ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



For Cuba, a sea change with barely a ripple

Posted: Sunday, February 24, 2008 3:10 PM
Filed Under:


Cuba’s rulers seem to have pulled off what many would have considered unthinkable just a few years ago – a systematic and tidy transfer of power from one Castro to the next.

For ages, Cuba watchers feared that the island would either unravel or erupt when Fidel Castro stepped down. Some predicted a political power struggle would ensue, sparking thousands to flee across the Florida Straits on homemade or smuggler’s boats. Others envisioned Cubans flooding the streets to demand democratic freedoms denied under socialist rule.

Instead, when Raúl Castro officially took over the presidency Sunday, the nation serenely went about its daily business.

In truth, over the past year or so, people here have acted fairly blasé about the whole Fidel business.

VIDEO: Complaints about new Cuban leader

Shortly after he fell gravely ill and temporarily handed over power, Fidel’s overshadowing presence began to fade from the country’s collective consciousness.

People began referring to Fidel’s rule in the past tense.

People dared to imagine life after the man who had ruled for close to half a century.

And the longer he remained hidden from public view, the more people began speaking out.

During the 18 months Fidel Castro was sidelined by illness, average Cubans openly advocated his retirement — from his detractors to those supporters vowing to carry out his legacy.

"He has been our teacher, and now it’s time for him to rest," said Daniel Soto, who studies economics at Havana University and belongs to the UJC, Cuba’s young communist organization.

Daniel Yero, a waiter in Havana’s Chinatown, thinks the entire system is broken and supports a radical change to sweep across Cuba’s political structure. "I think it’s a terrible country because we don’t have money. We don’t have freedom. We don’t have nothing. We need change. Change! Change! Please!"

Scratch the surface, though, and you see a new Cuba emerging.

For the first time in all my years on the island, people are speaking out loud and clear about what does and doesn’t work here.

VIDEO: Raul Castro takes over in Cuba

"Just about everyone is clamoring for change," admitted a Cuban government official. "The genie is out of the bottle."

And it was Raúl Castro who held the lamp in his hand and released that genie.

Over a year ago, he authorized grass-roots meetings across the island for people to air their grievances. A leaflet laying out the guidelines for those meetings stated that the discussion would take place in an "atmosphere of profound freedom and sincerity."

Many took his words at face value. No topic was considered taboo, although the meetings were off-limits to the international press. Before the process ended in December 2007, more than 3 million people attended close to a quarter of a million of these government-organized gripe sessions.

Surprisingly to no one familiar with this island, millions of complaints rolled in about how hard life is for the average person.

People mainly grumbled about the high cost of living and low state wages, the island’s dilapidated housing stock, inefficiencies in the national health care system and problems in public transportation.

"No one in this country is happy with their wages. After paying your mortgage, bus fare and electricity, there is not enough money left over to pay for food. It’s that simple," said Liliana Rodriguez, a social worker who helps families in trouble.

People also complained about not being allowed to open up small businesses or book a room in Cuban hotels reserved for international tourists. Others want the law to change so they can freely travel abroad without first asking for government permission, as well as buy and sell their homes and cars.

"Who owns my house and car? Not me, since I can’t sell them!" complained Lucy Valdes, a retired engineering professor.

Raul Castro is viewed as a reformer by good numbers of Cubans, having earned that reputation after he himself publicly criticized food shortages and hardships of everyday life.

"Criticism when handled right is the key to making progress," said Castro, acting then as interim president. "We agree that too many prohibitions and rules do more harm than good."

At the same time, though, he warned the nation not to look for quick fixes. "Nobody here is a magician or can pull resources out of a hat," said Raul Castro.

Both outside experts and government officials appear to share his view. For the time being, sources tell us not to expect to see any big or systemic changes to the Cuban economy -- an idea reinforced on Sunday when the Cuban parliament named hard-line idealogue Jose Ramon Machado, 77, vice president.

