ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



China's 'Smiling Angel in Wheelchair'

Posted: Thursday, April 10, 2008 2:09 PM
Filed Under:

By Ed Flanagan, NBC News Researcher

BEIJING – In recent days it has been difficult to take away any positives from China's now unfortunately titled torch relay, the "Journey of Harmony to Beijing," at least based on international news coverage of the events.

But the media here have found a positive face in the young, handicapped woman who was confronted by protesters in Paris this week. 

Image: French policemen hold down a pro-Tibet protestor as the Beijing para-Olympics flame is carried by Chinese fencer Jin Jing
AFP - Getty Images
French policemen hold down a pro-Tibet protestor as the Olympic flame is protected by Jin Jing in Paris on April 7. 

Jin Jing, 28, a former Paralympics fencer from Shanghai who uses a wheelchair, won national acclaim for what the media described as her heroics in protecting the Olympic torch from a group of pro-Tibetan protesters (all protesters have been ubiquitously labeled "Tibetan separatists" and "pro-Tibet independence activists" in state media reports).

Jin's feisty defense of the torch – she suffered scratches and a bruised leg during the confrontation – has been heavily covered by China's media, which has the unenviable task of mitigating the scope of the protests.   

Protecting the torch
In a radio press conference which was quickly picked up by the official Beijing Olympics website, Jin described the Paris incident:

"When the second torchbearer was accepting the flame from the first, I was waiting at my position as the third torchbearer. At the time the security around me was relatively light, there were only a few police officers and three, maybe two, escort runners around me. Several Tibetan separatists and members of ‘Reporters without Borders’ came over to protest.
                       
"They began lunging toward me, trying to grab the torch from my hands. I tried to hide the torch with my body and managed to keep it from them. I was focused on the three or four separatists attacking me. I'm not sure how many were behind me. I felt people trying to take the torch from me. That's when some of the escort runners, as well as the tourist guide assigned to me in Paris, came over to help me, drawing the attackers away.

"People ask me how I dealt with the danger. I don't think I thought too much about it. I trusted the escorts around me. They were the ones, along with my guide, that faced the danger."

Hero’s welcome
Upon her return to Beijing, Jin was treated to a hero's welcome as crowds gathered to hail the woman news reports glowingly described as the "Smiling Angel in Wheelchair" and the "Most Beautiful Torchbearer."

Jin, who had part of her right leg amputated at the age of 9 after a malignant tumor was found on her ankle and later underwent a year of chemotherapy, is a charismatic woman with a glowing smile.

And hungry for a positive Chinese figure to serve up to its audience, the Chinese media clearly saw the star potential in Jin: at the time of this posting, fully half of the "News" section on the official Torch Relay website were accounts of her actions that day, including one entitled: "Jin Jing's mother: I'm proud of my daughter." 

Online forums have also been abuzz with praise for her and her dedication to the Olympic spirit. One netizen on an Olympic thread wrote, "I burst into tears when I saw how you [Jin] protected the flame, I think you protected the torch and also saved the spirit of the Olympics."

Attacks heighten nationalism
However, not all messages have been positive. On another popular website, Mopu, the picture of Jin being assaulted by the ethnic Tibetan protester sparked outrage among posters. "Kill with no leniency!" and "kill the foreign !@#$!" – using a slur for Tibetans used amongst ethnic Han Chinese were popular sentiments shared by many of the contributors. 

The majority of such sentiments appeared to be from angry mainland Chinese blowing off steam over the perceived international humiliation that protesters have brought to the torch and by extension, China.

However, if these protests grow, the Chinese will likely settle into a siege mentality, an "us versus the world" attitude.  It may become increasingly easier for Chinese to look at what many would consider legitimate calls for change and dismiss them as nothing more than Western rhetoric and propaganda.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

The Olympics are entertainment, nothing more.  And therefore superficial.  China's oppression of the Tibetan people is serious and real.

The Olympic Committee has adopted a policy of appeasement of the Chinese Oppressors, and have conscripted delusional and wheel-chair bound "athletes" as propagandists.

