ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



In Germany, ‘green’ and kitsch don’t always mix

Posted: Monday, February 25, 2008 2:13 PM
Filed Under:

RUMMELSHEIM, Germany – Fair warning: This story involves one of those fairytale, somewhat kitschy German villages.

It also includes a cuddly toy, environmental laws and high-tech sneakers.

Let’s start in Rümmelsheim. Rummelsheim is the type of village where the grass seems to have been cut with rulers and fingernail clips. The sidewalks are so spotless you could eat off them.

Many Germans would call this little wine-growing town near the Rhine River a "lawn gnome community"– referring to those plastic dwarfs which often characterize "proper" German gardens and are a common sign of the German propensity for orderliness.

Sometimes that penchant for order is taken to extremes.

Take, for instance, a recent visit I made in an effort to shoot some video of the picturesque village. After I parked my car – perhaps a little sloppily -- I was immediately approached by an elderly local man, who was passing by with his grandson.

"You should be filming your car and the violation," the man began yelling at me.

Startled, I turned around to see what had gotten him so angry. It turned out that the tires of my car were on the edge of the sidewalk.

"This is not in order," were his last words as he walked away, steaming mad.

Which leads me to the cuddly toy....

Not first to violate strict codes
A couple of years ago, another criminal – this time it was not me – disposed of an old white plastic garden chair beneath a lonely tree along the country road between Rümmelsheim and a neighboring town, Waldalgesheim.

A scandal! Especially in such a tidy town. In addition, the German Product Recycling and Waste Management Act, plastic requires adequate and special waste disposal – and the chair was in clear violation of the code.

"We were just about to send out our waste disposal team, when somebody placed a large teddy bear in the chair," said Albert Fastner, Rümmelsheim's mayor.

Fastner and others in the town liked the colorful new roadside eye-catcher – and the town council quickly voted to leave the chair and the stuffed animal in place for a while.

VIDEO: A look at Germany's stuffed animal shrine
"Ever since then," Fastner explained "cuddly toys have come and gone. Even the original bear disappeared for a while. And once, somebody added an umbrella to protect it from the rain."

Today, the big brown teddy enjoys the company of a happy, fluffy red heart, a colorful caterpillar, Disney's Pluto, a gigantic stuffed banana and a smiling yellow guitar.

The mayor admitted that strictly speaking, the "cuddly-toy-cemetery" – as a few disgruntled locals call the site – violates municipal waste disposal laws. But, Fastner argues that the generally positive response from the community justifies an exception to the rule.

He may also have in mind the fame that the cuddly collection is bringing to his town – over the past months, German, as well as international, media have picked up on the story and numerous radio, television and newspaper reporters have visited the toy-strewn tree.

"As long as whoever is responsible for this little shrine keeps the site clean and it does not impact public order or obstruct local traffic, we will tolerate its existence," he said.

Which leads me to the sneakers....

Recycling: serious biz
Protecting the environment is a hot issue in Germany – and, just as in Rummelsheim, adhering to environmental standards is taken very seriously. These days, almost every German household has a minimum of three different garbage cans: one for paper, one for plastic and one for "regular garbage."

Many German communities even top the "sorting enthusiasm" by providing an additional brown bin for organic substances.

My hometown, like many others, even has three extra containers for glass (one for brown, one for white and one for green).

And if that’s not enough, a pending legal decision may even create new regulations for throwing out old sneakers.

Adidas, the German sports clothing manufacturer, is waiting for a decision from the Federal Administrative Court in Leipzig on whether or not its new high-tech running shoe, the Adidas Intelligence 1.1, will be considered "normal waste" or fall under special rules for electronic appliances. The reason? The shoe contains an electronic cushioning control unit.

Since 2005, manufacturers in Germany are required to take back electronic devices and assure environmental-friendly disposal under German law – creating additional costs for the manufacturer.

Get ready for sneaker-sorting bins!

