ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



Mood turns ugly in Beijing

Posted: Friday, April 18, 2008 2:16 PM
Filed Under:

By Adrienne Mong, NBC News producer

What a difference a couple of months can make.

As people returned to work following the end of the Chinese New Year holidays in February, there was a palpable sense of anticipation for the Olympic Summer Games. The intense winter cold snap lasted longer than the holidays, but there was a spring in everyone’s step.

Friends working in professions as diverse as business and the arts spoke of an accelerated rate of activity; people seemed to be jetting back and forth from the United States and Europe in a frenzy to meet deadlines on special projects before the Games begin August 8.

Image: Protests in China
AP
Chinese youths protest outside a Carrefour supermarket, a French owned company, in Qingdao in east China's Shandong province on April 18. 

My e-mail inbox was getting clogged on a more regular basis with press conference notices from the Beijing Olympic authorities, BOCOG. And I was fielding dozens of requests from far-flung friends to crash on the floor of my apartment in the months leading up to August.

It was as though Beijing had become the center of the world and everyone wanted to be here.

And then, the protests and violence in Tibet and surrounding regions happened.

In response to international condemnation of its policies in Tibet, the Chinese government has taken a hard line against critics. At the same time, Chinese people have become more upset over what they perceive as Western media bias against their nation. 

Targeting the Western press
CNN has been the target of intense criticism and threats for allegedly biased coverage of the protests in Tibet, and particularly for remarks made by commentator Jack Cafferty, who referred to China’s leaders – not the Chinese people – as a "bunch of goons and thugs."

On Thursday, CNN’s bureau chief in Beijing was summoned to China’s Foreign Ministry, where officials demanded an apology and a retraction of Cafferty’s comments. 

CNN has apologized for any offence, and Cafferty clarified on air earlier in the week that his comments were referring specifically to the government and "not to Chinese people or to Chinese-Americans."

But even before this latest incident, we had heard from CNN staff that non-essential personnel had been asked to stay away from the CNN Beijing office because threats from angry Chinese activists were growing serious.

A Chinese friend who once worked for CNN learned Friday that his name and personal information had been posted on one of the more virulent anti-Western media Web sites in China. He said he was shocked by the coarse language people used to accuse him of being a traitor.

Not just CNN
An acquaintance at a top-selling U.S. newsmagazine described an incident in which someone rang the doorbell of her home and tried to set off a fire extinguisher in her face when she opened the front door.

NBC News hasn’t been subject to the same level of harassment as some other media outlets, but for several weeks now in the late evenings our bureau has received prank phone calls from Chinese people asking whether we are CNN or just randomly cursing all Western media.

The anxiety isn’t confined to journalists.

Chinese furious over how the Olympic torch was received in Paris on April 7 are planning a demonstration Saturday in front of a branch of the French supermarket, Carrefour. And a more widespread boycott of all Carrefour branches planned for May 1 is gathering steam.

A friend with French relatives coming to visit Beijing next week is anxious about how they might be treated and is reluctant to leave them on their own to explore the capital.

In a way, however, this French family is lucky they can even be here.

Crackdown on visitors and residents
Chinese authorities are cracking down on entry visas. Reports are circulating among U.S. businessmen that many companies are starting to suffer from a restriction on business visas for legitimate employees.

Every foreign freelancer or independent contractor I know here is looking for a sponsor, as they’ve been warned their current – and legitimate – business visas are not likely to be renewed. Even a college student whom NBC agreed to take on for the summer has had to cut short his internship, because he won’t be allowed to extend his student visa beyond August 1; extending a visa was previously a common practice.

It’s believed that the visa restrictions are to prevent foreign activists from entering China ahead of the Olympics and staying through the games.  

One of our local staffers told me that five security people showed up at her home at 9:30 p.m. Wednesday, pounding on her front door and demanding to see her local residency permit. They were rude, she said, and they examined parts of her apartment without her consent.

"They wanted to know if I was the only one living here," she said.

Of course, some of this might appear trivial compared to the domestic political housecleaning taking place across China. Many dissidents or potential noisemakers have been rounded up since December. 

In the wake of these incidents, one can only wonder if this is the image China’s government and its people really want to present to the outside world as they prepare to host an Olympics bearing the banner "One World One Dream."

