ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



Mood turns ugly in Beijing

Posted: Friday, April 18, 2008 2:16 PM
Filed Under:

By Adrienne Mong, NBC News producer

What a difference a couple of months can make.

As people returned to work following the end of the Chinese New Year holidays in February, there was a palpable sense of anticipation for the Olympic Summer Games. The intense winter cold snap lasted longer than the holidays, but there was a spring in everyone’s step.

Friends working in professions as diverse as business and the arts spoke of an accelerated rate of activity; people seemed to be jetting back and forth from the United States and Europe in a frenzy to meet deadlines on special projects before the Games begin August 8.

Image: Protests in China
AP
Chinese youths protest outside a Carrefour supermarket, a French owned company, in Qingdao in east China's Shandong province on April 18. 

My e-mail inbox was getting clogged on a more regular basis with press conference notices from the Beijing Olympic authorities, BOCOG. And I was fielding dozens of requests from far-flung friends to crash on the floor of my apartment in the months leading up to August.

It was as though Beijing had become the center of the world and everyone wanted to be here.

And then, the protests and violence in Tibet and surrounding regions happened.

In response to international condemnation of its policies in Tibet, the Chinese government has taken a hard line against critics. At the same time, Chinese people have become more upset over what they perceive as Western media bias against their nation. 

Targeting the Western press
CNN has been the target of intense criticism and threats for allegedly biased coverage of the protests in Tibet, and particularly for remarks made by commentator Jack Cafferty, who referred to China’s leaders – not the Chinese people – as a "bunch of goons and thugs."

On Thursday, CNN’s bureau chief in Beijing was summoned to China’s Foreign Ministry, where officials demanded an apology and a retraction of Cafferty’s comments. 

CNN has apologized for any offence, and Cafferty clarified on air earlier in the week that his comments were referring specifically to the government and "not to Chinese people or to Chinese-Americans."

But even before this latest incident, we had heard from CNN staff that non-essential personnel had been asked to stay away from the CNN Beijing office because threats from angry Chinese activists were growing serious.

A Chinese friend who once worked for CNN learned Friday that his name and personal information had been posted on one of the more virulent anti-Western media Web sites in China. He said he was shocked by the coarse language people used to accuse him of being a traitor.

Not just CNN
An acquaintance at a top-selling U.S. newsmagazine described an incident in which someone rang the doorbell of her home and tried to set off a fire extinguisher in her face when she opened the front door.

NBC News hasn’t been subject to the same level of harassment as some other media outlets, but for several weeks now in the late evenings our bureau has received prank phone calls from Chinese people asking whether we are CNN or just randomly cursing all Western media.

The anxiety isn’t confined to journalists.

Chinese furious over how the Olympic torch was received in Paris on April 7 are planning a demonstration Saturday in front of a branch of the French supermarket, Carrefour. And a more widespread boycott of all Carrefour branches planned for May 1 is gathering steam.

A friend with French relatives coming to visit Beijing next week is anxious about how they might be treated and is reluctant to leave them on their own to explore the capital.

In a way, however, this French family is lucky they can even be here.

Crackdown on visitors and residents
Chinese authorities are cracking down on entry visas. Reports are circulating among U.S. businessmen that many companies are starting to suffer from a restriction on business visas for legitimate employees.

Every foreign freelancer or independent contractor I know here is looking for a sponsor, as they’ve been warned their current – and legitimate – business visas are not likely to be renewed. Even a college student whom NBC agreed to take on for the summer has had to cut short his internship, because he won’t be allowed to extend his student visa beyond August 1; extending a visa was previously a common practice.

It’s believed that the visa restrictions are to prevent foreign activists from entering China ahead of the Olympics and staying through the games.  

One of our local staffers told me that five security people showed up at her home at 9:30 p.m. Wednesday, pounding on her front door and demanding to see her local residency permit. They were rude, she said, and they examined parts of her apartment without her consent.

"They wanted to know if I was the only one living here," she said.

Of course, some of this might appear trivial compared to the domestic political housecleaning taking place across China. Many dissidents or potential noisemakers have been rounded up since December. 

In the wake of these incidents, one can only wonder if this is the image China’s government and its people really want to present to the outside world as they prepare to host an Olympics bearing the banner "One World One Dream."

