ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



Soap opera upends traditional Arab gender roles

Posted: Thursday, July 31, 2008 9:48 AM
Filed Under:


CAIRO, Egypt –  A relative newcomer to Arab TV, the Turkish soap opera "Noor" has helped narrow the gender gap between men and women across the Middle East.

Women see the lead female character – the independent, aspiring fashion designer Noor -- as a role model. Meantime, her husband on the show -- the blue-eyed former model and athlete Mohannad -- has become the region’s first pin-up boy.

The nightly soap opera has mainly female viewers glued to their TV sets not only because Mohannad is a cuter version of Justin Timberlake, but because he offers something many lack in their lives: romance, tenderness and a supportive partner to his independent wife. Mohannad has become the standard against which many Arab men are being judged, much to their chagrin. 

Image: A family watches the Turkish soap opera "Noor"
Susan Baaghil / Reuters
A family watches the Turkish soap opera "Noor" in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, on Saturday. 

Too much to live up to
According to Arab newspapers, marriages in Jordan, Syria and Saudi Arabia have dissolved because wives insisted on putting Mohannad's picture on their mobile phone display, or on their bedroom wall. In Bahrain, a woman allegedly begged her husband to have plastic surgery to look like the actor. Another recent divorcee allegedly told her husband "I want to sleep with Mohannad one night and then die." 

In Saudi Arabia, where about one in seven people tunes in each night, men circulated the rumor that Kivanc Tatlitug, the actor who plays Mohannad, is gay, which left female viewers distraught until the rumor was dispelled. 

Saudi society abounds with Mohannad jokes such as this one: A Saudi woman was touring Turkey with her husband and son when her husband went missing. As she described him to the police, her son shouted, "But that's not what Daddy looks like." "Be quiet," she whispers, "They might just give me Mohannad."

Image: Palestinian women walk past T-shirts
Muhammed Muheisen / AP
Palestinian women walk past T-shirts with pictures showing the lead characters of Turkish TV soap opera "Noor,"  in the West Bank city of Ramallah, on Sunday, July 20.

"Mohannad" and "Noor" are now the hottest babies' names in Saudi – even though the religious establishment has condemned the show. A top Saudi cleric forbade viewers from watching the "malicious" soap operas that "corrupt and spread vice" and has also declared that any TV station airing them is against God. This has put Saudi-owned Middle East Broadcasting Company (MBC), which airs the show three times a day, at loggerheads with Saudi religious leaders.

Saudi clerics may have an uphill battle: The Turkish serial has so wooed Saudis with its scenic backdrops of the Bosporus, and green, clean vistas of Istanbul that Turkish tourism officials say it has caused Saudi tourism to the country to more than double. 

The series has not only made Saudi women aware of the failings of their partners, but the advantages engendered by a more liberal, tolerant Islamic society such as Turkey. 

"It is eye opening for Saudi women. They haven't seen such a sensitive, passionate, giving personality," explained Dr. Fawzaya Abu Khalid, a writer and women's activist based in Riyadh.

For many women, the show has opened a whole new world and a lot of men aren’t happy about it. "Men feel threatened. It is the first time women have a role model for male beauty and passion and can compare him with their husbands," said Abu Khalid. "It is the first time they found out their husbands are not nice, that they are not being treated the way they should be, and that there is an option outside." 

Glued to TV across the region
Filled with scheming relatives, corny romantic scenes, melodramatic acting and amateurish effects, the sequence bombed in its native Turkey, but found new life among Arab women of all ages from Riyadh to the West Bank, when MBC began airing a dubbed Arabic version four months ago.

Reem, a young Saudi businesswoman who prefers to use her first name only, was introduced to the show by her nieces, ages seven and eight. Reem explained the show’s allure. "Romance is not here, living in a dry desert. Saudi women are missing something in their lives, in the treatment in the family, the wife with her husband and the husband with his wife. What I see from my female customers is that they are attracted by the love and romance and the way the man is treating the woman." 

And in east Jerusalem, every night at 10 p.m., the streets are suddenly empty – everyone is glued to the TV watching "Noor" there, too.

