ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



The ‘working girls of Quetta’ – children

Posted: Tuesday, March 24, 2009 11:51 AM
Filed Under:

QUETTA, Pakistan – The 11-year-old girl blushed as she walked into the car dealer’s showroom on Quetta’s Adalat Road in southwest Pakistan. Her 17-year-old cousin, eyes fixed to the ground, followed her. When the younger girl asked the owner for five rupees (6 cents), he pointed to the back room and told both girls to follow him. 

A stocky man in his mid-forties with sallow skin and puffy eyes, he told the girls to lift their shirts – he wanted to see. "Very nice," the owner said. "They are getting bigger," he told the 17-year-old as he touched her. 

The 11-year-old was excited as she told us the story; we had followed them inside the showroom pretending to be customers interested in renting one of the Land Cruisers parked inside. The owner had given them 10 rupees (12 cents), the girls told us, more money than they had asked for. Then, giggling, they ran away.

It’s dangerous to be seen following these girls – some of their clients are wealthy feudal land barons and powerful politicians, others are ordinary shopkeepers who will give money to the poor, but want to get something in return.

The girls are part of an alarming problem that gets little attention in Pakistan.

"Prostitution is rampant in all the big cities throughout the country," said Senior Superintendent of Police, Raja Shahid, who heads the police investigation unit in Rawalpindi, a city close to the capital Islamabad.

"There are loopholes in the laws that need to be changed. For example, in order to nab the culprits, we need to conduct a raid – but we cannot conduct a raid without permission from a magistrate. By the time we get the permission we have missed our chance," he said.

Calls for Islamic law
Others in the country have targeted the police’s inability to protect children as a reason to rally the people against the government.

"This is exactly why all the religious parties are campaigning for Shariah law," said Maulvi Noor Mohammed, a hard-line Islamic cleric, known for his ties to the Taliban.

Mohammed preaches "jihad" against the West to young boys in his sprawling madrassa (religious school) on the outskirts of Quetta. In an hour-long interview with NBC News, Mohammed argued that prostitution in Quetta is the perfect example of the corrupt morals of the secular, pro-Western Pakistan government and why it showed the need for a worldwide Islamic revolution. 

"What these men are doing is against Islam and they must be punished accordingly," he said. "Islam guarantees protection for these young girls."

The last study on child prostitution in Pakistan was conducted by the government's Federal Bureau of Statistics more than 10 years ago. At that time, the study concluded that an estimated 20,000 to 40,000 children were involved in prostitution.

Today, there is no reliable data or updated figures, perhaps because it is a national shame.

Image: street scene in Quetta, Pakistan
Shahid Qazi/NBC News
Chaotic street scene in Quetta, Pakistan.

Poverty increases problem
Fathers often send their young daughters out on the streets to earn money for the family. The girls begin by begging – some as young as 3-years old – and as they grow older, they become part of the flourishing sex trade in this deeply conservative city in southwest Pakistan.

 "The fathers of these girls are usually drug addicts or alcoholics and the family is impoverished," said Fauzia Baloch, a coordinator for the Aurat Foundation, an NGO that works for women’s rights in rural Pakistan. "We can act, often only when a member of the family comes forth and complains, usually of domestic violence, and then we provide shelter for the girls and their mothers."

On a recent afternoon, we sat outside a tea shop on Quetta’s Adalat Road and watched young girls move easily in and out of the crushing traffic – a chaotic scene of rickshaws, donkey carts piled high with bathtubs, rainbow-colored trucks decorated with gaudy paintings and men on bicycles. The girls made contact with the shopkeepers and with the men sitting in parked cars who were waiting for them.

"We know this is going on," said Inspector Malik Durrani of the Quetta police. "Even though prostitution is illegal in Pakistan, the police cannot arrest anyone without first lodging a case in the courts," he said. "[President Pervez] Musharraf changed the laws in 2007 to give women more rights but the laws are now so complex that unless the woman complains the police are powerless to act."

Life on the streets
One 30-year-old woman with piercing light blue eyes said she has worked the Adalat Road for 25 years. She goes by the name of Shin Khalai.

