ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



Bangkok inferno puts spotlight on police payoffs

Posted: Thursday, January 08, 2009 11:19 AM
Filed Under:

 BANGKOK, Thailand –  The initial investigation into the pub inferno that killed 64 New Year’s revelers here makes for depressing reading: Not only did Bangkok's Santika Club have no operating license or insurance, there were no heat or smoke detectors, no fire alarm, no emergency lights, no fire escape sign and no sprinklers. It was packed with highly flammable material, electrical wires were dangerously exposed, windows were blocked and the main entrance was just over six feet wide, according to experts quoted in the local media.

It was, in other words, a death trap.

Image: Bangkok nightclub fire aftermath
PAIROJ/AFP/Getty Images file
Thai policemen and rescuers stand by the bodies of victims of a fire that ripped through a nightclub in Bangkok early on January 1, 2009. 

Yet this was not some seedy, underground establishment, hidden from view. It was a large flashy building on a busy upscale Bangkok road, with the capacity for several hundred, frequented by well-heeled Thais and foreigners.

How on earth were they allowed to get away with not adhering to any safety codes?

Police corruption
Newspapers reported Thursday that the police have summoned the pub's manager for questioning, but he's yet to respond to their invitation.

There may be many in the police wishing he never does.

Thais generally have a very low opinion of the honesty of their police, and nowhere is this more apparent than in the relationship between the cops and Bangkok's notorious entertainment business.

A while back I met an academic from one of Bangkok's leading universities. He was compiling a study of Bangkok's sex industry, and was trying to find an accurate figure for the number of sex workers in the capital.

I can't remember what the final sum was, but the most reliable statistics came from the police. The academic told me cheerily that the cops kept detailed logs of how many worked in each establishment in their area, since they based their payoff on this head-count, and no bar or massage parlor could operate without paying the police.

The Santika pub was not a sex establishment, but bar owners who have tried to upset the system of payoffs have found themselves arbitrarily closed down or subject to dubious drugs raids.

‘Tea money’
There's a distinction here between regulation and control. The entertainment business in Bangkok is poorly regulated – safety rules flouted and not enforced, but the bars are tightly controlled by the police, who even have a stake in many establishments in their area.

The pay-offs are generally referred to as "tea-money" for the poorly paid police force. The authorities this week said they are investigating whether bribes were paid by Santika's owners.

That's encouraging, and would be nice to think that out of the New Year’s carnage a proper investigation of this corruption could come about

The problem, of course, is that we are not talking about a few bad apples in the police force, but an entire rotten system of routine pay-offs.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

