ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



Where did the Berlin Wall go?

Posted: Friday, November 09, 2007 4:01 PM
Filed Under:

This week, visitors to Berlin can get a feel for what it meant 18 years ago to look at Brandenburg Gate with a wall in front of it.

A South Korean artist has installed a fluorescent plastic copy of the Berlin Wall in front of the city's historic gate in protest of the enduring division of the Korean peninsula. But for many visitors interested in the history of the once-divided city, the display is just another piece of chic artwork in the vibrant German capital, and not much more. 

Korean Artist Eun Sook Lee performs next to her illuminated installation 'Vanished Berlin Wall in front of Brandenburg Gate in Berlin
Reuters
Korean Artist Eun Sook Lee performs next to her illuminated installation "Vanished Berlin Wall" in front of Brandenburg Gate in Berlin on Friday.

It is hard to find any of the few remaining sections of the Berlin Wall these days. After reunification, the German government was quick to sell off these reminders of the Cold War. 

A few crumbling segments and a brick trail through Berlin are all that remain of the wall. In an odd way, the now sanitized path reminds me of the Freedom Trail in Boston – it does not resemble the gruesome "death strip" that was equipped with barbed wire, landmines and watchdogs to prevent East Germans from fleeing the country.

Checkpoint Charlie, the famous allied border crossing, is now just a small booth at the end of the elegant Friedrichstrasse, a major shopping area in central Berlin, where tourists can take photos with actors dressed up in old army uniforms.

Gorby – spotted near the old wall
And whatever happened to Mikhail Gorbachev, the man whose Russian policy of perestroika played an important role in the dismantling of the iron curtain?

Well, he’s been seen near the remains of the Berlin Wall recently – in a Louis Vuitton ad.

Gorbachev, a seemingly unlikely face of the French luxury handbag designer, is shown sitting in the back of a car as it drives past what remains of the Berlin Wall in a glossy ad photographed by Annie Leibovitz.  

For sure, it was not an East German Trabant that he was sitting in. But it could have been.

The boxy two-cylinder vehicle that East Germans often had to wait up to 10 years to receive has not entirely disappeared from German streets. This loud, smelly symbol of the communist East has actually become somewhat of a cult object. It serves as a nostalgic reminder of life in the East, "Where not everything was bad," as many former East German citizens say today. 

GERMANY-HISTORY-COMMUNISM-WALL-COMMEMORATION
AFP-Getty Images
Young visitors stick flowers in a portion of the Berlin wall during a commemoration ceremony at the Bernauer Strasse memorial site in Berlin on Friday. 

Unified – but still dissatisfied
A recent poll found that a significant minority of East Germans – 21 percent of those surveyed – feel that life was better before reunification. One reason for East German dissatisfaction is that 74 percent think they are second-class citizens in the new Germany.

It seems that the frustration is mainly a result of continuing economic disadvantages. Wages in the eastern part of the country average 25 percent below those in the West and unemployment is twice as high in many eastern regions.

But, despite continuing economic challenges and a "wall in the minds" of some, most Germans remember November 9, 1989, for what it was: a euphoric, emotional and long-awaited reunion of a nation that had been physically separated by a wall for 28 years.   

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

As a member of the US military stationed in Berlin at that time (1982-1990), today's anniversary reopened a flood of memories.  I can remember the "brefreiungsgeld"  and the long lines of East Berliners at the Aldi stores.  I remember the heady celebration of getting hosed by the East Germans as we danced on the wall.  I also remember taking our family (four sons, two born in Berlin) to plant a tree by a small pond in what was blocked by a portion of the wall near our home in Dueppel just a few weeks before.  I have three very large painted chunks of the wall still...one on my desk at work and two in my office at home.  Alles guete an meine brudern und schwestern im Berlin an dieses Hochtzeit!
Isn't it amazing how quickly people forget?  Not only in Germany, but in the USA as well.  We go about our daily lives, without considering those who made and still make the sacrifices that make our daily lives possible.  I forget who said it, but it's true....those who don't remember the past are doomed to repeat it.  Isn't that mankinds history?  Repeating the same mistakes of the past.

Even today in the USA, we aren't allowed to view photos of the towers or the destruction that came on us that day.  Many Americans have forgetten how it felt already.  And our politicans only consider what political gains they can make off those who died on 9/11.  It all just makes me want to cry and at the same time....it makes me angry!
PLEASE bring back the "Cold War". The world was better off. How many American corporations "downsized" during the "Cold War"?  It seems that when the United States has a "outside" threat, things in the US is almost status quo.
 First the world has The International Communist Conspiracy, now it is the International Capatialist Conspiracy.  Is the world better off now or before?


