ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



JOURNEY TOWARD THE QUAKE'S EPICENTER

Posted: Friday, May 16, 2008 6:31 PM
Filed Under:

 SICHUAN PROVINCE, China – I moved to China from California, so earthquakes are unfortunately familiar. But even in California, the most populous state in the U.S., the epicenter of any quake is often located in a place where it doesn't seem to do much harm: in the woods or off the coast. Here in Sichuan province, I thought it was tragic that an epicenter located so far from a city center could be blamed for so many deaths – including 70 percent of the 10,000 residents in a town called Yingxiu. Why did this happen? And how were the town's survivors coping days later?

I'm curious to find out, so we set out for the town, located in the scenic mountains of Sichuan province that are the habitat of the giant panda. We know there will be challenges getting there. The town itself is in a fairly remote area to begin with; access has been blocked further by damaged roads and falling debris. With my GPS in hand and a knowledgeable local guide behind the wheel, we set out for Yingxiu, dodging road closures, convoys and landslides. As we move closer to our destination, it's remarkable to see the impact of this quake: not just damaged structures but also the countless people living street side in makeshift tents. They are everywhere.

msnbc.com

We move through the city of Dujiangyan and see a gathering of residents standing outside a partially collapsed apartment building. A yellow heavy hydraulic shovel is there with its arm extended onto an exposed section of apartment floor. Both lurching and delicate at once, the shovel paws at a section of debris, moving it off the floor and away, we soon learn, from another fatality of this earthquake. Notification of next of kin is instant, with the sound of a wail from a relative watching from the crowd. She soon learns that three other relatives also died in that apartment. With casualties this high and widespread, death is not always dignified for the victims or their families. We leave.

As we head into the mountains it's apparent we are getting closer to Yingxiu. Its proximity can be measured by the increase in emergency vehicles and rigidity of the guards limiting access to the hardest-hit areas – though we have permission to be here. If our van is not allowed through the access point, then the question is how to get up the mountain. We spot some local motorcyclists and immediately begin negotiations. We are told they can take us to a point at the river where we can try to hire a private boat and move us closer to the town. As it turns out, none of this is necessary. Our driver gets the van through, and as we make our way up the hill, we learn from a soldier that Yingxiu has been hastily abandoned by the surviving residents. We find them on a roadside turnout waiting for buses, tractors, anything to take them down the mountain. Their stories are horrific. One man tells us the ground shook so hard, that everyone was knocked off their feet. A woman says she had no food for four days and bad weather and conditions prevented her from escaping. Her only nourishment was rainwater that she scooped from the ground. The most disturbing story comes from a resident who said most of the town's children died because they weren't fast enough to escape the heavier debris when it started to fall.

Ng Han Guan/AP
Damage in Yingxiu, China.

It is the number of fatalities, both young and old, that is why these residents are here. There are so many bodies in Yingxiu, says one man, that they fear disease is going to break out. "We ran for our lives as fast as we could."

Unlike so many rural Chinese who are determined to rebuild their homes and lives, the survivors of Yingxiu don't appear to be looking back. A bus approaches and they jam the door, competing for a seat. Our journey concludes as theirs begins – though theirs is a race to nowhere. Many have no idea where they will go next. They are positive only that they don't want to be here.

(For a Newsweek interactive map of the stricken area, including aerial images of the devastation in Yingxiu, click here.)  

