ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



India asks what election means for ‘world’s back office’

Posted: Friday, October 17, 2008 8:00 AM
Filed Under: ,



NEW DELHI – As Election Day approaches, India is looking nervously at the United States. Pundits here are asking how big an impact the U.S. economic downturn will have on the booming outsourcing business, and how the next U.S. president will react to pressures to protect American jobs.

Anamika Wani, a business consultant in Mumbai, India’s financial capital, says she's liked Sen. Barack Obama ever since she heard him speak while she was visiting California.

 

VIDEO: Indians wonder how U.S. election will affect business 

But she says many in India are wary of him. "A lot of the Indian economy has come about through outsourcing," she told me. "Because the U.S. has been willing to shift business centers out of the country. So if that reverses, then there would be a fall in the economy and job losses here, so from that perspective, I think a lot of people don’t favor some of Obama’s policies." 

Many see Sen. John McCain as more committed to free trade, which will keep the outsourcing work flowing to India.

Closely tied to the U.S. economy
Outsourcing is now a multi-billion dollar industry here. If China is the workshop of the world, than India has become its back office, doing everything from working the phones in call centers to transcribing U.S. doctors’ notes and tutoring American students.

There are two schools of thoughts here: either Indian companies will have less work as the slowdown bites, or else more work will be sent to India to keep U.S. costs down. A great deal of backroom legal work takes place in India, and some canny entrepreneurs are already positioning themselves for a flood of work related to bankruptcy and litigation as a result of the meltdown on Wall Street.

What’s harder for them to calculate is the politics, and the enormous pressure on the next president to keep jobs at home.

"We are getting so much more integrated," said Dr. Usha Tuteji, a professor of agriculture at Delhi University. "What happens in the U.S. affects the overall welfare of the globe."

She told me that the close interest in the election this year is not only the result of the candidacy of Obama, but also because of the growing numbers of Indians studying in the U.S. "Many middle-class families send their children to the U.S. or U.K. to study, so we’ve become more curious about what’s happening on the other side of the world."

Nuke deal
Aside from Wall Street’s woes, the other big news from America has been the signing of a nuclear accord that allows American businesses to sell nuclear fuel, technology and reactors to India. This reversed a three-decade ban on atomic trade with India, imposed after New Delhi carried out its first atomic test in 1974 and refused to sign nonproliferation accords.

The nuclear deal was the result of three years of often difficult political and diplomatic wrangling. The two countries have had a prickly relationship, but the deal seems to signal a new beginning.

"India and the U.S. are coming close economically and diplomatically," said Dr. Nirmal Jindel, Professor of Political Science at Delhi University. "It is very important that India and American should have a strong relationship in the future, so the U.S. election means a lot for us."

There is also a sense here that Obama might be easier to deal with, in spite of suspicions about his commitment to free trade (or outsourcing, from the Indian perspective). "Obama, he doesn’t appear to be so hard core," Jindel told me. She thinks Obama might engage more constructively with the world.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

What the hell are you talking about India??? Of course we are going to take care of our selves first, just like you would.Create your own economy and stop depending on the U.S.A.. WE NEED OUR JOBS BACK!!!
Let's get real folks...
The jobs that are taken to India are jobs that could easily be done here, in the USA, by US citizens.
I personally try to buy "Made in the USA" when I see two of the same type of products and one is made in India /China and the other in the USA.
What are all these companies thinking?
They must think that they can take the jobs from the US and give them to India but how exactly do they think that American's will obtain the money to buy the goods created elsewhere? The jobs need to stay here, so the money can stay here. Granted you might pay more for goods and services BUT if you actually have a job and get a paycheck, then you can pay the difference.
It makes no sense to leave so many here in the US jobless and expect them to still prop up the economy.
By the way - Outsourcing doesn't even work. Many times, specifically in the I.T. sector - the work is sub-par and the money being spent is the same or more due to the many project failures - you see we are still the I.T. leaders of the world - we just need to focus and except the fact outsourcing was perhaps at one point in the 1990's a seemingly good money saving idea that just didn't pan out and ruined our economy... Wall Street (companies with stock - thought they could prop up their stock by cutting costs and shipping jobs elsewhere) now what - 401K's are falling and jobless rates are at their height - Oh yeah and the stock market got it's Karma.

What we need now is Change We Can Believe In.