No one cares about the wheel-chair olympics but the "athletes" and their families, so even within the irrelevant sphere of entertainment, this "athlete" is even less than significant, and is only useful to prop-up the chinese government and distract attention away from the real issues at stake.

Crippled people from all over the world to gather under the Olympic banner to deny that the Chinese Government is an Oppressive Regime.

Hero ?  She would have been much-more heroic if she would have handed that torch to someone that deserved it, rather than to yet another in a long line of communist stooges.
Most Chinese people like me, think that the Game is a great event, and have at least wishes for it. Pro-Tibet protester in torch relay didn't ruin the events for Chinese gov, but for Chinese people. It's not wise to insult 1/5 of the earth population, how could anyone expect Chinese gov/people to respect "legitimate calls for change" from those guys after this kind of humiliations. They will gain nothing at last if this turmoil is going on, but hatred from common Chinese people
Jin Ping, you have courage and strength. Defend yourself and your country from these cowards who have no morality.  They are supposed to demonstrate peacefully but what you see is hysteria, extremism and lawlessness. Because of their actions, beautiful Tibet will be closed to the outside world for another 50 years.
And the website is Mop.com, not MOPU, for those of you who know Chinese or actually CARE to know what China really is like.
It is unfortunate that a country that has state-initiated, black-market harvesting of organs for petty criminal offences would attempt to use our heart strings against us by putting the Olympic flame in the hands of a handicapped woman. Perhaps that's the greatest Chinese offense of all.
No one in China seems to be crying over the many Christians who, often on wheelchairs, are presently languishing in Chinese "gulags of reeducation"!
I thought that the olympic spirit was suppose to be friendly. China is demonstrating to be as hard head as North Korea. They are trying to show the world that they can be more human, but within their border the story is totaly different. China ha over 300,000 people leaving in poverty. I wonder how much was paid to the IOC official to grant China this olympic games. I am all in support of France if they boycott the games, and if other countries follow. It will embarrass China, and they government may re-think they position.
You know Sometimes I believe that people try to disrupt something good when it comes to a world envolvement of games. Times have changed from the hated sinces why not let the young athletes show there talents, are the rest jealous of who they are or are they jealous because they don't no how to do anything but run thier mouths.I for one am an American and I believe that world games is a challenge to who train and work hard,everyone involved picked to show there talent showed be proud to to be picked and who's that don't have the talent showed shut up and learn something.
Ed, I guess that my previous mild critique on your article was censored. Therefore I just suggest that you go to read the following speech by Singapore's Prime Minister, Mr. Lee, at http://www.channelnewsasia.com/stories/singaporelocalnews/view/340788/1/.html

After reading that, I'm sure that you'll realize the importance and responsibility for today's online reporter. Trying to make it as fair as possible for both sides of world. Thanks
As susual, negative stories about China. Now, the chinese "defenders of the torch" were too rough on the anti-chinese (mind you, not pro-Tibet) "demonstrators".

However, these "demonstrators" were not too rough in mobbing, harassing and trying to wrestle the torch out of the athletes.

Since all these "demonstrators" (harrassers) were westeners, it does not stand to reson of how they can react with such ferocity for something that does not even concern them; they probably don't even know where Tibet is.

They probably are paid thugs by anti-china elements.
After all this humiliation and embarrassment to the chinese (ppl and govt) up to this point. I think it's enough. Can we just let the Olympic proceed? ...
I've been to Tibet and Nepal several times, and think that the condition in Tibet in better than Nepal (its neighbor). Thus, I think China did alright...Not sure if an independent Tibet would fare that well...or end up like Nepal?
How can she be a hero? Because she is crippled? I better  get in an accident and I can become a hero, too!

Is it because she held the torch? How can something as insignificant as a sporting event, and a torch relay that was begun by the Nazis be heroic?