But telling Cuba’s working poor to be patient is another story as they struggle to better take care of their families and improve their current standard of living.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I can not understand the majority of the US politicians and the well-paid reporters that keep hammerigs the news of changes in Cuba and how much is Raul Castro  going to change the country.
Why dont you understand that "NOTHING" has changed.
The same criminals are in power and to change is to give up the power and the arms. Do you know how much blood is in Fidel, Raul and the rest of the criminal'hands. Only naive ignorants believe there will be any change or the Obamas of this world will repeated for political advantage
What makes me sick is the American left, who revere Castro's Cuba.  Why don't they fight for the political prisoners in Cuba like they fight for al-quida in Iraq?  Traitors all.
cubans have to get permission to sell their homes and cars because they got them for free from the government
As a Canadian who has visited Cuba twice, the second time for 2 weeks in Old Havana I find some of your comments on Cuba to be wrong.  The idea that Cubans hate Castro and the country couldn't be further from the truth.  Yes, they wish life was easier but they know most are far better off than before the revolution.  Their schooling and medical is excellent and on the whole, I found them to be warm, happy people who go out of their way to make tourists feel welcome.  Maybe take some blinders off and see the good things that Cuba has to offer.  
Thank you, B. Martin
Russel: The gov did not give away any homes or cars in Cuba, they stole them from thier rightfull owners and they "passed" them to the snitches and all who helped them do their crimes that way a segment of the population will always be scared of change
This is sad, the American left is without any understanding of unchecked power. The communists murdered millions of people. Not just in Cuba, but in every country that they held power: Russia, China, Czechoslovakia, Poland, East Germany, Viet Nam, Laos, Cambodia- the list goes on.
Be real Mr. Noboloney, why would you think it's the left that's not concerned. Where are you getting your info? Maybe it's not a priority as the security of our country and it's people
Cannot phatom the thought of the U.S. Media lauding the "Democratic transition in Cuba" (Smoke screen)when in reality the power basin is transending from Fidel to Raul; who's going to stand up against the Castro brothers and their political cronies whom for 49 yrs. have had absolute control of the island and because of this have become millionairs!

All "Leftist Revolutionary" movements that came from Cuba's (1959) and the Cold War era are nothing more than well elaborated schemes that exploited the Western powers: U.S., Canada, the E.U. and the likes for 50 yrs; Communism in its true essence is a scam, period.

Now, Castro decides to retire and the liberal media are head over heels trying to get the headliner about Fidel, Raul, and the island cronies, please folks let end this Zero Sum game, we've been hood winked!
What is the REAL reason we can not have Cuba as a friend. Germany, Japan, Viet Nam are friends. But not Cuba. Some day the truth will be known.
Elmer  Kirkland, WA
There was no retirement from Fidel Castro.  People need to read his statement more closely.  His words were "I will neither aspire to nor accept, the positions of President of the State Council and Commander in Chief."  At no point does he say he will be gone from the political landscape of this communist government.  He remains the Head of the Communist Party (the only party in Cuba) and the most important post in the nation's government.  He will still be around, even his successor and brother Raul said he would still consult everything with him.  The same party loyalists to Fidel will be there for Raul.  Sadly for Cubans they will have to continue to live poor and oppressed with the younger Castro in power.  Sadly for Americans we will still continue to be blamed for Cuba's failed economy, even though the problem is from the country's leaders and not the embargo.  Canada, Latin American and Spain will continue to be economic partners with Cuba's soprano-like leaders and guarantee that they will continue to persevere and increase their fortunes in offshore accounts, and the Cuban people will continue to yearn for better living conditions (economic and political) and continue trying to flee this once great countr; now in ruins because of a revolution that is a mythical falsehood and battle cry for the new generation of leftist leaders who call themselves socialist.
Does this mean that all the Cubans will now be able to back to Cuba????
Nobody has a clue of what has pappened, is happening and will happen in Cuba. Most of those who make a living out of writing about Cuba are as ignotrant as can be
The reason the U.S didn't use the same tatic as in Middle East is simple. Cuba doesn't have oil. If they did, the U.S.would have overthrown Mr. Castro years ago.Mr.Casto was crook and his brother is propbably the same.Sometimes there is isn't any justice in this world.
please, get a grip! We fought a war with Vietnam, had our soldiers tortured in prisons there, and we voted to give them favored nation status. China is our largest trading partner, lender to us and our banks, and yet both countries treat their own citizens as bad or worse than Cuba. And don't forget Russia. We're just still pissed off the Castro wouldn't be our lap dog after we backed him and all the Cubians in Florida vote as a block for either the Demo or Republician who is "Anti-Castro" the loudest.  Nixon went to China and Russia and opened doors and started the changes and the ONLY way it will happen in Cuba is when we have people willing to buck the politicans and bow the the vocal minority and do what is right.
There will be change.Cuba is going to step in the direction of China now.The fact that the Cuban government is now allowing workers to be paid directly by the foriegn companies that employ them is a very good sign.They have to pay heavy tax but it's still a first for Cuba.
The U.S. should ease up on demands for political change and reciprocate economic change with increased trade.The Cuban govt. cannot be expected to commit political suicide.It's just not realisitic.But economic libralization will put food on the table of the Cuban people and in time,democracy will follow.
Russell,  ""they got them for free from the government"" ????
There is a popular saying among us Americans, "It is better to stay quiet and look dumb than to open your mouth and remove all doubt" WHAT IS FREE IN CUBA?  You work like slaves for pennies a day just to survive, with no hope of improvement, no promises, no guarantees.  The government allocates housing to a select few the rest need to fend for themselves.  FREE? Two or more families living in a space divided by a cloth so they can have somewhere to call home? FREE? You have a lot to learn.
I think Raul Castro is working to change Cuba, but
like everyone says it will take time. He has just
become President of Cuba . He's already start by authorizing meetings across the island, for people to
discuss there grievances. Thats a great start freedom of speech.    
OMG!!! You guys are so ummmm... informed!!!
Ah, what joys it is to have uninformed republicans talking. What party was JFK again? Yes I'm quite sure he 'revered' castro's cuba... I'm sure if I listened closely I can hear all of those 'traitorous' democrats talking about how much they LOVE cuba. Oh wait, sorry they're too busy digging us out of Iraq and the hole the republicans stuffed this country in.