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I have been in Germany for 4 mos and live in the Kaiserslautern area.  It took a bit to get used to the recycling. My daughter is 4 yrs old and knows the recycling rules better than her 16 yr old brother.  The Germans take much pride in their villages.  I see people outside sweeping the sidewalks daily.  This has got to be one of the most best kept countries in Europe.  I love it and I think the U.S. should start to take some pride in how cities look there.
I have lived in Stuttgart for the past 3 years, and can't say the recycling is anything different from what we had in Sonoma County, CA where I come from. If anything the idealism is a bit useless, as after you sort everything, most of the garbage just ends up being incinerated in a thermal energy plant here in the region anyway. Sadly, I have seen things trending here to more packaging and less reuse as cheaper EU imports are now flooding the local markets, making the local grocery stores look more and more like Albertson's...
As an American currently living in Naples Italy, but having lived in Germany for 9 years, I long for the "Ordnung" that is omnipresent in Germany.  To those who consider such control overbearing, try living in a city where the garbage piles up, nobody takes care of common spaces, and the citizens regard the whole out-of-doors as their wastebasket.  You'd be glad of some organization and common sense of order.  Guess this just shows that either extreme has its detractors.  Moderation in all things, including moderation.      
Week after week I have to go to the front of my property that borders the highway for a couple hundred feet and pick garbage.  Some weeks its only a few pieces, some weeks a half a bag full.

Maybe the Germans take it to extremes sometimes, but I could sure use a little of that ordnungswahn here in Kentucky.  Why do Americans think its okay to toss trash out their car windows?
I am all for enivormenatlism, but this article explains why the Germans cannot tolerate people who are differing ethnicities than themselves. It is Ordnungswahn which leads to ethnic cleansing and Nazism. I would rather have a mess with multi-culturalism than the measure, toenail cliped lawns of Germany.
Like in all things, moderation and balance is usually best.  This German mentality which I am all too familiar with, since I live in the German part of Europe, is not reasonable and its inflexibility leads to injustice and empowers the nosy and the know-it-alls.  Moreover, it leads not to respect but rather to gratuitously judging and loathing your neighbors.  And worse, as to not leaving a twig on the ground, this compulsive orderliness and cleanliness has cause the extinction of countless local species that needed a brushy environment.  General tolerance for petty rules creates a predisposition for fascism on a grand scale, as recent history bears witness.  A little disorder is a good thing after all.


I think we as American's could learn something from the Germans as well.  We may not have to take it to the extreme that the Germans have but it would certainly make an impact on this filthy place we call home.
sounds like a good place for monk
Mary- Perhaps you could refrain from lumping all US citizens into one big piggish basket.  Some of us do take pride in our surroundings, but when the government does not make policies to fix the neighbor's trashiness, there is very little recourse to those who want things clean.
I was stationed in Germany in the U.S.A.F. from 1964 to 1968.  We didn't see much of the recycling then, but I can attest that if a German threw something away, it wasn't worth anything!
Has anyone ever thought of the fact that in Germany an awful lot of people sit on a small piece of real estate - something that leads to the absolute necessity of cleanliness and order? Paired with the "stern earnestness" of the Germans - which has evolved over hundreds of years of Kings Kaisers and Dictators, it does come off, often enough, as scurrile and ridiculous. BUT a shot of orderliness wouldn't sit too badly with our rubbish littered parks, beaches and mall parking lots here in the states.
I lived in Germany in the 80's and early 90's, and while no place is utopia, there were many things I thought made good sense and could be beneficial to those of us in the USA.  Recycling is one of those things.  I can't tell you how frustrating it is to see my neighbors and colleagues tossing cans and plastic bottles into regular garbage, when it is so easy to sort and recycle!  I understand cleaning out a peanut butter jar might be a chore - but a water bottle?  
I agree that recycling may have gone too far in some parts of the world, but many Americans act lazy and spoiled when it comes to cleaning up our environment even a little bit.

As I read these blogs, I smiled, remembering being scolded by an old German man over letting my car warm up in the morning.  When I looked confused, he pointed to the exhaust and plugged his nose to help me get the picture.  Apparently I had broken a law about idling a car, but in hindsight, I understand.

I'm sure I was considered a slob by the locals for not sweeping my sidewalks and washing my windows more than twice a year.  They worked hard to keep their villages clean and, while I didn't do such a good job, I have to admit: the neighborhoods were lovely!

