ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



Russia changes leadership; does it matter?

Posted: Wednesday, May 07, 2008 9:15 AM
Filed Under:

MOSCOW –  Russia inaugurated a new president today. And while there was never really any doubt or drama in the March presidential elections here – Dmitry Medvedev was assured of victory the moment Vladimir Putin announced him as his chosen successor – it is still a mystery what exactly this inauguration will mean for Russia.

Since the elections, Russian media and chat rooms have been trying to guess what the power balance will look like after Medvedev takes over the presidency and Putin becomes prime minister – which is expected as early as Thursday.

VIDEO: Who is Medvedev?

The question is: who will really be in charge? Can a "tandem-ocracy," with two leaders at the head, actually work – or will there be power struggles between the two? Media reports say Putin may have as many as 11 deputy prime ministers. The president is the stronger post on paper, but can Medvedev compete with the political capital that Putin enjoys?

Key to success – stability
For some Russians, it doesn’t really matter. Many people I spoke to had no idea when the inauguration is – which may be just the way the Kremlin wants it.

Masha Lipman, a Russia affairs expert at the Carnegie Moscow Center, said that Putin has established a "non-participation pact" with the Russian public. "People accepted it…as long as you deliver, we will not meddle in politics."

While Western media and governments may criticize what it perceives to be a rollback of democracy in Russia, many here simply want the stability, economic growth and newfound feeling of patriotic pride that Putin’s era brought to continue.

Enjoying a sunny day on Red Square this past weekend, retired teacher Irina Ivanova, 73, said she "hopes that the new president will be like Putin. The respect that he commands in the world…he’s beginning to lift this country up."

Part of Putin’s popularity here is due to the fact that he had such an easy act to follow – almost everyone I spoke to compared Putin’s era favorably to the chaos of Yeltsin’s.

"Putin is better than any president we’ve ever had," said Lina Fasulakis, a Moscow businesswoman. "Medvedev will be more of the same. He’s Putin’s chosen successor."

Younger generation – looking for more
But it looks like a simple comparison to the past may no longer be enough. While acknowledging Putin’s accomplishments, many feel the new president has to start delivering more concrete results. Sasha Zhukov, a 25 year-old engineer, said that the biggest problem is corruption.

"Putin hasn’t really done anything about it. We need more active reform," he said, waiting on line at McDonald’s outside the Kremlin walls.

These reforms include translating the petrorubles that Russia enjoys from high oil prices into actual improvements on the ground – better infrastructure, overhauling the healthcare system and figuring out a way to check inflation.

"All this money goes to the bureaucrats!" complained Yulya Ivanova, an industrial manager. "I love Russia, but I don’t love the Russian government. And Putin is …"

"Quiet!" Her mother, Larisa, cut her off. "If you say that about Putin, he’ll print it and then it’ll come back to hurt you!"

"We still have freedom of speech here, don’t we?" Yulya shot back.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

What was Ford's line? Oh yeah, "You can have any color you want, as long as you want black". In Russia, you are free to say anything you want, as long as you agree with the government.
Anything in print or even said loudly against the president will come back to hurt you.  The mother was absolutely right to quiet her daughter.  Way to go mom!  There is no freedom of speech in Russia.  Mom just proved it.
A puppet or not. It does not matter. You Westerners have a western mind. You think this way. When you think this way it is difficult to understand another culture. You only know it your way. Which is why you push around the world with you ideas. Worry about your country, and worry about your president. It doesn't look too bright on the American end considering the candidates. But, of course they aren't swayed or pushed by the money that brings them to power? Are they?
Putin has been and remains a Communist.  He has proven this by his actions as well as his words. As a devoted Communist he is in favor of the demise of Democracy, Capitalism and Freedom in Russia and throughout the world. He uses and tolerates companies and allows them to operate only for his benefit and will take action to steal assets as needed, as he did in the oil technology swindle in the guise of environmental issues. He smiles at U. S. and European political leaders as he takes action to undermine their countries.  He should not be trusted and he remains in control!  
Russia and russian will never change. Their history speaks for it's self. From muziks and czars to kommunist dictators. After all they love it, because they can not think for them selfs. They're already stripped of all the other countries. Thank God. No more borsc. Just like China just few people making billions on oil or crime like betting (maybe ex KGB }. Just stay away from the small europine countries. We don't want your pathetic culture and occupations anymore. Keep it at home under the ice.
There are no USA type elections in Russia, this man is Putin's choice not the people's choice, Russia does not have elections like the U S.  They are a communist country that has enslaved it's people for years.  This is just more of the same from Russia, the world is so gullable to think other wise.  I hope that more and more people are seeing the difference.  
I'm afraid Russia is sneakedly slipping back to Communism, not that it ever entirely disappeared. Medvedev is merely a puppet on Putin's string.