But wait, why worry about small potatoes Cuba when we can take on North Korea!? Yeah! Oh wait they have nukes, nevermind. Let's waste time on some country that hasn't made a TRUE hostile overture towards us in decades.

Genius.
The US has accidentally protected Cuba and the communists. If Cuba were not so close to us geographically, with the added complication of GITMO, some right wing Latin dictator have kicked their butts a long time ago.
Cuba has not had a military coup all the years that Fidel was in power BECAUSE the wealth and power was distributed enough to keep them happy. With Raul in charge, there has been no change in this power/wealth distribution. Expecting change from those currently in power is not very likely. What I hope will happen is that Raul will be more humanitarian, see what there system has not served the people well and is open to changes and economic reform. Hopefull the USA will change its policy towards Cuba, which trying to force change of a dictator has hurt the 11 million Cubans on the island. I hope exports will increase tremendously and that the USA lifts travel and financial aid restrictions from Cuban-Americans here in the USA.
This has probably been considered for a while. Still a dicatorship in Cuba. :(

JFK should have sent the air support at the Bay of Pigs. Havana would have a MLB team and a couple of World Series pennants by now. Not to mention the people being better off in every other way :( Think South Korea vs North Korea.
Free?! .... NO. Russell you got it wrong, my grandparents got their farm taken away. The city house was a consolation prize for the land they lost.
Change will only come to Cuba when an American gov't finally realizes that the 40+ years of embargo on this island country has been nothing but stupid and  futile and stops the whining long enough to maybe start with some diplomacy - not exactly your greatest strength in recent years
Oh please.  Doesn't anyone get this?  Fidel Castro will give up "power" when he is dead and in his grave.  Didn't anyone notice that he is still 1st Secretary of the Communist Party of Cuba.  These two positions are parallel/equivalent with the party leader position probably superior, especially with Fidel Castro in the position.  Ever heard of "Chairman Mao"?  Mao ran everything until he became decrepit and died, and he did it from the party position, not the government position.  He does not need the "position" of president to be the Stalinist dictator of Cuba.  Communist dictators do not retire (exception Kruschev---who was made a nonperson by a palace coup).  Check your history books---Lenin/Stalin/Brezhnev/Chernenko/Andropov/Mao and on and on.   He will croak, in his bed with his syncophantic retainers awaiting his last breath; clawing his hold on power and trying to prevent his final descent into hell.
Raul Castro is Cuba's savior?

Is this the same Raul who excecuted over 500 Cubans the first month of the Rovolution and was accomplice to over 4000 Cubans shot?

Is this the same Raul who gave the order to shot down the unarmed planes of Brothers to the Rescue?

Is this the same Raul who convicted General Ochoa to be excuted after he had authorized drug traffic to support the regime following the fall of the Soviet Union monetary support?

Give me a break.
I am somewhat amazed at the ignorance of your responders with regard to Cuba.  People seem to forget the cruel and harsh dictatorship of Baptista who was supported by the U.S. sugar and tobacco industries. The U.S. has itself to blame for the hostility of Castro and his turn to the Soviet Union for financial aid.