Bakiza, the matriarch of a large household in Jerusalem’s Old City, surrounds herself every night with her children, grandchildren, nieces, and nephews. They each take something different from the show. "I admire the story of Mohannad and Noor because of what it shows about how a family should be," said Bakiza. "The grandfather, Fikhry, is the one who takes care of the whole family, decides everything, and solves all the problems. Everyone respects him."

Malouk, a 15-year-old niece of Bakiza, has her own reason for watching the show. "I can only watch it because of Mohannad. He is handsome, romantic, and takes care of his wife. In fact, he is better than his wife."

The popularity of the series goes beyond the family room. It is also a business success story in the local communities. Restaurants, coffee shops, and clothing stores, proudly display posters of the couple in their windows to attract business. In Ramallah, nargila cafes (where water pipes are smoked), have their TV sets tuned for the channel of the series, to keep the customers there.

Even small children are onto the show and are making purchases based on the series’ merchandising. Haitham al-Halak, 45, a grocer in the Old City, says, "I was surprised how children from 6 to 15 years old, are buying from me only the potato chips with their pictures on it!"  said Haitham al-Halak, 45, a grocer in the Jerusalem’s Old City.

A positive role model for women
To some young women, the aspiring fashion designer Noor, provides a positive female role model and encourages them to raise the bar not only on future spouses but on themselves. 

In Cairo, Na'ama Hegazy, a single 25-year-old, watches "Noor" three times a day and says it has influenced the way she sees her future.  

"I want a romantic [man] who treats me like how Mohannad treats his wife. Every day he brings her flowers and tells her romantic words," said Hegazy. "The life will be very good when a husband treats his wife [like that]."

But Hegazy also wants to emulate Noor who is a both a good wife and mother, and a self-reliant professional. "When she has troubles with Mohannad, she wants to him to leave her alone. She wants to work and doesn't want anything from him. This means any woman who falls out with her husband can work and depend on herself."     

NBC News’ Lawahez Jabari contributed to this report from Jerusalem.

 

 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

life is never that simple. I respect other countries and their ways, not all their ways are good, but not all thier ways are bad. We all have to respect God first and then respect each other.  Then and only then will we be a world of peace.  Romance is fine, but you can not have it 24 hours a day.  Love you can have 24 hours a day seven days a week and 12 months a year and 356 days a year, but it takes work and understanding and respect for each other.
Isn't it strange that when people see a happy, liberal relationship on TV, they want to have that kind of freedom for themselves?  You know, this bascily proves what I have felt for years.  

The very best way to improve the world is by exporting ideas, especially the culture of liberal freedom found here in America.  Not shutting down trade borders or sancitioning a country, but by showing the people an alternative way to live and allowing them to demand change themselves.  

Now Turkey has finally done what America should have done years ago, and given the Arab world a story that shows the kind of freedoms usually unacceptable in Mideast society but is firmly rooted in that society.  Good for them.
Looks like this soap opera might be more effective than President Bush's bombs in making changes. If the women band together, good luck to all the men.
ridiculous, what they are looking at is not "islamic turkey" but some sort of secularized, westernized jarbled mess. No surprise the media is at the forefront of subversive and perverse ideas. As always.
This soap opera is starting to inspire women in Saudi Arabia and the arab world but how long will it take for women to get equal rights in Saudi Arabia? Saudi women face severe discrimination in many aspects of their lives, including education, employment, and the justice system and are clearly regarded as inferior to men. Saudi women are treated like crap and I hope this soap opera will change things for the better. I hope this show encourges Saudi women to stand up for their rights.
I think "Noor" will have a positive impact on the young girls. It will show them(and probably already does) that they can be their own person and don't have to be dependant on someone else to have a "life".
As a Palestinian-American, I have to admit that I too notice differences in how most (not all) men treat their wives depending on where they were born. The Arab culture, which was advanced light years by Islamic practices towards women regressed in a colossus way over the past 300 years or so as society brought back the pagan Arab man and dressed him up as a symbol of what an Islamic husband should act like. Nothing could be further from the truth. The irony as I see it is that it's in the West, and not the campuses of Al Azhar University or Mecca that Arab/Muslim men are re-discovering the treasure that is the Muslim woman (and how to treat her). Helping around the house, baby-sitting while my wife takes night classes, and even changing my children’s' diapers flabbergast my father-in-law much less anyone else. Yet he sees his daughter's happiness (I hope), academic and professional success and our children’s' beaming smiles and laments the 'generation that lost Palestine' as he puts it. We should keep the trend going and Islam should be the guiding light. The West has nothing to fear and much to gain.
If you look for someone who fits Mohannad's profile you will stay single your whole life.  What's is more important, flowers or love, protection, and family?
Although this program is produced in Turkey, I doubt it reflects married life there. I am married to a Turkish man and there are no flowers or romance. Too bad it doesn't play there any more. I would make my husband watch it on his Turkish satellite tv. Maybe he could learn something too!
Even if it's a corny soap opera, it's nice to see something opening up the eyes of middle eastern women.  As long as they are under the iron fist of men in the name of religion, they are not free.
I majored in anthropology as an undergrad and was amused to realize that one of the things nearly every human society has in common is soap operas. Everybody loves them!
Listen up Saudi women. I think the key here is Saudis have several wives and Noor is an only wife. When you are one of many you lose some serious clout.

