ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



Chinese coming back to Marx amid crisis

Posted: Wednesday, April 08, 2009 10:31 AM
Filed Under:

BEIJING – Just 126 years after his death, Karl Marx’s moment may finally have arrived.

The People’s Press – the biggest publishing house for China’s orthodox revolutionary books – reports that Marx’s anti-capitalism opus "Das Kapital" has been selling about 4,000-5,000 copies nationwide a month since last November. That’s a big jump from before the economic crisis, when the book sold well under 1,000 copies per month on average.

The "Selected Works by Mao Zedong," a book owned by almost every Chinese citizen a few decades ago, is also witnessing a big jump in sales since late last year, according to Mr. Pan from the People’s Press circulation department.

Image: Utopia bookshop
Bo Gu/NBC News
Chinese shoppers peruse Beijing’s Utopia bookshop.

Han Deqiang, a university professor, believes these sales trends reflect the fact that many Chinese are starting to question their new economic orthodoxy.

"For so many years we’ve been wading across the stream by feeling the way, trying to reach the other side of the stream in capitalism. Now the building on the bank has collapsed, and we realize maybe we had a wrong goal?" said Han.

With China’s economy characterized by widespread privatization and double-digit growth rates over the past 30 years, Marx’s critique of capitalism had fallen out of favor. But his "bible" of communism – first published in 1867 and worshipped by the Chinese people decades ago – seems to have found a new audience in China amid the global economic crisis, as evidenced by book sales.

Late last year, news organizations reported a similar trend in Germany, Marx’s birthplace.   

"It's definitely in vogue right now," Joern Schuetrumpf, director of "Das Kapital’s" Berlin publisher, told The Associated Press. "The financial crisis brought us a huge bump."

Image: Utopia bookshop
Bo Gu/ NBC News
Beijing’s Utopia bookshop sells titles like the "Biography of Hugo Chavez" and "The Politically Incorrect Guide to American History."

Leftist shop’s sales up
At "Utopia," a tiny bookshop in the academic center of Beijing’s Haidian district, sales of "Das Kapital" are on the rise, according to Fan Jinggang, the bookshop’s manager. He said his store has sold about five copies a month over the last six months compared to just two copies a year previously.

"Some scholars on our Web site had already predicted the economic crisis as early as in 2007, but the mainstream opinions were too optimistic. Now our Web site is receiving 100,000 hits every day and both ‘Das Kapital’ and ‘Selected Works of Mao Zedong’ are selling better," said Fan.

Fan’s Beijing bookstore and Web site don’t sell the usual fare of popular novels or business texts you might find in other shops – instead it caters to a more leftist clientele.

Shelves are lined with titles like the "Biography of Hugo Chavez" and "The Politically Incorrect Guide to American History." Pictures of the late Chinese leader Mao Zedong are the only decorations on the wall other than a clock above the counter.

Han, the university professor, is one of the writers on Utopia’s site.