"I started begging when I was 5 years old," Khalai said. "My father was a drug addict and my mother sent me and my seven brothers and sisters out on the streets to beg. I am married now – my husband is a gambler and he knows I sleep around with other men but he wants the money I earn so he can keep on gambling."

Haji Naseem, another car dealer on Adalat Road, blames the city’s politicians and religious leaders. "Everyone knows what is going on with these children," he said. "No one bothers to stop it because our leaders have forgotten their duties to the people and are only after their own power and their own riches," he said. "We are being destroyed from within by moral corruption and greed." 

"Look at them," Khalai pointed out three girls, as they walked down the street, dressed in colorful shalwar kameez – the term for traditional baggy trousers and long tunic shirts.

"They are the working girls of Quetta – those little children. What life do they have? This is no life for any of us," she said as she walked away – to go back to work.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

this is really sad... it kind of left me speechless.
In this world, beast and cnildren have no choice or voice.  Is there someone out there who can tell me how I can help stop this?  My heart bleeds for these children.  Is there no one else who sees what is happening as monstrous?
Poor girls. This is disgusting.
Islamic law abuses girls too by marrying them off at a young age. What is the difference between a girl making money having sex at age 12 or being forced to have sex with a man as his "wife" at age 12? It is child abuse either way. Both are unacceptable. The key is education. Education for both the boys and the girls. Education frees people from poverty in most cases.
This is so sad
We can say we can't do anything, or we can learn from what has been done in other countries such as Thailand, where international pressure has lessened the destruction of young lives. Organizations such as International Justice Mission are having success in combating exploitation like this. Thanks for keeping issues like this in front of us.
I understand that temporary marriages are permitted in Islam (as is done in Iran) which is essentially prostitution, which may allay the religious ... qualms ... some people may feel about the situation but I suspect Sharia law would do essentially nothing to improve the situation for these girls (and the women they become).  Obviously, the laws need to be cahnged to allow those police who are inclined pursue these issues to do so.
It is sad that this article gets so little attention. We pretend that this happeneing just in places like Pakistan when it doesn't take too much research to find it is happening throughout the world. The use of women and children in the sex trade simply doesn't raise the ire of enough people. It is sad and until we reach the point where the dignity and value of each human life is important to us we don't deserve the luxuries we seek.
Stories like this point to why the Islamic revolution is succeeding and democracy is failing in many parts of the globe.
THIS IS DISCUSTING... THE GOVERNMENT DIFFENTLY NEEDS CHANGE AND ALL THE PEOPLE ABUSING THESE YOUNG GIRLS AND TEACHING THEM THAT THIS IS WHAT THEY NEED AND HAVE TO DO SHOULD BE PUNISHED. THIS IS NO WAY OF LIFE AND MOST DEFINITLY NOT A WAY TO RAISE YOUNG WOMEN AND CHILDREN!  
How sad, just babies
I am absolutely appalled that given the horrid situation these girls are in, someone chose to title them "Working Girls." Why isn't the title of this post "The rape victims of Quetta"? Surely no one is suggesting that these girls are old enough to consent or freely choose this line of work.
This is a sad sad story...
Things need to change in the world as a whole. This story could have been set in the US also. It is happening all, all over. The children are the ones that are suffering.
May GOD keep them in His sheltering arms.
God Bless!
Reply to Melissa:
Warren Jeffries must have been following islamic law huh ?
And I guess most people in Utah are closet Moslems too.
Why doesn't some god help out?