The whole world had better keep an eye on them.
With Medvedev being a Putin trained man this should be a smooth transition and a win-win for all. The bureaucratic complaints are a sign of a developing democracy at work. Imagine openly discussing politics at a MacDonalds in Russia!! Twenty years ago who could have dreamed?
I did visit Russia for the Olimpic Games in 1980. The Younger Generation is the only Prepared For Changes. The Yongers do not look on Regions. They are the only capable for Focusing in Iternational Affairs.
AL Colón
1027 C/ Flamboyán
Coto Laurel, PR 00780
Another insightful article about Russian political scene, along with lifestyle and attitudes. From all I read and some I have pleasure to speak with, life is improving there. It is too bad USA cannot just accept that they are making great progress, and report it more. It has opened itself up to western ideas, technologies, and cooperation very well. As for tandem-ocracy - it is alive and well in this country’s government for decades. It is just better disguised and layered here amongst government and corporate powers. Not much difference in many aspects of our seemingly opposite worlds. The Russians still love their children too... and are always a proud people like ourselves. :-)) they deserve the comfort to feel good about the manner in which life improves - despite the similar corruptions. Congratulations and support to the new leader Medvedev.
Russia has never had democracy or free speech in it's entire history-Genghis Khan, the Tsars, The Commies-so nothing has changed for them with this election.  The Russian people would be happy to live life without fear of starvation or being sent to Siberia.
This is all very nice, but did the Russian people as a whole elect this man.  Personally I think they should bring back the Imperial Family and have it done with.   Now that would be continuity and the people could elect a Prime Minister.
I think it is an extra-ordinary time for Russian history. For a start power passed to the next leader without a fanfare. Second, Putin who was very popular refused to change the consitution and lead for a third therm. Russia is rising from the ashes of history. It should be congradulated.
i hope these people dont get in trouble for what they have said
I would disagre with two things in this article. The quote obtained regarding Putin's activism against government corruption is a little inaccurate. Putin had made several internal purges of the local beaurocratic systems and worked to remove many of the corrupt officials within the federal system. By no means am I saying that the work is finished, far far far far from it. However I think Putin should be credited for his desire to lift the country up to a more stable Russia.


for example, my fiancee and her family, who formerly lived in Russia, told me how Putin fired many of the local officials of Astrohaun because of their embezzlement of state funds that were supposed to go towards historic restoration.

2nd. The implication made by the last two points regarding freedom of speech in Russia is the quite far-fetched when compared with reality. This sort of dictatorship scare about Russia is being spread by oil companies in the U.S who fear the nationalization of Russia's oil resources. Nothing more.
It doesn't really matter in reality. The Bolshevik Corporate Families - whatever their names and whatever country they reside in now - are still the controlling forces throughout the world and have forced many a governemt facade to be created and torn down as the scipts are written according to dictates of wanted history. Whether it be Washington,D.C or the Kremlin - the same rulers doing the experiment betwix the two still rule. It's just a matter of who they hire to do the maintainence on their creations.
Russia is moving in a direction of confrantation with USA...Putin is puting Russia back to the dark ages.
He is aligning himself with Iran and other terorists. He is also and imperilialist when it comes to neibors...Very sad for Russia. They can never get it right...Forsaking nation
"RUSSIA CHANGES LEADERSHIP; DOES IT MATTER?"
A great heading. Here is one to use after the November election:

"THE US CHANGES LEADERSHIP; IT WILL NOT MATTER!"
Yeah you are free to say anything you want in Russia, as long as you don't mind a bullet in the back of the head. And it is soon going to be that way here in America. The power of the government to do whatever it wants is increasing daily, as our rights go out the window. And everybody is supportive of it, as long as they can stay surrounded by their junk.!
Russian people are long accustomed to being ruled by autocrats, from the Czars to the Commissars.  Their brief exposure to democracy under Gorbachev frightened them more than necessary, and made much worse by the neglect from wealthy capitalist nations. The economic "shock therapy," which worked well in Poland, with its pre-communist experience with a stable government that put economic rules in place, could not possibly work with the Russians, who knew nothing of sensible regulation and therefore hungered for return to tyranny, leaving them vulnerably to the "oligarchs," who stole the nation's wealth and hid it in their personal wealth portfolios in Wall Street. Once again, the Republican Party championed the unethical fleecing of the poor by the rich, in Russia as in the U.S.A.  How many times will we let the dogs run free?
More than 70% of people in Russia don't care much about the politics in general and goverment of Russia in particular. I've lived there for 40 years. People live it's own life while government live it's own. These lives NEVER cross. Why do simple Russian should care who is the new nomenee? What's the difference for them? I don't really see any. That circus last March - also - who cares?
"I love Russia, but I don’t love the Russian government. And Putin is …"