"We thought the market economy was the only way out, it’s so widely accepted," he said. "But it’s natural to come back to Karl Marx and Mao when we find what we believed earlier isn’t always correct."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I guess history lessons are short-lived, otherwisse these people would realize that communism has never worked.
It's only natural for people to go back and check were they are, and analyze from that point to the future. Eventually learning that there is not perfect path for every problem. Only a combination of economies dotrines will bring prosperity and peace to the world. Obama is in the right path, the world need to change it's fundamental of going business to equalize religion and the distribution of wealth.
Typical! And the Chinese want the Yuan to become the new US Dollar in world currency!  Once a communist, always a communist.  Same as in Russia, when things in a market capitalism economy goes awrey for a few months, people fall back to wanting "parents" take care of them, like mom & dad caring for their children.  Pretty soon we'll be seeing demonstrations in the streets like the student uprising & the tanks mowing the students down 15 or 20 years ago.  
China can thank the US for what they do have.  So much of their technology has been stolen from the US and so has patents and copyrights. Of course it's our own fault, many of our greedy politicians and business men have betrayed us.  
Really?
It is easy to see sale of this kind of book going up in Communist regime. That is called propaganda. When I was in China, back in 1970s, every family had whole stacks of those kind of books, maybe the highest quality paper we could have. Now can you find anyone who believes in communist? Even those high ranking officials are sending their family outside.
I would call the author of the article is so out-of-touch with the reality.
The reality is the Chinese people are fed up with with the communist.  
How sad - But Mao also made a comeback after Tian
An Men Square too (more encouraged by the government then).  Taxi drivers had Mao emblems hanging from their rear view mirrors.  Grasping for "certainty" in times of uncertainty.  If only more of the Chinese people could hear and believe about the resurrection of Jesus Christ, the truly certain message that God is for us even in our darkest hour.
They'd be better off studying GROUCHO Marx
Das Kapital isn't "anti-capitalism".  It says that Capitalism, if allowed to opperate freely, is self destructive.  It says,absent regulations and constraints, capitalism will create such a concentration of wealth that political unrest will result.  I have always viewed Das Kapital as the book that gave us the key to making Capitalism work.  Regulations.
Again we see those that fail to achieve of thier own efforts seek the supposed safe harbor of communism and socialism.  To them the GOVERNMENT is the answer.  How willing many are to throw away INDIVIDUAL FREEDOM for THE STATE.  But than again the Chinese have never been FREE!    
China has never been a free thinking country. It's very leadership are communists so what is this author talking about?  Capitalism is the only way to prosperity.  People need to get up off their lazy asses and WORK!!!
I dont think its a bad thing that people choose to educate themselves. I think the differences between communists and capitalists is a communist government doesnt care that they are crooks and opressors. In caplitalism, there are plenty of crooks but they may be harder to identify and you too can aspire to be a crook as well.
This is a terrible time for everyone.  The greed was spread throughout the world and everyone was happy to participate as long as the bubble didn't burst.  We all have many things to learn from this, one big thing being that people didn't heed lessons from history, especially in the USA.  I hope that China will heed the lessons they have learned from their history and be smarter than the rest of us.  Going back to some of the restrictions of communism I do not believe is the answer.  Building China's own markets and selling their own products in their country, and thus raising the level of living for their own people with the freedom for entreprenuers to gain reasonable wealth in China I think is important.  Building their leadership on the world stage and not isolating themselves is also important.  Building partnerships vs imposing rules that are too restrictive, and promoting sustainable growth.  Sustainable, steady, reasonable growth vs unrealistice quick $$ returns - everyone seems to have forgotten what the best business practices are.  Promotion of new technologies.  I welcome China's participation!
Great, now it seems China is going to head into the wrong direction (if the politicians there adopt the same ideals, mind you, 5,000 a month is nothing considering China's population).
Once you go "Adam Smith", you never go back!
The North American audiencies are illiteries to undertand this, the scope of world, 'cause they just know to eat junk food, glu to the TV, and go to the bathroom and not to take a shower.
So,does this mean the Chinese want to return to the "good old days" of the "Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution"?  I doubt it.  Mao's little red book might be in vogue for a while, but the Chinese are all too "capitalistic" to return to those times.

On the left, what is really going to take off is a combination of Che Guevara and Catholic Liberation Theology in Central and South America.  How long it will last is another matter, but it will be "in vogue" much longer than any nostalgia left over from Mao or Marx. Che really is a popular folk hero for a lot of people in Central and South America.  And there is now a really good movie (and book)romanticzing him called the "Motorcycle Diaries".  Che is a flesh and blood guy the campesinos can identify with, whereas Mao and the Gloomy looking Marx tend to be somewhat depressing when you look at them too long.  
Isn't it ironic that they have to pick up a book on communism via capitalistic methods?
Wherever we are the Chinese are heading, they are in stronger position than the Weaken and faultering USA.

Of course everyone knows our Goverment (in all their Geitner Wisdom, Tim "Cive my Banker Buddies free Money" Gietner, by the way that little Umpa Loompa of a man is the Undisputed King of All Stupidness), has borrowed tons of Money from the "Economic Dragon of the East".

