ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



Harvesting unlikely allies

Posted: Wednesday, November 14, 2007 10:47 AM
Filed Under:

AWARTA, West Bank –

Once the month of Ramadan is over, just before the first rain, Palestinian farmers harvest their olive groves.

The importance of olives to the Palestinian economy cannot be overestimated. They are the single biggest crop for Palestinians and hold important cultural significance – especially as they symbolize land ownership.

As such, the olive harvest has become a major point of contention between Palestinian farmers and Jewish settlers.  

Miri Yehuda / NBC News
A Palestinian family works during the olive harvest near the Palestinian town of Awarta, in the West Bank.

Every year, there are reports of violence against the Palestinian farmers as settlers intimidate them and even beat them and steal the olives. 

But Palestinians have found an unlikely ally in their efforts to continue their harvest – a group of Jewish activists, "Rabbis for Human Rights," put themselves in harm’s way to help protect Palestinians during the annual harvest.

Helping to guarantee access to lands
"Rabbis for Human Rights" is an NGO that operates on donations, mainly from outside Israel. 

During the annual harvest, rabbis and other volunteers coordinate with Israeli security forces and the local Palestinian population to help guarantee Palestinians access to their trees during the harvest. Their sheer physical presence helps reduce the number of violent acts of theft and vandalism during the harvest season.

"It’s difficult for me as a rabbi to say this," said Rabbi Yehiel Greiniman of Rabbis for Human Rights, "but I believe there are people who say they do things in the name of the Torah when in fact they go against it. I want to able to tell my children and grandchildren that I acted against wrongdoing."

The rabbis go out with Palestinian families on a daily basis, help pick olives, and when they detect a threat by Jewish settlers, they call the army or Israeli police for help.

Miri Yehuda / NBC News
Rabbi Yehiel Greiniman takes a few minutes to pray while working with Palestinian olive farmers.

Since the second Intifada (Palestinian uprising) began in 2000, the Palestinian economy has taken a major downturn as a result of the many Israeli checkpoints and closures that restrict ordinary Palestinians from travelling anywhere for work.

"We’re happy. Since the rabbis started their activities over three years ago, we can get to our land and work it," said Abu Niaz, a Palestinian farmer from the village of Awarta.

"The rabbis are different from the settlers," he added. "They help us, make it possible for us to stand up, not try to get rid of us like the settlers."

According to the World Bank, up to 100,000 families depend on the olive harvest to some extent for their livelihoods. 

In 2006, thanks to a case brought before the Israeli Supreme Court by Rabbis for Human Rights on behalf of five West Bank villages, the court ruled that the Israeli army must not close off areas in a way that prevents Palestinians from working on their land. The court even added that the military should take steps "to prevent the settlers from interfering with Palestinian farmers from working their lands, and realizing their rights to freedom of movement and freedom of property." 

During the month or so of olive picking, the rabbis publish an appeal for people to volunteer and help out in protecting the Palestinians. They provide transportation for the volunteers and are in touch with locals Palestinians in order to assess where protection is needed. 

It’s heartwarming to see the connection between the Palestinian families, the rabbis and the volunteers that work with them. But this gratitude is rarely discussed. It seems they believe this is a basic right, one that doesn't require a "Thank You."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I don't understand the whole thing, I wish someone would educate me on the entire deal between the Palestinians and Isrealis.

Our God is the same.  This region can provide bountifully, with hard work and ingenuity.
Disagreements, caused by the need for control of others, to be right, to impose ones own vision upon another, have lead to conflict.  Cooperation, forgiveness, courage, and an inclusive vision, will prove prosperous to all.  Common projects with an equal balance of control, and power given to the contributers will result in trust.  It will transform everything.  It would so affect the world to see this example of common goodness that it would ignite a movement bigger than any witnessed since the removal of the iron curtain. Developing water resources, investing in education, solving common problems, bridging differences and recognizing the complex etiologies of those differences.  