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I must admire the Chinese and their spirit of pulling to gether.  My heart breaks for their losses and grief.  I will pray for the children and the bereaved parents.  
Just curious: did you bring anything to the people there, say, a bottle of water? Or you just took a tour?
People live in places where there is a means of economic sustenance. Those who live at a location because of emotional ties (like a family living in a village for several generations)still need an economic structure to sustain themselves into the future. When the economc and the social structure is wiped out, as can be inferred from your report on Yingxiu, there is no reason to stay. God only knows when and, more importantly,if the Authorities decide to rebuild the town then the people would have a reason to come back. I think the people are wise to have sought an emotional closure on the greatest tragedy of their lifetime and are moving on to secure their future well being. I disagree, with respect, that it is a journey to nowhere.
Well I think chinese people will overcome all these difficulties because they are greate people and greate nation inspite of western media's hostile report especially MSNBC, May be they are still having the mind set of China is Communist and blind folded themself of what they are supposed to see the changes and improvements China has. Just like capitalist western world in 19th century the human right records are even worse and working class were exploited badly that days but not so today. If people from non-western world see Western world capitalism still like 19th century's what is your feeling? Go to China and stay for some years then make your comment or big article (remember bible said before criticize others try examine your self; are you that perfact?
Interesting how you don't see looting and such like our greedy American counterparts of Hurricaine Katrina. People of Katrinas disaster need to open their eyes and be more like the Chinese.
It sounds like the people of  Yingxiu have more courage and sence then the many residents of New Orleans which would rather whine about the help they received and demand much more rather than moving on with their lives, and helping themselves.
Thank you Mark, Great Story. Admiring your courage to visit the still dangerous earthquake hit area. Expect more stories like this!
what's the main purpose of going into the area? to see how much sufferings being experienced by all victims? or to lend a helping hand on humanity base? the article doesn't sound the latter! I'm as curious as Helen... did your sense of humanity arise when you see the victims, what have you done at he moment? taking pictures....?
all of us are break hearts for the people perishied in this terrible disaster,everybody around me donate money,blood----I have never seen this during my 20 year's of life.everyday i was touched by something,let alone tears falls down from my eyes and the warmness rise in deepside of my heart.our 1.3billion people get together do our best to help the  suffering compatriots and pray for them.
Mosttime i am not so object to the opinion (your)media
express,but this time the almost coldblood attitude i really can't appreciate it...... you know, i can still remember deep sorry i felt for 911
In the dark days,all I see only the People are eager to donate money and blood.
By the way,if other nations were willing to show patience, the party hoped, the Chinese people would be encouraged to follow suit.
My 10-year-old son was one of ten Tulsa, Oklahoma elementary school exchange students (plus their teachers) in Chongqing, China.  Our children-students were treated with great respect and kindness.  We thank and appreciate the Chongqing teachers, students and host families, adding compassion to our most sincere interests in life-long friendships and mutual understanding with the Chinese.  As the experience was joyful and exciting - with departure to Shanghai and arrival a mere 15-minutes before the earthquake, so too is my admission that rescue pictures bring tears to my eyes as empathy is easily expressed - contrasted with happy pictures (early in) the day of the earthquake.  The vivid contrast to the result of this catastrophy provokes emotional realities we know are facing our newest friends.  Notwithstanding, we look forward to Principal Xiao Fangming's return to (Tulsa's) Hoover Elementary this fall with their exchange students and teachers from the first experimental primary school of the central district in Chongqing, China. Our prayers and best wishes are heartfelt, which my writing cannot adequately express to them.
It is difficult to imagine the magnitude of this destruction,and the resultant human sufering.I live in Trinidad & Tobago in the Caribbean, and we have had our share of quakes and tremours,it is really frightening.Luckily,most times the epicentre is hundreds of miles in the sea.I shudder to think what would happen if something like this hits us.
The photos included with the article tell the tale. What horror the survivors must have experienced as their world crashed around them. These folks must still be in shock, and it's amazing that they have the strength of will to begin again so soon. -Such a tribute to their character!- My thoughts are with them.

Why do so many writers from greater China feel it's necessary to criticize MSNBC? I have found MSNBC's reporting on this issue to be perfectly normal, with no undue criticism of China. Perhaps westerners view news differently than Chinese, but some of the Chinese comments seem very silly to me lately. Every MSNBC article can't be an entire social history tome. Do other western readers think MSNBC is unfair in its reporting? Do any Chinese admire that reporting? The way some comments sound, you would think that MSNBC is the appointed propogana outlet for Western thought.