The first place that Castro approached after overthrowing Baptista was the U.S. under President Eisenhower.  The U.S. tobacco and sugar lobbies screamed bloody murder and Castro did the only thing he could do and that was to approach the Soviet Union.

Like it or not the people of Cuba, particularly in rural areas are far better off in terms of living conditions, health, education, housing than under Baptista.  I was there a few years ago and hitched-hiked in rural areas in the eastern part of the country.  In every area there were maternal-infant clinics with regular exams, vaccinations.  People had access to post-secondary education free of charge.  Dental care is free and of top quality. Housing is not the greatest but the water is sanitary and safe to drink.

And, unlike Mexico, Columbia, Guatamala there is a law and order.  As a middle-aged white woman I could walk the streets at night and hitch-hike without  problem except for l drunken German tourist.

What is amazing is that Cuba has survived regardless of the embargo of the most powerful military force in the world.
It is time to bury the grudge between the US and Cuba. The embargo has only served to hurt Cuba's people not it's leaders. I fail to see the point after so long. The removal of the embargo would more than likely encouraged change and do a lot more good than harm. Cuba is a wonderful place despite Its issues and the people are gracious and refined. I wonder if this would have been the case in a democratic Cuba.
Does anyone really care about Cuban economy? Really? All we can do is sit in our living rooms, watch CNN (communist news network) and criticize other countries as well as our own on things we don't know anything about.  In that regard, if you don't like America that much, why do you take what you have for granted?  Just move to another country if you hate it here so much.  So many are quick to point the finger, but will do nothing about it. (mostly because they don't hold a position of authority to make the change)  But still, if you don't like it here I'm sure someone has a closet big enough for you to cry in...jerks.
what is really amazing is the coment by Russell.  It shows the level of ignorance that we have to deal with in this country.  I will like to post a question to Russell, what do you really know about Cuba or cubans?  I will await your answer with great curiosity.
Cubans categorize Fidel as such a monster.As a Caribbean- American I detest communism however there is some credit he deserve. Look at health care and note that in Cuba if you can't study academically, you learn a skill.Most Cubans when theyimmigrate they bring something. SO GIVE TO FIDEL WHAT IS FIDEL..
tony from michigan...being a democrat or a liberal does not automatically mean that one supports castro's cuba.  it angers me when i see ignorant assumptions like this that generalize the electorate as if some magical "liberal boogeyman" exists on the left in this country, and that we support autocratic dictators like castro.  this is typical conservative pundit's hogwash.  guess what: if you bother to READ karl marx, whom i'm sure you think all liberals worship, you'd learn that he would've PREDICTED all of the problems faced by Cuba right now because they centralized power in the state, just like every communist regime has done in recent history.  Marx said that "socialism is the surest path to democracy."  what castro's cuba has done has nothing to do with this at all.  in marx's ideal state, people could directly elect their officials and had the ability to recall civil servants at will.  this, of course, is not the case in cuba, which has an oligarchic regime based on propping up a cult of personality devoted to a dictator.  it happened in russia, it happened in china, and it's happened in Cuba.  educated american liberals do NOT support fidel castro, nor do they want to see us move to something as out-dated and foolish as a command economy.  if they did, they'd be communists, not liberals.
Mr Rusell since when car or houses are free in Cuba? You pay for houses once you receive one. But do not forget that in Cuba renting is not commnon because is mostly illegal. Many times three or four generations live together in the same old family house. They are cheap, maybe. Subsidize? Yes. The rest of the people inherited or built their own houses with many difficulties, including working on the project. Cars? What cars? Most of them in CUba where inherited from your parents or grant parents. A few had car sold to them by the government. Others bought from old people until they banned them. Please. Inform your self better or do not talk about what you you know nothing.  Julio
Car or houses are not free in Cuba Theou pay for houses once they receive one. But we should not forget that in Cuba renting is not commnon because is mostly illegal. Many times three or four generations live together in the same old family house. They are cheap, maybe. Subsidize? Yes. The rest of the people inherited or built their own houses with many difficulties, including working on the project. Cars? What cars? Most of them in CUba where inherited from your parents or grant parents. A few had car sold to them by the government. Others bought from old people until they banned sales years ago.  Julio Benitez
OK LETS SEE IF UR GREAT US GOVERMENT WILL DO WHAT IT HAS SAID IT WILL DO WHEN FEDEL IS NO LONGER THE PRESEDENT OD CUBA I GOT A 1000.OO TO BET WE WILL NOT I DID DOT LIKE FEDEL ONE BIT  IM GLAD HE IS GONE BUT I DO KNOW WE WILL NOT KEEP OUR PROMUISE TO THE PEOPLE OF CUBA  AND THAT IS TOO LIFT THE EMBARGO AGANST THEM I THINK IF WE CAN HELP REBILD JAPAN  AND NOW IRQUE WE CAN HELP THEM ALSO
Poor Cubans - if they weren't so lazy they could start a revolution
Gee, and who built those homes?  Who paid for them?  Certainly not the "government."
This is a reply to Russell:
Sir, in Cuba nobody gets free houses or cars,  everybody pays or paid a mortgage but you can't sale your house even if you paid it, exchange of houses is allowed, without money involved. About cars, for modern cars the government gives the authorization to buy it, but you have to pay for it and then you can only sell it back to the government that will pay you almost nothing for the car, and to get this authorization you have to be a government officer older cars from the 50's and 40's can be sold freely.
Instant political reform in Cuba will only result in a similar scenario that befell Russia and the fall of the Soviet Union. Socialism cannot be converted to democracy overnight. Anarchy will prevail and the poor will suffer even more as corruption ensues. Patience and slow social change will give Cuba strength, economic growth and political freedom.
The last thing that Cuba needs is our interference and our (US) pressure to reform. Give the Cuban people a chance.
I say open travel and commerce with Cuba but restrict outside political influence.

