ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



Life returns to Iraq’s ‘ghost town’ suburb

Posted: Wednesday, June 11, 2008 7:43 AM
Filed Under:


Dora, in Saddam’s time, had it all – a power station and oil refinery provided jobs and its large bungalows hidden in date palm groves drew rich, powerful Sunnis and their families to this southern suburb of Baghdad.

 But Dora fell on hard times at the start of the war in 2003.

When I visited Dora about 18 months ago, it was with the U.S. 1st Cavalry Division, before the surge of U.S. and Iraqi forces into Baghdad began. The once bustling "gateway to the South" was a ghost town. It smelled of cordite, an explosive powder.

NBC Nightly News video: A turning point in Iraq?

Sunni residents were in hiding; Dora’s Shiites were dead or had fled to other provinces; its many Christians – doctors, architects and other professionals – had also fled to escape the sectarian killing. The insurgent town had become an al-Qaida stronghold. But that wasn’t the only threat: Shiite death squads, masquerading as National Police, had murdered and maimed so many Sunnis that the 1st Cavalry had to force the police out of their precinct and cordon off the area. 

It was a very different Dora that I saw this past week, once again embedded with U.S. forces – this time with the 4th Infantry Division. Life had returned. Dora’s famous Friday open market was bubbling with people, produce and color. No one looked afraid.

Working together
U.S. troops, who now live in an outpost right in the middle of town, were not the only force patrolling the streets. So were the infamous, primarily Shiite, National Police, as well as the so-called "Sons of Iraq" – local volunteers, all Sunni, who were mostly former insurgents. It was something quite remarkable I was seeing for the first time: U.S., Shiite and Sunni armed forces cooperating for the general good.

Sunni residents, who wouldn’t have dared to be seen talking to members of the National Police a year ago, were now complaining to them about rising food and fuel prices in the market or asking for advice.

"Before we all suffered from a triple threat – al-Qaida, the militias, and sectarian kidnappings," said Alladin Hussein, a former major in Saddam’s Army, who I met in the market. "Now we are living in stability and security. It’s like a precious gem, something very fragile that you have to take care of."

Image: Christians in Dora, Iraq
AP
Iraqi men walk in a church behind a cross in Dora, Iraq, on June 2. About eighteen Christian families have returned to their homes in the neighborhood now that security has improved. 

Lt. Justin Chalvko could be called "Mr. Dora" as far as Iraqis here are concerned. He is the face of the U.S. presence in the area – he lives in the local U.S. Army outpost and leads daily patrols through the market with his platoon. He knows many residents by their first names, and jokes with them in his broken Arabic.

Chalvko said the changes in Dora since his arrival six months ago are "like night and day." But he’s no fool.

"Even though it’s good now," he warned, "it’s only been good for four or five months. People are starting to move back into the area, but it’s like everyone’s walking on eggshells still. They want to make sure that it’s for real, it’s not just something temporary."

Sure, the hundreds, perhaps thousands, of 12-foot high, 10-ton blast walls that now surround – and isolate – Dora help keep al-Qaida at bay. But local Dorans don’t seem to care. In fact, most Iraqis I asked about the blast walls said that they actually felt freer these days with the concrete barriers and joint patrols to protect them.

Chalvko walked us past Dora’s reopened parks and replanted gardens, past its new library, its primary care clinic, and high school.

Bank open for biz
He explained that, at first, people just wanted security. Now they want services. He then led us to one service that had just opened last week – the Dora branch of the Rafidain Bank. A bank! I hadn’t been inside a functioning Iraqi bank in years. The last Rafidain Bank branch I was this close to was burning out of control on Baghdad’s Haifa Street during those chaotic days just after the fall of Saddam.

We went inside. There were a dozen or more customers, one in a wheelchair, counting small piles of Iraqi dinars they had just withdrawn or were about to deposit. Tellers, mostly women in head scarves, were busy filling out bank slips and attaching paper clips to deposits. The manager, all the while, was pacing back and forth, smiling nervously, from his office to the tellers and back. I guess that being a bank manager in Dora is not the safest of jobs, no matter how many troops or blast walls surrounded you.