I don't typically comment on articles, but this one really grabbed my attention.  Soap Opera or not, I think it's wonderful that Arab women are being shown a different side to what life could and should be.  In the States, Soaps are made fun of and disaparaged and no one ever watches them (when, in fact, we all do), but that's also because it is an exaggerated way of life most of us, as women, already know and understand.  So to us, it's silly.  I'm glad that Saudi women are inspired by the main characters and, as a result, want more from not only their husbands, but themselves.  I hope the show continues, despite religious clerics opposition.
This show may be the best thing that could ever happen to the West. Finally, this may be the thing to take Muslims out of the 10th century.
Turks are not Arabs.

Perhaps a better title would be: "Soap Opera Upends Traditional Muslim Gender Roles."
"Hegazy also wants to emulate Noor who is a both a good wife and mother, and a self-reliant professional. "When she has troubles with Mohannad, she wants to him to leave her alone. She wants to work and doesn't want anything from him. This means any woman who falls out with her husband can work and depend on herself." "

Oh God, Allah or whoever, please let this catch on with the muslim herd.  This idea has at least made the christian herd more tolerable...
I do not appreciate the generalizations about Arab relationships in this article.  There are plenty of Arabs I know who live in the Middle East and have very loving relationships. As a matter of fact, I recently visited and was touched by the kindness the men in my family showed to their wives.

True, there are those without that loving relationship but who are we kidding? Aren't soap operas the same thing to American women that this article tries to point to Noor as being for Arab women? This is an old story; the article tries to point to poor misteated Arab women with their mean husbands. The same could be said for any group anywhere. There are good and there are bad in any group.

Looking forward to the days when these generalizations about the Middle East are no longer popular...(I know, I shouldn't hold my breath)
My inlaws are from Jordan and I have seen thsi show here in the states.  Granted, I have NO IDEA what they are saying, but, there isn't a whole lot of dialogue.  It seems really sappy.  But, arab men do rule the house...It will be interesting to see if the next generation changes
about time. the true backbone of a country are there women!we as a country should send them help. make more soap opera, instead of bombs and bullet's
It is too bad that there isn't some promotion of protecting their children and keeping them from becoming bombers that kill civilians.  
I'm glad that the series is giving Saudi women an idea of what a relationship could be. No one deserves to be treated poorly and taken for granted. Still, I wonder whether the show is merely setting these women up for another kind of disappointment.  

"I want a romantic [man] who treats me like how Mohannad treats his wife. Every day he brings her flowers and tells her romantic words," said Hegazy.