Perhaps not. A commentary posted on the state-run Xinhua news agency Web site Friday urges the Chinese people to contain their "patriotic zeal." 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Thank God!!! Maybe China will sooner show it's true colors and we can disconnect ourselves from them before it is too late. Right now, the hold over one trillion dollars in U.S. assets and currency. If we anger them, today, they can do us a lot of harm... all because of corporate greed and stupid blind politcian's allowing this to happen. If we continue down the globalization path we are on, they can wreck us entirely. It's time for this country to wake up to the dangers of outsourcing, free trade, guest workers (like Bill Gate's cheap Indian and Chinese H1-B engineers Microsoft and other high tech companies use to displace American engineers and programmers).
Kudos, Benet! You were spot-on with your analysis. Oh, how self-righteous we become when we forget to look in the mirror...
What do people expect from a communist, totalitarian government? American corporations have salivated at the propect of making money by setting up businesses there. They have supported communists, aided and abetted totalitarian rulers--ie, sold out humanity for the sake of filthy lucre. These same corporate people allied themselves to Hitler, Mussolini, and Franco. They know one thing only--profit, even at the expense of justice, righteousness, and goodness. They are the real enemies, for they know better.
If the Chinese want to continue to make the situation even uglier...they will see countries seriously consider boycott the games completely
 Tibet has been a part of China for hundreds, if not thousands, of years.  The Dalai Lama has asked for autonomy for the region, not to secede.  Although, why "now" could be the question, since he has been politcally involved in this since he has been exiled.

 We in the "Western" world do not look at things the same way a those in the "Eastern" world, and quite often it is our way, or the highway.  So, now it seems that China is saying our way, or the highway, and we "Westerners" are ticked off.  I may not agree with China's human rights issues, and the world has a collective right to have the Chinese government answer those questions.  Although, we must all look at our own histories, as well.
 
 The Chinese people are a diverse people and have a wonderfully historic culture.  This is a time of celebrating all cultures and diversity, and I plan to watch as much of the Olympics as I can.  Let the games begin.      
Boycott!  The only resaonable response from any reasonable country or athlete.
I still don't know how the IOC awarded the Olympics to China, I plan to boycott the olympics by not watching.
MONEY, MONEY, MONEY... People who are claiming "the athletes have trained their whole lives" for this chance have missed the point - the athletes have a chance to say I have trained my whole life for my chance - and it's worth it to me to say NO to your government, NO to your brutality... But they won't. It's about money. Why hasn't NBC been the target like CNN - because NBC is owned by GE - one of the largest money-grubbing corporations in the world. They can't wait to get into China to reap their rewards...
Wake up America... You're being treated worse and blinded by your television and the media...
Rob from Washington likes to compare the American government to that of China.

Rob that's why this country has headed down hill because people like you don't appreciate what you have here.

Why don't you simply move over seas so you don't have to be suppressed by this government!

Enjoy your frappuccino and shut your pie hole you don’t sound radical or hip !
Jim, Phoenix, AZ

