ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



Anger boils over as aid trickles into Bangladesh

Posted: Thursday, November 22, 2007 3:43 PM

KALIKA BARI, Bangladesh -- We could hear the angry crowd well before the yellow, squat government building came into view.

It was under siege from 200-300 desperate cyclone survivors, jostling and shouting as they clambered for a share of the first aid to arrive in the village since a cyclone devastated Bangladesh six days ago.

"We need more, we need more," one man told NBC News. "One hundred per cent of the people in this village were affected by Cyclone Sidr. Everybody needs help. Everybody."

Inside the government building, a team of agitated aid workers handed out high-protein biscuits through a barred window, three boxes per family. Faces were pressed against the window; outstretched hands implored them for more food.

Police officers tried to keep the crowd at bay.

Within an hour all the biscuits had gone, but not the angry crowd, which remained demanding more help. The survivors taunted a police officer who urged them to return to what remained of their homes. An aid worker promised that more relief would arrive Friday.

A town uprooted
That was the scene we found in the village of Kalika Bari, where almost every house is damaged. Up to 20 people died here.

Corrugated tin roofs and uprooted trees still litter the roads and fields. Most crops were destroyed; the shredded stumps of banana trees line a narrow river.

Villagers recalled harrowing stories of escape. One fisherman showed us the injuries to his chest, lacerated after twelve hours clinging to a tree.

We also heard complaints about government storm warnings. Although these warnings did get 1 million people out of harm’s way, Jehangir, a local teacher, told us that many in this village did not know about the approaching storm.

"The people here are illiterate, they don’t have television or radio, they did not know the storm was coming," he said.

Jehangir also showed us the battered village school where he worked, its roof ripped off, walls and windows destroyed. Yet in what remained of one classroom a small group of children continued to study.

Weathering the storm
The main school building was sturdier. It had been deliberately built to serve as a storm shelter and 800 people huddled in there on the terrifying night the storm hit, as the 150 mile per hour winds battered their homes. The storm was the worst disaster to hit Bangladesh since 1991, when a cyclone killed 143,000 people.

Kalika Bari is in southwest Bangladesh, in one of the worst-hit areas. It took several days to clear the roads, but traffic is now moving, and a local ferry service should start Friday.

Relief workers insist that large amounts of aid are now flowing into Bangladesh, but from what we have seen on the ground here, it has yet to arrive in large quantities in shattered villages like Kalika Bari.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