"Quiet!" Her mother, Larisa, cut her off. "If you say that about Putin, he’ll print it and then it’ll come back to hurt you!"

"We still have freedom of speech here, don’t we?" Yulya shot back.

Yes, and you have the right to be punished for using it.  Having been to the Russia several times shortly after the fall of the Soviet Union, I am deeply disappointed in the way in which Russia politics has played out.  However, I now have a more clear understanding of the expression "You cannot escape the past".
What a trick Putin is pulling on the world. Anybody in the US who thinks this man is a democrat and really cares about Russia's people, needs to go back to the fifth grade. Putin looks on his home country and its people as the start of the map to crashing power over Europe. He really is not any better then
the communist wacko's. Everthing is for him. This is the thinking in his brain: "Screw democracy, put everything in "MY" dirty pockets, not the peoples. Everything is for him and his cronies. He has his eyes hard on Europe. He wants to own its economy, its land domanate/rule its people. Meanwhile, he is trying to hide his long time interest in dominating the US. This man is not democracy friendly, His actions and goals are to hurt and kill. Everything is for him, nothing good for the average citizen of Russia. He is a great cheatter who is eventually going to murder the people of Russia.
i am very frustrated to read commentaires of people , that have not idea about Russia.You do not know culture, religion or history of this great country.
Before judge country like Russia , come back to elementary school and learn something.
Your commentaires are smelling by hitlerism
Just one comment to my previous message.

E.g. you can't ask (in fact there is nobody to ask) why the goverment guy is using a VIP Tu-134 jet to fly twice a week Moscow to Rostov (1 h 20 min flight). He was offered this good position but...his wife doesn't want to leave Moscow. So he simply uses VIP jet every Monday and Friday. Every flight (round trip) cost about 30-40 thousand USD, which is paid by taxpayers money. Do you think anybody cares? No. He was flying for few years before he was promoted again...Guys, I tell you. Two different worlds, two different mentalities. We would never understand each others. And the question is - do we really need it?
Putin and Medvedev are both communists. Russia is in for some harsh times...again.
When Bush said he saw Putin's soul in his eyes, I laughed so hard I cried, and both were appropriate. The man is an ex-KGB thug; that wasn't his soul Bush saw, it was fire and death to all who oppose him. But Russia has always preferred its leaders to be powerful, charismatic men who bully their rivals. In that way, Putin is perfect. Will Medvev be any different? I don't know, but I do know that the sooner Bush gets out of office and stops his saber-rattling at Iran and even Russia, the better our relations will be with those countries. We'll have to watch and see; but we'll never get anywhere banging our head against Russia's brick wall.
The more I read comments on any subject about Russia, the more I understand how brain-washed you people are! American idiotism trully has no boundries! No freedom in Russia? You are affraid of your own shadows in your own country-go eat some more burgers and leave us alone. We are a free, souvereign nation with our own way of life and we don't need your retarded advise how to run our country. Worry about Paris Hilton or Britney Spears instead.
I'ts their culture not ours, how dare we tell them and any other country how to run their govt. As you can see ours is't so great right now - those in power -what a joke Bush's ratings with the public is the worst in history besides Truman. Congress well look at them and all the money they make !!!!
Communism, Capitalism,Democracy are all terms used by the true rulers of the world. In order for world peace and a way to rid the world of evil, we must stop living like puppets. Religion and governments are two of the biggest reasons we can not be one with each other. Hell, extraterrestrials wont even communicate with us due to religion and governments. People, we are born with nothing and we will die with nothing. Get that fact inbedded in your mind because you are the only one in charge of what is to be in the future. Can you just imagine how great this world would be if we had one people. I said one people not one government. Religion should be based on what you chose to believe. It is not wrong or right, however it should be based again by its believers not by a man appointed leader of the religion. Help me out people, we dont have very much longer to live the way we are living this life. I love my country, USA, however I dont believe any other country is less loved by its people. Can you only imagine how much we could accomplish if we had no barriers seperating countries or religions.
I love all these comments about Russia, freedom of speech, a few people making all the money and how we have it soooo much better here.

