ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



JOURNEY TOWARD THE QUAKE'S EPICENTER

Posted: Friday, May 16, 2008 6:31 PM
Filed Under:

 SICHUAN PROVINCE, China – I moved to China from California, so earthquakes are unfortunately familiar. But even in California, the most populous state in the U.S., the epicenter of any quake is often located in a place where it doesn't seem to do much harm: in the woods or off the coast. Here in Sichuan province, I thought it was tragic that an epicenter located so far from a city center could be blamed for so many deaths – including 70 percent of the 10,000 residents in a town called Yingxiu. Why did this happen? And how were the town's survivors coping days later?

I'm curious to find out, so we set out for the town, located in the scenic mountains of Sichuan province that are the habitat of the giant panda. We know there will be challenges getting there. The town itself is in a fairly remote area to begin with; access has been blocked further by damaged roads and falling debris. With my GPS in hand and a knowledgeable local guide behind the wheel, we set out for Yingxiu, dodging road closures, convoys and landslides. As we move closer to our destination, it's remarkable to see the impact of this quake: not just damaged structures but also the countless people living street side in makeshift tents. They are everywhere.

msnbc.com

We move through the city of Dujiangyan and see a gathering of residents standing outside a partially collapsed apartment building. A yellow heavy hydraulic shovel is there with its arm extended onto an exposed section of apartment floor. Both lurching and delicate at once, the shovel paws at a section of debris, moving it off the floor and away, we soon learn, from another fatality of this earthquake. Notification of next of kin is instant, with the sound of a wail from a relative watching from the crowd. She soon learns that three other relatives also died in that apartment. With casualties this high and widespread, death is not always dignified for the victims or their families. We leave.

As we head into the mountains it's apparent we are getting closer to Yingxiu. Its proximity can be measured by the increase in emergency vehicles and rigidity of the guards limiting access to the hardest-hit areas – though we have permission to be here. If our van is not allowed through the access point, then the question is how to get up the mountain. We spot some local motorcyclists and immediately begin negotiations. We are told they can take us to a point at the river where we can try to hire a private boat and move us closer to the town. As it turns out, none of this is necessary. Our driver gets the van through, and as we make our way up the hill, we learn from a soldier that Yingxiu has been hastily abandoned by the surviving residents. We find them on a roadside turnout waiting for buses, tractors, anything to take them down the mountain. Their stories are horrific. One man tells us the ground shook so hard, that everyone was knocked off their feet. A woman says she had no food for four days and bad weather and conditions prevented her from escaping. Her only nourishment was rainwater that she scooped from the ground. The most disturbing story comes from a resident who said most of the town's children died because they weren't fast enough to escape the heavier debris when it started to fall.

Ng Han Guan/AP
Damage in Yingxiu, China.

It is the number of fatalities, both young and old, that is why these residents are here. There are so many bodies in Yingxiu, says one man, that they fear disease is going to break out. "We ran for our lives as fast as we could."

Unlike so many rural Chinese who are determined to rebuild their homes and lives, the survivors of Yingxiu don't appear to be looking back. A bus approaches and they jam the door, competing for a seat. Our journey concludes as theirs begins – though theirs is a race to nowhere. Many have no idea where they will go next. They are positive only that they don't want to be here.

(For a Newsweek interactive map of the stricken area, including aerial images of the devastation in Yingxiu, click here.)  

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Despite the heart rendering images of disaster hit Chinese people, there has been much talk of how all new buildings were built to withstand this quake, including the school that collapsed.

Unfortunately the Chinese government and its corrupt regime, failed its people, and now they suffer, and will continue to suffer, as the ame government officials will just get even richer, skimming money off the rebuilding projects, using substandard materials again, to suspect standards, leading to yet another disatser to happen in the future again.

Someone earlier mentioned you dont see looting like in the USA, no you dont, its the government that does the looting, which keeps the people poor and oppressed.

The Chinese people know all of this, yet they continue to silently suffer.