Bless the people who faithfully tend to their olive crop.  And bless the Rabbi's for recognizing the inaliable rights of these special people. I challenge every settler and farmer to get to know his neighbor and to walk in their shoes, so that they might walk in yours.


As a Jew and a Christian I am glad to see the Rabbis'
do the right thing and reach out to their Arab neighbors. If these neighbors, in turn, stood up to their Muslim brothers and denounced the hatred and violence aimed at the Israelis, there would not need to be any restrictions on their access to the olive vineyards.
These people have the solution, we can all learn from it. If only these people were our world leaders, just think what a world we could live in. God bless the Rabbis and farmers.
I guess it's great that rabbits can help out, but I'm not sure what a bunch of bunnies can do.
We live, we work, we toil, we kill, we spin our wheels, but do we ever really truely get anywhere. Because of course we die and the cycle begin again.

I guess we all have our parts we should play and it so nice just to say and give praise. But, as a rancher once told me, "nothing gets done unless you dirty your hands son".

How are your hands?
TO DEREK FORT SMITH ( AR ), WHAT IS AN AMERICAN? WHAT IS AN ENGLISH? WHAT IS A BELGIUM? WHATIS A FRENCH?
WHAT IS A GERMAN? A PALESTINAIN IS THE RIGHTFULL OWNER OF PALESTINE AND NOT ISRAELZ AS CLAIMED. IT IS PALESTINE FOR HUNDRED OF THOUSANDS OF YEARS, NOT JUST LIKE AMERICA THREE HUNDRED YEARS OLD.
After the good rabbis leave the settlers will still terrorize Palestinians all year long. The settlers usually get drunk then go out taunting and doing physical harm to Palestinians they encounter on their way.
Hardly any of it is news in the US. But when a Palestinian loses his mind after all this and harms anyone it become an "international terrorist" event.  
To the Rabbis and volunteers, I say God bless you, protect you and continue to give you the strength to carry on. For the people in the region, may be "One good turn deserves another," in this instance, tantamounts to oversimplification. But you have to be tired of hating,killing and dying. There is no gain-saying this is not what God intended.  I hope you reach in and find the peace you sorely need, we all sorely need.
To the Rabbis and volunteers, I say God bless you, protect you and continue to give you the strength to carry on. For the people in the region, may be "One good turn deserves another," in this instance, tantamounts to oversimplification. But you have to be tired of hating,killing and dying. There is no gain-saying this is not what God intended.  I hope you reach in and find the peace you sorely need, we all sorely need.
It seems funny to say that the world would be a better place if we'd just be nice to each other but it is undoubtedly true.  And it's easier and cheaper to be nice.  And people don't get killed, maimed and psychologically ruined by it.  The far reaching effects of being nice are all good--people are nice in return and things get done in the fastest, easiest way and everybody profits from it in many ways and we become contented.  Being nice=contentment.  The people in this article bear that out.  Seems like a no-brainer, doesn't it?