For as long as I can remember (over 65yrs) Bangladesh suffers every few years from another horrific cyclone. Why doesn't the government or the world community build centralized structures capable of housing thousands and also capable of withstanding a category V cyclone? With a decent warning system and such structures, surely thousands could be saved.
i hope that while so many of us are eating our thanksgiving dinner and watching tv tonight, that we can remember those in this country and all over the world who are without. many of the ills in our society are caused by greed and reprehensible extravagence...we act as if it will not run out, that we will always have this abundance. in reality, it is running out now and we are destroying the Earth and we are guilty of destroying the cultures and communities of innocent people, both at home and abroad. so please, in betweeen mouthfuls, please take a reality check and ask yourself what you are doing to give back, ask yourself if you harbor hatred for people who are different, ask yourself if you really want to destroy this Earth so that your children and grandchildren will face suffering and privation you didn't see in your lifetime? ask yourself, and please remember those who suffer, many of whom suffer directly because of american greed and exploitation.
Whatever happened to self reliance?
Where is the rest of the world. It seems to me that healthy regions nearby should get more invoved.
I wish that all countries able to assist these victims would do so as time is critical.   We have to help each other out; let us all realize that we are all connected to each other; we all share the same planet.  
I had spoken to a friend from Bangladesh. Apparently his area was unaffected. I am a 40 year old man and the world has never seen so much chaos at once, in all of my years. I live in mexico now. These people have ALWAYS suffered to some degree. As an American I find it sad that there is so much misery in this world. Yet as an American I have never experienced it.
The Bangladeshies will survive, many more I am sure will die. The ones that die may indeed be the lucky ones.
How many lives can be saved in a disaster, if only the people were educated? Why cannot governments require education? I just cannot rationalize the reasoning of keeping people ignorant.
I have read many articles on this disaster, which have stated aid is going out, aid has been pledged, american naval ships are standing by with necessary items, with only a request from the government needed. This is not a time for pride, or 'requests'. Just do it. Give the aid even if it is dropped from choppers. We are intelligent enough to know what is required to sustain basic life-- food, water, shelter. It can be energy bars, water tx tablets, tents, etc., etc.. We can get a rough idea as to how many people are in need. Do the math, start dropping necessities. The world is insane, if it cannot figure this one out. Those in charge of disasters--in any country--wake up you morons.
our thoughts and prayers are with those suffering in bangladesh, battered by one form or other of devastation to the already suffering country. no amount of help can replace the loss of a loved ones. it is a sigh of relief that the generosity of people around the world is pouring in.  thanks for the generosity.
Sir
I have always stated and will harp on one small fact. Like this or not. The world may be flat and we are closer to one another. Many years gone. The wealth how ever is the barrier and poor will be kept at bay. Rich will have their own club. Poor will look at the rich for few crumbs they see by the diamonds and gold with their sweat stuck to these. The poor will remain poor. Who cares as long as the elite have the shiny roofs over their heads.
I thank you
Firozali A.Mulla MBA PhD
P.O.Box 6044
Dar-Es-Salaam
Tanzania
East Africa
the world is to busy making war to worry about saving lives
DAMN!. WE COULD KEEP THAT SHUTTLE ON THE GROUND JUST ONCE AND FEED ALL OF THESE POOR PEOPLE!< IN THIS DAY IN AGE THIS SHOULD NOT BE HAPPNING!. These OIL COMPANIES ARE CONNTING THEIR WEALTH AND THESE PEOPLE ARE FIGHTING OVER WHO GETS A BISKET!. COME ON WORLD!. AND I MEAN EVERY SINGEL COUNTRY ALL UNITE!. LIFE IS OUR PRIORITY AND HELPING YOUR FELLOW MAN IS TWO!> I am ASHAMED TO BE A HUMAN BEING AT TIMES!. I CANNOY EVEN BEGIN TO IMAGIN WHAT GOD IS THINKING!. WHAT DO YOU THINK?!.
lets see, didnt bill clinton and g. bush sr. just beg for millions to be sent to about the same area a couple of years ago, what did they send for katrina, oh i remember.......nothing.
It is sad to see that western countries gauge everyone in the world by their own standards. First it was distributing cookies and bags of chips with forks and knives to Afghan refugees in Kabul. To people who have never had any concept about such frivolities! And now it is "high protein cookies" to Bangladesh. YOU WANT PEOPLE TO LIVE THER LIVES ON NUTRIGRAIN BARS??? HEY, WHY DON'T YOU LIVE ON IT ALL DAY HUH? Why the long lines outside Burger King for MEAT ON BREAD, or Wendys for BAKED POTATOES??? When are these "aid" agencies - that only serve to line their own pockets, the pockets of their administrators, the pockets of the corrupt government officials in less developed nations, and the pockets of the army mess - these eyesore "aid" agencies who put salt on wounds insteaad of helping them heal - WHEN are these "aid" agencies - and the people who contributeto them - going to realize that PEOPLE WHO HAVE NOTHING NEED REAL FOOD - Rice, Wheat, Barley, Maize, Beef, Chicken, Fish, Eggs, clean drinking WATER - NOT COCA COLA!! - how come humanity forgets the edible food pyramid when it comes to shelling out "BARE NECESSITIES" for poor folk???

Nutrigrain bars!!!   Looks like Kellogg sure makes money from bad situatons.

Wake up people! Oxfam, Save the Children - wake up and distribute some rice so that people can eat their own food the way they KNOW HOW. Stuff your aid costs down your snobbish high-falutin throats, and save the price of packaging and recycling costs as well. Wake up and BE MORE EFFICIENT!!! Stop patting yourself on the back for peanuts, and DO SOMETHING!!
With all the billions of dollars these oil rich nations are paid every day one would think that they would be more than eager to give relief to another Muslim society in urgent need. So once again the burden falls on the free and generous people of the so called decadent west. The poor wretches will now bemoan that the wealthier nations in the west ignored their pleas and their greed has them turning a blind eye to their plight. Sorry if I heard that tune before I'm getting immune to all this wounded duck mentality it comes at us non-stop. Is this how they intend to destroy our great nations through our generosity. Just stand by while we go broke aiding and feeding the needy while them with their greedy hands keep gathering in record oil profits. The time has come people to see the world like it really is them against us. Just because they need help does not mean we have to supply it.
For a country whose population is almost 90% Muslim, where is the aid for Bangladesh from the oil-rich Arab states? I'm afraid it's the same story as with the tsunami in Indonesia. Despite the Arabs' petro-chemical billions, the largest amount of aid from the Middle East back in 2004 (once again, for a Muslim state) was from ISRAEL!
give me a freaking break. Illiterate or not, tv or no tv, radio or no radio, if you see a million person exodus, what would you do?
With all the billions of dollars these oil rich nations are paid every day one would think that they would be more than eager to give relief to another Muslim society in urgent need. So once again the burden falls on the free and generous people of the so called decadent west. The poor wretches will now bemoan that the wealthier nations in the west ignored their pleas and their greed has them turning a blind eye to their plight. Sorry if I heard that tune before I'm getting immune to all this wounded duck mentality it comes at us non-stop. Is this how they intend to destroy our great nations through our generosity. Just stand by while we go broke aiding and feeding the needy while them with their greedy hands keep gathering in record oil profits. The time has come people to see the world like it really is them against us. Just because they need help does not mean we have to supply it.
I can't help but wonder what other nations think of today's MSNBC front page.  On the one hand are the people of Bangladesh--almost a footnote.  On the other are frantic Americans rushing the doors of stores so that they can get their "share" of the Black Friday sales.  We'll spend hundreds, and sometimes thousands of dollars, on our families trying to give them the "perfect" Christmas, while on the other side of the world, the poorest of the poor beg for help.