The USA needs to buy up the old wall and install it at the border with mexico
Funny, I'll never forget my trip to Berlin...staying at the Westin Grand Berlin on the former East side, just a few blocks up from Checkpoint Charlie.  And walking down to the Brandenburg Gate at night with the soft, silent, snow falling....covering, quieting.  But I must say that the chic jewelry, shopping, and leather stores cast a shadow of ickiness in and of themselves.  Seasons change.  
I stood on the Wall on December 31, 1989.  My sense at the time was that the euphoria was derived from the end of the division of the city of Berlin more than the nation of Germany.  As I described it to people, imagine a wall down the middle of Broadway in New York.  When given the chance, New Yorkers would have dismantled the wall and reunited the city as fast as possible.  It is natural to expect Berliners to do the same.  I think the brick strip is a great way to remind people as they drive over it and hear the double "kerthunk" how the Berlin Wall disrupted and corrupted a single city in everyday life.
My asvice to the ex east germans is that,"love your freedom what ever the cost as there is no substitute for it" May i ask the german goverment as to why it is present in afghanistan and iraq, towing the american line when so much discrimination exist between the ex east germans and the others
My world and everything I was taught to believe in college changed  when teh Wall  came  down.  I was a Political Science major at a major American University.  We were taught from day one that the Communists would never, ever freely give  up power.  It was an Iron Law that the East would forever be communist.  And that this man Gorbachev was  some upstart who would  be  replaced if he proceeded to far.  That year, one by one the Communiosts governments seem simply to pack up and go home with little blood shed.  My Political Science world and all the  stuff in it was turned up side down.  When I graduated, no one wanted to hire me because I was taught under the old  belief system which failed to predict  the reality.  I should have majored in Biology.
eBay.
You can see a piece of the wall at Frank Lloyd Wright's "Kentuck Knob" house in South Western Pennsylvania. The British Lord who owns it, Peter Palumbo, an "architecture collector," has a sculpture trail on the grounds that includes the Berlin Wall segment.
There is a piece of the Berlin Wall in one of the men's rooms at the Main Street Station Hotel in Las Vegas.  No kidding!
There is a piece of the Berlin wall at Capital University which is in Columbus, Ohio.  It is a huge piece, and it still have the original graffti on it and bullet holes.  It was really fasinating.
I would think that the East German's feelings of being "second-class" will subside eventually....just lots of patience and more time for adjustment!  It seems only natural!
My dad was in the Military over in Germany when the wall went up and I was a 22yr old Military Wife stationed in Germany when the wall came down< I was there a week after, Still have chunks of the wall in a box. Has it been 18 years? wow
part of the berlin wall is at westminster college in fulton mo. this is where chirchill gave his iron curtain speech
There is an old saying in Texas... "Good fences make good neighbors." It is sad that a nation's failed policies included attempting to fence in their populace. That was the Berlin Wall. Here in Texas, we must "fence out" the invasion of those folks who live under similar Cold War politics. Sorry folks, go back home and change your own country. We in America will gladly help you!
My daughter and partner gave three small sizes rock to them this summer.  They just said that it was the Wall, and gave a write document. Free! From the Berlin Wall. Don't know, but they believe they took from the wall.
Good story, I think West Germany should use some of it's money and build industry in the east so more East Germans can have jobs and share in the dream of a unified Germany. I wonder if their feelings of being second class citizens is real or just a feeling of inferiority with the west.
I have a piece............
To quote John Mellencamp, " The wall came tumbling down ."  Let us hope that the number one sign of the Cold War never rises anywhere in the world again ? Let us compare what happened to Germany after World War I and II ? The Allied victors in World War I, imposed such harsh economic restrictions that it allowed a psychopath to get 32 % of the vote. That was all he ever needed !  The Allied victors in World War II, went to occupation.  What did we get ? The Cold War !  The Berlin Wall !  The nuclear age ! Let us hope that Germany never starts a war again ? That was the one thing I came back from my only trip certain that would never happen ! Democracy was good for West Germany. Someday all of Germany will prosper.
I know where a tiny piece of the Wall is -- in a friend of mine's living room!
I saw a section of the wall in Eureka Springs Arkansas. It had just been placed and there were small fragments that had fallen off. The masons let me take the fallen of chips. I keep them in a small heart shaped porcelin box from Bavaria.
I remember driving to my home in Atlanta from a meeting that evening in late 1989, when I heard on WSB radio that people were tearing down the Berlin wall.  I ran into the house calling out the news to my husband, who had not yet heard it.  I yelled,  "Hasn't ANYBODY heard?  I've been driving for 20 minutes since it came on the radio, and I've seen no reaction.  People should be excited; we should be dancing in the streets!  Where IS everybody? It's dark and quiet out there, and it's not even late!"