And yet, for the most part, we just can't seem to do it very often.  We'd rather make war, cause devastation, terrorize people, destroy the environment.  You have to wonder what's wrong with us when we prefer to do the wrong, harder thing than the right, easier thing.
This is wonderful!  Please tell us how others may contribute to the works of "Rabbis for Human Rights".  If they are willing to protect the rights of others, I am willing to help make it possible financially, for them to do so.  I am sure a lot of people would be.
I salute these courageous rabbis;may their tribe increase. The question is, will the imams respond similarly? See Romans 12:17-21 for Paul(Saul)of Tarsus' admonition, circa 60C.E.
At this time of chaos among this two nations,it's heartwarming to read such a news, that rabbis have something that the humanity had lost,"solidarity".
I salute these courageous rabbis;may their tribe increase. The question is, will the imams respond similarly? See Romans 12:17-21 for Paul(Saul)of Tarsus' admonition, circa 60C.E.
I'm certainly no sympathizer to the Palestinians, yet I am totally aghast to discover that any Israeli, settler or otherwise, would, of all things, attempt to disrupt an olive harvest, regardless of who owns the trees. Olives hold a sacred place, of all fruits, and it is disrespect toward Almighty G-d to mess with the olive harvest. The Rabbis are doing the RIGHT thing, and the truly Jewish thing. Settlers who would disrupt an olive harvest, are nothing but godless hooligans. Fight over something else if you must, but leave the olives alone, OK?
The God of Abraham, Isaas, and Jacob created both the
heavens and the earth. Jews, Christians, and Muslims are to live on it as brothers and sisters. Did I miss part of the movie?
I have been told that there will ultimately be no "real" and lasting peace in the middle east until the return of Jesus Christ. Period. So while these individuals are spiritually enlightened and truly do "love their neighbors" this is not a "tangible" peace--not yet, we'll all know when that time has come.
"Blessed are the peacemakers,
for they will be called the sons of God." (Matt. 5:9)

Well Done!!  May the rabbis and their volunteers continue to show God's love.  No matter the creed, basic human kindnesses are a blessing.
Wow. American readers are hailing rabbis who protect palestinan farmers from criminal gangs of settlers. That's good. But where did these settlers get all the money to commit their criminal activities ? Answer: United States tax exempt "charity" foundations are probably biggest contributors.
This is a patch and only temporary.  What is needed is a solution to the ongoing strife culminating in peace.  A few, standing in the way of harm in an effort to slow down violence, is a far cry from peace.
A wonderful story indeed!  It takes alot of courage to say what Rabbi Yehiel said in the article.  Bless you Rabbi.  Quote: "It’s difficult for me as a rabbi to say this," said Rabbi Yehiel Greiniman of Rabbis for Human Rights, "but I believe there are people who say they do things in the name of the Torah when in fact they go against it."  It's horrible that the native Palestinians live in squalor in their own country, but hopefully, people will open their eyes and realize we all live on one Earth.  

p.s. to Derek from Fort Smith- what is an isreali anyway? Citizen of an area that was a country from a few thousand years ago?  Or a descendent of a European settler who emigrated to this land no more than 90 years ago living in occupied Palestine?

p.s. to Joshua in New york- Actually, if you are as religious as you indicate, the Romans didn't steal anything.  The covenant God made with the Jews was to live by His law and His word.  If the Jews could do just that, then God would always keep the nation of Israel. The Jews resisted many threats to ancient Israel, even against staggering odds.  If the Romans conquered them, then one of two things occurred.  Either God betrayed the covenant (which is sheer sacrilege) or the Jews failed to live by their own codes of conduct.  (Hmmm isn't that what Rabbi Yehiel was just alluding to?)
Many countries have land holdings won during wars and no one accuses them of stealing the land. I admire the Rabbis for doing God's work and caring more about what's right than what's popular. Did no one else notice that the settlers are said to "see it as their right and no thank you's are said"? It is that attitude of entitlement that is separating people all over the world, including in our country, and it is what I see as the reason that there probably will never be "peace on earth". If a kindness is done, it should be repaid with gratitude, no matter who you are or what you see as your "right".
i thinks it good to see some people of isereal being tolerate towards the palastinians, seen as they have completly taken over there country and have made them trapped ion there own country, wish the government were like these rabbi's
How is it that Jordan doesn't have some legal claim to at least the west bank? I thought that Jordan owned the west bank at least until they joined Syria and Egypt in invading the U.N.- founded state of Israel. Shouldn't Israel and Jordan agree to give the west bank back to Jordan, with security measures to protect Israel? Then, Jordan can help cultivate olives.
Joshua of NY,

Regarding the lack of "Arabs helping Jews".

I don't think the Arabs are in a position to help out with the checkpoints here.

Maybe you can find a story of a Jew helping a German in WWII Germany?



SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=466123

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.