I hope that some good will come out of this horrific tragic event. I"m referring to the people responsible for the poorly constructed schools and other buildings.  A complete and unbias investigation should expose and punish all who participated especially if fraud and payoffs are evident up and including officials working in high gov't positions.
I believe that we are having huge communication issues.  I know of no one who is not heart broken for the Chinese as they deal with losses of so many loved ones, as they try to survive with little or nothing left, as they try to pick up and start again.

I do realize the job of a journalist is to report.  But I do hope you were gladly giving what supplies you could to those in need without reporting it to us.  

My heartfelt admiration for the Chinese people has increased beyond measure in seeing them deal with such an enormous tragedy with such strength and dignity.  My love and prayers go out to you.  I truly believe the love and prayers of most of the western world is going out to China now.

God bless you.
There is no one to blame for this horrific event. It was a terrible earthquake.Trying to place blame on the goverment or builders just adds to the over whelming pain.At this time the chinese people need our prayers and peace.
The U.S. showed compassion to the Chinese people by sending supplies and other kinds of support to the victims of the quake...so where's the Chinese government's compassion for the people in Darfur?
It's really a shame that the U.S. government gave only $500,000 in Earthquake aid (though they said it was just the initial aid, but stil, there is no follow-up until now) whereas the Chinese gave $5M to Katrina's cause...
Interesting how you don't see looting and such like our greedy American counterparts of Hurricaine Katrina. People of Katrinas disaster need to open their eyes and be more like the Chinese.

Debbie Weahkee San Marcos California

very well said, Debbie, The American indeed have a lot to learn from the Chinese.

