ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



Harvesting unlikely allies

Posted: Wednesday, November 14, 2007 10:47 AM
Filed Under:

AWARTA, West Bank –

Once the month of Ramadan is over, just before the first rain, Palestinian farmers harvest their olive groves.

The importance of olives to the Palestinian economy cannot be overestimated. They are the single biggest crop for Palestinians and hold important cultural significance – especially as they symbolize land ownership.

As such, the olive harvest has become a major point of contention between Palestinian farmers and Jewish settlers.  

Miri Yehuda / NBC News
A Palestinian family works during the olive harvest near the Palestinian town of Awarta, in the West Bank.

Every year, there are reports of violence against the Palestinian farmers as settlers intimidate them and even beat them and steal the olives. 

But Palestinians have found an unlikely ally in their efforts to continue their harvest – a group of Jewish activists, "Rabbis for Human Rights," put themselves in harm’s way to help protect Palestinians during the annual harvest.

Helping to guarantee access to lands
"Rabbis for Human Rights" is an NGO that operates on donations, mainly from outside Israel. 

During the annual harvest, rabbis and other volunteers coordinate with Israeli security forces and the local Palestinian population to help guarantee Palestinians access to their trees during the harvest. Their sheer physical presence helps reduce the number of violent acts of theft and vandalism during the harvest season.

"It’s difficult for me as a rabbi to say this," said Rabbi Yehiel Greiniman of Rabbis for Human Rights, "but I believe there are people who say they do things in the name of the Torah when in fact they go against it. I want to able to tell my children and grandchildren that I acted against wrongdoing."

The rabbis go out with Palestinian families on a daily basis, help pick olives, and when they detect a threat by Jewish settlers, they call the army or Israeli police for help.

Miri Yehuda / NBC News
Rabbi Yehiel Greiniman takes a few minutes to pray while working with Palestinian olive farmers.

Since the second Intifada (Palestinian uprising) began in 2000, the Palestinian economy has taken a major downturn as a result of the many Israeli checkpoints and closures that restrict ordinary Palestinians from travelling anywhere for work.

"We’re happy. Since the rabbis started their activities over three years ago, we can get to our land and work it," said Abu Niaz, a Palestinian farmer from the village of Awarta.

"The rabbis are different from the settlers," he added. "They help us, make it possible for us to stand up, not try to get rid of us like the settlers."

According to the World Bank, up to 100,000 families depend on the olive harvest to some extent for their livelihoods. 

In 2006, thanks to a case brought before the Israeli Supreme Court by Rabbis for Human Rights on behalf of five West Bank villages, the court ruled that the Israeli army must not close off areas in a way that prevents Palestinians from working on their land. The court even added that the military should take steps "to prevent the settlers from interfering with Palestinian farmers from working their lands, and realizing their rights to freedom of movement and freedom of property." 

During the month or so of olive picking, the rabbis publish an appeal for people to volunteer and help out in protecting the Palestinians. They provide transportation for the volunteers and are in touch with locals Palestinians in order to assess where protection is needed. 

It’s heartwarming to see the connection between the Palestinian families, the rabbis and the volunteers that work with them. But this gratitude is rarely discussed. It seems they believe this is a basic right, one that doesn't require a "Thank You."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I salute the rabbis and volunters, hopefully this act will grow to protect all Plaestinian who only want to make a decent living, so I name them Emasadors of good will as my right of a  ex member of the IDF in the war of independence, that is what I fought for, to have a state like the Swis, An Israeli Canton and Arab Canton, all living in peace, but it never happened, what a pity.......If they export their olives or oil, I will be their costumer. Just imagin, Olive oil and olives from the Holy Land.
I applaud the Palestinians and the Rabbis for working together in a loving way as all humans should.  I believe this is how Jesus would have reacted and lived were he living in these lands today as he did many years ago.
May God bring such peace, harmony and love to all the middle east and to all peoples of earth in the new year.
God Bless,
Don
That's awesome.
This is what humanity should be about, that we stop being sheep and step up to do what is right. Love, tolerance and respect will go a lot further and resound alot longer than everything else in this world. This story renews my flagging hope for humanity!
This is awesome, Steal the land and then work along with the people whom you stole the land from. Awesome indeed !
Interesting that only the Israeli's and not the Palestinian suicide bombers are held accountable for the downturn in the Palestinian economy - clearly this is a nice balanced article.