He answered, "If we go out to dance and scream on the cul de sac, people will think we're crazy!"  I conceded, and we did'nt do it; but I have regretted it ever since.  I feel as strongly now as I did then that we Americans should have realized immediately how momentous an occasion it was and given it a proper celebration.  It seemed to take days for awareness of the news to seep into the public consciousness, and by then it was touted as "old news."  

I was glad to hear that, later, many people went to retrieve scraps of the wall for souveniers.  It told me that not everyone was oblivious, although I sure did wonder for a while.

It saddens me to realize that, now, we Americans are building a wall (not to keep Americans in, but to keep others out), but it still is a wall of separation, even if Homeland Security calls it a "fence."  I have seen part of it, and it sure looked like a wall to me!  I pray that we as a nation can grow to the level where we can deal with our neighbors in positive, productive ways, without building barriers between "us" and "them."  If the free movement of goods between nations is beneficial to the world economy, why wouldn't the free movement of people (especially workers) be equally beneficial?
Well, I suppose they now know what it was like to be a Southerner for several years after the American Civil War ...
they are re-building it around the U.S. thats where the Berlin Wall is
I find it interesting that the walls people can build in their minds and lives can outlast walls such as the one in Berlin and be even more divisive.
Back at the fall of the Berlin wall, a coworker of mine happened to be vacationing in Europe.  After waiting a few days for things to settle down, she and her family went to see the now crumbled wall.  They brought home a large concrete chunk (of the wall) which they broke into small pieces, and she gave other coworkers and me pieces of it when she returned to work.  My piece had obviously had graffiti sprayed on it.  I thought it was pretty cool to have such a (small) piece in the history of freedom!
Two small sections of The Wall are on the grounds of Kentuck Knob, a house designed by Frank Lloyd Wright which is located in southwestern Pennsylvania.   The house is fewer than ten miles away from the spectacular Fallingwater.
I was a 20-year-old soldier stationed in Weisbaden, Germany, serving in the U.S. Army, when "the wall came down."  It was such an exciting and exhilarating time of history to be an eyewitness to.  I remember driving into what was still East Germany, marvelling at the differences between the West and the East side.  Euphoric is no overstatement.  I also visited Russia during those perestroika years, and the cities I visited were giddy with hope and excitement.  What a happy moment of history to have experienced in those times; I was too young to realize just how much of a privilege it was!
God...I sure do miss that city!  I was stationed in Berlin from late 1989 (right before the Wall came down) until 1992 and I loved every minute of it.  It's funny...being young and dumb, I really didn't realize how important the times were...I just thought it was a great party!  But now that I am a teacher, I often talk about the wonderful spirit of the German people and their quest for unity...and also what a unique opportunity it was for me to be there as a witness.
re Berlin Wall.  I recrently saw the portion of it was removed to the Churchill Memorial in Fulton, Missouri, by the grand daughter of Winston Churchil.
I feel that a lottery over a few short years would have been a far better way of letting these folks through the wall. To have one's life completely turned around such as it was may not have been the best way. There were way too many people flooding the streets of western germany at the same time. This was great for employers because they could lower their pay rates. Yes, the dismantling of the wall, and all it stood for was very necessary. It was just done the wrong way. As best as I can see, it was done the worst way possible. It left a bad taste in both, the eastern germans, and western german's mouth. to this day, and for many decades to come, there is going to be many dissatisfied people from either side. As for those from the east that have issues with the freedom that was so freely given to them, they can take advantage of what freedom gives them. They are free to leave and even go to a country, such as Cuba, if they miss their rights being violated at every corner. Take care and for both sides, be grateful for what has been given to you. Life is way too short to be focusing on the bad things.
...Said wall is being reconstructed in the southern portion of the United States....there along the border of Mexico...It could be deemed "Bush's Barrier".
there is a small section of the wall in Seoul at Chungechun near City Hall.
well,i do believe that the case of south and north Korea is different in part to the one of Germany when the Berlin wall was build up by the Soviet Union, that different is that the center of the American Vision,wish is a universal goverment,bigin with the reunification of Germany wish is the hart of Europe,the agenda of Norte America do not have the unification of Korea as a priority.