Perhaps not. A commentary posted on the state-run Xinhua news agency Web site Friday urges the Chinese people to contain their "patriotic zeal." 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

They want the international money coming into China,  they want the work for their people,  they want the technology,  they want to look like a free people,  but it is still alot like the old China.
 And American bussiness give it to them and take jobs away from americans so they can put more money in their pockets. Shame on greedy American Bussinesses.  Anything for a buck
Maybe the only way those Chinese "patriots" might "get it" is if (a) people started giving serious thought to boycotting the Beijing Olympics, and (b) in the future the Olympic Committee think twice about scheduling the Games in places with totalitarian regimes.
CHINA IS STILL IN THE DARK AGES WHEN IT COMES TO FREEDOM OF SPEACH.
The Chinese government very obviously fails to understand the implications of it's actions and instead of minimizing the issue makes it worse. We should have a good understanding of that since our own Bush administration seems to suffer from many of the same issues.
It is apparent we have all forgotten China continues to be communist controlled country.  What do we really expect .  Their true colors do come out.....  
Is any of this a surprise?  Remember Tiananmen Square?  Remember the rape of Tibet and the ongoing brutal occupation of that peaceful country? Just because greedy business people in Western countries make make money by dealing with China, doesn't change the reality that China is a brutal dictatorship that deserves the privilege of hosting the Olympics about as much as Myamar and North Korea would.
China,
Welcome to the real world!
Nice job on the overdone nationalism, Chinese government.