In the west if buildings are found to be bsubstandardly built in disaster areas, then theres a head hunt for those responsible, In China, theres a head hunt to award the same corrupt officials yet further corrupt contracts for rebuilding.

Yet another distaster waiting to happen, and the world stands by and applauds the Chinese Government for its progress, Well done world,

when is someone going to wake up and smell the coffee??

Please do so before many thousands of other Chinese are sacrificed.
My heart is heavy and my tears are many as I see and hear the stories unfold after the earthquake here in China.I am from the US but live here in China now and I came here to share with the people about our Lord Jesus Christ. I love the people here and my heart gose out to all those who have lost loved ones but what hurts my heart the most is to know that out of the many that died,how many died with out knowing there Lord and savior Jesus Christ. People around the world say that their heart gose out to the people here in China at this time when many have died and that their prayers are with the people here,well I pray that this is true because God knows the heart and will judge the person acording to their heart but the true fact is if a person hasn't repented of their sins and put their trust in Jesus Christ when they die they will go to hell. And just like many that has died here in China not knowing they will spend eternity seperated form God. So if the readers here have a heart I pray that it will be a heart for the lost because a heart for the living that are lost is the only true heart. I thank God for the ones he has placed here to get this story out and the pictures that are taken and I pray that it will touch many around the world and bring them to Christ.
Its time to spare those poor people and give them a chance at life, the world needs to tell them  either let us in to help or go in and take them down and help the command people, this is what happens when you disarm a country-those who can not defend themself through out history-this has happened to(country with the no gun law, you really need to study world history and no what happens when only the goverement has arms!! do not take my word for this. look at the truth its not my word.
I looked into the faces of people I do not know and their pain and suffering flooded into my heart. May they find new direction and hope in what seems to be a hopeless situation. I am praying that light will flood the darkness of this great tragedy. The placement of one's foot in their shoes by the photos that were taken will readily turn each heart with grief of their suffering. Thankyou for the excellent reporting that allowed me to see this great need of a people I am no longer a stranger to.
To Pam et al, Mark was just doing his job
as a reporter, describing what he saw and
experienced to the world. It really does
not matter whether he handed a bottle of water
or lent a helping hand to victims or not.  
He was very couragrous to go there and do the
reporting with aftershocks still going on.
I am an American from North Carolina teaching and living near Shanghai for the past two years. I came here with pre determined views about what China was and what I would see. After two years,I can honestly say I have never been treated with more kindness and respect than at any where I have lived before. My western views have changed significantly as I become more knowledgeable of Chinese culture. All the Chinese I know and heard about give willingly to the Sichuan earthquake victims.They are a proud people and will overcome this tradegy. I was in Beijing two weeks ago and they are ready for the olympics.My reason for writing this is I feel a connection to the Sichuan earthquake victims as I visited there last year and went through by bus to many of those towns that are no longer existent.My heart and prayers go out to them.

Map placement of Chongqing is incorrect. Chongqing is Southeast of Chengdu. The last time I traveled from Chengdu to Chongqing is was about a 3-4 hour bus ride. My maps printed in China also show that placement UNLESS there are two cities spelled Chongqing. Chongqing was once considered part of Sichuan province but is now a separately administered entity.
wow im surprised as a chinese to see how hard they work together. shows great patriotism, i wish i could go back and help physically.
thank all your praying. we will overcome the tradedy with all peoples' best prays and help in the world
I was in Chengdu,China this time last year. The thought had crossed my mind; where would I be able to run to if an earthquake struck? The buildings aren't really tall, but didn't look that stable either. I'm sure tougher building codes will be placed and enforced after this. But the coming tragedy is, where are the millions of homeless people going to go? The world community needs to open their doors, and make it easier for temporary immigration,along with the China Government easing departure proceedures.I personally would be willing to make room for a family of three or four to stay with me and help in finding employment until such a time they could return to their own country.
I was in Chengdu,China this time last year. The thought had crossed my mind; where would I be able to run to if an earthquake struck? The buildings aren't really tall, but didn't look that stable either. I'm sure tougher building codes will be placed and enforced after this. But the coming tragedy is, where are the millions of homeless people going to go? The world community needs to open their doors, and make it easier for temporary immigration,along with the China Government easing departure proceedures.I personally would be willing to make room for a family of three or four to stay with me and help in finding employment until such a time they could return to their own country.
I find it strange that some posters would even question the intention of the writer's trip to the devastated area. The intention was obviously present to the readers the first-hand count of what the aftermath was like. That is a reporter's job.  Why someone would even question if the reporter had lend a helping hand? It is really missing the point.  By the way, thanks to the writer for a very informative article.
Dear people of YingXiu,
Hats off  to your spirit. Be brave, carry on, Pray for the departed, gather your strength and live on