hey liberal, those people can choose to live how ever they want...reminds me of those Arizonians who live in a desert with no resources except for what the rest of us give them...shoe goes on either foot...they have room in China for you too
until America and Americans send a message with their wallets China and its government have no reason to change. We love the cheap goods that are made there.quit buying anything made there and they will have to change.
Leave China alone. Theyre still better than US who go to other people's lands and bomb women and children just for oil.
...China wanted to be on the world stage and the Olympics was a forum they wanted to host
...the Olympics have in modern history ALWAYS been a forum for political statements -- this is NOT news
...China had (and still has) a golden opportunity to increase it's stature in the way it treates Tibet.  It has woefully failed to capitalize on that
...Chinese dignity will not bow to Western pressure, but by setting up the farce of a global torch relay while not proactively showcasing relations with Tibet, they have becoming a laughing stock.  And why?
... Tibet is too small to be a problem for China
... Tibet is a magnet of dreams (Everest, the Dalai Lama) and China is failing to capitalize on that
... AND IMPORTANTLY
... the rest of the world is NOT interested in being the backdrop for Chinese government propaganda.  No one made them march the torch all around the world
... China wants to celebrate its entrance onto the world stage as host of a global celebration, but it seems to be tone deaf to the concept of orchestrating its presence in a world that will join in that celebration, but only as participants, not detainees
You Americans are full of double-standards and hypocrisy. I will admit though that your media plays a major part in this. Almost feel sorry for you
LISTEN AMERICA, we have to show more intelligence and love as a people. I shouldnt have to bring up our own past, such as the treatment of American indians, slaves, and some of our own families and peoples on the streets, in our homes or even in traffic today. Even the Dali Lama isn't talking protest or a seperate Tibet. Reguardless if America and China will never see eye to eye, it is OUR responsibility to keep a positive line of communication or we will end up with a much bigger problem. I lived in China for 2 years and we dont want to get over a billion people into a mob mentality based on patiotism of their own. Lets stop pushing like 10 year old kids, calling names, and forgetting that we have plenty of problems of our own. Do we want results or do we just really want to do something reguardless of the outcome? Talk of protest will only hurt the atheletes, and judgments will only end up back at our front door.
Weiyang in Berkeley,CA (as oppossed to Beijing China), you are correct to say that a superpower will have many enemies.....it's a convenient tactic until tyranny comes calling....then the US becomes the savior.  Certainly we Americans don't agree with our government's foriegn decisions and actions........and we openly protest them!....as you must see in Berkeley........but the comments made here on this site don't demean a love for China's rich culture, history and people.....only it's bullying government......much like we do our own when it's out of hand.......as it currently is.  This is how free people think.  Surely living in America you can understand that, so be a responsible free person and voice your opinion on human rights.  It's yours and every Chinese persons right and obligation to the world!
I think if we start coming down to hard on China they might begin to hate us and then begin to put deadly substance in  some of our goods we have them my for us. OH MY GOD WHAT A NIGHT MARE!
Will someone please tell me where I can find something that is not made in China? Macy's, Nordstrom, Lord and taylor down to Wal-mart, Target, JCPenny. Show me something that is not made in China. I'm talking ordinary shoppers here, not Gucci or Prada, etc.
Rob from Washington, if you think it so bad here, move to China and see what those comments would have gotten you there. I trip to a very dark cell at best,at worst,you wouldn't be here any longer
Once again, it is easy to see that the Chinese are being attacked in the media because they are not Americans. We can attack country after country, but we still want to criticize others about their human rights while we admittedly torture people. We need to reread the Golden Rule. If China did what the USA has done, we would be at war with them. It is so embarassing to be a citizen of a country with so many hippocrates!
I always get a chuckle when the Hate-Crowd uses anything like this as an excuse to bash the U.S. President also, kinda like Rob from Washington did above. Geesh....talking about narrow-minded.

On the actual topic of the article, initially I felt that we needed to continue with the games, so as to separate sports & politics. However, seeing China's recent actions & attitude, I'm leaning towards a full boycott. Or better yet, just don't even acknowledge that they exist. Bring all the athletes home & just ignore anything associated with the games.

That is usually the best way to knock an idea into someone's head. People HATE being ignored.
Benet Garcia, Seattle Wash

the western media can't "just report the news"...look at the liberal bias they put on the news in our own country...Joe McCarthy tried to tell us
   Communist Chinese government is clout with imperialism. We should recognize their current territorial disputes with Japan and ASEAN (oh so little countries you are!!)  countries which it silently impressed the latter with their latest weight throwing economic and military subleties (lately). Incidentally,  these pressures from this eastern giant should be brought into the UN or World Court.
   They have been pushing, punishing the truly democratic Chinese nationals of Taiwan and around the globe since the 50's and continually squeeze the natural course of the Tibetan people and we shall not forget, despite the demise of the USSR, the Maoist underlings showing their recent distinctive color among the nations around China (Burma, Thailand, Philippines et. al) and South America without mentioning the economic assault in Africa and the Iran issue.

THESE ARE SIMPLY NEED TO BE ADDRESSED, REVIEWED AND ACTED UPON FOR THE NEXT 50 YEARS.

Hello WalMart, are you guys listening?  Everything I pick up there has "made in China" on it.  Here's the REAL boycott, come on folks "vote" with your pocketbook.  Get their attention!!
Sr. Pinot: Tibet was a sovereign nation with a rich history of independence going back a couple of thousand years, until the PRC invaded and subjugated it in 1950.  What is happening now in China and Tibet is the real face of the Chinese government, not the phony smile they put on in order to put our dollars in their pockets.  Make no mistake: China is nobody's friend, least of all ours.  
Better be nice to China without them we will be running around without underware,shoes,socks,&
no computer's.We need them to produce all these
item's for us.We have so many law's & tax's that
these so called politican's jam down our throats.
China pump's Billion's of Dollar's in there factories
All high tech super modern.