Here, where CEOs take home millions for failing while the working class gets peanuts. Here, where the Patriot Act has made significant inroads into Freedom of speech, expression, etc. Here, where librarians had to say no to the government wanting people's reading lists, the very government established to protect that freedom. Here, where Siberia is called Gitmo, where due process goes to die. Here, where Haliburton gets no-contract bids (how anticapitalist is that!). Here, where the myth that Soviet Russia was "communist" is perpetuated (totalitarian, yes, communist, no). Here, where people do just as lousy a job of thinking for themselves as anywhere, with a media that's not biased as much as it is useless.

So before you break your arms patting yourselves on the back, remember that we have plenty of dirt on our stoop to clean before we start looking at others.
Who remembers the German president Hindenburg? Nobody. But everybody remembers who was the German Chancellor at that time. His name was Adolf Hitler.

Who remembers the Russian president Kalinin? Nobody. But everybody remembers who was the Prime Minister at that time. His name was Joseph Stalin.

In a few years we'll be asking once again the same question and saying the same coda: Who remembers the Russian president Medveded? Nobody. But everybody remembers who was the Prime Minister at the time. His name was Vladimir Putin.

History repeating itself?

Sadly, under Putin Russia will become an ultranationalistic military dictatorship, worse than Nazi Germany and the USSR put together. The Russian people prefer to sacrifice their "democratic freedoms" as long as they can have STABILITY, ECONOMIC GROWTH, and RUSSIAN PATRIOTIC PRIDE. It's engrained in their "Love for RODINA, the Motherland."
To my recollection Nikita Krustshev was the Prime Minister.  Who was the President at that time?
Igor, before writting any comments. Learn some English friend.  
I think you Mr igor also need to join the rest of the people, you just referred to, in elementary school and re-learn some of that grammar. Although everyone is touting russia as still being run by commies, america is still being run by the elite. sure they give us a little here and there, and let us think we have control over our govt, which only ignorant fools think is true. In this case I think both sides are right and CCClute (wayyy above) hit it directly on the head.
Americans like to talk as experts about things they have absolutely no clue about. Having a tiny bit of knowledge is more dangerous than having none... You think you know what you are talking about, but really you don't. It is Fahrenheit 451 all over again.

Besides given the sad state of American empire, I would keep your mouth shut. Just take a look at our own presidential race here... what a sad lot, I think despite being a US citizen I am staying home this November.
Russia is what it is. We as Americans don't benefit from Russia's economy or any exports for that matter. So I say who cares.
Igor, that should be, "go back to elementary school...," unless of course you are still there perhaps learning the proper use of grammer and punctuation.  And please, don't drop a "smelling by Hitlerism" comment on me, Dawg.  

Don't silence the little man, or woman, let your daughter speek. Then we'll check back to see how she's doing in a couple days.
Its rather unfortunate, with all the technology and history Russia has, no-one has come to realize just how much of a threat they are to the United States.
Putin has already warned us of any actions taken against Iran, they would retaliate. They remain one of the most dire threats to the US. More than any other foreign country at this time. Nuclear weapons don't just disappear. The world needs to open their eyes! Russia has not changed. Their government will not allow it. They will be as silent predators and the blind shall not see.
Russians deserve to be oppressed. It is their own fault for not standing up to their goverment. I would die for my rights!!!
This message is for Daniel, Moscow, Russia who wrote above talking about how Westerner's mind sets are on tunnel vision, basically. The fact that you wrote what you wrote displays your complete ignorance. Not everyone is as narrow-minded as yourself so think before you write next time.
Good points all of you!  The statement that Russia prefers a strong authoritative government is accurate...just like the countries in the Middle East prefer a theocracy government or clan rule.  Yelstin created anarchy, while Putin restored order.  Despite the fact that Putin is NOT stepping down, Russians prefer this arrangment as long as there is stability!

But, looking at the big picture, the USA isn't much better concerning democracy at the Federal level.  We are given two choices, Democrat or Republican, and nothing else.  What many Americans don't realize is that most of these politicians are cut from the same cloth.  The last guy who actually tried changing the status quo was Kennedy...and look what happened to him and his brother!  Reagan made a lot of changes, but he worked within the system to make it happen.