But, it struck me that the very presence of a bank was a symbol of change. Dorans could now avoid traveling through interminable checkpoints, across Baghdad, risking their lives to deposit or withdraw money for loans on houses or cars or new businesses. They could do all their business right here, in their own neighborhood.

"Instead of looking to the Americans to help them out," said Chalvko, "they can come here. It’s a sign that things are going in the right direction."

How many Doras are there?
Covering the war in Iraq is often about analyzing the trend lines. We’re all looking for the elusive "turning point" – that gauge that ultimately allows us to measure victory or defeat.

One of my Nightly News editors in New York, Robert Dembo, summed it up nicely, "I guess the real question now is: How many Doras are out there?" And I’ve got my own new question: "I wonder just how long Rafidain Bank will stay open?"

We shall see.

Jim Maceda is an NBC News Correspondent based in London. He has reported on the war in Iraq since the U.S. invasion in 2003 and is currently on assignment in Baghdad.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments


Working out of the Green Zone as a Contractor and having been too Dora several times (was there 3 days ago), yes, things are slightly better, tentatively, everything is dependent on security provided by US troops.

Abit taken back with and scratching my head over Mr Maceda comment "Keeping Al-Qaida at bay", if he kept track with figures trickling out of the Green Zone, you would know that less than 3 percent of all violent activity is attributed to Al-Qaida, the remainder is civil disputes into what has become a on going power struggle over which sect, clan or leader will control the real prize, and that is Iraq's huge Oil reserves in Kirkuk and Basrah.

Unbelieveable the huge amount of citizens, who are totally dependent on our security presence. What will happen to these people if our troops pull out?

We brought all this misery to the Iraqis, by invading their country (for what many feel were false reasons), we owe it to them to stay in there at least another 20 years until they can get back on their feet.
is it just me or does this story have a negative tone. even though they subject matter is positive , it seems like the reporter went out of their way to put a pessimistic  spin on things. but anyhow good to be hearing good things about Iraq. keep up the good job over their guys, god bless you and be safe.
I wonder what Nancy Pelosi, Harry Reid and yes, the beloved Barack Obama have to say about this story.  On MSNBC's website no less.  

Watch 'em bob and weave.
That's a good question and here's another: Why do Americans have to pay, in both blood and treasure, to police and rebuild their neighborhoods?
Isn't it nice we are patrolling the neighborhoods of Iraq while our Mexican border is wide open to invaders of all kinds year after year and our inner cities have five,six seven drive by shootings every day with no cops or troops to prevent the slaughter.
It's nice that we dump suitcases full of money on Iraqi chieftans and mini  potentates to "calm them" and build blast proof walls to "protect them"
It is good to be kings of another country while they charge us $140 per barrel for oil.
We and our troops are dupes.
Isn't it nice we are patrolling the neighborhoods of Iraq while our Mexican border is wide open to invaders of all kinds year after year and our inner cities have five,six seven drive by shootings every day with no cops or troops to prevent the slaughter.
It's nice that we dump suitcases full of money on Iraqi chieftans and mini  potentates to "calm them" and build blast proof walls to "protect them"
It is good to be kings of another country while they charge us $140 per barrel for oil.
We and our troops are dupes.
Wow, a positive story regarding the war in Iraq! I didn't think American news outlets were allowed to publish positive stories. Whats next, might we be able to win this war?    
These kind of stories are encouraging and I hope to see more of them as security improves.  However, I have to chuckle whenever I see these positive stories and notice the absence of liberals and their comments.  I'm still waiting to see a post condeming the Bush admin. and the "neocons", maybe its still too early...
Nice to hear a positive story as it seems the mainstream liberal press and the Democrats have suddenly forgotten their Iraq agenda of failing miserably and now take up the economy issue. The only reason we lost in Vietnam was lack of backbone to get the job done. Let's not forget this time around what became a ralleying cry for our enemies around the world (Vietnam) and stick it out as a democracy emerges that may lead to long term stability in the region. Most people are too short sighted in their day to day lives to see the impact of a free democracy in the Mideast.
Holy cr@p, positive news out of Iraq!  Will wonders never cease?!
not long i would guess. we don't want them to be to safe to fast or we have no present fake reason to be there. A rocket will sail over the wall in a few weeks and then periodically after that. Our top brass could let loose our troops, but they won't, not to fast anyway. Just like the current adminstration fooled us into the war, it will order the army politicians ( generals who's real mission is to keep control over red blooded american warriors so that they don't do the right thing all the way) which is all the officer corp is, they aren't necessary to actual combat and every grunt knows this. all the money all the time could have been used to erect a virtual fence of patrols and border walls But the repubs need insugency violence to make the cause to stay. If Iraquis wanted freedom they would have fought for it, but they didn't so they must have liked it. We like being puppets, controlled by corporations and Big "Sneeky" Govt. Govt. is the same as it's ever been, they want the money for themselves, while dem. big govt wants it for everyone. There's nothing more pitiful then a regular person who thinks because they register as a member of the republican party, that they are actually a member. Same goes for Dems. YOU DON"T COUNT!! not anymore, not like the Sons of Liberty did back in day, back in Boston.
Dear Mr. Maceda:

Reporters like we listen to them. You are bringing the truth to the Americans from the boiling  points of the world. I say to you keep safe and I thank you for your historic reporting.

For Lt. Justin Chalvko, the American army officer responsible at mid town Dora, I say to Lt. Justin, your work will never be forgettable to the Dorans people, you deserve to be called "Mr. Dorans" for all the good work and pationate heart you showed the people in that volatile area of Baghdad. Just couple of months ago no one can walk the streets. Keep continue the good work you are doing and enjoy your spare and relaxing time with the Iraqis, because once they know you are a man of dignity and peace, they will protect you with their lives. It is you and your friends that has changed the war picture in Iraq.  At the begining of 2003 the Iraqis thought that they had a good chance to change to the better in their lives after 40 years of dictatorship. But soon they recognized that the plan of invation had many weaknesses and cap points which resulted the divsion, the killing and the lack of security in the Iraqi community.  It is your work and the work of your friends is gardually changing this picture and winning the heart and mind of the Iraqis once again, and remember once they trust you, they will never want you to go away. Lt. Justin, you will see that some will cry when the time comes to say bye for you to come back home. Keep your self safe when you patrol the streets of Dora, because always there are bad boys. Keep your self in a high spirit and rememebr that your good work is not only serving your country but serving the entire world community and the peace process on earth.

I thank you and I salute you Lt. Justin Chalvko. I also thanks reporter Jim Maceda for his amazing reporting to bring the facts to the beautiful  American people.
It is a start,  Hope and pray to God they can hold it together and we can come home. Which, we should have never been there in the first place.
But as the old saying is Somewhere in Texas they are missing their village idiiot George Bush
it's good to hear a truthful story for once, it's good to hear about people going back in living in peace. it's good to read the truth about the hard work, our service people are doing and the friendships they are building, it's good to hear about different factions working together and living in relative harmony.  why can't we see more success stories ,about the good in people,like this, i'm sure there are many.
The very first line: "Dora, in Saddam’s time, had it all."  Yes, life in Iraq was sunshine and candy canes!  Everyone was happy - we should all have been priveleged to live under Saddam's golden rule!  This article is emblematic of today's media m.o. - everything in Iraq was great until the mean ol' Americans showed up, spin positives into negatives, give no credit to the president or our military - and if you have do, do it cautiously and grudgingly.  Heaven forbid you expose the real successes happening all over Iraq - that would blow the hate-Bush, hate-military, hate-America template out of the water!
What does "Winning the War" mean? Our president and many others are saying we are winning the war! What exacly does that mean? Who wins what?
Maceda just had to put a negative comment at the end of his otherwise extremely positive report. I wonder why there can't be more positive reports coming out of Iraq and why any positive report isn't getting covered on the nightly news.
Nice job Jim, right up to the end, that is.  Why can't a positive piece be positive throughout?  I think your quip at the end regarding the bank was not only unnecessary, but underlies the pessimism that is pervasive throughout the mainstream media.  I know death and destruction is more spectacular to report than happiness and prosperity, but anyone who has beaten the odds like the citizens of Dora should have their moment in the sun without speculating on their ultimate success or failure.
thank god for a positive press release. Now, if the McCain camp isnt smart enough to capitalize on this press, dont come crying to me when Obama, as the new prez, surrenders in the midst of these successes. Wake up John, you aint that charismatic!! and not you're going to ride in on your looks!!
mission accomplished! call the troops home.