It is better & eaiser to have it shipped over here
then go through all the red tape to have anything made over here.And if you own the building that you produce item's in your property tax's look like an oversea's phone number. Hell let's put up a Chinease flag on all our buildings.


And I would love to thank G.M. for building the largest engine making plant in the world over there.The only thing different between a Communist & a Capitalist is the Communist has the job's & all the Money.
Due to the high pay union wants for there employees.

It Has a population of what 5 Billion, U.S. Has a population of
200 Million & look at the problem's we face.
China pump's Billion's of Dollar's in there factories
All high tech super modern. While our's are delapated
Our Government does nothing. Our economy is in shamble's. Look at katrina point your finger at that,
Still year's later & take a look. People have a short memory.
Im sure China will work out there problem.


Shawn, do you really think that any of our "leaders"give a hoot what you as an individual says
I really don't understand how my fellow Americans can attack China, when we have so much housekeeping to do at home.  What about the folks at Guantanomo? What is going on with the war in Iraq?  Remember Abu Gharib?  I love the U.S. and the right to freedom of speech, but we have to finish our accounting at home first
Apparently western media and culture has forgotten how wrong it is to speak ill of foreign dignitaries. Blatant disrespect for authority has it consequences. Lucky it was only a call to the Chinese foreign bureau, with hat in hand, for an apology.

In the future, I offer some suggested phrases properly describing the Chinese leadership position on Tibet within acceptable bounds of free speech:
-Illegal occupiers (or better yet foreign occupiers)
-Repressors (although debatable as Tibet is an autonomous zone allowing some religion)

Evil speaking outside of the bounds of good journalism, and common sense:
-Goons and thugs

Instead of slandering Chinese leadership, it might be better to recognize that 100% of Chinese consider respect for authority as a high virtue. Considering, that the Chinese may consider ruling Tibet a ‘manifest destiny’, not unlike the U.S. conquest of the west. It is foolish for the U.S. media to take sides. No good can result. I pity Tibetans when the U.S. media gets involved.
Communist through social reform, capitalistic through economic reform. As economic events such as the olympics bring China to the spotlight, the shadows of society within the Communistic regigm can not but help be in the spotlight as well. Hopefully, the olympic committee took this into account when rewarding China its' spotlight. I doubt it concerned itself a decade ago with the fact that economic reform in China does not equate social reform. After traveling to several of the Chinese economic districts, I must say the world is naive. China and its' government will remain corrupt to maintain power. Power to opress, power to destroy the environment through economic progress, power to dominate the region and control the world economy.
The Chinese are so self centered. I have dealt with them for over 40 years as a "co-asian". So Chin centric that they cannot comprehend why anyone would not like their dominance. The Tibetians should co-align  to the Tianamen Sq uprising to point out that the Chinese crush freedom wheather Tibetian or Chinese. In fact, the Chinese people themselves should rise up and join the Tibetians to raise their own level or human rights in their own country.
kj

we are thinking Vietnam here...63,000 dead...Kennedy sent them to die...North Vietnam never attacked us...China has had every opportunity to handle this situation like human beings...so far they have failed the test

To Jim in phoenix Az.  Do you meen just like the worthless standing on just about every street corner
in the city. You know the ones , they have no natural
resources, they don't produce anything and expect charity all the time.
Interesting, there is no comments from any Chinese society, concluded by the names.