Ok, now let's see, is it because she tried to defend the torch? Hundreds of thousands of folks in labor camps and prisons in China are suffering, and she is giving their oppressors legitimacy. She is absolutely no hero. At best she is an unwitting tool and accomplice to tyranny and genocide, at worst she is a worthless human being who betrays all human values in the name of national pride and personal gain. She is the epitome of selfishness. I have no remorse for these comments, and I know history will judge her as nothing but a PRC tool.
It is interesting to see so many uninformed views on these blogs. Dont comment unless you have been there and dont comment if you are a stooge of the Chinese government (which a few of you are). There is one point no one seems to know or care to look at. The health care system in China is not socialist, you have to pay for your care and if you dont have the money, you die, it is that simple. I have been there many times and know this to be true. Most of the hospitals in China resemble the 1950's in their equipment, etc. I have been to these hopsitals as a patient and felt like I was in a time warp sent back to 1955. Take a look at how she lost her leg. You might find it was because the care was sub standard. I dont know for sure but would not be surprised if that was the case. If you have cancer in your ankle, you shouldnt lose your entire leg. I felt it was wrong to "attack" her, even though she was not attacked in the trueist sense of the word. They were just trying to get the torch, she got injured due to the reaction of the Chinese agents guarding the torch and their overly agressive actions. Shame on GE for portraying health care in rural Chian is so advanced in that commercial. Its not true.
Someone questions whether it is a true story if it's not on CNN. Interesting.

CNN is not God.

Occasionally, CNN is SLOW (or selective) to pick up news happened in foreign countries, e.g. prisoners abuse case in Iraq.

During the Gulf War, CNN was criticized for excessively pushing 'human interest' stories and avoiding depictions of violent images (according to www.answers.com).
Why weren't people protesting all the innocent ethnic Chinese who were burned to death last month by the radical element of the Tibetan movement?

I think we should oppose rioting and attacking innocents by all sides.  But the media coverage in the east and the west both seem to only focus on one side of the story... sad.  
For all you Chinese sympathizers, there is a wonderful country you can go to. Get a feel and how wonderful the great country is and how it treats the underclass.
Then inquire why, everyone wants to leave the wonderful country and do better everywhere else. Once you are successful, you can then denigrate the local people (who made you successful) on how lazy and dirty they are. and these natives made your wealthy.

After that, you lament why the foreign country you have been living off starts deteriorating because you are unwilling to assist.
All civilizations need proactive engagement. If you leech off on, pretty soon the host will be run dry.
1) International community is NOT equal to the handful wertern countries
2) International media is NOT equal to the media from these handful wetern contries
3) Small group of protesters is not equal to the all Tibetian people. Among these protesters, large part of it is from these handful contries, and they are not Tibetian
4) These small handful countries exployed other countries in recently history by killing, slaving, robbering, burning. Some are still continue to do so
5) Ha, they think they represent the INTERNATIONAL community
6) They use so called Democracy, Freedom to achieve their dirty aims.
7) Peoples from other contries are not stupid, they cannot be fooled.
The Olympic Games are to be held sacrosanct; above politics and protests. To protest China's (or ANY government's) policies by attacking anything Olympic is WRONG. It doesn't matter if the protests are justified or not. The Olympic Games is NOT the venue to air grievances... period. We have very highly-paid State Department people to take care of this kind of thing for us (just like every country). So if there is a problem you go to them, and THEY DO THEIR JOBS. Don't think for one minute that China will be impressed by any protest. They don't care what you or anyone else thinks (actually neither do I). The Chinese will reap what they sow, as will we all. Sowing strife amidst the Olympics will only bear poisonous fruit.
God Bless China.
The Dragon from East will rise and RULE!
"legitimate calls"?
The problem with those human right lovers is that they always think their calls are legitimate, but without being "justified".
China does need to improve on human rights, but which other country doesn't.
OK, you can forget about Iraq, about Kosovo, about Afganistan and point fingers at China;
and OK, you can call for a "FREE TIBET" without knowing a bit of the culture, the history and people's living there.
but pray just listen sometimes what the majority of 1.3 billion Chinese are saying and report the true story.
don't take Chinese as fools, and believing in their government rather than "western propaganda" does not necessarily mean they are "brainwashed" by communist officials.
you're talking human right and press freedom?
don't you deliberately ignore what people on the other side are saying and witnessing, and just pick up those you like to hear?
bet the biggest loser will be the western media after all this chaos ends;
you're losing trust of the Chinese, pro-democracy or neutral or conservative, who did in the past tend to believe what You are saying rather than their own government, because you're acting so blatantly biased, to say the least.
Everyone talks about the "History of the Torch" but no one seems to know the fact that the Olympic torch relay was created by the Nazis during the Olympic games in Berlin to promote Aryan pride.  Do some homework people, and then decide if this 'torch' is really a symbol of peace and unity.
Does any one know if there are any Tibetans participating in the Olympic Games?  Would China allow a Tibetan to participate in the Games?