My heart goes out to the Chinese people, and I hope the best for them.
I too am often deeply disturbed by the callous, uncaring attitude of reporters in general. The US press is a business comprised of people that try to cash in on others' misfortune. To offer aid in any tragic situation like this would cost money. It would never occur to them at all.
We have seen how badly the US Government responds to a disaster that didn't directly affect their money interests. I don't recall the US letting in foreign aid during the disaster they made of Katrina (by not keeping adequate flood protection in good repair). No one in the US was punished for that fiasco.
I hope the survivors of this tragedy do not suffer unduly. My thoughts and prayers are with them.
In defense of journalist, Mullen, I think his report was respectful and professional.  I am Canadian of Chinese ancestry, and have been moved to tears by much of the heart breaking news reports, photos, and videos of this disaster.  It is because of this reporting, not just in this disaster, but for 9/11, Katrina, and others, that I can feel empathy towards the profound suffering of others wherever and whenever it occurs in the world, and has and will hopefully move me to at least donate some money.

To those who would criticize journalist, Mullen, for apparently just reporting the facts, and not actively engaging in relief efforts, I respectfully submit to you that, in my opinion, there is no absolutely correct professional, ethical, or moral duty to do one or the other, or both.  

I can't fault journalist, Mullen, for reporting the facts, nor could I if he were moved to drop his pen and lend a hand. In his role as a journalist, bearing witness to a tragedy and the inconsolable grief of victims, his words and pictures can have the effect to move many people around the world into action, to donate money, to feel empathy, and to give insight into the circumstances of the disaster that might give rise to understanding how to mitigate or avoid the same catastrophic losses in the future.

I'm not qualified to speak for the professional duty and ethics of journalists, but I can venture an opinion on when one's human code of conduct trumps a journalist's professional duty to bear witness and report.  If a reporter were to happen upon a victim, at imminent risk of losing their life, and it was safe to intervene, all things considered, I think one's human code of ethics should compell them to temporarily suspend their reporting duty to save the victim. Perhaps this distinction or exception is already found in journalist's code of ethics. This report doesn't suggest to me that journalist, Mullen, neglected to intervene in saving any victims in immediate peril.

Lastly, I would not discount the power of words and pictures to save lives, just as ably as the strongest and skilled rescue and relief workers.  I also understand and respect the feelings of those who feel its the duty of everyone at the scene of a tragedy to do more.
I am totally saddened by the tragedy the Chinese people are suffering. In addition to admiring the people for their courage and spirit in this difficult time, I think the Chinese leadership and media deserve their share of appreciation. In 1976, an earthquake of similar magnitude hit Tangshan and over 240,000 people died. Though Tangshan was a more populated city, I believe that Chinese government and media could have done a much better job to save lives. The Chinese leadership today demonstrated their connection with the people and was not afraid of showing their true feelings to the world. The honesty and openness of the media were unprecedented in China. One can only hope both the Chinese leadership and media will keep the same spirit and ethics not just in time of tragedies.
I am as shocked as the world to read of the pain and suffering that the Chinese are experiencing.I am praying for you and hope that my country,Jamaica will extend some foreign aid.I admire the resilience and dedication of these people,you will be overcomers.So from Jamaica to you one love!BLESSINGS!
I do feel bad for the human toll, however I hope the Chinese Government takes this as an oppurtunity to learn and fix its building practices. This earthquake would not have nearly as severe if they didn't have builders getting away with cuttin corners building houses. It may have saved them the money in the short term, but now they'ver got a human tragedy, that hopefully, unlike tianemen square will be something remembered and learned by.
I am worried about other countries in need as there has always been a need but I am worried that if a country denies help from US then why not help the US talking about our government. Gas is out of control I work for the community and have little help for helping others. I know I am not alone here its outrageous to think of making a country take our help and we are suffering here in the US. I cannot believe that our president is still in office he has created the next 3rd world country right here to the working class. Feel good GW.Bush?
Thank you all!
As chinese living in the States, My wife and I have been weeping in front of the computer screen for the past week. Our heart and prayers are with the people in China.
It is so heart warming to see people here in the States sharing the same feeling, and it is beyong our words to express how grateful we are for your sympathy and compassion toward the peolple in China.
God bless you all.
I think sniffer-dogs should be sent to help find the bodies and anyone else left alive.