I appreciate the compassionate reporting of such tragedies - viewing the pictures and reading the stories cause me to see their loss and commiserate with them.  Just looking at the pictures during the last few days has made my heart pained as tears streamed down my face.  I can't even imagine the feelings of loss that they are experiencing - parents losing their children - wives losing their husbands, etc.  If I wasn't able to see the photos, I wouldn't be able to quite grasp the reality of it.  I want to mourn with those who mourn - I don't want to go on living my fancy-free American lifestyle while those on the other side of the globe are suffering so much.  To all my Chinese friends, my heart and prayers are with you!
A chinese man lives near me.  I find he wants the same things for his children that I do mine.  I wish that all people could be safe and happy.  I know my church will send help--Latter-day Saint.  Our newsmen try to give us the news, they are not critical of those who are in need.
As a Chinese, It is so sad to see the tragedy unfolding. So many life lost. On the other hand I want to remind everyone that China is ruled by commuist party and they are so good to put on shows. This time it is not exception. Check this video out
http://www.youmaker.com/video/sv?id=73f459af72de4f1eb46785160ab60654001
I can not imagine how difficult it must be for these citizens of China some losing their only child, these are strong proud people they will make it through and rebuild, I am happy to see China open up it doors to out side help something they have never done, If only I were in a place I could go help I would be on the first plane out.  I watch as the citizens pull together to help each other, far different scenes from what we saw in New Orleans, people looting stories of sexual abuse against children and rape of women, New Oreleans may have many attractive sights and wonderful restaurants but the underside is a whole different life,  When 911 happened I was so proud to say I was American as I watched the New Yorkers pull together and help each other through,God bless the people of China
I would like to know what the purpose of your visit to YingXiu. Did you offer any help? China is a great nation, people are strong. However, this terrible disaster is devastating. Please HELP instead of criticizing!
As a citizen of  United States all I can say is that seeing this horrific catastrophy in China was extremely heart wrenching and it's not what I heard but what I saw.  The Chinese people are very strong  and very determine people but nevertheless, they are people that lost their love ones, homes and communities.  How great their grief,fears and suffering can we all see in their eyes.  In any castastrophy we want to reach out to help and comfort our fellow man.
As a citizen of  United States all I can say is that seeing this horrific catastrophy in China was extremely heart wrenching and it's not what I heard but what I saw.  The Chinese people are very strong  and very determine people but nevertheless, they are people that lost their love ones, homes and communities.  How great their grief,fears and suffering can we all see in their eyes.  In any castastrophy we want to reach out to help and comfort our fellow man.
It does no good to lay blame on anyone. a tragedy occured and they will handle it the best they can. When a tragedy occurs it's usually the less affluent people that have the most affliction of the tragedy. We should not blame anyone, but offer what ever we can, including prayers. Everyone suffers a tragedy in their life of some type. Do not wish any ills upon anyone, less you wish them upon yourself.
My sympathies and heartfelt compassion are with the people of China in their great loss of life and the pains they suffer in losing their homes and cities in this horrible catastrophy.
We in America certainly understand China's heartaches since we have had our share of storms, earthquakes, Tornadoes and Terrorist attacks and experienced the same tragic losses. Certainly the numbers of people affected in China during the recent eartquakes far surpasses the hundreds of our victims. But a life lost is nonetheless a tragedy for everyone.
 The Chinese people are resilient and have displayed a tremendous amount of courage and determination over the centuries to overcome whatever tragedies they encounter. I am sure they will continue to overcome this current one with that same spirit.
 So from one human being to millions of others in China, my heart is with you all, as are my most profound prayers.
Punish those who built the schools???  Go and help build a better one.  Or teach the children ... never mind, stay home.
We Americans can help the Chinese through donations to Direct Relief International. This is is a non-profit NGO which aids millions around the world with medicines which are delivered, with integrity and accountability paramount to the mission of DRI. Google - Direct Relief International to make a donation.
I am a chinese,the quake so big that 29000 people die in the quake,I hope more and more people can be helped.I hope more and more people can help these people.A gile,who was in the quake,by her hands,safed her dad and mom from the quake,used 4 hours.A 11 old student,safed her teachers and students form the quake.A father and mother,when the quake was happening,they used their hands and bodies,safed their dougther.A mother,when the quake was happening,used her body,safed her dougther,when the baby had been safed,the baby hand a call,the call has a massage,it says:"my baby,if you can safe,you mast live batter".More and more examples....
My heart goes out to the chinese people, they are a great nation that will overcome, I myself have been there, we have 2 adopted daughters from China, it has been reported that the orphanage in that area only had building damage no injuries, we continue to pray for these people
beter things to do is to find time to offer prayers to the victims of the quake. We know it is not easy to suffer such destruction and start such new living again. let us contribute courage and show concern to the Chinese people. To the victims of quake, be strong and be brave, my prayer is in you.
Journalists should have a sense of responsibility in such times of crisis. Everytime you hop on your SUV to these disaster zones just for your petty sense of finding out what is going on there, you are congesting the so precious roads cleared by soldiers and workers that should be used for relief and resecue. Next time, think for the victims first!!!
In time of disasters all humankind needs to extend a helping hand regardless of race, color, nationality, etc.....  that's what set us apart from animals.
Thanks for your sympathetic and critical comments,we'll overcome this catastrophe and hold the hard-earned beijing olympic game well!
I am a 66 year old man who has broken down and cried over this horrific most catastrophic and devastating tragedy.
My heart & my prayers truly goes out to the many,many thousands of families who have lost their loved ones
as well as everything they have ever owned.
If it were at all possible I would be there myself
and doing anything and everything to help these wonderful and helpess victims as well as those who have survived. I am very upset over how after only 5 days now the media does not keep this tragedy as a main headline. I myself live in earthquake country (san Andreas fault ) I was in and had experienced the
Northridge quake 6.7 mag. Jan 17,1994 at 4:31 a.m. Monday morning. The epecenter was a block and a half from where I was living at the time.
This should be a real wake up call for the people of
california. We are way overdue for a huge and more devastating earthquake of 1994. I myself am preparing
emergency supplies for survival when it comes amd it will come. I see and feel constant change in weather, hot & cold in temperatures.

