realizing what they are missing, so they don't revolt. While South Korea has cell phones and I-pods, not to mention basic farm equipment, the people of North Korea don't even know this kind of technology even exists. The US does not hold back information about North Korea, North Korea holds back the information so we cannot become disgusted with their leader as all the world should be including North Koreans. Cuba and North Korea cannot be compared, they are two very different circumstances. Just as North Korea and South Korea are like two different worlds.
and what of this guy' son: Men Tal Lee Il?
Won-hee Kim

What??  u need to see Oldboy s.korean cinema is some of the best in the world right now!!!!
Hey, Mario in NYC, it is good to know you love North Korea, and possibly Cuba. You still choose to live here in the good ol' USA. Interesting how a nation that kidnaps its neighbors citizens-both South Korea and Japan have many horror stories-is worthy of your affection. Both father and son, "Il's", have killed, tortured, and forced starvation upon millions in the name of patriotism. Please, Mario, this country has made many mistakes, but closing the door on possible allies is not ever in its policies. Next, you will be telling us you are pen-pals with Mr. Chavez.
China Needs To Come Clean in North Korea (And Pakistan)
When it comes to North Korea, there are few good options for the United States. This nation clearly possesses some kind of nuclear capability and has good mastery of rocket technology (despite the failure of its test this week). How did this happen? North Korea is an isolated hermit kingdom. It would have problems building a bicycle. So where did this capability to build sophisticated weaponry come from? The same can be said incidentally of Pakistan, though the two countries are very different. The one thing that both countries share, is that they both border, and have a close alliance, with China. It is our belief that China has decided that it is in its strategic interests to pass on weapons technology to both countries in a bid to keep its democratic neighbors down – Japan, South Korea and India. However, in trying to thumb its nose at the West and Asia’s democracies, China runs the risk of letting things collapse too far in both countries. In particular, China itself will suffer tremendously if North Korea collapses, not America.  Let’s leave this problem to the Chinese. If they are not willing to come clean and help in solving the stand-off, North Korea’s economic collapses will be their problem. And they are the ones who will have to pick up the pieces.
http://dailyexception.com/2009/04/07/china-needs-to-come-clean-in-north-korea-and-pakistan/
President Obama will reach out to the N. Koreans, much as he is doing with Cuba.

The real key to all this is China. Put pressure on the Chinese (Oh I almost forgot we owe them allot of Money), no that won't work.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1888472

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.