Any thoughts on the Nuclear portion of this article?
We outsource manufacturing, we outsource IT, we outsource call center jobs etc.... Call center jobs are usually minumum wage jobs that are being sent to India, you mean to tell me that this is getting done for less than 7 bucks an hour outsourced?
How do we break a circle that goes like this, banks and corporations inflate the housing market pricing, banks and corporations outsource work that people do who own these houses, people without jobs can't pay their mortgage, forclosures happen in droves, corporations still make a fortune, the value of homes plummet to what should have been the actual value.....
We outsource to save money but we price product at a level only well paid citizens can afford. There are a lot of things you can buy at Walmart but in my area they don't sell houses or cars.
It's going to be really hard to purchase items, even at Walmart when you don't have a place to put them because you can't afford to keep a roof over your head.
I have been saying for the last five years that we will become the new third world country and 2008 has really pushed us more in that direction than any other year in this decade.
I really want to say God Bless America and I Love My Country but it is tough to have that relationship with all the infidelity.
Well its done by companies whose Executives get this to do for cheap and bring results every quarter and we invest in them heavely. Nothing wrong with the part of Indian workers.
We are responsible for it. STOP INVESTING IN COMPANIES THAT TAKE JOBS OUTSIDE THE COUNTRY BECAUSE ITS CHEAP
Who doesn't want to make money? Who is not looking for opportunities? Instead of blaming the citizens of another country, may be people should start blaming the greedy corporations that outsourced the jobs. Don't blame the people who are ambitious.. Blame your own country's greediness..
It is tough to sympathise with the Indian call centers who have gotten alot of the out-sourced jobs from U.S. companies. While alot of folks go wanting for jobs at home. While call centers are not the best paying jobs unless you are superior producer, we still need them. In India for instance a $25k job is very desirable and that goes alot further than here. But we need to think of home first especially with the economic climate as it is. Obama is the only one who seems to be speaking about this.
My former company just laid off 110 tech workers so they can offshore the jobs.  I feel just terrible for those that are having a hard time finding new jobs.  What is the sense of this?  It won't really save money in the long run, it never does.  
When did we become isolationist, while I get frequently upset with this outsourcing I also see America is the land of dreams. We as a nation inspire others to seek a better life for themselves. Everything in life has its complications but we Americans have boundless opportunities other nations do not. IF we cut off open door abilities we are selling ourselves short. I myself can and will provide others with what I have found is a golden opportunity, home based business. Don't limit yourself or others, inspire with action, commit with solutions, and provide with intregrity in what you have so that others may realize a dream. Seek the Dream,
Jobs will continue to be outsourced to India. We may be able to decrease the number of jobs that are outsourced, but it simply won't end. That's why I'm supporting Obama. He'll atleast try to decrease outsourcing even if it's by 2%. But McCain and the GOP? They'll ADD countries to the current "outsourcing network". I'm a dedicated Republican that realizes that a clean sweep of the GOP this fall is the only way to make this happen. A fresh start is what this country needs....
Everything needs moderation. Speed at which things are done matters.
Jobs go to other countries, They buy American goodies and product made my USA companies and the money of finished product comes back.

Indians (or others) buy Microsoft software, Intel or AMD PC (no one else makes them in the world)

Growth of US companies is outside USA, as here every household got PC , a cell phone.

Many of these US companies don't pay enough Tax neither here nor there.

It is the law of capitalism and entropy - people will buy the cheapest stuff.

With outsourcing a shirt in walmart costs $ 10, with current salaries can middle class buy $ 50 shirt from 5 saks avenue ?

if outsourcing is put on hard -brake, executives at 5 Saks ave would mint $, while middle class lose their shirt.

What is needed is normalization of salary. Distribute the salary of executive theifs to middle class.

In order to compete with other nations , study hard and dont waste years hanging out. Study the subjects which are in demand not some theorotical subject. It does not get goood paying job anywhere in world

Many hi-tech companies claim that they don't get enough knowledgeable workers locally because people here are stuck with mainframe programming skills , when the demand is to make applications for iPhones (alike)
In todays knowledge economy one needs to update their skills every year, else no way one could survive.

10-15 year down the line Indians may get their own Microsoft/Intel and may not even buy from them.

and US companies would loose billions of customers

One should compete in the changing world - thats the american spirit , not ask for "help".

Govt should spent money to help people compete, cheaper and right education, not creating walls.