Unfortunately, that is an unrealistic standard for many men, even in western societies where male sensitivity is encouraged.
This is blasphemy, so sayeth the lord, viz. 1 Timothy 2:12
"I do not permit a woman to teach or to have authority over a man; she must be silent."
YESSS!!!!  at last, the Arabic equivalent for Ozzie and Harriet, I love Lucy, Leave it to Beaver  --we can use the same tools of soaps and implied decadence  to change their world!  Now, if we could go from the 50's to 2008
I just got back from Ramllah & yes!!! everything in this article is on target...nice reporting Charlene!
What a wonderful idea to use T.V. as a means to show and teach respect for one another. If the roll model for Arab women is an arranged marriage with a husband who is allowed to beat her and ignor her feelings, I can't think of anything better that this to show them a different kind of life. Just wait till they have a show with an Arab husband and wife spending time with a marraige counselor. Talking about feelings together and sharing new ideas on family living in the real world.
Here is a chance to see how TV program in a form of a story can have good influence on society. I remember few myself, growing up in 60's in  a Eastern European country. I bet our daily soaps from over here would not pass in that society. I wish they didn't pass here either, they have become filled with trash.  But cheers to those women over there, they need to stand up and show the men that they're not almighty, and need to shape up or else!  
That's it!!!  The way to defeat radical Islam:  Muslim soap operas!  Who'd a thunk it?
Media vs Religion?  That's certain not something that goes on in America.  Wait, yes it does.  I think it would be interesting if this show got shown in America or other countries outside of the middle east.  
I am glad that Turkey is supplying the "role" models for the Saudi women. They do need to break out of the shell that they have been cast in. The U.S. cannot supply that. "Sex in The City" (sp) certainly cannot.
This article talks about traditional Arab gender roles, but "Noor" is a Turkish show and Turks are not Arabs.
They are Turks.
On a related note, a lot of Americans  think that Iranians are Arabs, but they are not. Iranians are of Persian ethnicity.
Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him) is the best example of how Muslim men should be to their wives. If the women are really going this crazy over a character that is really sad. Where are you Muslim men?!? You need to be more like Prophet Muhammad so that there is happiness in marriages!
That's a pretty far fetched ascertion to claim that these women are so deprived of loving male/female relationships that they are attracted to the show like a moth to a flame.  Does that mean American women aspire to be like the women on Desperate Housewives?  C'mon people... This article is another shining example of how Western thought believes that there way of living is supreme.  Most women want more romance and intimacy in their marriages.  Your assumptiosn in this article are short-sighted at best.
that's half the reason the arabs hate us, we export our culture in such a way that it "pollutes" their culture with our values. if we left them alone, they'd have a lot less interest in retaliating
Who would have thought that a soap could do more to change the Arab world than war and occupation? LOL Good for them!
No offence, but how silly!

For decades, since the late-50's actually, there have been countless Arab tv and movie dramas and comedies that have shown working and professional women.

Also this attempt to transfer Western sentiments and reactions onto Arab men and women is ridiculous as well as bigotted. Every society has its own way of seeing the world, not everyone behaves like afternoon sopa opera-watching American women, and , beer-guzzling wife-negletting American men.

This is a non-issue and a waste of internet space.
As an American woman married to an Arab man (Libyan) I am amazed by this! Long time coming... Now if only all men treated the Arab women they marry this rommantically! Luckily mine was raised in the US. So I have the strength of an Arab man who understands the functionality of romance in a marriage!
If this show is of benefit to any individual and helps any individual to be happier as a result of the show - then I applaud the show. I wish the producers much success.  
This may be the way to implement change in a region that desparately needs changed.   There is nothing wrong with a healthy, loving, family with independant characters.   It is a shame that many hide behind God's cloak and attack anything worthwhile -- blaming others for their own shortcomings.
Article needed more info on how Arab men are currently treating their women.
Get a life people, are you all saying  Arab women do not have romantic life, beside cooking and cleaning. By the way everything you see in that little scene is not all true, please have some sense of yourselves and get back to business. Educate your selves and do not listen what the outsideworld tells you...will I'm woman myself,
Wow!  Mohanned and Noor's effect on Arab sociey reminds me of how we in the U.S. and Western Europe were affected in the early days of movies and television.  I can see a parallel in Rudolph Valentino's influence on how women started idealizing men and even how shows like The Mary Tyler Moore Show empowered women.  I think social historians needs to watch this new phenomenon CLOSELY.
Approaching women in their own cultures and emulating portrayals alike their own lives is the way to set them free.  We keep harping on western freedom and equality to no avail. They can relate to this soapy.  That is great.    
I was struck by the part about the kids and the packages of potato chips. People who preach repression and hatred can never win against a revolution that is carried by kids on potato chip bags!