China just keep doing what your doing- you are much better than America.
is this supposed to mean something to an american? I am sorry but marx was a fool and mao a genocidal maniac. I hardly think many americans will fall for this bald face propaganda effort to socialize us.
Well, there is no wander except lack of suffieciant experience in life, histrory repeat itself.
Well, there is no wander except lack of suffieciant experience in life, histrory repeat itself.
Where can I buy a copy?  The Capitalism stuff is not working for millions of us unemployed americans either.
The Chinese embraced a market economy in the first place because they became wealthier, both individually and as a nation. Granted, the markets are down now, and the promise of wealth isn't quite so "promising". But why do they think Marxism is the answer? At this point, Marxism will only drive the markets down even further. Is that what they are saying - that they don't care about wealth anymore?  I seriously doubt that.
China is not communist it never has been, it is a socialist totalitarian state with a mixed market economy.  True communism is a completely centrally planned economy controlled by a democracy...  Centrally planned economies are inefficient, we saw that with the Soviets and the Chinese, that's why they have been moving toward privatization.  The free market has and will continue to be the best choice to decide what goods and services to produce.  The Chinese government will never fully prosper until democracy rules.
Fine by me while it's not 'Mein Kampf'.
The title of this article is misleading - China never abandoned its Marxist and Mao inspired ideology despite its recent economic boom. It is not a news but a fact that is just not accepted here in the West.
Please don't tell this to the well-dressed young Shanghai lady who owns the bustling hair salon underneath my building and nearly ran me over in her black Audi TT because she was texting into her iphone.
Economies go up, economies go down.   There is nothing wrong with capitalism as long as management of publically traded are held publically accountable for misdeeds.   Responsible capitalism balanced is certainly better than communism.   Just look at the differences between the Western Democracies and the Communist East.   Where would you prefer to live?
Communism is a beautiful concept on paper.  It can never succeed, however as there will always be rich and poor, greed and desire.  It's simply the human condition.  Even before monetary and political systems governed our world there were have's and have nots.  Rich in love, poor in love, rich in knowledge, poor in knowledge, rich in power, poor in power.  Whomever you choose to lead your communist utopia will still have power and as the saying goes: power corrupts, absolute power corrupts absolutely.  Until humans are free of very human emotions such as greed, jealousy, envy, desire communism will never function as Marx envisioned.  Get over it, search for a real world ideology, because this one aint it.
China hasn't yet had freedom, stuck revolving between state-controlled socialism and state-controlled capitalism.  Over time, hopefully, the culture will change so that people can operate in a way that doesn't require extreme nationalism, overbearing state control, or cynical warfare capitalism.  A regulated but largely free economy that respects individual expression is still far away, but still a hope.

Further calls to war, whether in the name of socialism, capitalism, communism, etc. are not the answer.  What makes a nation great is not its ability to conquer others but its ability to inspire.
Great!, let them get on with it. When China was last in their Marxist period they were cut off from the world and didn't make our socks, shoes cars planes or anything. There CO2 emmisions were almost zero and millions of them died from starvation... This is a great way to save our planet and the global economy.
Maybe without the 30 + years of capitalism there would not even be the book store or the published books to buy... in order to read about the failure of capitalism. What failed are the moral guidelines that capitalism requires. I was in Bejing in 1979 and there were only two hotels open for business.
OK, it's back to Marx and Mao.  How soon will the Cultural Revolution pick up where it left off?
I wonder if they are selling the books "for the cost of printing + shipping" or if they are making money on it in a capitalistic manner :)
People are feeling ripped-off and powerless to do any thing about it.  Capitalist countries need to deal swiftly with "obvious" perps like Madoff...confiscating their "stolen" wealth AND repatriating it with the victims! Then we need to follow the paper trail to the Swiss banks and do the same with those funds. We should also take away all the "perks" are elected officials receive, like the "best health care", so they are motivated to work on behalf of the people they represent! In this global economic down-turn the average person needs to SEE their government working FOR them...not as an instrument of corrupt capitalists...this would be a good start!...i'm on my way to the library.
It's ironic that these capitalist (book sellers and writers) make a killing selling anti-capitalist materials.
Ho-humm! So Karl and Mao are on the upswing in China.  Sounds good to me.  Let them go back to their poor agricultural lifestyles while the party members bleed them dry.
Well, right now the U.S. is utterly dependent upon Chinese production. If we have a shift in balance of powers from capitalist-Christian to communist-Atheism (and the "death" of God in America is now nigh) ... Stalin, anyone?  Jail & torture for the intellectuals and no religious freedom...am I the only one who's scared here?
The United States is not a capitalist economy any longer...

