ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



In an African market, pennies are not peanuts

Posted: Tuesday, September 16, 2008 8:10 AM
Filed Under:


MWANZA, Tanzania – None of the shopkeepers had change for a dollar, and I marveled, not for the first time, at how the gap between rich and poor plays out in real life.

I wanted to buy a tiny bag of peanuts while waiting for a ferry to cross a pretty bay on Lake Victoria in Tanzania.

Nagona, the woman selling the peanuts, didn't have change; so she went from stall to stall, waving the 1,000 Tanzanian shilling note, which is actually worth about 88 cents. But nobody could break it. This vendor had 60 cents worth of money, that one had 80 cents, but nobody had the resources to break the 1,000 shilling note.

And all the while they smiled and laughed and joked with each other. I asked how business was and they said good. They sold peanuts, small cartons of milk, warm, sweet, fizzy drinks, dry biscuits labeled "energy bars" and, of course, cigarettes.

One cigarette at a time, that is.

Image: Ferry headed across Lake Victoria in Tanzania
NBC News
A passenger on the ferry we eventually caught to go across Lake Victoria in Tanzania.

The waiting ferry passengers milled around, joking at the man who had a baby chicken inside a tiny cage made of twigs, which he had tied to his bicycle seat. The cage was so small the chick's neck was bent. When an old man's bicycle fell to the ground, scattering his load of pineapples and nuts, everybody laughed as if this was the funniest thing, and he joined in the gaiety, and then everybody helped him pick up his load.

One little boy was carrying boiled eggs in a tin container. You could dip the peeled eggs in some salt he carried. Two boys were checking an egg, tapping it, shaking it and listening, as if they were experts assessing the finest goods.

Two teenage girls approached me and my cameraman, Dave Copeland, smiling shyly and curtsying while holding pieces of paper and a pen, which they shared.

"It's for the orphan's education fund," said our translator. "They want 500 shillings or 1,000." Fifty cents or a dollar. Everybody smiled in appreciation, and a satisfied murmur went through the crowd as we handed over a thousand shillings each and wrote down our names and our contribution amount and then signed the paper. (In all my years covering stories in Africa, hailing back to when Zimbabwe was still Rhodesia, I have never seen any students who study harder than orphans.)

We waited an hour and a half for the ferry. It was hot and dust covered us each time another truck pulled up, its horn playing all kinds of zany tunes. Somebody's cell phone rang. The ring was a baby crying and everybody looked up in concern, and then laughed. Giant clumsy maribou storks hovered with beating wings and then settled on electric cables overhead, clacking.

In short, it was a typical scene in rural Africa.

Image: Lake Victoria in Tanzania.
NBC News
The picturesque scene crossing Lake Victoria in Tanzania.

Again, not for the first time, I reflected on a comparable scene in my world. I imagined the shoppers in a busy department store. How many would stop and help if a lady dropped her shopping? Would everybody laugh (with her, not at her)? And would she laugh, too? And would they then all stop their business to help?

We have plenty of money to spend, even if it is not as much as we would like, and most vendors, if pushed, could break a hundred dollar bill. But some people would probably be more concerned about the caged chick with the bent neck than with the people around them.

As for the peanut vendor, she never did raise the change to break my dollar bill. The shopkeepers had said it was a good day, but not that good.

It seemed condescending to say keep the change, so I bought six packets of peanuts and ate them all.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Wow... happiness amid "poverty," and not a single anti-depressant in sight.  Great story!