the only way iraq will stand on its feet is when we give everyone a gun and last man standing rules the country. seems to be whats going on now. how many hundreds of thousands are dead? shock and awe, too bad its we americans who are now shocked by the waste and awed at the number of dead.  
Well I think that it is great that we here something good for once. I enjoy hearing about improvements both here in our own country and around the world. I have been getting sick of the librals only allowing the negative news to filter through so that they can fulfill there own political agendas.
"Now we are living in stability and security. It’s like a precious gem, something very fragile that you have to take care of." Tell Barack Obama, John Kerry, and every other soft democrat who whines about the US going to Iraq being unjustified to put that in their pipes and smoke it. While it is early, and Dora is not reflective of all of Iraq, this is very intriguing. And while we're on the subject tell the Iranian Ayatollah that the "presence of foreign occupiers" is clearly not the problem in Iraq, that clown. This is what we do here in America. We're not perfect, not even close, but we know a few things about personal freedoms, and no one in their right mind will argue that having them isn't a special thing. Now, if only ourselves as a country, can begin to act humanely towards one another and cut all the selfish BS out, there might be hope for the future of our kids. The economy is rough, costs of everything are going up, this is not a new occurence. What is scary though is when a man gets hit by a car (reference Hartford, Connecticut incident) and nobody makes a move to help him. I would have been in that street a quarter second after he got hit trying to do something, anything. Thats the level of citizenship and comraderie that we need to get back to as a country. Focus on the small things, the "hello's" and small acts of kindness - one at a time. Wake up American citizens, no one is going to do this for us, we must take action ourselves to create the type of environment that we want to live in. Now is a perfect time to start.
well by the looks of some of the above blogs , it seems to me that now all of a sudden conservatives think that georges revenge war is now a noble venture . they refuse to accept that they and most of us were dupped into this huge blunder by the current administration!
For all of you who are happy to see a good story out of Iraq and are so ready to jump up and say the President and his cronies in the administration were/are right and the Dems and Mr. Obama are wrong: is it that easy for you to ignore the FACT that the invasion was based on fault info, propaganda, and lies; the FACT that Saddem Hussein had no Al-Queda connections, no WMD, and no way to reach out and touch this country with any kind of terriost attack; the FACT that 4000 dead and tens of thousands of wounded American military have been wasted for NOTHING; the FACT that we as Americans are less safe in this world than before the invasion; the FACT that before the invasion gasoline cost no more than half what it costs today; the FACT that we are more disliked by the rest of the world today than before the invasion??? It seems that you who justify this 5 plus year abortion we are involved in conveniently forget the above mentioned facts so try to remember this cliche: those who forget the mistakes of the past are doomed to repeat them (with the same stupid and unnecessary consequences).
Those who critize, what are you doing for America's
freedom? Sunday morning quarterbacks will always have
comments after the fact. You have to deal with the hand your dealt and try to correct our mistakes and move forward. We are a better country if we deal with each other honestly, not always politically. The story is just one story told where there a hundreds not being told. God does bless America and all people willing to make the right choices in life.
Thank God for some positive news for a change.