Is MSNBC has no influence on these specific audience or all other voice have been filtered(aka censored)?
To "9th step"...who do you think was in Viet Nam?  The hard core Chinese and financing it also.  They don't stay home, they just keep it low key, but they are very active in supporting a lot of the S*** going on in the world.
Reading these posts is instructive.  First, if they are truly representative of the writing skills of the average American, then the American educational system is broken.  Simple grammatical errors abound up above.  At least run your posts through Word and SpellCheck before you put them online.  Second, make the distinction between the people of China and the government that does not represent them but controls them.  Condemning the Chinese because of the actions of their government is wrong.  Make the distinction and don't insult them.  Third, most people posting above do seem to "get it."  The People's Republic of China's government is totalitarian, corrupt, and could care less about human rights.  Unfortunately, many Chinese take criticism of their country's dictatorship as criticism of them and their culture.  This is not so.  We all hoped that the Olympics might signal a turning point in China's evolution into a country with an accountable government.  To the chagrin of the world, it appears to be backtracking on all its promises.  Wake up, Beijing!  You are looking more and more like Berlin in 1936.  Finally, shame on the IOC for giving the Olympics to a dictatorship.  The IOC is a closed "gentlemen's club" that conducts its business behind closed doors and needs to be dragged out into the sunlight.  Come to think of it, there are more parallels between the IOC and the dictatorship running China than there are between the IOC and the liberal democracies of the world.
When Tibet was invaded in the 1950's the world did NOTHING.Tens of thousands of monks and nuns have been tortured and imprisoned;ditto for other Tibetan citizens' rights,not to mention  priceless knowledge,artifacts,temples and homes.Tibet was self -supporting and has asked for autonomy. Communism makes no room for freedom,religious or otherwise.If we continue to tolerate this  behaviour we disown our own principles as a free country [although China owns a great deal of American debt]and perhaps that is a quid pro quo of sorts...I say ,BOYCOTT! ITS JUST TOO BAD THE PEOPLE AND CULTURE SUFFER FOR THE STUPIDITY OF THE GOVERNMENT.
Lets not forget to call China's Tibet policy what it is....genocide.  Just like the oil magnates...Bush/Cheney/Rice.. were guilty of genocide in the initial bombing of Iraq  (100,000 killed vs estimated 90,000 to 140,000 killed in dropping nuclear bomb on Hiroshima)
Do not buy any products made in China and encourage your friends as well.
How about a REAL boycott -- one of companies that advertise on TV coverage of the Beijing olympics? Now THAT might do some good!
We should stop buying Chinese-made products and we should totally boycott the Olympics. Many of our problems at home are caused by the fact that millions upon millions of good manufacturing jobs have been moved to China.  If we stop buying Chinese goods we will send a good message to China, and to our own "leaders" here at home who have allowed all those jobs to be lost.
Everything here in the USA was shipped from China.
Except automobiles. How much fuel was used to do that???
Money for Gas & oil from my pocket to give to the rich. EXPLOTATION AT ITS FINEST!!!!!!!!!
Also pres I need a job...........
Welcome China the past is finally catching up to you. I'm surprized the media has not linked the events in Tibet and Tianemen Square and put the spotlight right on the Communist Regime.I only hope the Chinese leaders "lose face" enough to change!!
Oh, please read books before placing stupid opinions, you don't know who Tibet belongs to, you are just following the stupid media, which has owners with political agendas.
No wonder people hate Americans so much, always giving opinions about everything while knowing nothing.
Can't handle Iraq and now are trying to pick on China, bunch of fools.
All this retoric is beautiful and am in agreeance
when people condemn human rights violations, but
as one well knows americans are the biggest consumers
of chinese products,and how many of us shop at wal=mart?
Mario Muniz, read up on your history and you will find that what you are saying is not true. Tibet was a sovereign nation invaded by China,not some rogue province wanting independence. It's not the same as the south wanting to be free from the north in the American civil war. If we were to invade Mexico and then put our foot on the necks and try to eliminate their culture and then they wanted to be free, that would be a batter analogy
China is just a little behind in the human rights arena. just like Europe was behind the US when it came to democracy. But then Europe got a little ahead of the US when it came to the abolishing of slavery.
Each country move at its own pace. Is china moving in the right direction?
I spent considerable time in china 1989-1992 consulting for an American Firm. I found the people very nice and hospitable but their system of Govt. stinks. I have regrets now, thinking by helping them, I have sold out my country. I and my wife avoid purchasing any China made products. Negotation with their system is a myth. They only negotate on their terms. Been there. Al Pennsylvania
If Tibet was really an integral part of China why have the Chinese been committing physical, cultural and social genocide in Tibet for decades? International corporate interests have made sure that governments and the United Nations look the other way. A total boycott of the Olympic Games is the only thing that will save the Tibetan people from total extinction.
Larry from FL, what really is ruining this country is ignorant people such as yourself. You dont appreciate the dangers that the Bush administration has cast across this country, with the destructive policies and simplified actions it has commited over the years. Why dont you pack up your trailer and move across the border to mexico. We need to seriously clean this country of its white trash.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=917308

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.