By the way, I'm a hardcore republican but I'm also a pragmatist.
dear tony noboloney. where and when were you brainwashed ? Was it the idiocy of Rush Limbough? The lunacy of Bill "O'Reilly? The unintelligent blather of Ann Coulter? You for one aren't the American you think you are, and it doesn't surprise me one bit that you are from Michigan.
In response to the first comment, I fail to see so much difference between politicians in general.

I am happy to be living in a country where one is free to be an idiot and express their idiocy on a web page such as this one...  What do Al-Quiada supporters have in common with Cuban supporters?

Cubans got their homes and cars from the government because they couldn't buy them.

I wish our government would organise large gatherings to protest agains their lunacy, but they frown on gatherings and force you to get permits, etc., and then they beat you up if you're having too much fun.  And if you appear to be on the verge of actually accomplishing something, you might get shot.

I wish the Cubans all the best and look forward to the day when I am free to visit.
One day they will topple the statues there as they did in the Soviet Union.  What a waste of a revolution!
It is a shame when foreigners are flocking to the beaches and hotels of CUBA and spending money that does not go to the needy.  The CUBAN people are some of the most well educated in the in the world, yet they are not allowed to use this intelligence to run their own enterprises.  A free economy would do much to help the impoverished improve their life.
The government seized those homes.
Only the will to help to others would be the solution of cubanpeople.What I am trying to say is how the international community and american media don't see further their nose;I mean ,It is a real chage now in Cuba?NO, is just a legalization of the Raulpower, another criminal and selfish communist;I think only the will of great humans in the world  will be the end of this Dictatorship.
There are certainly much more evil dictators in this world than Castro and his kin.

I suspect that if a giant super power wasn't sitting right on their border harping about how bad communists are they would have been a more open government. Rather they had to shut down and worry about people poisoning them and making their beard fall out.

Not saying he's all good. Just that there are a dictators out there that are lots worse and lots more evil. Castro isn't a nut.
My family that's left in Cuba owned not just their homes but some of the other homes on their block. Now they have nothing.  I do agree that the majority of the people were given their homes for free though.  I also believe that as long as there is a communist in the Cuban government, there will be absolutely no change whatsoever!
liberta,liberta,liberta.....
There is not such a thing as "for free" nothing is for free there, you pay a high price, you pay with liberty, you become a slave of the government, only a few, the ones that help the oppression, will get a car or a house
I guess nobody understands that the transition couldn't be any other way. Fidel and his brainless brother have ruled Cuba for half of century bringing terror, death, and misery. If you say the wrong thing at the wrong time in Cuba, you will be dead, that's how communism works for those who live here and take things for granted not knowing how things work in a communist country. You could, in fact, we are expressing our opinion here, right now; unfortunately this is only a dream for any cuban living within the Castro's brother regime.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=698452

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.