Lonnie D Cross
Colombia SA
It is good that our troop can provide the Iragi people with safe and security. All those who reported news should be reporting good new like these.Instead pounding on the negavity issue all the time. I am a refugee from Asia and I know about war and suffering.
It is encourging to see one spot,that christians for
the time being are safe and that that the people see
democracy,one time in their lives.That is what my nephew died for in this war.
It figures,this story has been out before 8:00 A.M. EST and there is not one comment about something good happening in Iraq.The Iraqi ppl need news like this to know it can and will happen if they work together with out the involvement of terrorist countries like Iran ans Syria trying to screw things up.Then again I guess it is hard to bash when your eating crow !!!
Just yesterday I filled out a survey where I basically said I had no faith whatsoever in anything related to NBC.  With stories like this I may have to re-think my position a bit
No WMD?  Tell that to the hundreds of thousands that were killed by Saddam's WMD.
Life is so great as depicted--watched over by massive US troop presence.Any more of these showcases and we'll need several more surges.Guess it's all worth a shredded US economy,increasing populations of Jihaders and,reputation as SS-type torturers,billions of bucks disappearing into
Cheney's fraud factory and a generation of mutilated & PTS vets--Again,"Iraq--What For?"
So we Americans bring a few months of suspect peace to one neighborhood in Iraq and that is supposed to make up for 6 plus years of killing over a matter that was not our business in the first place?  Hooray for Bushies/Clintonites (Bill Clinton’s Administration is just as much to blame for this failed policy as is Bush and Bush Sr. – Iraqi Liberation Act of 1998). You have to be kidding me.  

The deflation of the US dollar and inflation of our prices by the Federal Reserve is what we have to pay for in order for the American taxpayer to rebuild what we have destroyed.  The fact is our country is at stake because of these liberal spending programs and war mongering.  Do you think the Iraqis will be there to bomb us and then help us when our currency goes the way of the Deutsch Mark did during the great world wars?  All of you lemmings that think this is good news are just being fooled by the same mainstream media that fooled the American public to believe the war was just.  

Let’s not also forget that the Democrats were brought in with a “mandate” from the American people to stop this war.  In fact, Pelosi had a bill withdrawn that was dealing with the Iranian problem and was to be used to reaffirm the need for Congress to declare war and not a dictatorial President.  Too bad Pelosi listened to our “friend” Israel and took down the bill.  You all have been bilked for too long.  

“We marched right in there and we can march right out.” – Ron Paul
Winning the War refers to the fact that the United States Military, with support from Iraqi forces and Sunni militants who have turned against al-queda are kicking the terriorists butts. Even though this was also true in Vietnam (and before any liberal yahoos challenge that remark please google tet offensive) it was a combination of the msm and the democratic politicians who raised the white flag of surrender (kinda like the O man)with the liberal commentator and news icon walter cronkite pronouncing the war as unwinnable and boobus americanus meekly accepting (or simply too lazy or ill informed to challenge)this lie.
It is encourging to see one spot,that christians for
the time being are safe and that that the people see
democracy,one time in their lives.That is what my nephew died for in this war.
I was always under the impression the a good, no a great reporter, reports the news with facts, “Invasion” I would think that MSNBC would prefer actual facts on the home page.
Oh, I agree with Paul from Ohio, it must be KILLING Harry Reid and Pelosi, and all of their ilk, especially Obama, that there is good news coming out of Iraq.  My bet is on Obama never visiting Iraq.  Know why?  He'll have to state the obvious, i.e., there is stability and good news.  He'll never do that!  Why?  He'll lose the election, pure and simple.
Great Story . >I'm proud of our President and our troops ! .    

Liberals will try to downplay it . !  
I am so happy the Christians in Iraq are able to attend their churches ...It can't be easy struggling to maintain faith in an Infidel land. God Bless Bush and our troops...Doing the right thing is never the easy road..But God is watching all of this..God Bless America..and a President who did not blink...
Evans E,

What information do you have that factually states "we are less safe" since "the invasion"? What information do you have that factually states "the invasion" doubled the price of gas?