Fortunately, "double-edged sword" translates into Mandarin.
Unbelievable. If China had a genuine open society there would be no debate. Do any diligent research on China's human rights record, especially Tibet, and you will understand that the emperor is naked people. This isn't about nationalism or patriotism and Tibetan acts of terrorism. It's about the largest most well-organized despotic, brutally tyrannical regime on planet earth. Why make nice about that. Call it what it is. It's not the Chinese people or culture that's under fire. Most thinking people on earth would readily agree that Chinese culture and history is one of the magical wonders of the earth. Let me be very clear; what we're talking about is the boot of totalitarian authority being pushed down on the neck of the people - that's us - you and me; and that's wrong, and should be resisted at all times and in every place.
Just more reason for boycotting the Olympics in China, I personally cant see how any atheletes would want to perform there, I would be afraid that they would be detained or arrested if they won over a Chinese in the games.  Maybe this is over reating but then isnt that what China is doing already
If one wishes to stand on the center of the world stage, one must be prepared for both the good and the bad.  To use another cliche, if you can't stand the heat, get away from the fire.  China apparently wants to be a part of the world community without abiding by accepted world standards of openess and related scrutiny.  One would think they would save their vengeance until the Olympics have concluded rather than prove some of the protestors right.  Boycott anyone?
You treat China and the Chinese people as your enemy, you get what you asked for. This is such a simple human reaction that many so called 'human right' preachers are never able to admit. But who cares? America has probably more enemy in the world than any other coutry does. If this is what takes to be a superpower, then surely we will live with it.
Mark my word, these Chinese communist fanatics will yet start a nuclear World War 3, and if my guess is correct, sooner rather than later.
This is the true face of the Chinese government. I spent a month in China in 2004 and came home with a true appreciation of the Bill of Rights. They are an absolute totalitarian country. A massive boycott of the Olympics might get their attention. China is a menace.
I've really heard just about enough on all this Chinese Olympic crap and there continued crackdown on Civil rights activism. I for 1 just one person say to hell with their olympics and all the coverage, I will not watch nor will I purchase any products from any of the olympic sponsors. If we are really in favor and support all peoples civil rights lets make a real stand here where the whole world can really see what the fight is all about. If AMERICA really supports civil rights for all people of this planet I urge all AMERICANS to BOYCOTT the Beiging Summer Olympic Games in any manner you choose. Either your for total and absolute Civil Rights or your not. There is no middle ground....  
If government's would vote with their checkbook and not their mouths, China would be in a very bad position right now. Instead they are hosting the 2008 Olympics and getting more support than ever. I believe it is time for all the world to speak and change their buying habits to reflect their beliefs.
It is still 'Red China' to me. An oppressive, closed, Communist regime is in charge. Anyone or any organization dealing with them basically deserves whatever they get. I wouldn't watch 10 seconds of an Olympics from this country.
"Patriotic zeal."  Ha!  That's the understatement of the week.  
Tit-for-tat.  Its time we stopped buying Chinese products, as far as possible.  Make a small token, try to at least buy one item a day from a source other than China.
I will not pretend to support in any way the horrific manner in which the chinese government and some of its people are conducting themselves.  And perhaps a reconsideration may need to happen for many participating in the games in China. But I also sense there is a responsibility on the part of western media to simply report the news and to leave their opinions to themselves. Freedom of speech is an American right not a Global one. And journalists here and abroad have no qualms about presenting their filter of "their" views. In many ways inciting much of the backlash that is now occuring. There is a lot of bad behavior from papparazzi, news media, political analyists  etc. And there is no accountability or recourse for those harmed or insulted by it. We should be careful about "throwing stones" at China. As a talk show host recently said "If the games where held in the US, we would have to boycott ourselves based on our recent human rights violations". Why doesn't the media report on that?
Well said, Tim from Portland. I love the country of China and the people are the best. American's go to other countires and kill people in that country. China historically has stayed home and killed each other.
Is anyone really surprised about human rights violations going on in China? This county is a dictatorship, not a democracy. The only difference between China and the former USSR is that the Chinese government was smart enough to embrace free trade. Now, with an increasing military build-up, plus china owning most of America's debt, this county is set to overtake the USA within a decade at the earliest.
I am totaly on China's side on this one. People should be thankful that China has taken on the burden of supporting Tibet. Those people live on a desolate mountain with no natural resources; they don't produce anything; they dont sell anything. If it were not for China, Tibet would rely on the charity of the world.
I plan on boycotting the Olympics this year.  It is obvious the Olymic Committe made a terrible mistake picking China as a place to hold the Olympics.  BOYCOTT THE OLYMPICS IN '08.  That is the only way we can to exprss our disappointment in the Committee and our anger in what is taking place in China.
Is this an internal issue of the Chinese? What is the issue? What relationship Tibet will have with China? For example if the South wanted to secede from the Union would we welcome other countries meddling and giving them encouragement to form their own nation? (Assuming the North did not want them to go). What human rights are being violated in Tibet? I think I saw the Dalai Lama said he wanted the games to go on in China. I have the impression that Tibet was a backward province of pre-communist China.
It's such an irony that the government would approve such demonstrations just because it's anti-west. If it's a demonstration against the government or any leaders, it'd be cracked down, people arrested and jailed, possibly shot at. That's China's demonstration policy. If it's a demonstration you can see publicly, you know it's backed by the government. I'm not even for the Tibetan independence, but I just can't stand the hyposcricy of Chinese government. If you are really ok with demonstrations, then allow other demonstrations, such as Tian An Men square demonstration in 1989 where students just sat there and starving themselves, asking for freedom of journalism and speech. But no, they sent in the tanks instead.
Wonder if George W. will go to war with the Chinese to free Tibet?  oops, forgot, Tibet has no oil.
Xenophobia if there ever was any.  The Chinese owe thier national pride to the free world who have seen fit to out-source all of goods and jobs to their country.   Try buying an American made product today...Good Luck.....Isn't ironic that Capitalism is responsible for thier boom economy? Not to mention the stealing of our technology, lax copy right laws and human rights abuses.   Lenin is proud~  
You human rights activists. What is the deal with you? China conquered Tibet fair and square back in the 50s. We might not like it, but that's a fact. Furthermore, what right do you have to criticize China? Why should every nation be like the United States? We aren't the greatest, the ideal, the envy of every country in the globe, and it's time for you to accept that.

Tibet has even been under Chinese dominion from before the 50s. The Tang dynasty administrated the region, the Mongols took tribute from it; even if it wasn't a formal part of the empire, Tibet was still controlled by China.

Why doesn't China have the right to decide what goes on in it's own borders? They try to clean up their act, let more people in, and instantly! Protests, riots, killings, mobs pop up. China tries to control its people, and bam! Everyone around the world is up in arms, because there cannot be such a thing as strong central government. Just stop wishing for the colonial days already.
Is there any way to make the Olympics illegal?
What happen in China (people upset over western media) is exactly what happen here (people bashing China), it is natual reaction, what do you people upset about? If you treat others badly, they will do the same to you.

As for Tibet, it's not even a human rights issue, it is about somebody trying to split away from China. do you still remember what happen here during the civil war?

As of human right, China might have long way to go, but do you guy still remember what's like here in this country just 40 years ago? last time I check, Black people could not even sit on a bus in the 60's.