Begining too believe, that the right thing to do is to boycott the games.

I relise that the American Athletics may suffer or you could look at the other way and that is that, these marvelous Athlete's, would have the honor of fighting imperialism and freeing Tibet.
Learn the truth, open your eyes, and see the world with an untainted mind. Don't trust everything you read or see. Most of you don't even know the true facts. Journey to the land first before you form any opinions. I say this because I have been there, and I'm telling you right now: Western Civilization, grow up. You claim that China is not ready to meet civilization and you pick at the fault of others while your own is hung heavily on your back where you refuse to see it.
You want to stand on the side of the street with posters and banners highlighting China's problems, go right ahead.  You want to jump in the street and physically accoust some innocent person carrying a torch, prepare to get you butt kicked.
Before I start, I'd like to make it clear that I do not have any Chinese ancestors to my knowledge, and definitley do not have the looks. While I do support 100% the idea that Tibetians deserve respect as individuals, and deserve their cultural and linguistic autonomy, I would first like to remind our "right-thinking" Western civilisation that their states and governments have recognised China within its 1940 borders WHICH INCLUDES TIBET. Where were you people when that happened ? Secondly,there is nobody here entitled to give lessons of humanity to any other nation. What arrogance when most of the genocides and harshest invasions (including that of China, and burning down the famous summer palace - by the British) have been perpetrated by the same "right-thinking" people or their ancestors! From the Jewish holocaust (6 million by the Germans and their European allies), to the genocide of North American Indians (between 20 and 40 million by the settlers), to that of the Incas (2 to 10 millions by the Spanish), to that of the Bosnians (40,000 by the Serbs), to that of the Congo people (5 to 10 million people, by the Belgians), to that of the Algerians (400,000 to 700,000 civilians, by the French), to that of the Turks in Crimea ( 50,000 to 200,000 by the Russians) etc... etc... it has all been instigated by the "right-thinking" Western countires, peolpe or ethnic groups. It sounds like it is OK for us to invade and massacre, but it is not OK for others - do you think Irak's invasion by the US is acceptable? Are you aware that for the 4000 US troops that died there is 1 million Iraki civilians that got killed? Of course there have been other massacres, this is not to say that non Westerners are tame! I just want to put things into perspective. And definitley, you do not attack a sportsman, and especially not a handicapped one at that. This is low!
If the world affairs are to be determined by those few protesters, we will not have Olympic, WTO, WHO, UN, European Union, any corporations, any conferences, etc..

The quality of Western media has been going down the hills for the last ten years,  The reporters have little knowledge about history, cultures, international laws and professionalism.  All they like to see is confrontation, chaoes, and riots.

The Tibet issues shall be adressed based on historical facts, international laws, the unjust Tibetan social systems and the wellbeings for the people associates.  

Tibetan monks are the most brutal religious police and terrorists in human history.  They were chopping off the hands, fingers, even the waists of the many Tibetan untouchables and slave farmers.  Why the media wants to present them as human right advocators?  What a joke!