What is wrong with this picture?
enlist 200,000 bangladesh men for peacekeeping duties in iraq! was it not once called east pakistan
Why do reporters report these types of stories without information or links on how to give?
Why couldn't there have been a siren sound
that means disaster coming:  EVACUATE! for the illiterate people of Bangladesh.
There are floods and hurricanes often there; there needs to be a warning and evacuation plan in advance.  This news was half obscured but a panel at left of screen.
I feel sorry for these people. But the truth is the Katrina and Rita help wasvery slow in comming. Many are still with out homes. Promises of goverment aid and small buisness loan, which as so full of red tape, and disapointemtn to the many who have applied. The ones I know that recieved approved FEMA money, had $10,000.00 held back by FEMA, saying if more funds came then they would get it. I say if they where approved they should have gotten the full amount.We pour millions of dollars abroad, but forget out charity starts at home.I am not saying do not help others, I am saying tend to your own first.
THE INDIAN GOVERNMENT STATED
that dam, and other infrastruture were never finished, and no one knows where the money appropriated for these "disaster prevention" projects went.
Now - we have needless death, starvation, pestilence..a pox
on the bad politicians.
While I may have sympathy for those unfortunate people in Bangladesh, where is it that I must correct the problems they face? Charity begins at home, where were they after Katrina?
Maybe if this country had, say a spare $2 billion laying around we could do something - oh wait! Didn't we literally LOSE as in MISPLACE AND HAVE NO FREAKING CLUE WHERE IT WENT that exact amount in our "war on terror"?

Oh well Bangladash, I guess you're shit out of luck.
Why do people write such stupid stuff? No wonder the world is f'd up.
I am sure if they just contact Iran they are more than willing to send them anything they neeed! After all they are muslim brothers. Yea, right.
My brother is a United States Marine and is on a ship headed to the region now to help the victims there. So DON"T GIVE ME ANY BULLSHIT ABOUT THE GREEDY AMERICANS!!!! We are first responders all over the world from Pakistani earthquakes to Indonesian Tsunamis and beyond! To the American people please say "thank you"!
I’m broken hearted for their plight, but were there hearts broken with our 9-11 or Katrina or Rita? No help from them. My father all ways said don’t complain about your neighbors yard until your own yard is in order. We need to clean up our own back yard before we clean up the worlds yard.
I say for a few years let's just stay out of all of the worlds affairs. The wars, the politics, the finances, and yes...the aid also. I am sick of the world telling me that I should have a hand in this, but not that. That America is the most charitable, but then "the great satan". We are accused of oppressing the whole of the world's population for our own gain and what has really happened is that those who want to better themselves and live in a society where there is a reward for that, those people will do better. We would be in the same sad shape as everyone else were it not for our ancestors standing up and saying, "We're not gonna take it!"
 I'm tired of being dinged because of that "American Cowboy attitude". I'm proud that I pull myself up and fight for mine. I am not waiting for help. I work every day, and keep my government responsible for it's job. All of these governments everywhere are made up of their people and by their people. It is the responsibility of those people to learn a lesson from this about the quality of their governments and DIE fighting for a quality one instead of dying because of the lack of a quality one.
Listen people. I am not rich, but I am not starving either. I have no mansion, but my roof does not leak, yet I would fix it if it did. Now if I was given or had a large amount of money and claimed to care for these people I do not know, here's what I would do if I was you. 1-Buy a plane ticket for yourself and for each of those kind people on TV who have reality shows that build, fix or repair things. 2-Go to Bangladesh and do everything that the governments "red-tape" is taking too long to do.
I WISH I WAS RICH SO I COULD ACTUALLY BYPASS OUR USELESS SYSTEM THAT FIGURES PAPERWORK AND WORDS ARE  MORE IMPORTANT THAN ACTIONS AND OUR FELLOW MEN AND WOMEN WHO NEED OUR HELP NOW! NOW! NOW! GET IT? GOT IT?
GOOD!!!
I am very sad to hear about the Bangladesh cyclone victims, I am sure Saudi Arabia, Iran and others oil rich counties in the Muslim world with their astronomical resources will be able to help, they could divert the money they spend on supply various GROUPS, mosques and hate books around the globe. I suppose the money they saved from what they didn’t give to the starving in Darfur and other parts of the world will be available also.
Strange that the Red Cross is always in all disasters but I don’t see much of the Red Crescent out side of the Muslim countries.
Sorry, I am merely making an observation and this is the truth of the matter and people in other parts of the world are waiting to see some support from the moderate Muslim community.    
Bangladesh is poor country. America has no inters in it. Just like darfur..............
India's economic gains are documented... the outsourcing from the US has pours Billions into the Indian economy, their economy is on track to surpass the US and Britian, in some reports....while I have no problem sending immediate aid, please don't cry for poor india anymore...

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/south_asia/6294409.stm


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=478497

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.