"Since the second Intifada (Palestinian uprising) began in 2000, the Palestinian economy has taken a major downturn as a result of the many Israeli checkpoints and closures that restrict ordinary Palestinians from travelling anywhere for work."
A true unselfish act of kindness.  How wonderful,  how rare.  One small step for olives, one tiny step for humanity.  Peace and love.
I hope this serves as an example for everyone in the region.  We are all human and deserve respect.  The three major faiths of the region, Islam, Judism, and Christianity can all trace their ancestors back to Abraham.  Imagine the good we could do in this world if one day all three faiths worked together as children of Abraham.

Good luck and God Bless both the Rabbis and the farmers.

From a Catholic who grew up on a farm.
Finally, some people with common sense and a pair of balls taking some intuatives in the Middle East.  They are doing G-d's work.
It is really nice to read people in this region are working together towards something positive. The Rabbis and the Volunteers helping the Palestinians access to their trees during the harvest shows how if people just cooperate and help eachother good things will be the outcome. The olive harvest will continue to be a success. There are good things happening it sometimes is hard to find. Thank you for the posting on this subject. Peace to all!  
What a step in the right direction, hopefully, the President would have seen this article. Now is the time for the government to act in bringing these two divided nations together and make this place a prosperous place in the New Year.
Maybe this action will spread and turn into a peace movement thru out the middle east. Where everyone can get along and the fighting will end.
Not only was this "WWJD" this is what every Jew should do.  If we want a just world, then we must do our part to ensure justice!  

I'd be interested for the author to tell us though, who are these "Palestinians"?  Are they, Israeli citizens, or citizens of another state living in Israel, are they descendants of the people who lived in the area in 1948? The article seems to indicate they are not refugees, they are landowners in Israel. Exactly what is a Palestinian?  Just curious.
This is a prime example showing that two diverse communities can work together for what is Right and Just. As a citizen of the world,I find this heartwarming; As a Jew I am very proud.  Bravo!!
One small step taken by Rabbis and volunteers and if we all followed their foot steps wouldn't this world be a better place and peace on planet earth will prevail and all of can live in peace and harmony.