Regarding the French President, he shall focus on his marriage and divorce.  This is the only thing the French are good at.  They are not sophisticated to deal with the complicated world affairs.
Knowing what we know now, would the world STILL have granted Nazi Germany the Olympics in 1936? Well, we DO know about the PRC, and yet we've allowed corpoations interested ONLY in profit to reward the fascists in Beijing to bask in the glow of Olympic glory and acceptance. This is the SAME government who perpetrated the Tiananmen Square massacre; the SAME organized gang that decides that flooding the world with poisoned goods, food and toys is justifiable in their rapid pursuit of cash to prop up their rule through military procurement; the SAME illegitimate, immoral, corrupt and bloodthirsty regime that murders Tibetan pilgrims and a nun in the Himalayas, is caught on film doing so and STILL lies with a straight face to the rest of the world. So the "sacred" Olympic had to be protected by Chinese Secret Police thugs (the SAME Secret Police that commits murder in Tibet, in Tiananmen Square and all across China) -- this alone should tell the world (and our ever-greedy profit-conscious corporations) that there'ssomething seriously and morally wrong about giving THIS government the "honor" of Olympic recognition. Who's next as an honored and acceptable Olympic (Nazi?) host -- North Korea? Burma? Cuba? Vietnam? Sudan? Zimbabwe? Venuzuela? This is NOT intended as an insult or indictment of the the Chinese people or civilization, ONLY of their THOROUGHLY EVIL so-called government -- and quite frankly, the Western corporations that appeased their wishes and used their ad/sponsorship money to force this travesty of an Olympics on the entire world. ANY athlete that participates in Beijing might just as well be shouting "Hiel Hitler!" and giving the Nazi salute to ALL the ruthless mass-murderers and evil regimes of history (and for what, a "medal"?)...    
I say protect the torch and on with the Olympics!  The athletes across the world have prepared to long and hard for this for those idiots across the world to try to ruin the ceremony of the torch being moved around the world.  The Tibet and Chinese political issue is just that, a political issue.  The Olympics is not the ‘Arena’ to play politics.  This is the time for the athletes to show their excellence.
If you truly want to get China's attention, then hurt it where it hurts the most and that is financially. If you stopped purchasing 'Made in China' goods, then you will get China's attention faster than by any other methods.
What everybody fails to remember is that politics have no place in any part of the Olympics. Say these protesters got a hold of the torch, were they going to free Tibet with it??? No. As far as these "thug guards" go, I'd say they wouldn't be so thuggish if people weren't assaulting torchbearers. Seriously, I just don't get what these protester think they can legitimately achieve hampering an event that while yes, China will host, is really an international event. The torch does not belong to China, it belongs to the whole world. Geez.
Anglo-US Intelligence Agencies dupe Tibetian activists to target Beijing Olympics
http://onlinejournal.com/artman/publish/article_3167.shtml

Around the world, Beijing’s hosting of the 2008 Olympic Games has become the target of unprecedented, well-orchestrated and extremely hostile mass protests. Through propaganda, China is being made into the single arch-villain.

Meanwhile, geostrategic realities, and historical and current parapolitical fact, suggest that the protesters and passionate activists have once again become the willing dupes, propaganda shills, and street bullies for “causes” created, fronted, and pushed by Anglo-American intelligence agencies (CIA, British intelligence, etc.) that continue to target a government (this time Beijing), in a host of long-term subversion and sabotage plans. Behind the powerful din created by the popular and celebrity-embraced “Save Tibet,” campaign is the fact that the CIA is behind financing the Tibet independence movement.