This earthquake may affect the Beijing Olympics.
We have not yet heard of any prospective Chinese Olympians killed or hurt in the earthquake.
It may be a sad nation indeed hosting the world .
it must be quite a shocking to see the rubbles there in Yingxiu. We're constantly talking about saving mother earth and global warming. Mother earth just yawned and look what devastation it caused. No amount of "saving earth" matters when there are still wars.
Last night, Wendy and I watched news report on TV for the whole night. As young parents, we were really sad to see the primary schools were destroyed and more than 1000 kids are buried in the building - I can feel every second counts. Now they are in the ground for more than 48 hours. When I saw small school bags on the ground, my tears really run down, for long time...

It is sad. Really sad.

Now, according to Sina, 14866 people already died and about 25788 were still buried under the collapsed building. Let us keep praying for the people who are still alive and hope they get rescued very soon.
<a href="http://www.handandaily.com">Handan</a>
My heart goes out to the people of China for there great loss of life, for the homes and the cities they have lost.  Chinese people have over come many things and they will over come this one to with the same courage they always show. You are all in my prayers.
Couldn't part of the billions being spent on space programmes be diverted towards research, to predict natural disasters of this magnitude, so that untold human misery could be averted?
I must be going blind.  I have not seen any criticizing by the author of the article.  What in the world is offending you Chinese?  The article is simplly describing some of the devistation and suffering.  If you consider that critical, then you are definitely mistaken and possibly having trouble with the translation.  Ease up on the reporter.  That is his job.  To help tell the story.  We all would help, if we could.  Everyone feels compasion for the victims and their families and friends.  I hope they are able to rebuild, so the people who want to return will be able to someday. God bless all.
Ironic is the word that most comes to mind when I think of the events of the past few weeks in regards to China, and country we all know, or at least know of, and Myanmar, a country name the average American wouldn’t begin to know, although they might possibly recognize the old name of Burma.  

Here we have two countries, with two separate, but equally devistating disasters, and two totally different responses from their respective governments.

A cyclone strikes Myanmar over two weeks ago.  Their government refuses aid and assistance at first, saying they can handle it, but gradually began to allow outside agencies and other countries some limited access, all because they are parinoid of anyone outside their own little circle, and because they really don’t care about anyone but themselves.  How many people have died, and will continue to die, because of the actions, and lack thereof, by their government?  Will we ever really know the answers?  Probably not.

An earthquake strikes China.  A country that has recently been under intense media scrutiny, nearly all of it negative, in regards to their stand on Tibet, causing much public outcry and rage in the rest of the world, and whether it is justified or not at this time, China’s political view and stand on Tibet have been pushed aside when they were struck with disaster and a country banded together as one to help.  I’ve read report after report of how individuals have banded together to help.  How companies have opened their doors, and bank accounts, to help.  How charities have leaped at the opportunity to do everything they can to assist.  And how China, this “mystical” country that many of us know little about in reality, even appealed to the world for assistance in an effort to save their people.  