Sam Shivji
I want to thank these Rabbis, for protecting not just the palestinians but also treating them as human beings. Mercy begets mercy and hope and pray that the settlers can see the pain of these people and try not to destroy those olive trees which probably is the only source for several families. My heart goes out for these decent Rabbis and I have seen a video on You tube, how the settlers even kick and drag these rabbis from there beards and hair. I have serious doubt when the settlers cannot show mercy to these rabbis, palestinians are probably dust for them.
why is it that always you hear a israelis giving a helping hand and hardlly ever any palestinian.however this is a good step if the other side apprieciate it
To know what is right and not do it, is the worst form of cowardice."   Confusius.
This is a story with many analogs from the Israeli side, and virtually none from the Arab side.  It's great, but only so far as it goes.  This dispute will never end until both sides demonstrate a willingness to accept the other on the other's terms.  A clear majority of Israelis have made this psychological leap; few Palestinians have.
This is directed to Mike from NH. First off the Israelis  
did not steal the land from the Palestinians, The romans stole it from the Israelis. Second of all regarding your comment about them working next to the people they "stole" it from: what do you think your doing living on land that was full of Indians. Don't see to many of them around here anymore. Are you paying some sort of restitutions to native americans?
I think it's important to understand that there are always civilians (non-combatants) in the center of any conflict, just or otherwise, and they strive simply to be able to work, feed and clothe their kids, and achieve some semblance of a normal life. So, regardless of the explosive emotions surrounding our various opinions on the trouble in the Middle East, it's important to separate these citizens on both sides from those who are politically motivated (which in itself is often necessary). I am happy to see that these Rabbis are reaching beyond social, cultural, and politically boundaries to be kind in a world where kindness is in serious deficit.
These are Jewish rabbis.  The religion factor.  Jewish people and Christian-Palestinians and Moslim Palestinians lived together in Palestine for many years in harmony.  It is the Zionists who terrorize Palestinians and preach hate and horror in the name of Judaism.  The Holy Book never tells anyone to kill or to hurt other people.
To add to my earlier comment, I think it's important to note that these farmers are also reaching beyond social, cultural, and political boundaries to embrace the Rabbi's assistance So both they and the Rabbi's should be commended for being willing to work together where others have failed.
Blessed are the Peace-Makers.
This is wonderful and I wish ALL the people who live there PEACE and HARMONIOUS living together...
I am profoundly proud of the Rabbis. There is a difference between "history" and "his-story". And the Rabbis actions makes them "eliminationists" as per the racial divides that permeate society all over the world. There is one race, the human race. And when we all acknowledge it, the entire world will be bettor off.
it's about time we stop killing each other in the name of god, and start working with each other in the name of god. Everyone needs to step up and do there part even if the cost of the action is dear.
These rabbis have marked themselves with the sign of their faith. I am in both admiration and gratitude for men such as these, and for the Palestinian workers.
Once again we are reminded that, "ACTIONS SPEAK LOUDER THAN WORDS."
G  
why call criminals settlers they are criminals the end. i am sure that all settlers are not criminals. And the rabis also have the support of the Israeli  courts and the military to protect the victims of a crime.I think it would be nice if Palestinians returned the favor when it comes to rocket attacks.
Joshua, Panama city:
 You have it 100% right Rome drove the Jews from JUDEA but people just will not fess up to it. It does not the liberal let's blame the JEWS agenda. Sorry. it's just the way it is.I have tried to bring it up before and no one till now will even pretend that they read it.
Its nice to see Jews helping Arabs.  What we never see is Arabs helping Jews.  Where are the Arab moderates that help the Jews and protest against terrorism?  Where are "the Muslim Imams for humanity"?  Where are the Arabs who dare to stop their brothers from committing terrorist acts??  The problem begs the question of humanity towards Jews...
I commend the rabbis for their courage to do the right thing. Echoing Lyn, I also believe that the Palestinians should be commended as well for working with the Rabbis; surely the more extreme elements of the Palestinian resistance are not happy to see that.
Have some sympathy for Native American Indians. One and two centuries ago they had to deal with Manifest Destiny. During the 20th century Palestinians have to struggle for existence against Zionism. Recognize that  less than 10% of the population of historic Palestine in the late 1800's was Jewish. 90% was Palestinian - whether Christian or Muslim.
Notice that the article (at least the link was ) "Harvesting Unlikely Allies in Israel." If I read correctly these events actually took place in the occupied West Bank, which is not Israel.
God bless the Rabbis and God bless the farmers!!! Peace and love to the whole world in the new year. I pray a peaceful and prosperous Isreal living in Peace with all Arab neighbors will happen in my life time.
Acts of good faith go unpublished far to often. Truth is, for the most part these people want to get along and in daily life they do. The exception is the radical ends of each side. These are the people who make the news and give us the impression that all Palestinians and Jews are hostile towards each other. Think about it, will you ever see a front page headline 'Jews helping struggling Palestinians'?
To Abraham Groswirt: they are already exporting olive oil and olives from the Holy Land, and it's usually fair trade. See www.canaanfairtrade.com and www.holylandoliveoil.com.
Is this another blog to support the american supply of propaganda ? The jews are not willing to give anything ....can not they live with GODS children?
                        oztoona
I will pray for the grace of God to bless
I cannot think of a more beautiful story in these hard times of strife Hats off to all those who thought out the idea and put it into motion
Love breeds love, hatred breeds hatred! No nationality is above the other. We must work together for peace!
To Maury from MD who said: "This is a story with many analogs from the Israeli side, and virtually none from the Arab side. [...] A clear majority of Israelis have made this psychological leap; few Palestinians have"