 

The companies that outsource should be taxed. The inequities would be balanced. The H1B should be closed. Indian businesses are getting a free ride from this. If things do not change, there is no incentive for an American to spend time and money going thru college and then see his job outsourced to India. Unfair. Keep American jobs in America.
Let's be clear, everyone has their own selfish concerns at the top of the list.  We all want the benefits of the free market and free trade without the disadvantages, and that isn't going to happen.  Sending jobs to India made sense in an inflating economy.  Keeping jobs in the US makes sense in a deflating economy - but it isn't easy (if at all possible) to suddenly switch directions. Let's stop complaining about India and understand that we're currently facing the consequences of our own decisions as a country and society.  
Isn't it interesting that India for centuries had only the ultra-rich and dirt poor, but now with all the outsourced work they have a developing and growing middle class?
And isn't it interesting that all the jobs being outsourced are middle-class jobs, such as customer service, industrial manufacturing, and technical trades.
I've also noticed that more and more people in the US are losing their jobs and homes and becoming very, very poor while others seem to be getting benefits from lavish CEO salaries, reduced corporate and capital gains taxes, and loopholes to reduce taxes that get bigger the more money you have.

Am I the only one noticing that the US is exchanging our socio-economic makeup for India's?
The concept of "free trade" means any job (manufacturing, software, or other jobs) can be sent anywere in the world. One can imagine that this can only result in lowering the standard of living in one country (e.g USA), while raising  the standard in another (eg. India, or China). But does free trade benefit every country by increased volume? This is the theory, but I do not know if this is proven....
No country is actually practising free trade! China has artificially kept its currency low, anmd accepted poor working comditions and environmental standards. India does not manipulate its currency, but does not allow free access to all of its markets. The US and Europe protect their farmers  with costly subsidies.
On the other hand , economic growth in countries like India helps the US by creating a large demand for US products, such as planes, and nuclear plants(a 250 billion dollar market). Similarly, if we can become the world's No.1 producer and innovator of green energy and green transportation, all of these countries will be our markets, as proposed by Obama.
How can we reconcile these conflicting advantages and disadvantages of free trade?
Can we pass legislation that states that no country should have a trade deficit of more than 20% for any goods or services which are able to be produced in the USA? This will have a major impact on China(Korea, and japan as well), but not India which has a healthy trade balance with us. We have to keep in mind however that we are heavy debtors to China, which can manipulate politics in our country by impled and real threats....
We need to find creative solutions which benfit us (Americans) and others in the world as well....
Outsourcing does not produce for the middle class consumer a porportionate savings as compared to the profits gained by the Big Corporations. How does it trickle down if there are no employees of the respective corporation in America? So why would a middle class American support a candidate that wishes to further "globalize" middle class American jobs and qaulity of life?
 There has to be some type of subliminal message eminating from those negative GOP campaign adds?
   
Halliburton outsourced my and about 100 of my co-workers professional jobs while they were raking in billions from Iraq un-bid defence contracts. What a Great American Company!
I am a GC holder from India and I undersatnd anger about it.Unfortuantely, its American Corporate Greed which is killing Americans.During cold war era Russian Kruschave said lets bury Americans but with the current crisis and future outsourcing trends American will bury Americans forever.Corporates get lot of tax breaks for cost reduction etc. and for the last 8 years all companies are cash rich but not hiring anyone in US but outside e.g. IBM keeps hiring in India and keep laying off in US(last year 10,000 jobs creatd in India but more than double get downsized in US by IBM). Rich wants to deplete and finish middle class of USA. There will be only Rich and Poor like USSR was before bolshevik revolution.Unfortuantely, I don't see American protesting and fighting.I found that was the greatest thing of US -- to fight and win.But I found Americans are badly scared of all Rich elite. India is still a developing nation and started shouting big without understanding the pain on the other side.Hope things will change and good and haigh paying jobs will remain in USA.People have to fight.
GREED is the number one recipe to our down fall! It starts with the CEO's wanting to outsource our jobs overseas to generate more profit so that they can have fat bonus and take home millions of dollars. Also, we need to understand that these MORONS are the products of consumer GREED. As investor, we keep demanding bigger profit AND we refuse to pay for quality service! It doesn't work! We can't have it both ways. We need BALANCE. We cannot isolate ourselves from the rest of the countries. But we americans must also protect our interest. Like how we conduct our business outside our household. Our family first and the country. That's all I have to say. We need to find BALANCE.
It takes policy changes in D.C. for any reversal in (Free Trade) and that's not going to happen. Our manufacturing industry has left because of self inposed tax reasons. The only way now to get some industries to return is to keep gas and oil high enough to make transport to expensive, and policy change.
 I don't see and change for the better coming! Where is the outrage over this Bailout! (ENRON), Fannie May, Freddy Mac! What is the differance?
 In Japan or China CEO's do not receive billions of dollars for taking a company down, and our fellow Americans with them!                
I cant believe how hypocritical some of these comments are and how some of you have a ridiculously blind fatih about Obama being the solution to all the problems that we have. Most of you here dont even know the economics of outsourcing. The whole outsourcing pie including backoffice and IT jobs is probably less than 10%. The majority of the job losses are in the manufacturing sector where the jobs go to China. Reasons corporations go out of the country is obviously to save money. I am a small business owner and would give you an example: Four years ago we used to spend about $80,000 per year for 2 qualified accounting professionals and that cost does not include the benefits, HR cost, time and effort of managing. Now I get twice the work done and with less management at about 30,000 per year. Because of the money saved I was able to invest in other field of my business, expand it and hire more than 8 people here in US.