ARE YOU PREPARED ????  WILL YOU BE PREPARED ??? OR WILL YOU PAY  THE PRICE FOR  PROCASTINATING. I SINCERELY HOPE THAT YOU DO NOT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

WHATEVER YOU DO DO NOT COUNT ON  F.E.M.A. THEY ARE A JOKE !!!!!
THEY DO NOT KNOW WHAT THE WORD GRANT IS,SO BECAREFUL IN ACCEPTING ANYTHING FROM THESE CLOWNS.
THEY SENT SOME YAHOO FEMA INSPECTOR IN FROM TENNESSEE
WHO PROBABLY DID NOT KNOW HIS BUTT FROM HIS ELBOW WHEN IT COMES TO EARTHQUAKES.
I WAS GIVE A GRANT  HA HA HA AND AFTER ALMOST A YEAR
F.E.M.A. WANTED THE MONIES BACK.
WHY ???? BECAUSE THEY THE YAHOOS DECIDED THAT MY PLACE OF LIVING DID NOT WARRANT  ME HAVING THEIR MONIES.
THIS WENT ON FOR YEARS AFTER THE EARTHQUAKE AND I FOUGHT THEM TOOTH AND NAIL.
I HAD TO REPAY THIS GRANT MONEY ( WHAT A JOKE F.E.M.A.
IS) BACK PLUS INTEREST ON TOP OF IT
SEE FOR YOURSELF HOW  THEY SCREWED THE PEOPLE BIG TIME IN NEW ORLEANS HURRICANE KATRINA AND PROBABLY STILL ARE,  WHICH CERTAINLY WOULD NOT SURPRISE ME AT ALL.

DO YOU DETECT THAT I AM I BITTER OVER F.E.M.A. YOU BET YOUR SWEET A"" I AM.I WOULD NOT EVEN ACCEPT A BOTTLE OF WATER FROM THEM
NOT NOW NOT EVER. HELL THEY MIGHT COME AFTER ME ONCE AGAIN AND WANT A 100 BOTTLES BACK FROM ME
I am totally saddened by the tragedy the Chinese is suffering. In addition to admiring Chinese people for their courage and spirit in such a difficult time, I think the Chinese leadership and media also deserve their fair share of appreciation. In 1976, an earthquake of similar magnitude hit Tangshan and more than 240,000 people died. Though Tangshan was a more populated city, I believe Chinese government and media could have done much better to save lives. The Chinese leadership today demonstrated their connection with the people and was not afraid of showing their true feelings in front of the world. The honesty and openness of the media is also not precedent. I can only hope both the Chinese leadership and media will keep the same spirit and ethics not just in time of tragedies.
Debbie Weahkee said...."Interesting you don't see looting". From the pictures I've seen there is nothing to loot unless you are in the market for rubble. The fallen buildings have literaly buried everything that was once important.
As others have said, where was your helping hand? Sounds like you did nothing to assist, just beat it out of town rather quickly.
Disasters and war need dispassionate observers in order to relay the true horror and suffering accurately.

I have donated, and I'm sure the reporter has, what we can to our suffering fellow humans.

Making critical remarks based upon a blog entry of a professional eyewitness is cheap and immature on the part of some Chinese in this blog.

Not everyone in the news business is callous nor has a lack of compassion for people suffering.

I was in Beijing/Xi'an, as a tourist, from 2nd to 10th,May,2008 and returned to Malaysia on 11th,May. My heart goes out to all the affected people in China. Being a Malaysian, I was amazed by the vast extend of China and the isolation of some of its populated areas, as compared to Malaysia's, while overflying Sichuan. Hence I understand China's problem of providing rescue operations in such a huge natural disaster. To me, China's government did a very good job here. Well done China.