The US media focuses on Israeli acts of kindness, but that doesn't mean that there are no Palestinians being kind to Israelis. As per your second comment, do you have stats corroborating that? Opinion surveys show that up to 40% of Israelis would be ok with forcefully deporting the Palestinians to Jordan? Isn't that the equivalent of "pushing the Israelis to the sea"? I think both groups have been radicalized after decades of war, and only acts of kindness like these will take them out of the mess...but you seem to care more about judging others than about appreciating kindness.
To Paul from Boston: You said "Interesting that only the Israeli's and not the Palestinian suicide bombers are held accountable for the downturn in the Palestinian economy - clearly this is a nice balanced article"

If you read the article carefully, it did not say that the root cause of the problem was the fault of Israel or the Palestinians. It just pointed out the restrictions of movement imposed on the Palestinians prevented them from working and this was the main cause of the devastation of their economy. It is debatable whether these restrictions were justified for safety reasons or not, and the author did not address that debate.

You missed the main point of the article (an example of kindness and peace) and just focused on confirming your own political view. It's because of people like you who only focus on the "we vs them"/"we're right, they're wrong"/"we deserve dignity/they don't" mentality, that the conflict in the region goes on....
Wonderful, truly great people. Now, if we can only get these Rabbi's to ask the Palestinians to lay down their arms and hatred towards the Jewish people. That would certainly be the accomplishment of the century. Sounds like we should give them the entire "ball of wax" At least someone's on the right track.
A Thank you is still in order. Even though it may be a basic right. I feel the holding back of saying thank you is just plain pride. While there is nothing wrong with having pride one should not let it interfere with common courtesy.
Yes in the land of the hopeless, even the hungry wolf brings hope.... yes take their land and let them work in it instead of kicking them out.  Lesser of two evils indeed is nice but its still Evil

Maybe Mexicans in California one day will say this is our land because many years ago it was all spanish so now there are enough of us here that we will take it away from the Americans and start slaughtering them.

WOW great story " one small
step" wonderfull. But what about these comments ? How
deep does this hate go that
people can not accept this
beautiful act just for what it is ?
It is a step in the right direction. For those who see this as a leap on the part of the Israelis but don't see any effort from the Palestinians-- you should consider the socio-economic situation. Due to sanctions and violence, most Palestinians are barely surviving. It is hard to reach out and help others when you aren't in a position to give help. I wish there were more articles such as these circulating rather than those about violence in the name of religion and beliefs. I am Muslim, and I am saddened that Israelis and Palestinians have used the name of religion to support their underlying agendas. Some of my closest friends, who have my utmost respect, are Jewish. I have been fortunate enough to see openmindedness and compassion from people of both religions. It is my hope that this compassion continues to expand.
Finally a story from the holy land that gives one hope. We in America are quick to demonize the Palestinian people because of the likes of Hamas and other radicals.  This shows that they are decent people and deserve peace as the rabbis would not put forth this noble effort if otherwise. I hope one day there is peace there.
   To Maury who believes that the Israeli's have made the "psychological steps of reconciliation". The Rabbis have not taken a step towards reconciliation, (yes-many Palistinians and Israelis have) but they put themselves in harms way to protect Palistinians from criminals (in this case the settlers). Reconcilliationstarts starts and ends with the nation that holds all the cards, the nation with the power and influence. And yes we need more people like the Rabbis.
This is very moving! we are all human being, let everyone live peacefully. No one is better than others.
Peace on earth, goodwill to all men from Yeshua a Mashiach.
The Rabbis are compensating for an intollerable condition whereby the Zionist 'Settlers' are systematically stealing the Palestian lands.  Justice will be served when the Palestinians asert authority over their territory.  


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=466123

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.