Utopia?  It is no where...  But adopting good ideas from other countries can sometimes make nice places even better!  Recycling is one of those ideas, and it doesn't have to be extreme or complicated to be benefincial to our world.  After all, we are all on this planet together, and we all share the air, and even the water eventually.
I'm originally from Ridgewood, Queens--which, when it was a predominantly German neighborhood, was famous (or infamous) citywide for its extreme cleanliness and orderliness. The Hausfraus used to scrub their stoops every week, and you were expected to keep your trash cans in your cellar until garbage pickup day.

This was during my father's time; the neighborhood was already in transition by the time I came along. But anyway... yes, the Germans seem to have a thing for orderliness!
Well my friends  I am  a German living  in the US and
sometimes I am  appalled at  how dirty   the country  in many  areas is ,how carelessly  people especially younger  people  just  trash  everything.Would it not be better , if you 'd show  a little respect  for your  country? Everybody is moaning  here  they  how much they  love  their country . .  . Talk and the flag is cheap my friend . !!! Trash  goes  to  trash in  life, I  miss  the German  cleanliness here and   America would do well if they ' d learn quickly from  those Germans.
Boy, do I miss Germany. I was stationed in Augsburg and LOVED it. There was some culture shock for a 19 year old girl raised in the south - but recycling became a norm for me - and I took it back with me. We are HUGE recyclers here and can only hope that it will catch on here in the states.
I recently moved back to the US after living in Germany for four years.  I loved the fact that we recycled so much and weren't adding anymore to the landfills.  The US could learn a little bit about taking better care of our resources.  It was a large learning curve at first but the benefits outweigh the senseless complaints.  
I lived in Germany for 8 years and I'm American. There are several regulations that Germany wants to impose on its citizen to keep a sense of control and to keep there country looking its best. These regulations work. Because no one is prepared to look like a fool in thier community not being in compliance. There could be nothing worse than not obeying the law and you will always be corrected if spotted not observing them by anyone that notices the infraction. I'm glad I'm back in California. But, I still look forward to traveling back Germay. Even if they seem to lack a bit of indivdualism. They must think we all beat to our own drum when they vist here. Some people obey the laws and some don't. I'm glad that we are a melting pot that is what makes America so interesting to me. Now where's the remote. Just kidding.... Germans really do relax more when they leave the country and travel. But as you know if you have lived there they will always be right and if you give them this and not to get defensive. You'll understand there point of view. That dose not mean that they will understand yours. Take the higher ground. We can travel 3000 miles by plane and still we are in the same country we border two oceans and have some of the most amazing national parks in the world should I mention some world class cities. Besides the control issues they have to live with, Germans need all the vaccation so they can get to recharge their batteries. They live in a country that is almost land locked and for the most part everyone lives in apartments that are about 900 sq ft. and its cloudy most of the year also its not common to just strike up a conversation with somone you do not know.
I agree with Mary and April, Americans can learn a thing or two from Germans about recycling and cleanliness.  My Mom is from Germany and I've had no problem with recycling except to do so here in Texas is hard.  Some of or recycling units don't have the proper machines to recycle most things plastics and certainly no differnce for us in green, brown or white glass.  I would love to see seperate recyling bins for glass just like I've seen in Germany.  We're on this earth as "visitors" and I believe we should work harder on keeping it "greener". "alles in ordnung" is not so happily or so easily embraced but would so benefit us in Texas, in America!
It's all about perception - some people that are comfortable with the German way of doing things may think that America is a filthy country - but they should try visiting someplace like Mexico City, or Amman Jordan.  I realize that we Americans could do a lot more for the environment, but at least we generally agree that it is a bad idea to burn tires in the back yard, toss bags of garbage on the side of the road at a downtown stop light, and throw leftovers [and other trash] out of the kitchen window.  Sure we can improve the way we do things - but it could be worse...
I am a Soldier living in Germany, this is my second tour, I have been here this time since 2005, Germany is a beautiful country. I love it here, I was here in 1998-1991; yes the forests was very clean, it has changed some, but it is still clean, and crime is not bad here. If I could retire here I would.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=700405

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.