Chinese Malaysian.
I've been following the news of this earthquake closely as my nearly nine-year old daughter is from Deyang, a town northeast of Chengdu and not far from the epicenter of this event.  Looking at your map and acknowledging that I am not a cartographer or geographer, I do believe the "towns" of Chengdu and Chongqing are reversed.

I must say that I am very moved by the many sincere and caring comments written by many in this blog to the Chinese victims and Chinese people in general, especially those of non-Asian ancestry. To me, this represents true America, and they are true Americans -- people who understand that we are all alike. I always believe that a country is not defined by its government but by its people.

There will be Chinese people who are upset with the Western press, and there will be Western people who are upset by the Chinese's upset. Hopefully a disaster like this teaches us and helps us grow -- out of the blame game into the help game.
Thanks to MSNBC for facilitating such a meaningful blog.
Some in the western media criticised the govt for not doing enough in terms of shoring up schools in preparation for potential earthquakes but comparing western standards is nothing more than pure double standard.  When faced with the sheer force of a 7.9 magnitute earthquake, i doubt most buildings would still be standing if this were to happen in los angeles.  A 7.9 (the equivalent of over 800 million tons of TNT) is close to the one that SF experienced in the 1906 quake. Compared to the complete embarrasment we experienced after hurricane katrina, I'm very much impressed by the chinese gov'ts response even though the magnitude of this disaster is several hundred folds worse than what had happened here.
uor nation is so great.people do show great guts.I have never been so proud since we face the disaster together bravely.we are sure this ,too, shall past.our nation should be highly honoured for her courage.
uor nation is so great.people do show great guts.I have never been so proud since we face the disaster together bravely.we are sure this ,too, shall past.our nation should be highly honoured for her courage.
What I remember also is strong criticism that the Chinese Army was too big, which the Chinese justified by saying that number of soldiers might be required for disaster relief. What foresight!
When New Orleans was hit, there wasn't enough Army to keep order, and even many of the National Guard were elsewhere. Just an observation from an Australian.
Last night I had a very sad dream. I led me staying home all day and couldn't really do anything I planned to do. In the dream I saw several people lying on road-side, and under one of the quilts my long time lost Mom was lying there. I rushed to her and lifted her up in my arms and run for shelter. I think the dream showed my deep pain of loss in hert was awaken by the horrable pictures I reviewed in internet recently. China is the place I was borned, at this moment my heart and preys comes to Sichung. All  Americans I know are deeply concerning Chinese people. I hope Chuan Tan and another friend from Baijing China know that American people are very passionate people. Talking about the media, maybe the two counties' reporting style are defferent, I saw reporters here discribing American desasters in the same way as they are talking about Sichuan situation now.The reported the leaders went to the desaster area at the same day which shows that it's better then some American leader.
I know how people get together to cope difficult situation in China. Now China is much stronger, I am sure Chinese people will overcome it and rebuild their homes!
Here all 1.3 billion chinese people are thinking the same thing how we can help for our brothers/sisters who are experiencing the big misery in the epicenter. can you imagine the blood center can't accommandate more blood donations? can you imagine the volunteers blocked the traffic? can you imagine how many eyes are fulfilled the tears on the live TV with the coutdown of rescue time after the earthquake?
 Please offer your help, here need your real help, about 3.5 millions people lost their houses, close to 30000 people lost their lives, about hundres of sodiers and medical workers are struggling to same more lifes in the epicenter.... no give up till last minutes to save the lifes under the debris.
I am an Englishman teaching English to the children and students of this great nation,and my heart goes out to everyone,and my personal thanks to everyone who organized everything so quickly and got things moving.I lived in the USA for over 15 years and all you hear from some Americans is whining and crying about what they want and are entitled to,some are never satisfied,be thankful for what you have and that you are still alive,when you get food and water...my hat goes off to the Chinese Government and all the people involved in the rescue of these poor people...


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1033971

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.