Make sure you can back up your "facts" before you start spewing your liberal, divisive, anti-conservative, blather.

Give it a rest. It's an encouraging story at a minimum.

For all those LIberals who think that this is a BUSH war, look up on YouTube, Clinton/Iraq. In his on words, back in 98 talking about Saddam and WMD. Just Clinton didn't have the balls to do something about it.
Why is there such a differing view between those Americans who have stood up and worn the uniform and served their country and those who have just sat back and taken all the freedoms that they have not protected?
I think we can all agree that we hope this kind of security lasts.  But that's the point isn't it?  How many times before have we heard of improving security conditions only to be blindsided by how quickly and utterly they fall apart (Tal Afar anyone)?  Bear in mind that the Sons of Iraq on our payroll, receiving $300 a month to not attack U.S. troops or ferment sectarian animosity and the increased troop presence.  Couple that with with an uneasy cease-fire from the major Shiite factions and their militias and you still have a potentially combustible situation, kept at bay by a U.S. presence that, in essence, keeps a physical barrier between Sunni and Shiite belligerents.  None of this security would be sustainable without that physical barrier, and U.S. troops cannot be expected to keep this up much longer.  The strain on them has been too great and too unfair for too long (and don't get me started on the shoddy treatment so many receive when they come home). This situation for American troops is especially true if the Iraqi government and their  military doesn't get their act together soon.  Keep in mind also that the some or maybe most of the stories we've been hearing about Iraqi troops "taking the lead" in various security operations may be exaggerations perpetrated by a nervous American military and presidential administration, meant to paint a better picture than the one reality does (This was reported by Time magazine some two or three weeks ago).  If something else doesn't rise up to replace the troop presence in places like Dora, then all we seem to be doing is delaying the inevitable.  That said, I hope this takes, I really do.  Iraq and the U.S. military has suffered an enormous amount of punishment at the hands of a war that Bush and his administration misled or outright lied the American people into and it needs to end.  4000+ troops dead and 600+ billion dollars wasted is probably enough for an erroneous war.
I hope the liberal NBC news had this approved by the Obama campaign before it went to print.  Otherwise, it will undermine his commitment to an immediate withdraw.  NBC news surely wouldn't do that to its preferred candidate.
As the mother of a future army solider, it is rather comforting to see positive things happening in Iraq.  I am not naive to think that there is no danger. We are blessed to be the greatest nation in the world for we are not just one race but many who live in harmony.  We are not a perfect nation but God has given us much and although we are critized here and abroad for this war and Afghanistan we are still a leader in this world who must show the other "older Nations" that this is what a true leader does with or without their approval.  We must help those in need.
Keep Reporting the good news out of Iraq.  There are more stories like this every day, but the news always wants to report bad news, because bad news people like reading..  Sad.. I would like to read more good new about the US and Iraq...  
OK, life is better in Dora when US troops are policing the area. It is interesting that some people appear to think that this fact alone is a proof that we should be there. Oh, we could also be fighting the crime in Johannesburg or Grozny and the life would improve in those places. So ?

Dear Dennis, sincere thanks and appreciation to your son for serving our country.  I'll peel the layers off of this onion:  Iraq will become the millstone around the neck of the Democratic Party.  Their constant negativity and lies have come full circle; I state this in spite of the left-wing media that is an utterly corrupt vestige of their Party.
It is the responsibility of everyone who takes a breath in freedom to do all that they can to provide that opprotunity to all of humanity. There are word in our history books that state "all that is necessary for evil to prevail is for good men(and women) to do nothing. is this a long road? YES is it worthwhile? YES is it costly? Yes is it necessary you will have to answer this yourself, but for this service connected disabled American Veteran I believe it is. We forget and disrespect the sacrafice of all who have fought and died for this principle in all the wars of history. Success come with perseverance and we can not walk away from this. I am thankful for this story and it's real message to the people of the world      


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1129504

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.