BECAUSE THERE ARE NONE!!
To say that prostitution in Pakistan is the fault of the West is ridiculous.  There's a reason why it's called the "World Oldest Profession"  Prostitution's been here long before there was a "West".  Anyone ever heard of Rahab  (Joshua 2:1)?
This is sad. But this is the story of every country of the world. Here in States there are 100s of thousands of registered sex offenders and millions are living under the blanket with noone is noticing them. Thousands of Eurpeans go to India and Combodia to do sex with minors. Why there is no article about them? We have to quit hypocracy in order to achieve better future. Peace
there is consequences for every sin.  that is very sad to what young girls have to go through. judgement is coming for those people who are committed those crimes to those young girls
There is no such a thing as "child marraige" or " Temporary Marraige" in Islam. Anything contrary to this is an aberation of Islam. Please go to the relaible sources on Islam and get your facts right. For example -- www.whyislam.org.
Here again we see the two-sides of Islam.  Sure, child prostitution might be against Islamic law but these middle-aged perverts are Muslim and they are no doubt blameless in the eyes of the insane radical clerics.  Naturally, the sin here is on the part of the young girls - it is their fault that these pigs cannot control themselves -- and no doubt, it is these precious children who will be severely punished.
WELL I AM ATONISHED TO READ ABOUT THIS COMING FROM AN ISLAMIC COUNTRY,WHAT SORT OF VALUES THIS SOCIETY HAVE,RELIGION IS NOT THE ANSWER TO THESE PROBLEMS ON THE CONTRARY IT WILL WORSEN THEM.I DO HOPE THE BUREACRATIC PEOPLE TAKE CARE OF THEIR DUTIES.
this is utterly dispicable and torturous!!!! I am a muslim and have 2 little daughters and I cannot immagine what these sick people are doing to these innocent girls. I do not consider these to be muslims and I will the first one to get these animals punished. just don't know how!!!!
Sharia law or not, religion or no religion, has nothing to do with it,it is no use blaming western cultures on what is going wrong in pakistan, it is just very low moral standards, and lack of self esteem and education.
Islam guarantees protection for these girls? How about education for these young girls? Stop blowing up the schools, idiots. What happens when they become women? They get treated like the women in Saudi Arabia; beaten and imprisoned for getting gang raped, forbidden to drive or be unaccompanied by a male member of the family among other abuses. The women are covered because the men in these countries are weak and can't control themselves. Islam is just as misogynous as any religion that seeks to subjugate women whilst turning a blind eye to their plight.
Yes, this is terribly heartbreaking.  However there is hope when children can be connected with aid organizations.  If you would like to make a difference, check out websites for International Justice Mission or World Vision.
where is the law enforcement in pakistan and other countries in that region. Actually all the governments around that area and in pakistan are completely corrupt in their own country but they try their level best to make them look better in the eye of west.They are abusing their own people. They simply
dont have any plan for the social security for their own country.All they know is how to talk sweet with west. My request to the west is for the sake of millions of innocent people in their country please try to be harsh with them politically and economically to develop the the justice and humanity
for their people.
This is so sad, I am enraged that all these people who call the west 'bad' do not look to themselves and fix the 'bad' around them first. Shame on them. I also know that Islam as a religon does not condone this-most followers are illetrate and ignorant enough to follow what the mullah says. I have been to Pakistan and feel that the basic cause of the so-called 'jihad' against the west and all their own problems, is ignorance and illetracy. SAD!! :(
I love that you quote a Taliban crazy who thinks the West is responsible for prostitution. Oh yeah, and Sharia will protect the little girls with circumcision and making sure they can't go out of the house without a male family member. But, say male members of their family are killed in a Taliban bombing? Oh, yes the girls get to stay in the house until they die. Much better solution.
Yes it is a tragedy but any reporter who quotes a source who thinks Islamic fundamentalists have the answer should qualify what his source is calling for.
Perhaps we should invoke Fundamentalist Latter Day Saints rules in America to fight prostitution here.
it is noble to try to fix a wrong one sees.  still, i must say, look in your own neighborhood.  a person needs loads of loads of money to try to fix another country's problems.  trying to fix your own neighborhood might be a little less expensive.  fix your own house before trying to fix someone elses.  they might not see any fixing needed.
10 Rupees =  12 cents
There will be many kinds of responses here:
Islam haters:  In some way or the other, it is Islam's fault.
Feminists:  It is MANkind's fault.
Bleeding hearts: It is poverty's fault.