Now dont get me wrong, I like to keep every thing in my office and infront of my eyes but I dont want to be a stupid businessman and loose to my competetion. If small business can get tax cuts and lower the cost of benefits some backoffice jobs will be kept right here. But I think the government and we the people should concentrate on education of our young kids so that there will be less dropouts and more graduates creating more workforce and hence reducing the salaries.
Before Americans blame Indian back office workers or Chinese manufacturing job workers for 'taking' their jobs perhaps it would be better to direct their anger at their greedy executives who essentially are the ones making money out of this. No one is outsourcing jobs to countries like Mexico, China, Israel, India, Phillipines or any other developing country based on the goodness of their heart or altrustic reasons to help the people of these countries. It is basic greed, plain and simple. And while the middle class citizens of USA get decimated a few of the executive class get rich. And yes, I am going to say it at the cost of being called a racist, because this is true too. Before you go blaming the black, yellow and brown colored people of this world for stealing your jobs, may be you could blame the mostly white executives who are responsible for outsourcing and the politicians of either party for facilitating it.
Giving Nuclear free hand to a country that refuses to sign the NPT..hmmm,that would make the world a safe place. Oh, they are not terrorists, I guess.
It's a global economy, folks.  Get used to it.  We don't just play in our own little sandbox any more.  Improvements in communication and transportation are big drivers.  We need to partner with other countries. Trying to block them out is like plugging holes in the dam with your fingers.
I had read most of the messages related to saying "No outsourcing". I am an Indian staying in US, finished my Masters in the States and currently working for a big organization in here. As Salomi Abbas said in her message, studying in India is not just easy or FREE. It takes its own effort for one to shine in his/her life. I know many of my American colleagues who have their Masters and are very knowledgeable, who make more money than an immigrant working in the same position. Everyone, either American or Indian get opportunity to choose their lives.

Outsourcing - Lets think about the basic problem of goods made in China and call centers in India - COST!!!! If American industry can make / deliver the same quality of product / services, there is no need for outsourcing.

I am not a supporter of India nor America....but Just facts.
I had read most of the messages related to saying "No outsourcing". I am an Indian staying in US, finished my Masters in the States and currently working for a big organization in here. As Salomi Abbas said in her message, studying in India is not just easy or FREE. It takes its own effort for one to shine in his/her life. I know many of my American colleagues who have their Masters and are very knowledgeable, who make more money than an immigrant working in the same position. Everyone, either American or Indian get opportunity to choose their lives.

Outsourcing - Lets think about the basic problem of goods made in China and call centers in India - COST!!!! If American industry can make / deliver the same quality of product / services, there is no need for outsourcing.

I am not a supporter of India nor America....but Just facts.
Judging by the comments, it appears most people don't understand that we've demanded outsourcing through our own purchasing patterns.  We have a high material standard of living in the US in large part because companies have outsourced production and other functions in order to make themselves more competitive to US consumers.  If the jobs were to somehow, across the board, be "brought back" to the US, then we in the US would have to either 1) pay two or three times as much for the end products or else 2) work for the low wages of India, China, etc to keep end prices the same.  Either course produces the identical outcome: American purchasing power evaporates and everybody realizes we're materially poor.