While preparations for the Olympics continue, the hearts and souls of the Chinese people are for those fellow countrymen, women and children who have suffered from the quake, and how they can be helped, with everyone more than willing to do whatever they can.  

As a “student of history”, I have always judge the “greatness” of a country not by what they achieved through military might, or even other standards such as education and the wealth of their society.  In my mind, what makes a country great, what sets it apart from others, is how that country reacts to their people in times of need and crisis.  

There may still be political differences that many of us do not agree with when it comes to China, and many of us may still feel like condemning or being critical of China in regards to those.  But no one can deny that this country has shown it’s greatness in it’s response to the disaster which struck.  

In my mind this response has done more to personally show me the progress and change in China more than any Olympics could ever do.  My hat is off to the country, and my heart goes out to the victims.  
I am a China business man who be stopped in U.S, hate that can not fly back to my homeland. Only thing can do now is donating... Thanks for all the American people who show your bright side.
If hot air, and type were aid, many people would be aided. But, look at Myamar, where leaders take food from their citizens mouth, for themselves. Americans pitch in and help their neighbors, and government arrives a week later to take credit. So wil Chinese leaders. Shame, isn't it
Maybe we all have to learn how to be as civilized as Chinese are, the way they handle themselves even in the worst disaster as this. At least admire their strenght and try to help in a positive way.
Bob and Debbie's observation of the difference of people in china vs New Orleans crossed my mind also. In New Orleans...the people there are lazy, complainers, need handouts all the time and are ruining every city they were evacuated to.  Our city has suffered tremendously from these whiny, lazy, overweight, dishonest, ungrateful people. All of Louisiana is not like New Orleans.  When Rita Hit you saw a different story with people that lived in that area of the state.  
I greatly appreciate the high risks Mark and his crew took to report this horrible tragedy back to us.  I do not understand how people can sit in their comfortable homes and criticize.  If it were not for Mark and other brave journalists how could we know or understand the extent of the devastation?  If we do not hear about these events why would we want to help?  Please do not belittle these professionals, read their reports and act positively.
Compare the tragedy of the hurricane to the tragedy of the earthquake.Bothe countries are dictatorships one seeks total control for the leadership the other tries to learnfrom its mistakes.There lies the tragedy of mankind.
I couldn't help weeping and sobbing during the solemn mourning ceremony, and so do all people around me, for this whole week, when we've been focusing on the quake. I have never been so much touched as I read the news about so many great teachers/ parents who died in spontaneous protection of the children; those volunteers/ soldiers who cried and pleaded (even on their knees)to save more possible survivors; who have already prepared their death letters before going to the dangerous front sites for rescue; for dear state premier/president who have always been on the quake areas sleepless for days; I'm also touched to see so many international friends who showed their humane and objective comments/prayers. all I want to say is "thank you", and nothing will baffle us as we're all here standing together in this world!
This story is moving and sad.  If a 7.9 earthquake struck out in The Rural Los Angles County area would result in the same sadness from me.

Maybe San Francisco should be considered "The Sister City" to The City In China that was virtually "Wiped-Out" by The Quake.

With The Bejing 2008 Summer Olympics not far off, China will have to "dig deep down inside Herself" to muster The Olympic Spirit-with so much devastation being needed to deal with!

Though The 1972 Munich Tragedy was Man-Made. It seems as if The Summer Olympics-no matter which country hosts the event, has its share of Dark problems to deal with!
That was an excellent article: it was objective and unbiased. I find it silly to question the reporter’s motives which he states clearly in the opening paragraph:
“I thought it was tragic that an epicenter located so far from a city center could be blamed for so many deaths – including 70 percent of the 10,000 residents in a town called Yingxiu. Why did this happen? And how were the town's survivors coping days later?

I'm curious to find out, so we set out for the town, …”

One reason why so many died was because China is much more densely populated than the reporter’s home country – the US.

One other reason I speculate is that most houses, even the 1 or 2 storey ones, are built of bricks without any consideration for earth quake proofing. The same houses built in lumber like in the US would be able to withstand the quake better because wood is more flexible than brick. Wood is also much lighter, its collapse will be much less deadly than that caused by bricks.