And Elizabeth in Madison... buzzkill much?  Laughing at one's own misfortunes as well as at others' isn't malicious so much as it is an acceptance that the "wheel of fortune" turns for all of us.  Most people in the world don't expect to be on top of the world at all times, then get ridiculously depressed when they aren't.  Public acknowledgement that life isn't always perfect sounds like a positive way of life to me (shhhhhh, don't tell the drug pushers!)
Ghandi said, "The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated."  Put two and two together.  You tell 'em Real Deal!
History has well doccumeted that before western influence African peoples traded in goods, crafts, services without exchanging currency, a practice known as Barter.( Does that sound like present day Wall Street?)Now that they have adopted valueless currency, we call then poor because they have so little of it. How quaint!!!  
To: The Real Deal

No need to get hot under the collar!  That is the way these people live.  Humor is their escape valve.  Are they really suffering?  That is entirely debatable.  If you asked them, I am sure they would not agree, they will always point to some-one who is worse off.  Having grown up in Africa, and adopted a 'westernized view' of the world rather early in life - pretty much similar to yours - I am amazed, that with every visit to Africa, I discover how wrong I was!!!  Do they need developmental aid, yes - medicine, education, better housing, etc, etc.; but not too much of it - we would not like them to become like us!!!!
what a picture you paint in such a brief moment.  so much to learn from it ... so much left to do about it.
I enjoyed the story, but was very disappointed at the ending's complete disregard for another living creature, caring for whom you dismiss with obvious condescension, as if that were an ignoble trait. An innocent is an innocent, regardless of how you determine their worth. The powerless who endure cruelty, pain and imprisonment by the powerful are no less worthy than you, be they another human . . . or even a chick. Consider compassion to all, of different species.
Mmmmm, Peanuts.  I wish there was a vendor close by here.  Those people are lucky.
Very nice story; Take these same folks to a developed country, and watch as they will join the hussle, working 3-4 jobs, trying to make a dollar out of fifty cents. I'm  originally from Surulere Lagos, but now live in this great country.
You got that right Mike! We have somehow been brainwashed into thinking any change in mood needs to be medicated, so we fixate on "depression" and the more we think we have/feel it, the more "depressed" we get. "Oh but there is evidence that depression is caused by imbalance in....blah blah blah" Imbalance in rationality maybe. Oh what did we do 50 years ago when we got a little down in the dumps!? Clinical depression used to be rare, now it is as common as the cold. Oh yes...the drug pushers love your depression. Same with ADD and all of its various forms. Go ahead, flatten yourself out with drugs. Make the pharmaceutical industry rich and happy. I'll take a real life, and enjoy it!
As the daughter of African immigrants, I can say I relate to both extremes of the bloggers.  On the one hand, I relate to people who are refreshed by the story, every time I take a trip home to Sierra Leone I really enjoy the simple pleasures of helping people out for the sake of helping and enjoying the quality time with extended family.  On the other hand, poor people arent oblivious to their problems, and just because they smile often doesn't mean they don't have a care in the world.  But I can say they very much value their way of life and their tradition of caring more about people than things.  I know plenty of folks who have traded village life for stock markets and rush hour; they may not miss the dysentary but they do miss the village.
to the real deal maybe you should donate all your assets to the african government so they could take care of their people. or maybe our government should give even more money. what do you think
This reminds me of my  home town Mwanza for the moments we used to laugh until we  break  our ribs !!lol.
" But now, If I don't either, spent some $$ for a beer, watch the American Funniest Video or any comedy show  then I will pass a month without laughing.. this is serious".
Thank you for your article.
I rather liked the article because at one moment in time it was perceived that all the hassles of modern day living did not exist… no hate, greed, chastising, impatience, complaining. ..  Just a brief kodak moment... one that hopefully everyone gets a chance to experience and realize what is really important in life. And it is definitely not rush hour traffic or my mortgage – it is enjoying every moment I have since you are not guaranteed tomorrow. To feel good about yourself and to show the respect that every other human deserves.  How wonderful it is to see that not everyone is  whining and complaining about what is owed to them or what they deserve. Uh- hum… ring a bell?
If you don't say how beautiful this story is, or how wonderful Africa is, you won't get your comment published.  So here it goes: "Gosh,what a heartwarming piece!  It sure puts things into perspective for a greedy, selfish American such as myself!"
KNOW THE TRUTH FEELING BROTHER AND SISTERS FORGET ABOUT MONEY AND SLEEP WELL FROM NOW ON.
 THIS IS JAMES BEDU GRAHAM CALLING FROM ACCRA GHANA WEST AFRICA. 
I lived in Kenya for ten years, on two separate occasions.  This story is so very normal; my family and I have bought many a bag of peanuts and cashews. Cigarettes are always bought one by one.  My sons learned to smoke this way.  This story makes all of the other junk going on in the world, seem not to matter so much. I hope to return to East africa one day.
This is one of the best stories I have read in awhile. The simple life. I love it.
Hey, Great story,
Nancy, Barrie, Harry, Hillary and Joe want you to experience that in America! Really, African bureaurocrats and Dictators have all the money,the people. all the pain.
George Soros and the Elites want us to be controlled in the same way.
Having just returned from Africa, I appreciated this story so very much. It makes one truly refect upon "riches" ... how can we have so much, and feel so little?
great story i'm just thinking we are going to be like this in the u.s. if obama gets in office !
You know it pains me to see that there are those that would take a beautiful story and break it down so that it is negative.  Come on we are all facing hard times these days and I for one really need to hear "Good, Happy news once in a while.  TV and the news paper sure wont give it to us.
We NEED more stories like this.  Sure people are hurting and dying but inspite of it all they still find time to laugh and love one other...
I wonder, What's it going to take to bring us to this place where we can love, laugh , and trust eachother again?
This is the media perspective that we never get to see. I applaud you and your positive point of view. This was exceptionally refreshing.  
I was in the Navy in 1961 and traveled to many Carribean Islands and Many countries in Africa.I saw this poverty and kindness for each other everywhere I went. I spent or gave away most of my money and was so rewarded with tears and thank you's I found myself tearing up too. One dollar can still feed a family in many parts of the world.
It is so nice to know that there are still places in the world that judge people by their character, and not their bank accounts. The story was beautiful and makes you have greater hope in mankind. A pleasure to read, thank you.
Thank you Mr. Fletcher for a very nice story.
AWESOME STORY, AND GREAT NARRATIVE. MAKES YOU THINK ABOUT HOW TRULLY LUCKY WE ARE.
Very, very refreshing.
I think many peopole take too much for granted.
We should also just slow down & enjoy the journey.
Thanks for the story....took a few mins of stress from my day to realize I have it a little easier than others!  