First of all, everyone should study their Chinese history carefully before commenting. There are a large number of, shall I say, "erronous statements" posted here.

Secondly, if I remember correctly, how did America react to criticism of our invasion of Iraq by the French in 2003? I'm not sure we were any different.

China is a large and complex country, whose government has only had 30 years or so to evolve after the Cultural Revolution, which was a disaster for the Chinese people. They have made much progress, although they have a long way to go. At a similar point in our history, we were actually pretty pathetic ourselves, and if you factor in Guantanamo Bay, etc., we're still pretty bad. If we use the same standards that we apply to most of America, Tibet has always been a part of China. If we want indepence for Tibet, then we should give America back to the native Americans. Kent State wasn't much different than Tiananmen Square, and what is happening in Tibet has many analogies to the civil rights movements in the 1950's and 1960's. Americans really should look at themselves more carefully before they criticize others. I think it is the right thing to do to pressure any government on the globe regarding human rights, including our own. China is not the monster that people are trying to make it out to be. If we were to focus on every police beating or other indiscretion in this country, we could make it look like a pretty bad place to live as well. Again, while China is not perfect, the media, etc., are creating what is a cartoon image that bears no relationship to reality. BTW, I am an American who has been to China, studied China intensely, speaks Chinese, etc..
For those of you could not help to lash out on China,  just see for yourself: tomorrow (4/19) there will be worldwide demonstrations in LA, Paris, Germney,  Those are Chinese live in the west.  They are offenned by the biased western media coverage too.  Please ask yourself why they are on streets, they are not under Chinese government/communist controlled/influnced free people.  

That French president is a jerk.  He was back from Beijin about a month ago,  in which he signed huge billions dollars contract with Chinese government for ~50(?) Airbus planes.  Then turn back split on his Chinese host.  Why should Chinese give him those fat contract, instead giving Boeing of unites stats?  If you knew this you might understand those upset Chinese people organize them self to boycut French business. It is understandable human nature.  