The one thing that no one else will get is that regardless of whose fault it is, this is the environment, of such enormous differences between the "haves" and "havenots" that allows this abuse to flourish.  While there is no lack of exploiters and abusers in developed and rich societies, (some of them even get caught!) it is the existence of this horrendous injustice that fuels the reaction that is exploited by al-Qaeda.  This horror is what breeds terrorists!  If we want to eliminate terror for good from this world, all we need to do is to declare War on the abuse and exploitation of the vulnerable!  But will we?  Probably on a cold day in Hell!
This is incredibly disturbing, disgusting, and disgraceful. How can these politicians who know this is happening not do anything about it? Moreover, how can they partake in this? What if it was their daughter? The sad thing is I don't know if anything can be done about this b/c the root cause of the problem is political corruption and personal agendas. Unless the scumbags who partake in this horrible crime or those who turn a blind side to this problem are out of office, nothing can be changed. I feel so bad for those poor girls. They deserve better! This makes me sick to my stomach!
this is a problem of POVERTY. Religious fundamentalists want to make it about MORALS, as if all things are equal in the world. Poverty is the SINGLE biggest cause of social ills, but we don't like to focus on that because poverty feels like a problem we can't solve, at least without completely changing how the world is structured. Poverty leads to social problems, making it seem necessary to "crack down" on people, as if they are the problem instead of the conditions they are forced to deal with. Religious or secular laws won't solve anything. Making sure people have the basics in life will go a long way.
one in four women in the US is sexually abused as a child.  the child sex trade is flourishing here as much as there - only here people do it to their own children.  why pay money when you can get it for free?  this story breaks my heart - as little is being done to combat this issue in Pakistan, in my opinion even less is being done here.
Pretty sure Sharia law wouldn't help these girls. If I recall correctly, hasn't Sharia law been used to punish rape VICTIMS claiming the girl was dressed too salaciously and therefore tempted the men into sin? It's also been used to justify wife beatings and honor killings where families are allowed to legally murder a female relative for bringing some alleged dishonor to the family, probably because she voiced an opinion without her husband's or father's permission.
Yes, it is a terible stat of affairs, however, we have the same situation or worse in this country.  Do you realize that as we speak American minors, mostly runaways whose parents did not want or could not care for them, are being sold into prostitution in other parts of this country and abroad.  We often make comments like awe that is terrible when we see negative situations abroad, but we can't see truth, because our noses are in the way.
truly very sad, the exploitation of these children... I am a father of 10 & 5 year old girls... I cant imagine.
Sharia law is just a cover for the legal domination of women, just another extreme that the world can do without.  For an example look at Saudi Arabia to see how it works.
http://www.notforsalecampaign.org/
Please check out this web site for more information on how to help human trafficking.
These poor children are part of a World Wide assault on Children. We as a Nation and a World do not protect the children as we should. This is happening in the U.S. and all countries. We are all too busy with other issues to save our own children from these horrors.
It's interesting to see non-Muslims act like 'experts' on Shariah Law.  FACT: you probably have never read the Quran, thus you have no right to make a 'conclusion' based on women's rights in Islam.  Leave it up to real, practicing Muslims -- those Muslims who practice true Islam and not culture. After all, Islam came to PAGAN ARABS WHO WOULD BURY THEIR DAUGHTERS ALIVE; THE QURAN CONDEMNS THIS, AS ILLUSTRATED IN THE QURAN, CHAPTER 81, VERSES 7-8:

"..And when the girl-child that was buried alive is asked: For what sin she was slain?"

This is what we, Muslims, believe will happen on the Judgment Day. The girl who was innocently buried alive JUST BECAUSE SHE WAS A GIRL due to Pagan Arab practices will finally have her chance to question her murderers. And non-Muslims believe Islam is oppressive. Why don't you actually read the Quran for yourselves?

FACT: there is a major difference between TRUE ISLAM and what you see certain 'Islamic' countries practicing.  In Islam, women have all the following rights, and more:

1) The right and duty to obtain education.
2) The right to work to earn money if they need it or want it.
3) The right to have their own independent property.
4) The right to express their opinion and be heard.
5) Equality of reward for equal deeds.
6) The right to provisions from the husband for all her needs and more.
7) The right to negotiate marriage terms of her choice.
8) The right to obtain divorce from her husband, even on the grounds that she simply can't stand him.
9) The right to get sexual satisfaction from her husband.
10) The right to keep all her own money (she is not responsible to maintain any relations).
11) To refuse any marriage that does not please them.
12) Custody of their children after divorce.

I could go on and on; but I am not going to force my beliefs on here, Quran-thumping. Rather, I hope to shed light on this issue so you we all can change ourselves in an attempt to bridge the gaps between Muslims and non-Muslims.