Far from actually alleviating any suffering in Darfur, Tibet or within China itself, activists are being guided into deepening the suffering; assisting the Anglo-American empire’s own plans to destabilize and conquer (energy-rich and strategically situated) Africa and (energy-rich and strategically situated) Tibet, and politically hamper Beijing.
I think my last message was blocked by administrator,but  i dont angry with it.
infact,i wannar say i dont quit like the report in western media on this issue.that's unfair to the chinese people,especially mainland China.If you whant to know the truth,please listen to both side,mainland china and tibet.
What we need ,just equity and peace.
thank you !
some how I dont see any one in the media complaining about the attack on wheel chair girl by able bodied men. Would they still have not condemened an attack on a white girl in wheel chair. I just wonder? i didnt read any news calling that attack reprihensible. So its okay to attack cripples, for tibeten freedom.
To the Pro Chinese government sycophants on this site.  It would have been nice if the Chinese government had not decided to pick on the weak once again.  If that suppression hadn't happened, there would be no problem and we all would have gladly supported the games.  As for Americans here we should be a little shocked at the amount of people on this site supporting this kind of behavior and so quickly calling pro tibet people 'terrorists'.  I believe that the Chinese people are good for the most part ... wo xihuan zhong guo ren ..I know some here.  I object to the government's actions.
The olympics have been a joke for years and if the U.S. condones the treatment of the Tibetans, it's no surprise as they are almost as bad as the Chinese with their SS troops running wild.  Screw the Olympics and screw the Chinese.  If tthe United states really believed in the validity of human rights there would not be a drug war or an invasion of Iraq and Afghanistan.
There is no doubt that these protestors were foolish and brazen, to reach for the torch and put anyone, especially someone who has a physical handicap.  I wish all protestors of this cause would use thier heads.  If you want to speak out against China's policies on Tibet (colonialism and religious intolerance), or on Sudan (complicity in genocide), then demonstrate peaefully.  Imagine the message of thousnads of protestors waving flags and banners without any attempt to "attack" the Olympic torch: much more effective.  Physical violence only detracts from and demoralizes your message.  Although the US has made many many mistakes and blunders in foreign and domestic policy, we are so fortunate to have freedom of pllitical expression, and we should promote the peaceful implementation of this freedom so that countries who crack down on free speech cannot deny to rightness of this particular freedom.
WHY IS THERE NOT MORE OUTRAGE IN THE US ABOUT THE CHINESE THUGS THAT WERE ALLOWED IN OUR COUNTRY?
WHY IS THE AMERICAN PUPLIC NOT OUTRAGED AT LAW ENFORCEMENTS APARENT SIDING WITH THE CHINESE FLAME GAURDS STRONG ARM APPROACH. WHAT AUTHORITY DO THEY HAVE IN THIS COUNTRY? ARE WE ALL STUPID NOT TO RECOGNIZE WHAT JUST HAPPENED? THEY JUST WALKED RIGHT IN TO OUR COUNTRY AND DID WHAT THEY WANTED TO, AND THE POLICE LET THEM!
OUR OLIMPIC ATHELETES SHOULD NOT GO!
THE CHINESE HAD A COMPLETE DISREGARD FOR OUR COUNTRY, AND I AM NOT SUPPRISED GIVEN THEIR TRACK RECORD FOR HUMAN RIGHTS. ALL THEY WANT TO DO IS SHOWCASE THEIR COUNTRY'S MIGHT IN THE WORLD.
I'm curious: don't westerners read history? I thought most of them were educated.
I personally respect Dalai Lama as a human, and I found some of his remarks make sense, whether it is true or not.
But I also pity him being used as an instrument by some greedy people behind.
He was only in his twenties when he ran away from Tibet, somewhat convinced and abducted by those that needed his charisma as the spititual leader to Tibebans.
It was ironic that he, as the spiritual leader (the top monk) in Tibet, was actually picked and certificated by the Chinese central government, like his predecessors by Chinese emperors in centuries.
Tibetan buddhist monks were serfowners and they collected heavy taxes from their serfs, every responsible historian will tell you that. It was when they became too greedy, corrupt and rebellious to collude foreign forces(from Nepal, from Britain) in attempts to break away from the lax rule of the central government,  Chinese emperors in the last dynasty Qing (by the way, they belonged to another minority ethnic group Man in China, not Han ethnic who the Tibetans said they hate) cracked down on their riots and strengthened control over the remote region.
I could understand devout religious Tibetans felt their culture were "penetrated" by Han ethinic people or communists. Mainstream Han people felt that way when other ethinic groups like Man invaded and ruled them.
Mainland Chinese felt that way when western capitalism invaded China under the communists' rule in 1980s. Some of them still feel worried about the adverse impact of it, by the way.
But "Culture Genocide"? how do you think thousands of Lama temples in Tibet and other Tibetan ethinc habitats in China have thrived in the past 50 years? Millions of Han Chinese Buddhists (not always so devout) and tourists have donated money to them, not to mention the funding of the central government, or Chinese tax payers.
The monks there until today are still the richest among Tibetans!
Free Tibet? Hey, the day it was called a "country" dated over 1,000 years ago. and common people had never been "free" before the "communist invasion" in 1951, or the former ruling republic government of Kuomindang (Nationalist Party).
They were serfs under the harsh rule of monks and local aristocrats, with the biggest ruler being the Dala Lama (mind you, that is not a name, but a title for the leader).
Hope this one would not be censored. NEVER THOUGHT I WOULD HAVE TO TEACH WESTERNER MEDIA COMMON SENSE AND BASIC HISTORICAL KNOWLEDGE.
There seems to be a lot of people with generic Western names, locations, and broken English denouncing "their" own Western governments. Something tells me Nick from New Jersey may be more comfortable denouncing the evil Western media in Mandarin.
human being, by nature, cannot be absolutely objective. especially, when it comes to the national pride and solidarity. in a way, i understand the chinese people. if i hear negativity about my country, i am sure i will lose my objectivity. same goes for tibetans. so i also understand them and their supporters. but also other protesters: pro-falung, pro-human rights, pro-animal rights, environmentalists, and so on... the list goes on. if there was only the tibetan issue, i don't think thee would have been so much noise. it is all of the above factors piled up together that has created this snowball effect. this said,
1. i hope that the protesters were NOT targetting the girl, instead they were going for the torch, because for them, unfortunately, this torch has become a symbol of oppression. there were many other torchbearers, noone meant harm for the torchbearers themselves.
2. threat to ethnic identity can make someone do crazy stuff, i can only begine to imagine.
3. i understand, that there is a lot of natural resources on tibetan territories at play here, which would invalidate claims like "china has nothing to gain from tibet, and wants to only help tibet to develop and also rid its people from the dictatorship of monks". this does not seem to be true.
4. i just wish that those chinese who are too xenophobic would stop being like that. i know for sure, that there is a lot of chinese who are friendly nice people. though, they too tend to be a little suspicious of other people and each other for no reason.