How to make buildings more quake proof may be one of the good outcomes of this terrible disaster and great human tragedy. Right now, we can reduce the sufferings by  sending in supplies and donations.
I am amazed at the unity of the people in China. Praise God! My heartfelt prayers go out to all the people in China, and the cyclone in Myanmur. May the God of all peoples comfort and sustain you and may we be a blessing to you!!!!!!!!!!!
Thanks all us kindly people,thank u very much. I am a chinese who had ever lived in Canada,I think keep in touch can improve the understanding with each other.
I agree with Al Cheung from Alberta that this is an excellent report.  Freedom of speech is a human right and I totally understand that some people only like to hear what they want to hear. There has been much criticism about western media being biased about China in several incidents. In my opinion, the only way that the media can avoid to be biased is for them to get to the bottom of the truth. This is exactly what Mark Mullen tried to do. He reported what he saw and heard first hand. There were not even comments or interpretations. I appreciate his courage and dedication as a professional.
As a Chinese living in the States, I want, and I think all the Chinese people will join me, to thank for the kindness shown the American people in this critical moment of disaster – the words on the blog are the best evidence. Chinese people, just as the Americans, are capable to understand the sincerity of the empathy from others. Some Chinese bloggers were still critical of MSNBC because certain bitterness that recent past has left in the heart of many Chinese people. People in China do have different opinions about the reporting by western media on China. It is understandable. We are very different culturally and politically. However, I believe as time goes by, Western audience will see that the people of the "communist" China are just as human as other peoples. The world will know the real China by more reporting on the ground. On the other hand, the Chinese people will also see that the Westerners (not just journalists), except a few, are genuine and honest people who will report truthfully what they see. On disputable issues such as Tibet, more reporting on the ground, even "biased" at the beginning, will eventually give more objective and truthful views, since China, as many Chinese people believe, has nothing to hide. Lack of first hand information will lead to speculation in Western media, foster rumors, and play to the hands of people with agendas. Trust will be returned with trust.
By the way, Chinese say "miseries build the character of a nation." Americans say "if it doesn't kill you, it will make you stronger." There is something in common between our nations.
I feel sorry for the those affected by the quake and the loss of life and economic damage it has caused. The people of China are strong and it seems that somewould choose to turn this blog into a political issue between the China and the United States.There are good people and strong people everywhere and in every nation on this green Earth, and sometimes this green Earth causes death and destruction to every one of those nations. It is at these times that only for a short time thatpeople step out of themselves and show that there still is good in the human heart. May the people of China be blessed, and accept the love, respect, sympathy, and freindship of the United States, and hopefully build a stronger bond between our two great nations. There are things we can all learn from eachother.
The impact this earthquake is having on China has been amazing and, I believe, will last, at least in part. I also think it is serving to humanize the Chinese for the West.
I applaud the Chinese people and the Chinese government for coming to their own aid during such a crisis. I think Americans have become aware of how much money we pump into China. I even hear our tax checks have come from money borrowed from China. While I feel for them in their time of suffering, I wonder about the need for foreign aid. Also, why the Katrina remarks? We are a country of small government. Most of that failure can be put on the city, then the state, and very last the federal government. Not to mention most people had a TV station to tell them a hurricane was coming.  Quit hating your own government America!  Tragedy happens everywhere, why must there be blame? You want to help China out? Buy another TV or most anything else for sale at Walmart
There are almost no words to describe how sad it is to hear about the tragedy of our brothers and sisters in any part of the world........
Chinese people though have always been a great example of wisdom, strength and capable of big accomplishments so may God help them to recover soon from this one.
Sincerely,
Lupi
I'm really sad of what happened in China. I know how it feels to lose someone specially your own child. As what my elders said, "They are now in the Kingdom of our  good Lord". I really wanted to give some help to China but I don't know who to contact. But my prayer is the best thing I could give now. Thank you MSNBC for such an informative and meaningful blog.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1033971

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.