Again, leave it up to real Muslims to explain Islam.  This is where the gaps between the Muslim world and the west come from -- ignorant non-Muslims acting like they're scholars on Islam.
"UNTIL COUNTRIES LIKE PAKISTAN DO NOT BUILD INFURSTURCTURE AND INVEST IN THERE OWN COUNTRY TO CREATE JOBS AND GIVE THERE CHILDREN A CHANCE FOR SURVIVAL, THEY ARE DOMED" !!!!!!
FIX THE CRAP IN YOUR OWN BACKYARD FIRST THEN WORRY ABOUT OTHERS. EVERY CHILD DESERVES A CHANCE...
GOD HELP US ALL....
There are basic human rights...are there not?  Who, how are these protected,defended? I read this, and the rapes in Africa...but what will be done? I say, for example, western men should be prosecuted when they return from overseas, where they have raped children and encouraged this "market".
And the UN must go in with troops and put a stop to what is going on in the Congo, men raping babies as young as 11 months or 4 years, and woman being shot in the vagina with rifles (article on MSN).  Oh wait, stupid me.  What do they have to offer, the US?  We don't go in a country to protect human rights unless there is some pay off.  Anyone remember Rawanda?????
We are a nation, a world, of whores, going to hell in a handbasket.  This is all pure evil.
    It is easy to hate terrorists.  It is not so easy to admit that we in the west conduct ourselves in manners that feed their cause.  
    Open sexuality cloaks itself in freedom's robes, thus undermining the very pillars on which freedom is built, encouraging sexual promiscuity and teaching the weak to give in even as driving the strong toward the development of weakness.  Worse, it cloaks itself in lies that start with truth in order to twist unacceptibility into acceptibility, and then into desirability.
    Muslims, and others who hate us, see the worst in those who lead them, and blame them for following our example even as blaming us for setting that example as fomenting corruption.  Then they blame us also for supporting the purveyors of that corruption in their own countries because we meddle to hold up in office those who are unwanted.  
    They see only the worst of our ways, and hate us for it, even as we see only the best of ourselves, and slowly evolve until we include the worst as goodness to - even though it isn't.  Either way, we hate them as badly for what they become because we will not admit how corrupt we have become. It is all a vicious cycle in which we create the very hatefulness we then exacerbate by our opposition as we meddle in other nations politics.
    Somehow, somewhere, some way, we need to begin doing things in a better way.  And it can only happen if we re-examine our own conduct and begin building by our own examples something that really is better and a true shining dream rather than just a false image of such.
    Else eventually we will be overrun by the enemies we incite.
Yes abuse But you don't understand in the jewish old bible it was very common for a nine year old girl to get maried and the coran comes straight out of jewish bible also they are the same people it is their tradition who are you? to crtisize some ones tradition.
As a mother of a almost 10yr old daughter, who loves her my little ponies and books about animals as I often lay on her bed in her shabby chic room I always remember to thank god for her for I know she will never know of hurt or hunger or scared of what evil there is outside of our home, for she is the lucky one and my heart aches that it hurts for if only I can help those children as well. God please watch over them as I watch over mine.

Wake up people -- this is happening right here in America.  And, why is not a girl pressured into sex with her boyfriend 'oppressive??'

And by the way, in Islam, there is no 'marrying age.'  Rather, the Quran simply states that once you reach the age of the social majority, then you may pursue marriage.
I thought this type of thing is punishable by death in the Muslim world....
Prostitution anywhere exists because of the demand- the clientelle -no matter their religion or the laws of the land. Laws, whether secular or religious, obvioulsy don't legislate all hearts, do they? Why think Shariah law can do what even God himself is not doing - preventing sin on earth. Yet. He will determine the time when He himself will act against.  
unbelievable. the politicians must be animals
There is an agency called Love 146, you can visit their website, www.love146.org, that is working at ending child sex slavery & exploitation.  You can donate to the organization and/or find out more about what they do by visiting their site.  This is a way to help when you are feeling very helpless worlds away from these children they are reporting about.  But let's not forget that this kind of thing happens in our towns too.  Find local organizations to help those children in your area too.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1858150

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.