Outsourcing is just one more way that America manages to temporarily live outside its means.  Deficit spending, unfunded tax cuts, a frenzy of real estate speculation, and a one-time-only, 25-year glut cheap oil are a few others.  One way or another, we're going to face a day of reckoning for all of this that will force us to live within our means as a country and as citizens.  Good luck to everybody with all of that.  
I agree that outsourcing is a cause for concern, not so much because jobs have left for India (or anywhere else), but because retraining and job re-placement efforts have not been implemented here in the US adequately.  Sure, call centers have sprung up in India, but Air India buys 777's built in Seattle, etc., in a circulating global economy.  The notion that we are going to keep every American job in America for all time just doesn't hold water.  We need to adapt to the fact that some jobs are going to leave and never come back.  We adapt by having real retraining and re-placement processes and financial assistance to workers and their families being put into new jobs in new industries.  But we cannot -- CANNOT -- just send jobs out and say "sorry, you're on your own."  If a U.S. company wants to outsource jobs, fine, let them, but we must insist (through legislation and lawsuits, if need be) that every worker they displace is given substantial assistance to find a new job.
I contacted a call center a few days ago, regarding the warranty on my American vehicle. (ironic) It was an Indian call center. The ACD switch was an infinite loop of recordings, until I hit 0 and actually got an agent, who started reading off her script. I had to repeat my very simple request 3 times, because I guess it wasn't on the script. I still don't think she got it.

Yesterday, another Indian call center contacted me for a satisfaction survey on the previous call. It was all I could do not to say, "y'know, an unemployed auto worker in Detroit would have handled my call efficiently and on the first try, and would be grateful for the work."

I let them know what I thought of their 'customer service'... as politely as I could.
Ravi Kaushika - I am delighted by your post! There are a lot of people, all them that stand to gain from outsourcing and guest workers, that blather about racism being the reason we oppose these practices. That is not the case. American's of Asia ancestory are harmed as much by those activities as every other American worker. Likewise, as I pointed out in my earlier post, those Indian (and, sometimes, CHinese and other workers) quest workers are treated like slaves here. They are forced to work inhumane hours with no overtime under horrific circumstances and, if they get sick from all of that mistreatment, they are shipped back home. The H1-B visa is simply barbaric and the L-1 visa is even worse (where 10 and 20 Indian naionals are literally stuffed into a one or two bedroom apartment and treated like garbage). Congress, end those programs! If we actually need foreign expertise in some area, and that is going be RARELY, then give them a Green Card and treat them with some human dignity!
I think its very unrealistic for people to pin their hopes of economic recovery on one candidate or the other, and expect the economy to be improved upon in a four year cycle of any one president.

The problems that have been created by moving jobs overseas and the 700 billion dollars, that we now "have" to spend, are not just problems that just "suddenly happened". The signs were simply ignored.

After its all said and done and we are lied to yet again about a supposed "new" direction we as a country are going to go, the policies of old will still be in place.

Americans can't "drill our way" out of an outsourced service based economy. Any new direction will be a farce so long as overseas priorities take place over any domestic policy. Any domestic policy that can repair and eliminate the ailments within the United States.

Lets also be realistic also about how long any recovery is going to take. Even if measures are taken to stem the tide of outsourceing employment, and the economy becomes centered on manufacturing by Americans for Americans, be it for our own energy needs, or goods for purchase. It will take over two decades after redesigning our economy for any positive benefits to fully mature.

Face it eden isn't just burning, its burnt. And we've done this to ourselves.

Its more than time to fix our own problems. Problems created by Americans for Americans.

The solution will have to be an American one.
Here is what stupid companies forgot that moved jobs to india and china. When no one in the USA can buy their cheap lousy products and they are making no money because nothing is selling they will finally learn when the CEO's are unemployed too. Our Goverment has to stop the outsourcing of jobs and make companies here in the USA keep them here or they will be taxed at a higher rate. NAFTA has ruined this country like I said if the stock market dkepps dropping then even Warren buffet will be poor. This economy has been losing ground since the 1970's and its finally comming home to roost.
The reason these jobs are outsourced is greed on the part of management.  It is not that it won't be profitable to keep the jobs here, it is that it won't be profitable enought to pay themselves the huge salaries and bonuses they currently receive.  So if we limit these companies from outsourcing, I think they will still stay in business.  Some managers may leave, but then one has to ask where will they go if all companies are under the same rulebook?  The service sector also has to start organizing more so they can gain the type of benefits that our unions were able to achieve for the manufacturing sector.  
I guess when americans (in goverment) don't care about america then why any on else will. As long as we have lobbiest in washington. We will lose jobs, money by exporting wealth and importing poverty.