Anyway, what i am trying to say is that i hope that change will come to china, and they gear their policies towards more compassionate and human-rights friendly and environmentally friendly direction. what they seem to be lacking is compassion towards other beings, and seeing them as their equal. As for Olympics, I don't believe in that thing. it's filled with greed, corruption and deceit, as a result of which, good athletes face a lot of disappointment and unfairness. i do not see the point of making a big fuss out of it and putting it above more pressing issues related to real human and environmental tragedies. that relates to all of the countries, not only china.
I find that many of the passages above have a consistent and incorrect use of the English language, though they all state to be of western, if not American, origin. Given the commonality of mistakes and such on this blog, I could not help but wonder just how many of the opinions expressed above we placed by people with rather direct ties to the chinese regime. Reading this blog has actually given me a chill of censorship and repression. Yes, what happenned to the girl is unfortunate, but China must also understand the deep reservations that the West has over the issue of Tibet. This is a region that should be granted an autonomy, if not outright independence. They should also agree to meet with the Dalai Lama and acknowledge him as a official representative in exile of the Tibetan movement. As an American business owner in the electronics industry, I find myself more often desiring to purchase my products from suppliers with as few ties or sources of origin in China as possible. I am willing to vote with my checkbook. Perhaps they will understand that.
Life is cheap in China.  Of cheap things, it is the cheapest.  

But saving face is another matter.  Of precious things in China, saving face is the most precious.
Dial down the emotion, please, all the Pro-Tibet folks.

