ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



G-8 goes green, sort of

Posted: Monday, July 07, 2008 10:53 AM
Filed Under:

TOYAKO, Japan – With climate change high on the agenda, the Japanese hosts of the G-8 summit have worked hard to make the event as green as possible. The temporary, low-emissions press center was built with recycled and reusable material and has many green features: solar panels to generate power, louvers to limit radiant heat and skylights to maximize natural light.

Even the air conditioning is environmentally-friendly: the press center is being cooled by 7,700 tons of snow collected from a nearby ski resort and held in an insulated storehouse in the building’s basement. The runoff from the melting snow is even used to flush the toilets and journalists can walk over glass panels to see the snow below.

Image: photographer takes photographs of snow used in a natural air-conditioning system
AFP - Getty Images
A photographer takes pictures of snow used in a natural air-conditioning system, through transparent floor panels at the G8 Summit media center in Rusutsu, Japan on July 6.  

But as inhabitants of an island nation slightly smaller than California, but with more than three times as many people as the Golden State, few natural resources and little room to put waste, the Japanese have long been concerned about conservation and recycling.

VIDEO: Bush attends his final G-8 summit

Did housekeeping get the memo?
The representatives of the U.S. television networks covering President Bush at the summit found one wall of their workspace in a Japanese hotel lined with six recycling bins: one each for "combustibles," "incombustibles" and "plastics" and three different "recyclable waste" containers for "newspapers/magazines," "mixed paper" and "bottles/P.E.T. caps/cans."

Feeling virtuous, reporters, producers and technicians have stood over the bins, waste in hand, puzzling over the options. Does a plastic water bottle go in "plastics" or "bottles"? What's "combustible" and what's "incombustible"? Where does leftover food go? A rubber band? A candy wrapper?

So when a hotel cleaning woman came in to empty the bins, she was watched carefully. Interest turned to bemusement as she took the contents of the six bins and mixed them together in a single, large plastic garbage bag.

Shortly after she left, one person who had witnessed the exercise walked over and, with great deliberation, put an aluminum can in the bin marked "plastics."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

...and the bag probably went to the landfill!  This brings up the important point about recycling; infrastructure.  Without all of the supporting people, processes and education, it will fail.
Our local supermarket gathered up shopping bags that were brought back for recycling. One of my kids went to work there and found out that they carry them to the back and toss them into the trash compactor. When it was pointed out to management, my child was fired. I now go out of my way to share the STAR market recycling program when I can.
Talk about trivial as our political leaders again fail to deal with the destabilisation of our planet climate the reality of inefficient recycling system it not high on G8 agenda. The use of recycled snow might be usefull though. What about the big picture
The G8 has grown disfunctional with India and China being left out of the event. Why? who is served by this limited level of consultation?
Well, the author of this article brings us a point, sarcastically though, about "window dressing"!

My suggestion is that we (in the Western Countries) have surged ahead with better implementations of waste management/recycling and ought to bring the "EDUCATION" to the next level.