The question is what can we do, if a good person want to get in politics "WE THE PEOPLE" never never ever votes for him, later blames THE ONEs we choosed. Dont we deserve these crisis ?

Cut all outsourcing or tax it on fair basis for american workers to compete with rest of the world.
It sounds like a great idea but will raise prices. Outsourcing makes either more jobs and higher prices or less jobs and lower prices.
Yes, outsourcing has cost America more than the politicians and corporate executives will ever realize.  The sad thing is that, like the company I work for, there are LAYERS upon LAYERS upon LAYERS of "Senior" management and executives who are making the REALLY BIG bucks.  The vast majority of virtually every single company in America's employee base are the people who DO NOT make the REALLY BIG bucks, but are the first to be outsourced.

The Republican party is known as the GOP.  This stands for the "Grand Ole Party".  This is the Good-Ole-Boy network in action, where every single family member, close friend or paper-boy from down the street are given positions of power simply through association, rather than actually being able to perform the job function.

This is what is causing the rampant product cost run-up, not the saleries of the next round of "right-sized" employees.  Corporate greed has been extended to the next senior-level person to be hired, along with 200 of their closest whatevers.

My company has reached a 3-to-1 ratio of senior executives-to-grunts.  For every 5 people my company "right-sizes", they hire one new senior level to do god only knows what, because they ARE NOT helping me with MY continually increasing work-load, but only seem to give me more to do.  While threatening to outsource me if I complain...
Do you want jobs to go to India, or soldiers?  Do you want foreign countries to work for their income, or starve and beg for humanitarian aid?  At one point the US was a little foreign nation at big risk and was in the position to borrow money from a foreign government.  Thank you France.  If India is an american Ally in the EAST and their Wealth proliferates, you might see exports of GOODS increase and more INDIAN TOURISTS spending their money here.  Exports are the real reason for downturn in jobs, do some research.  The population is what has grown, and we are hungry for cheap imports.  For the ONE job that we lose hear what like 20 people can get hired overseas?  What if we could get those 20 people to buy our exported goods?  When India has its comeuppance, and there is an end to starvation and child labor, there will be remittance to the US in a big way.  
This really ticks me off!  I am furious that with the state of our economy, someone from India could make such a statement. This is why "we"  the USA have to find the commonalities between us. United WE STAND, DIVIDED WE FALL!!
The simple fact is that burdens placed on corporate America such has the Second highest corporate tax rates in the world behind only Japan.  This has necessitated savings wherever possible.  If corporate taxes rates are increased the result will not be the outsourcing of valuable back office jobs to foreign countries, the entire corporations will move offshore and simple sell their products back into the US.  The only problem with that is that we will have no money to send on these products.  We have gotten to reliant on the Federal Government insisting that they protect us against outside competition, however this protect is exactly what is costing us our jobs.  
I expect the Obama administration, responding to pressure from Congressional Democrats, will institute protectionist trade and labor policies which will have the same effect as the Smoot-Hawley tariffs of the thirties.  That is to say the economy will go into free-fall.
Unionists and people who work, or worked, for industries which cannot compete in the world economy will be reassured by the democrats that they don't have to.  They will be told that the government can see to it that all America drives Edsels and we'll have our own fireworks factories in every American county.
Insisting that Canada and Mexico must have their labor and environmental laws made by the U S Congress will have the effect of abrogating NAFTA, and regulations at the ports in the name of safety and fairness will block Chinese imports.  The resulting trade war and inflation will be intolerable to American business.  As a result, those industries which are now outsourcing jobs will simply outsource themselves.  After all, nothing prevents them from moving their corporate offices as well as their plants to a country where capitalism prevails.
KEEP JOBS IN THE USA....AND COMPANIES THAT DON'T SHOULD BE TAXED HIGHER THAN THOSE THAT ARE CREATING JOBS FOR OUR UNEMPLOYED!
Outsourcing of jobs has indeed becone a problem. One wonders how a company such as AT&T can outsource its jobs, for example customer service to other countries when virtally all of its customers are in the USA.Americans could easily do the jobs here but AT&T and others outsource to make money at the expense of their customers while paying their outsource labor in India, Pakistan, China, Mexico and elsewhere starvation wages. I formerly worked in a manufacturing concern which moved to Mexico. A friend of mine saw two of the same product,one made here and one in Mexico. The prices were the same. We were told that (1) the move to Mexico was to be more competitive and (2) the finished products would be shipped to the United States for sale, of course. I guess that they weren't making enough money doing the work here. Very few of the Mexicanos could afford to buy them but as a staff member for my Congressman, told me, we don't care about the Mexicans. For the record my Congressman is Rep. Roy Blunt(R)Missouri who has very active in his efforts of late to bail out Wall Streert and the huge investment bankers. Of course it is his interest to do so to keep the campaign contributions flowing to himself so that he can continue to work over the American worker.
I had read most of the messages related to saying "No outsourcing". I am an Indian staying in US, finished my Masters in the States and currently working for a big organization in here. As Salomi Abbas said in her message, studying in India is not just easy or FREE. It takes its own effort for one to shine in his/her life. I know many of my American colleagues who have their Masters and are very knowledgeable, who make more money than an immigrant working in the same position. Everyone, either American or Indian get opportunity to choose their lives.