As an American who has lived in Bangkok for 17 years, I think it is accurate to say that there is no one who is succesful here who is honest, everyone knows it, and each has a rarionalization for their own crooked behavior and participation (like Jeremy above). Thai X SB, CA who posted above is right, the disheartening nastiness and animal level meanness of Bush and company smells, sounds and looks just the same as what happens in Thailand.  And Laos, Vietnam, Myanmar, Malaysia, Singapore, and China are all a lot worse than Thailand.  At a time when mankind is stupidly insisting on destroying the biosphere and itself, how could it be any different ?  The idiotic grin of George W Bush is on the face of almost every Thai, it's why it is called The Land of Smiles.
The Philippine police in angeles city are as corept as they come they target every one and tourests more so than most.But it is the same in the USA
If you ever look at the tangled telephone & electrical wires all around Bangkok, then you get a sense of what the legal system is like there. Kind of chaotic & beautiful at the same time.  Kind of like what Jeremy is going on about.  After growing up in the west & being of open mind & spirit; I kind of need it to clear
my head (I pretty much visit every six months) & come back with a different perspective on things.
life has little to no meaning in much of the world...the authorities could give a sh^t less if 54 people died in thaat club or 5400...I have some experience in a neighboring Asian country and its the same there too...cops are bigger crooks than the crooks themselves and the higher up the chain of command you go the more crooked/criminal they become...sorta like we have in the Congress and White House...and you can bet they crashed the US financial markets...
I've visited Thailand for about a month. I met a few Americans there and many other foreigners there. All of which loved the place. It's a beautiful country. The people are awesome. Thailand will always hold a special place in my heart. Some news becomes transparent at times but when Thailand is in the news it always grabs my attention. Many other people must feel the same way because they thrive off of their tourism. I hate that such a tragedy has happened there. My prayers and thoughts go out for all of the families and the business owner. I'm sure he/she didn't want or expect that to happen. Corruption is everywhere, no matter where you live and whether it be a baht or a dollar, I'm sure if the amount is high enough it can get you out of any sticky situation. Who says money doesn't make the world go around?
First I too would like to say I'm so sorry for the people who died and their families.  But I'm really surprised to even see this article... you cannot look at this from a westerners point of view. We lived in THailand for about 6 years and other countries in Asia as well. What some of your bloggers say is very true, about the corruption everywhere, monye means everything, etc.. and on the other hand.. it's not about rules etc.. there.. the rules are ALL different.. nothing in these countries is built to code or correctly... you walk down the street and see wires hanging out all over the place and not just in Thailand.... in many developing countries and some that are further along than that.. it's the way of things.. AMerica has plenty of it's own corruption to be sure.. but there are some checks and balances and at least some recourse and expectation of something different... this is not at all surprising.. just very sad.. and throwing a few "corrupted" people into jail will not solve it at all.. because it's the way everything is done there.. bribes etc.. Try China as well. same thing.. how do you think we ended up with all the "melamine scandal" in the news etc... same thing... it's a completely different way of life.. and yet.. we have our scandals and such as well.  Hard to understand uless you have lived there.
Fire works in a palce that has carpeting on the floor and serves Alcohol?  Fireworks in a building that the owners knew didnt have sprinklers or fire exits?  If you ask me first and foremost the owners may have paid the police to be open but the police didn't say to use fireworks in the place that didnt have anysafety precaustions.  THe owners of this club bear all responsibility for these deaths.  They knew what they owned!
I don't think you folks understand the extent of corruption in Thailand, it is everywhere from the lowest police officer to the top of govt.  Yea we have Louisana and Chicago with rampant fraud and corruption but it isn't everywhere all across our country at all levels.  There might be a single jerk working for the city of Cedar Rapids, IA scheming some flood victims but it isn't the whole city police, fire, welfare, water, streets departments.  Not like Thailand.
Were your closing comments directed towards Thailand or Illinois?
First, no matter if the police are corrupt, the owners knew the club they opened was fire safe.  IF teh club owners handed out "sparklers " to guests and if they allowed fireworks in the club, then no matter what they paid to the police to stay open the club owners aare the ones that are guilty for the tragedy that ensued.  The club owners knew what they had and didnt have in place for safety!
all of you farangs that talk about you lived their blah blah blah, no one has said anything about Thaskin the former PM. the walked with....Dr Evil.....Billions and flew it out on a Thai commercial airliner. Bottom line in thailand, like Mexico used to be, you pay the first cop off for a very small fee, and all is fine. in our good old usa, you pay, your lawyer, the judicial system, sometimes their lawyer, sometimes pay and still do time, taxes....think about it. the land of smiles has a much better quality of life, the people accept it, live with it, and still are hospitable. can you say the same about the US? too many people here, too many takers looking for a handout, can you say illegal immigrant.
payoffs to the cops here are part of the fabric of life. motorbike violations. want to keep the bar open til 5 a.m. assault charges. vehicular homicide. all no problem if one has the cash to buy their way out. if you can pay the cops and thrown a cash bone to the victims or their families, you walk. they consider these supplements as part of their salary.
Nothing will happen to these owners of the club most thai places you go in are death traps. i have been to thailand 17 times always the same. everybody else move forward they stay the same. the most important concept is face. The police are a joke i have had to pay a couple of times. they make things worse just watch them direct traffic i thought about this yesterday i think that thailand would be better off if the police just quit
also not mention is the police own some of the clubs i am next to one of the thai police stations and everyone breaks the law like it not even there. Thai have it taught from a young age that you can break the law and it means nothing. There is no rule of law if you are a thai  if you are Farang they throw the book at you it is just better to pay. just llok at the traffic the only place worse is vietnam which is a whole different story  I love thailand but they will never be a Korea or japan it just wont happen
Everything is fake here you just accept it and try to move on .Know you will get screwed every chance they get .there are many good thai but there are also lots of bad ones.
Everywhere i go i look for exits and try to be aware of my surrounding. You have to be real careful in thailand your safety is not important. Life is cheap i have seen people hit by cars and left on the road while the driver sppeds off.
When you are in thailand you are on your own. Lot of people are out to take advantage of you every single second you are here.
i love thailand you just have to accept for what it is .thailand will not change however if you arent careful it will change you
I like Jeremy's comment. The differnces between the US system and the Thai system rest on accountability for the losses. In the US we put the responsibility on a bureaucratic system that we know has it's own forms of veiled corruption, but, works to a degree and keeps the majority safe without personal accountability. In the Thai system, when a tradgedy like this happens, individual club goers may be more wary of where they go from now on and assume the responsibility for their choices. Therefore, a club that looks risky will have less customers and will not be able to stay in business for long. Of course, the Thai cop who cannot collect "tea money" from a business that is failing will put pressure on that establishment to change their risk factor or go out of business and be replaced by a new tennant.

In the end, there will unfortunately always be some tragedies in both systems.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1737055

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.