The USA was set up as a Republic, NOT a true democracy.  We elect people (politicians) who supposedly represent the people, despite the fact that they actually represent their corporate constituents and special interest PACs. The founding fathers didn't want a real democracy because they feared that the uneducated populace would screw it up!  The only real choices we have are at the local and county (parish) level, where it is much easier to hold our elected officials accountable.

Putin worries me because he seems bent on restoring Russia's former glory, which often conflicts with Western ideology.  His latest actions in Georgia are a good point of reference.  Were it not for NATO and the EU, it wouldn't surprise me if Putin tried to force all of the former Soviet Republics back into the communist fold.  His new title of Prime Minister is nothing but smoke and mirrors, an effort to show his supposed respect of the Russian consitution.
Hey igor, easy to say from New Hampshire.  Your history and culture are proof of the complete subjugation of your country from the get-go. I've been to Moscow and it quickly becomes obvious that it will be centuries (if ever) before Russians will even understand living free. The people are satisfied with their lot and don't have the power or energy to try and change it.
Governments regardless of the country are just big machines, and it makes little to no difference who is "running them".  The president or leader is nothing more than a new coat of paint on the machine.  Presidents especially in the US matter little.  We could dig up Dick Nixon and throw his corpse in the Oval Office and the daily lives of Americans would be completely unchanged.  I think the same principle can be applied to Russia.
If Igor 'loves' mother russia so-much...............why is igor in america
The sad truth, is all governments are corrupt, some are better than others in hiding it, but in the end they are all the same. There is no more room in this world for idealistic leaders. Results are painted by the media which also bends over for money by the corrupt leaders it brings to power. True real individual thinkers are dead.
I love Americans disscusing Russia using old cliches. They do not know the difference between socialism and guerrilla communism, they belive they being run by "democrats" and they believe they have free mass media. They do not know that Russia today is 100% looks like America in 1960s and current US economics is basically what Russia had in 1980 on a brink of collapse. Do not call Putin a communist. Russia is free market capitalist country which rapidly rebuild its infrastructure as one of main world power using slave labor (millions illegal immigrants). Do not call US a capitalist free market country - it is in fact socialist state run by handful of huge corporations and banks. Lion share of the buissness activity goes around government spending. In fact, back in 1980s Russia was well developed socialist state (current western european style) with biggest economy in the world and very high standards of living (higher than America has right now). Americans and young russians do not know it. Ignorance is a blessing. You can call USSR a communist state, but it is a cliche. North Korea is a communist state. Cuba is a communist state. Russia was never a communist state. And by the way, you know what Russians say? "-As long as we have a real freedom we do not need a fake western democracy!". Go check your credit score. Your entire life depends on it. Dealing with KGB was much more easier thing than living with credit, criminal and all of the types of different histories your "freedom loving" country invented so far. Sometimes, beetwen  taking prozak and watching soap opera just think that you, sitizens of America, are not the subjects to LAW system any more, you're subjects to scores system developed by handful of greedy individuals who took over your Country. You do not need the LAW and courts any more. As long as all judgments are being done based on credit scores and payment history you're destined to be a "free" people, as long as you're being told you are.  
Vladimir Putin, Dmitry Medvedev, Barack Obama,
Hillary Clinton are all the same.  Communists in Democratic, Socialist, Marxist clothing.  You get what you vote for.  Suck it up America (or should I spell it Amerika?)
Dan in Moscow: you aptly point out that money influences power, and you are correct that the Western mind does not entirely understand the East (of course, do people in the East really understand the West? Not likely)
However, one difference is that here, nobody is worried about saying, "I hate G. W. Bush" and then disappearing.
Our country has its politics, certainly. A CIA agent's cover might be blown here for political reasons, but they aren't poisoned with polonium like FSB chiefs.  
Moreover, there will almost always be political fallout in the U.S. when dirty politics is played.  The Russian government's silence regarding Litvinenko is deafening.

Igor, in NH: Criticism of Putin is not criticism of Russia. Perhaps this is a "western" view, but we easily hold the two separate. Calling something "Hitlerism" does not make it so. Fascism suppresses free thought and dialogue. Whatever you dislike about these comments, they are an open exchange of ideas.
Hitler wanted to subjugate Russia; we want to see Russians less controlled by their government. Kind of anti-Hitler, don't you think?
By the way, New Hampshire is a long way from Russia; it must not be too bad living amongst us ignorant Americans!



SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=989406

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.