This may be the most important story to come out of the Middle East of the day,week,month,year. If the women on the east and west banks are watching the same show and identify with it, the foundations of a real peace are being laid. "The ties that bind us are stronger than that which holds us apart."

If there is something people want, capitalism by it's nature tries to deliver it. It can be "whiter whites", "less underarm odour" or "a better life", if there is a market, capitalism delivers.

And it doesn't cost the taxpayers a penny...

wonderful.  Good, moral, positive.  Why not.  Everyone should be nicer, kinder and more giving.  Good for Turkey!@
Article needed more info on how Arab men are currently treating their women. I am deplored by the media's lack of objective research.  Why have a college degree in journalism or communication if you are not free to report and research the entire story.
The power of STORY!
What awesome power!  The popular media is a truly potent catalyst for change, isn't it?  

Can you imagine making a television show that fails miserably at home but somehow becomes not only successful abroad, but influencial in a way that sparks change in the very core of a society?  What could be more cherished and important to Arab society than their traditions of marriage and what is expected from a husband and a wife?

No question about it...  if you want to influence people, there is nothing more powerful than a soap opera or a sitcom!  "Noor" might be changing Arab society in ways that legions of western politicians and generals can only dream of.  

It seems that one crappy soap opera might be more potent than a million tons of military hardware and all the grand strategy our leaders could ever dream up.

It's all so obvious now...  all Washington needs to do is fund some second rate soap operas and stop bombing the hell out of people.  Then, maybe the world would be a nicer place all the way around.

For what it's worth, media-inspired change is often positive, as in this example, but not always.  Gangster rap stands out as a glaring example of one the more negative influnces media has had.  I'm sure there are many more, too.

I guess you have to take the bad with the good.
I am an Arabic girl living in the US. And I am watching this soap opera.
In my point of view, the real life is so much different than the life that Mohannad and Noor are living.
Mohannad owns a company, he has a lot of money, which means he doesn't have a lot of things to think about like bringing money to the house, or is he going to be able to pay his bills at the end of the month. While most men in the Middle East are so busy trying to find jobs and provide comfortable lives for their families. For this reason they are so busy to think of romance because all what they think is giving their wives the money that they are asking for.
At the end we need to realize that this is TV not real life. We can't let TV destroy our families because the actor is handsome and romantic
I am a lebanese American and I watch Nour almost
daily with my wife and the rest of the family. This
show has no influence whatsoever on the Lebanese society because we have a more advanced lifestyle than the turks that are realy going out of their way to show how civilized and forward looking they are and that is why this show failed in Turkey. We consider this show to be a tourism advertisement and amusing in the same time. In Lebanon we have more serious and Arabic speaking (not dubbed) series that are empowering to women and they don't have the same influence on the arab world because the Arabs consider Lebanese to be Christian or with mainly Christian ideas versus the Turks who are purely Moslem and who massacared every remaining Christian in Turkey (for example the Armenians in first worl war). I would like to mention that the magnificient mosque shown in this serie was an Orthodox Christian Church "Saint Sophia" built buy the Roman Emperror Justinian in the fifth century. And Istanbul is Constantinople the Capital of the Christian Byazantine Empire till the 15th century when the Turks overran it. The wisdom from this is that the Arabs consider themselfs Moslems first and foremost they are more influenced by the Behavior of Non-Arab Moslems than by Non-Moslem Arabs.
"What I see from my female customers is that they are attracted by the love and romance and the way the man is treating the woman."  

-- It makes one wonder about the conditions over there and how badly men are treating women that the women seek to find some kind of emotional gratification from a fictional character.  It's about time their eyes are open to better possibilites, and if it comes in a vehicle of a soap opera, more power to them.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1236952

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.