And for you  The Real Deal....  take a pill and chill, it was not directed at you...just relax and thank your God you have it easier than the folks in the story do....
Would you dare compare these people to our people in the United States who by comparison are "whiners" or does that make a certain person's recent statement too credible?  I suppose this blog won't get posted either.
It's not about getting what you want but wanting what you've got.
"...Give us this day our daily bread..." This article really put that line in perspective. If only we could really appreciate what we have in the moment we have it and realize that we are all so rich even when we are poor. I'm sure these people in your story have their own worries and concerns, but choose not to dwell on them and do the best they can with what they can. We should all try that.
This story is very meaningful...it should teach us all a lesson of simplicity.
To: the real deal
Life got you down?  Seems to me, because you don't think you could be happy in another person's position / situation that they must not be either. The quote "It's not really that big a deal for poor people to be happy." seems very condescending to me.  By that I also get the impression you are not a happy person.  Life means suffering.  How do you react to it.
A wonderful story, so peaceful, so rural, so stupid. Everyone who likes it - is welcome to move there. Everyone who lives there, in this mutually supportive, fun, stress free environment for one reason or another tries to flee it, and come live here, in the civilized world.
So while this bucolic depiction is literary wonderful, don't go tearing into our way of life, we still help old ladies across the street, but we also WORK here, and build things. Like computer on which the author created the story, or the Internet, where it was posted. Let's see the author getting paid in Rhodesia, for admiring sweet little nothings half-way across the world, and then he might have the right to lament the downfall of the western culture.
what a great story, I am touch althought I came from Tunisia north africa it is a little different but you put a smile in my face and I do count my blessing.
I have no idea why everyone thinks this a beautiful story. You think these women live lives free of worry and care? What do you suppose it is like on the days when they don't bring home enough money to feed the family. How do you suppose their day's wages at that work suffice when it comes to clothing and educating their children.  Oh, we can all feel so superior while we pretend to admire the simpler lives of these people.  If you think it is so great, go over there and give away all your money, then start a peanut stand.  All your worries will be just washed away.
To: A bit of reality
I think reality is all a matter of point of view and life experiences.  Mine must be different than yours.  
I spent several years in a similar environment, and picture painted here is true.  Not the complete story, of course, (spending days or weeks in a place is not long enough to really understand it), but true nonetheless.  These people are well aware they have little, they would like to have more, they would especially love their children to have more than they have.  This is human nature.  What is often missing is the dissatisfaction we westerners would feel were we to find ourselves in similar circumstances.  They know exactly where they stand within the community, but their identity is not wholly tied to their economic status.  They also do not have our American worldview that each person has unlimited potential, so they do not share our subconscious sense of failure when we do not ‘live the American Dream’ and become ‘rich’.   Happiness is largely a function of having a small gap between reality and expectation.  Westerners are taught to have high expectations (ever see a TV add touting something as ‘good’ rather than ‘exhilarating’?), so even our high level of economic success does not satisfy us, we always want more.  Their hopes run high, but their expectations are closer to their reality, making happiness more common.  They view westerners with both envy (for what we have) and scorn (for how we behave), and we view them with the same emotion for the opposite reasons.  Our grass is greener; they laugh at the time, resources and energy we put into maintaining a stylized patch of ‘nature’ which only exists as an artifice we construct…
This is a great story. I do not say this about alot of them. I wish Americans could adopt some of there views on life. It would help deal with the stress issues we have. Just to stand back and relax while working and dealing with life.
First I thought "Oh, Please," but I read till end and I am glad I did.
Yes, I would be more concerned with the bird with the bent neck.  To show compassion for those things which cannot help themselves is a desired human asset, not a misplaced liability as the author suggests.  