After all, were we once changed the name of French fry to Freedom fry, when French refuse to join us to 'liberate' those poor Iraqs?
Wow.. They (Chinese Govt) really do not get it. And sadly probably never will. I am sad these noble games being disgraced by the association with China's regime. If Tibet was not enough, The "rounding Up of Troublemakers" should be enough to end it. I will not watch or support the games this time around..
Here is the problem, most Americans know nothing about China and the way the live, work, and love their children and family members, the same as we do in America. For the most part the average chinese person knows no more about the political side of life in China, much like the majority of Americans do. Just like America, they are fed propoganda on a daily basis that is usually filled with lies, the same as here in America. "QUESTION" when was the last time that the "BUSHWACKER" told the truth about anything?? "ANSWER" "NEVER"?? When was the last time that "DICKHEAD CHENEY" ever told the truth?? "ANSWER NEVER" What the average American knows about China, could'nt even fill a thimble!! Now here is the truth from an American who spent six years in China as a University Professor. In a six year period, I never saw or even heard of one person being shot with a firearm, In a six year period, I never saw or even heard of a young woman being raped by a bunch of sick and demented persons. In a six year periiod I never was accosted by a bunch of illiterate bullies. In a six year period I never saw nor heard of a car being stolen or stripped down for parts. In a six year period, I never saw nor heard of a big drug bust by the police, "YOU MAY ASK WHY"?? well the answer is that in China, drugs are illegal and considered a very serious crime, punishable by even the death penalty. It's true that there is some high level corruption, but unlike America, if the culprit is caught he will usually be sentenced to death, "WHAT HAPPENED TO THE "ENRON" CREEPS WHO PUT THOUSAND OF OLD FOLKS INTO ADVERSE POVERTY The Answer IS "VERY LITTLE"
AMERICANS ARE VICTIMIZED FAR MORE SERIOUSLY BY THE PEOPLE WHO THEY HAVE PUT IN POWER, MUCH MORE THAN THE PEOPLE IN CHINA HAVE.
A MASSACHUSSETTS IRISHMAN, THAT'S WHAT I AM ANS AN ASHAMED CITIZEN OF THE GOOD OLD U.S. of A.
I won't watch one minute of the Olympics this time around.  Maybe North Korea or Iran should hold the games next.
Oh come on. Tibet was a totalitarian theocracy. Now, there is a bunch of religious kooks burning and killing to bring the theocracy back. Does no one remember the Taleban? Or do they nuts have to be muslims before the west stops supporting them?
This is about more than Tibet. This is about China's overall human-rights record. The United States has had its problems especially recently, but at least we have the hope of throwing our "bunch of goons and thugs" out of office. And at least I can make a post declaring our current government "goons and thugs" without having to worry that the government will make me disappear.
MY QUESTION IS THAT KNOWING THE TERRIBLE RIGHTS RECORD OF THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT, WHY IN THE WORLD WOULD WE AWARD THEM THE OLYMPICS?  DID WE THINK THAT THEY WOULD JUST ROLL OVER AND PLAY NICE?  NO WAY IN HELL!!!!!!!
The Olympics is total BS anyway why does anyone care?  Any event with Judges deciding the winners are fixed events.  What is so beautiful about FAKE events?
Sick and tired of some people and/or some countries acting as World Police or World Judge, telling other people or countries what to do. Look at yourselves or your own country first and take care of your own problems ( homeless, recession, oil price, inflation, health care, poverty, .... etc) first.
The reaction in Beijing and all over China is a demonstration of anger being "cheated and lied about" by Western world, particularly the media here.  Chinese people, especially young ones looked up to the Western world for so called democracy and justice.  When they found out what had been practiced here were "double standards", worst "cut and paste", and "distortion" etc, they were totally shocked and lost.  The "Western light" in their heart was lost.  Now, CNN/Cafferty is becoming the image of American in the minds of most of ordinary Chinese people; this is dangerous!  If we Amercian can not see this, then, God helps us!
President Harry Truman must have been thinking of China when he said: "If you can't stand the heat, stay out of the kitchen!"
Whereas China is clearly abusing human rights in Tibet, and has been cited for enabling the genocide in Darfur, let us not pretend as if the US has a pristine human rights record.  I'm thinking Iraq here.
It is against American short-terim/long-term interests to provoke the current and next generations of Chinese. For what?
If the world truly cared about democracy, rights, Tibet, Darfur, etc., they would not watch the Olympics from this totalitarian regime.  Amazing that despots such as Saddam are a threat, but the Chinese despots are to be coddled because we want to sell to them, use their cheap and slave labor and allow  them to buy our debts caused by the war in Iraq.  Aren't all despots a threat to freedom loving people all over the world.
C'mon people. Greatful that China took on the burden of supporting Tibet!?! I doubt the Tibetans felt that way when the Chinese tanks over ran them when China forcebly annexed their country. And continues to flood their country with ethnic Chinese so that a Tibetan can't even live or get a decent job in their capitol city. Wake up! China is a totalatariam regime, with no freedom of speech and a human rights record that makes Bush and his cronies look like Walt Disney. If you love China so much, go live there and see if you can bitch about the goverment, even a little, without the jackboots paying you a visit in the middle of the night!      
China is China. All the talk is getting annoying. Any country that is in disagreement with its politics and policies on human rights can choose not to deal with them, including everyone writing in whose household possessions are likely on average about 75% produced in China. Pipe down and take action.

And as far as any Americans making judgements, particularly the media, you must remember our political leader and commander in chief is nothing more than an ignorant oaf whom we have allowed to remain in office despite his repeated public insults to our intelligence and disregard for our international relations and well being of our military heroes.

It's easy to send a message to China without saying a word, just stop buying into it.

The sad part is, it seemingly much harder to get our own leadership (in a "free land") to listen to a damned word we say.
We owe the Chinese so much $$$ for the war in Iraq to toxic toys that we are to blame for all of this. We  as Americans are against oppression with our hearts and minds but support it with our wallets? Who is truly to blame for this? What goes around comes around. Don't get me wrong, I am against the Chinese gov't but is our gov't any better? What we are doing in Iraq is the same crap in Tibet or worst. This is what happens when you let Bush run the gov't for 7 yrs.
THE WORLD MUST UNITE AND NEVER AGAIN ALLOW EVIL PEOPLE (I include GW BUSH in this) TO GOVERN. HOW CAN WE ASSURE THE ENTIRE WORLD THAT CORRUPT PEOPLE ARE NOT IN CHARGE????
Remember....it's the Chinese LEADERSHIP, not the country or the Chinese people themselves.

Have the Chinese forgotten about NANKING and the Japanese atrocitie back in WW2??? Now the LEADERS are doing the same thing the Japanese did.

It's not the form of government!! It's the PEOPLE running the government.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=917308

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.