Outsourcing - Lets think about the basic problem of goods made in China and call centers in India - COST!!!! If American industry can make / deliver the same quality of product / services, there is no need for outsourcing.

I am not a supporter of India nor America....but Just facts.
Wouldn't it be great if the USA could be a true super power by being able to stand alone and not depend on any other country's for their products or work force.  Then it would be our choice if we want outside products.

I know dumb idea.  Put it would be great to be an independent super power instead of a country with great wealth and talent that everyone makes fun of.
It's a shame that our "outsourcing" has created so much instability caused by corporate greed. Our workers have actually trained their replacements. Now, our replacements sound like we're somehow responsible for their unemployment. It's going to happen if as a society, you produce nothing except cheap labor. Thanks NAFTA!!! Remember Ross Perot? People thought he was crazy, but it's all coming to pass.
Stop sending US jobs overseas! Tax the top 5% and spread the wealth around by giving chump change to the other 95%, Health care as a right not a responsiblity! Withdraw troops from unpopular wars regardless of the consequences! All of these things sound great to shortsighted, one step only thinking people that don't understand consequences of actions. Obama is betting that is the majority of the electorate and the polls and comments on this page are bearing that out.
Outsourcing enables US companies to provide products cheaper to the consumer. The consumer then has more money to buy other products [thus giving the consumer a raise] the people of India or whereever also have more money to buy luxury goods [typically US exports] which provide more jobs to American workers. All economists understand that Free Trade makes everyone wealthier. Politically, however, the people who lose their jobs know who they are, and the winners don't. That is why pandering politicians use rhetoric like on these comment pages.
Its funny to hear all the people just now recognizing the problem with all the outsourcing. I have been in the pipe trades unions for years and we have always preached "BUY AMERICAN" anything you can, but no, all you people bitching are the same ones that have been buying foreign cars but put your american flag sticker on it?!! Effing pathetic! Chinese crap from Walmart, anything to save a buck, and now that its hitting home you decide to pull your heads out! Nike was one of the first, did anybody care? NO, they pay athletes millions and make their labor work in 1$ a day sweatshops, welcome to the country you created...
Hmmmmm other than a few comments all echoed the same opinion outsourcing should not be allowed. well my dear Americans it is a global economy and the only way u can bring back jobs is by competing with indians and chinese workers. Dont whine about your lost job if you are not willing to do better than your competitors.    
If a company outsources because it must do so in order to compete, perhaps that company ought to move it's headquarters away from the US, pay higher tarrifs, and be subject to normal restrictions we place upon foreign entities. They no longer deserve to be called American.  Civic minded people need to remember their own nation first.  If they cannot live within our economy, they ought to leave.
None of these candidates can stop the outsourcing. This will happen, and this is the reality. Things need to be worked out is bringing down higher education expenses, making us competitive, so that we can compete in this global economy.
This has been a growing problem since 2000.  Companies are using the H1 Visas and outsourcing to reduce costs.  The issue is it is eliminating jobs for American citizens and even worse transferring the knowledge out of the USA.  Companies have decided to use the H1 Visas to save a few cents per share on income but in actuality they are mortgaging the US.
The following Business Week article gives an interesting insight:
http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/08_11/b4075062465238.htm?campaign_id=yhoo


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1548054

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.