http://truthalert.net/Capitalism.htm
Now china will figure out that to continue with prosperity they will have to go to war.That's capitalism
Coming from a former communist country myself (albania) . I rather live under the bridge on Alaska that be part of any  communist system. Cumunism has not not worked and will never work. Comunist regimes of China and company are guilty of genocides . They will never change if we think they will we are daydreaming. Unless they get over overthrown thing will not change . They are master of propoganda and will find any excuse to blame the west. I rather starve to death and free in west than live in any of communist regimes ( china , cuba, north korea, vietnam and so on). By the way no need to starve in west is plenty of food and work if anyone wanst to work. I have relized that maybe USA is not the perfect place but it is as good as it gets. And Im very thankfull to be part of it. So keep on china and read marx and that other looser Mao and you wil be breathing marxism for yrs to come.
Captitalism sure seems to please the bookstore owner! He's probably already planning his next major appliance purchase, with his profits. Unless he's donating all profits to the people.  This I DOUBT!
Maybe if China goes back to its communist ways and reverts to it isolationist ways the rest of the world would be forced to start manufacturing the items found on the shelves of stores like walmart.

That would sure be a great boost to our own economy!
I wonder if anyone has seen the irony of a bookshop (Utopia) promoting communism when I'm sure it's being operated by a private individual for those EVIL profits!!
I think all of this historical, while Marx and Mao are becoming popular, Mein Kampf is successfully selling in places like Syria, and various other middle east countries. The 20`s and 30`s (socialist agendas)were precursor to the second world war. If we let history repeat itself, then we can expect world war three soon.
You people spew rubbish. America is nothing but a plutocracy and oligarchy where its profits for a few (usually corrupt) over the needs of many. Capitalism never has worked either.

FOOD- SHELTER-HEALTH CARE-IS ALL WE NEED
I notice Cacibaquel doesn't indicate where s/he is from. What a warped view of North America (and USA). Yea some will eat their junk food, some will drone for hours in front of a TV. Isn't the wealth and freedom great? This is still the greatest country in the world. Cacibaquel is probably from Quebec -French Quebec, that is.
Even though communism has historically had great difficulties on the large scale, one might do well to remember that it is the capitalist ideal which brought about the conditions that produced the economic depressions of both the past and present. There is a middle ground to be found. And before one turns on socialism completely, one should remember that Cuba has a more effective Health System than the USA.
Now that people see the results of unregulated capitalism worldwide, they may be curious to go find what communism talks about. None of these "isms" works perfect. Realism is the way to go...  
parking tickets, traffic tickets, late fees, hidden fees, high interest, tricky interest fees, collective agencies for goverment owed debt with their own interest fees, all of this unchecked and the fees raising higher all the time, lets not forget the ever increasing rent, everything we buy is cheap and breaks on purpose, minimum wage was always there showing us where americans really stand. how much do you make?How much do you credit?? President Bush once stood in front of a working mother who held three jobs just to survive, just to hold her head above water and he tells her "ONLY in America". Does communism not suffer these attrocities? Is it perhaps only in America as Bush once said himself? The average American citizen, the ever increasing single mother with three jobs should of been a warning. The increase spending based on credit while mininum wage never increases might of been a warning. Funds for education are always being droped to the point where they almost dont exist, the outcome usually meaning more people living on mininum wage being forced to take credit after being devoured by the unchecked system of fees. Overworked under paid and then the hospital fees. Communism, capitalism, these are just ideas, it is the people who make it real.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1885418

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.