I support democracy and self determination for Tibet but the attacks on the Olympic torch bearers were a disgrace and a fiasco and made a good cause look very bad. Attacking a woman in a wheelchair holding the Olympic torch does NOT make anyone a hero or dignify their cause in the least. The people defending those actions are very, very foolish. Holding signs and singing and chanting are fine for a protest but the attacks on the people carrying the torch crossed a line and despite a very strong sympathy for the Tibetan people it turned my stomach and is a disgrace. The people who did it should be ashamed of what they did to those athletes and people who were given the honor of holding the Olympic torch and what it represents in sport, and that they made a very good cause look like the province of thugs and buffons. It was disgusting.
Tibet is part of China since 13th century.
http://youtube.com/watch?v=x9QNKB34cJo

This is the picture that you will not see from CNN, where Protesters Took Advantage of Handicapped Torchbearer's Disability.
http://www.anti-cnn.com/jinjing/paris_protesters_took_advantage.dwt
http://youtube.com/watch?v=NDLfj8cKmc0

CIA’s Secret War in Tibet
http://www.historynet.com/cias-secret-war-in-tibet.htm

Michael Parenti - Tibet: Friendly Fuedalism?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WWGGjpJJCKE

Dalai "Da-Lie" Lama's Naked Truth Exposed
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J1O-eLmAA8Y

Free Tibet, wait, where is Tibet?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=twHzXN3kNTs&eurl=h





It is so sad to see how the western world is being fooled by the so called "pro-tibetan protestors" they are no more than some criminals who started burning chinese shops and killing Han ethnic chinese people and the world call China of genocide in Tibet?, let us ask who is aiming to a particular ethnic group for attacks and killings, come on, it is time to open our eyes and see who is the devil and who is the victim. We can not be blindest than this. Tibetans are cruel and barbarian, they use violences to persue their goal, they don't respect a handicapped girl in a wheelchair. Western media and westerners should stop critizicing China for their so called "iron-handed crackdown" in Tibet which in fact China did not do more than restoring orders, protecting the civilians and self defense by firing couples of shots if need to. Picture this, if you were a policeman attacked by criminals don't you use your gun to defend yourself? or you think it is against that criminal's human right to fire your gun, then let that criminal kill you, sorry to say. Tibet has belonged to China since more than 1000 years ago and China has been sending around $300 millions dollars a year to build schools, for healthcares, and infrastructures, in return Tibet can produce nothing and is a burden to China more than a profit. For comparison if the state of New Mexico wants to protest to become independent from the US, what is the american reaction to that?.
China is the most racist, most oppressive nation on the planet.  China has always been arrogant.  China thinks Westerners are a bunch of idiots and has jailed more dissidents than any country.  We have problem with Cuba, but not China?  Incredible double standard.  Don't be fooled.
I as a human being think the tibetans and the chinese should be alowed to do, act, and think as they like. I dont think the chinese goverenment is evil or bad i just think they are wrong because what they are doing isnt working. China can be a major super power if they werent so restricted in everything they do.The wheelchaired torch barrer was very brave indeed and i think some of the protest are going way to far because the torch run has had a special place for everyone in the world for quite some time and shouldnt be used the way it is today for political gain. Then again there is a reason that 3 billion people disagree with the most populated country in the world and the disagrement is not with the people but the government. With that many intelligent people in your country surely masses can change the wrong to a right. I just hope the games can go on without incident because the athletes who live for this deserve better from all countries.
What a load of Chinese propaganda!
Dear American,
To destabilize China is our long term national interest since China take the road to the world superpower.We have to stay the course no matter our campaign is just or not. Human right is the best excuse and the most cost saving weapon since we cannot send troops to China.China is not Iraq. Dala Lama is our secret weapon, our country have spent billions on him and trained him and to arm his followers. Now his holiness has become to be a state of art performer on the world political stage. His holiness can mislead the majority of us, and our politicians can also be enlightened by his philosophy "reckless abandon".It will help us to abandon any blames from different sides. we are free to play at the DC community which is such a fun place. eg. DC Madam service, May Flower etc... Finally we will change Tibet to another Iraq peacefully, and Dalai Lama can share his serves with us.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=875154

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.