THe world needs that education and the time is now!
Classic... American restaraunts are great for that, as well. If it doesn't actually say it's being recycled, then you can bet the company's policy is to throw it straight in the trash.
In the Philippines the situation was the same, you may want to segregate in schools and homes and elsewhere but when the trash guy comes to pick it up it all gets thrown into then same bin.  However, nowadays we tend to advocate on-the-spot recycling, like left over food goes straight to the compost at the backyard garden or a nearby space of land, junk shops and the like collect plastics/scrap metal at the source (at home/school/office/mall/restaurant/etc) since it's also a livelihood for them, thus when the trash man comes less is picked up for delivery to the landfills.  The best tactic is to simplify the recycling process so that it takes less time and brain, is convenient and practical.
In Japan they have people at the recycling plants and waste disposal facilities to manually seperate trash in to the categories. When you live in Japan asI do now they wont even take trash bags with the wrong things in them. Since that hotel was set up for foreigners they probably figured, and rightly so, that the trash would not be properly seperated. If people cannot tell whats combustable I.E. food, paper, wood and whats not, metal plastic, bottles, pots and pans, then how can they sit there and be smug about saving "mothe earth."
snow stored in the basement? hummmm. wouldn't it be better to store it higher up as cold air sinks, natural convection as it were. oh g, to heavy. I wonder what the skiers think about their snow being taken for cooling purposes. kinda right up there with corn for biofuels. cows and people need the corn, not autos. where is the common sense these days?
I'm wondering how much it cost in gas to move all that snow and what happens to the water supply, natural life, trees, etc that need the water from all that snow.
I was impressed about the snow for air conditioning- but I'm sure it was expensive & used fuel to be transported. We do, however, need this kind of thinking: Use what's already there, build systems that are stationary or use small amounts of energy to build & run.  re: the recycling- we can do more here, & buying recycled end products will help fund the effort.  The summit was a temporary situation & probably hadn't been set up for long- hence the maid's actions.  It's a big example tho.  We need to personally be responsible & speak up when we do see waste & recyclables headed for landfills.  I was raised to conserve, reuse, not litter, & treat the earth with respect (in the 50's). It was always right, and now more than ever, it's vital!  
Standard protocol for cleaning/maintenance people in Japan (hotels, offices, schools) is to separate the trash once collected.  I suggest the author to follow the trash trail to provide a more accurate picture...or perhaps that's just something the author really doesn't care to see.
How much non-green energy used to transport the 7,700 tons of snow ?
More information is needed in this article.  There are sophisticated, leading-edge recycling technologies “out there” and, knowing the ingenuity of the Japanese culture, it’s seems highly unlikely that the country does not have at least what is available in Oregon.  We lived in Oregon a couple of years ago and were amazed at the ease of recycling.  

All plastics (except bags) numbers 1 thru 7, caps (usually not recyclable), aluminum cans, and tin cans are mixed together.  Machines handle most of the separating and the balance is done by hand rapidly because there’s not much left to sort.

Caps end up in the garbage.  Someday, someone will invent caps that are recyclable and manufacturers will stop buying cross-linked materials (not quite as bad as nuclear waste, but close).

Plastic bags (evil things!) have a separate bin and are handled by a different system.

All paper is mixed.

Cardboard, recycled differently because it’s corrugated, has separate bins.

Glass, no matter the color, was mixed.

Oregon has the simplest system I’ve heard or read about thus far and handled by far the most types of recyclables.  It's the simplicity that makes the program work so well.  The State also has a recycling program for computers and peripherals.

It’s a mystery that should be researched as to why this recycling set-up at the G8 was used if Japan does indeed have the most modern of recycling equipment.  
The report is disheartening to say the least. We depend on a system to do away with the trash we make.  In the end, we need to change the way we view our consumption habits from a priority of convenience to one of conservation. We need to learn to decrease the amount of trash we produce... Bring a hot/cold thermos where ever you go, refill at home or office (no plastic bottle trash). Don't buy single serving size foods, that just takes a little planning (less plastic trash to throw out). Bring your own eco-bag no matter what kind of shopping you're doing (less bags to throw away). Start a compost (less food trash). for starters.
Bob mentioned that plastic bottle caps are not recycleable and he is right.  However, Aveda has started a new program and will take your plastic bottle caps and recycle them into new bottle caps.  I have a small bin at work to collect these and take them to my local Aveda store.
Sounds utterly ridiculous to me,if oil is in short supply why is virtually everything made from oil.i.e plastic bottles synthetic fibers,pharmacueticals,and the list goes on,they waste more on these scams,sending people chasing blindly than we could if all countries were held accountable for pollutants,real pollutants not carbon dioxide which plants use for photosynthesis,this so-called greening scam is nothing more than smoke and mirrors by politicians and bankers.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1184538

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.