And I agree somewhat with The Real Deal.  How easy it is to romantacize squalor, degradation, and poverty  through the pompous words of a reporter.      
This story forcefully brings home my wonderful memories for the Peace Corps in rural East Africa in the late 1960's.  the people are still, apparently, in many ways as their parents were.

Yet, it seems that all development prosepects and improvements, I infer, have passed them by.  truly sad.....
Now that's Everyday People! Everyday they live their lives with what they have and make the most of it. Everyday we need to treat each other with kindness and respect. Everyday we need to laugh out loud and with others. Everyday we...... We need to go back to that(Everyday People), all of us do! What a wonderful piece of writing. Thanks,
Having grown up in West Africa (Nigeria)as an expat, I appreciate this article. What is poverty, but us telling them you are poor because you don't have what we have. But yet they are content with what they have and we in the Western world, are never content with what we have.
It is very refreshing to read about people in other areas of the world. Their laughter, kindness and care toward others reminds me that that a persons character is not tied to economy or status.  The way you completed the transaction is to me a crowning touch for the story. You too showed real respect for the business person you were dealing with and in that I see the character of one who knows everyone is equally valuable in world society.
As a physician here in the U.S.A but of African origins, i have had my kids(Americans) ask me why i migrated here. Cos anytime they visit Africa, they played around so freely, chasing and feeding chickens, playing soccer on parched fields, I mean no proper ammenities, and can leave them most of the time without supervision,and without the fear of them being abducted or molested, in the midst of such poverty yet they are always happy.  Like Jesus said " a mans' life does not consist of the abundance of possessions he has". Often times our perspectives about riches are wrong. Even as i prepare to finally go back home and settle, i thank the writer for re-enforcing my convictions.
Why isn't this story in the headlines along with the always popular bad stuff?
What a great story.  Thank you for giving us the story of a life time in our time of need.  We always forget whats important to us, friends, family and our neighbors.  Thanks again for reminding us how to live our lives, care free and less stress.
Thank you.  I needed this.
That was a AWESOME story! Thank you for that insite! It really makes you wake up and be truly thankful for all that we have.
I am going to read this story to my 9 year old daughter when she returns from school.
God bless the orphan children and all the people of the world! You are ALL loved!
*****ONE LOVE*****


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1401237

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.