I was privledged to own a small piece of "The Wall."  When a friend of my son's was going over there to visit his exchge. student's family, he asked what he could bring me.  I said, "A piece of history-the wall." I was in H.S. when it went up, so was caught up in its' meaning.  It now holds a place of honor in my china cabinet in my dining room & I bring it out to show friends/visitors including a Japanese exchge. student we had for a short time.  
I have a piece of the Berlin Wall. My parents were living in Germany when the "wall fell" and went during those days of rejoicing to visit the tumbled wall. My dad picked up a piece and brought it home to me on a subsequent vist to the states. The piece I have is about the size of my hand and has the remains of a peace symbol on it. I displayed it proudly for yeas on my mantle until I found the wall contains asbestos. I put it in a plastic bag and hid it away.
I was stationed at the Berlin Wall back in 1972. It was such a hard believing shock to actually see it , knowing that the imprisioned people on the other side were shut off from the rest of the world.A country in soletary confinment.
If people realized how innovative the people of the former `Eastern Germany' were and are; remembering that these people had so little to work with and had to improvise for most everything, if things broke down, they had to make it work somehow, more of these hard working people from that area would be employed by large companies as there is no better experience than real life, and the difficult times they had to work through their entire life span, (for some). This would make the former `Eastern German People' the smartest and most hard working in the lands! A work ethic is the most important and where I live the people have the very hard working attitude as well, small community of very hard working personnel, very dependable people to employ!
Visited Berlin in August and came away very impressed with the “new” Berlin. We were treated very well and the tourist information was useful. Our hotel was a couple blocks from Check Point Charlie and our subway stop. So we visited “Charlie” a couple times a day. This has become a major, significant German tourist site. Was surprised at the German families showing their kids all the details and, it appeared, educating the younger generation as to the Wall’s importance. If you walk a block right of “Charlie” you will find a long section of the wall that is still intact (behind a fence to keep the “pickers” from taking the wall apart). This section of the wall gave me a very menacing feeling – an echo of what it may have been like at one time.
21 percent felt that life was better before unification? These people are probably all that's left of STASI and the SED.
My parents drove through check point Charlie in the early 70's and descibed soldiers pointing machine guns at them as they began to leave. A silent symbol that if they had taken any East German stowaways with them, they would be shot. They also described cars being practically dismantled in harrassment searches, and people's lugguage strewn about. One can only imagine what the people who lived there went through. It's tearing down was way overdue.
I was there Nov 8th, 9th and 10th, while in the military.  Our group painted our unit symbol of 93rd Signal Brigade on the wall on the 8th, then on the 9th, we watched as the crane took out Check Point Charlie and the gates opened. Thousands of people on both sides. I have several pieces of the wall in glass jars that I rented a pick/hammer from a local and hacked away at the wall.  The reason for the glass jars is that the wall was built with asbestos in it. I even have video of the whole scene on all the days, even me picking on the wall.
It will soon be 20 years from that day that marked the end of communism in Europe,  but here in Venezuela we are quickly approaching to a new communist state!! God may have mercy on us
PRAISE GOD FOR THE FREEDOMS WE HAVE  IN THE USA.
No persons, whatever ethnicity they are, should be forced to live behind  a wall, whether visible or invisible.
Sheree McClernan, Kentucky
Am I the only one who sees the irony of Gorbachev modeling in a LV ad? I suppose he did help bring the Communist reign to an end, however he was still a Communist. I guess the intervening years turned him from communist secretary to capitalist model?
Seams we find the cracks in this cistern with every breath. Although I have a west german ancestry from my father who was born in Kentucky, I am also welsh(english?), mothers side in virginia, FFV, but I have refused to rebuild that mountain. The low road always looks up sir. To try and use any physical barrier from our beginnings is to pronounce the guilt in our part of creating it. Genesis 34:19
You who says that we need to buy up the wall and install it along our southern border.  You don't know that a hell of a lot of americans live in mexico and a hell of a lot more have to buy there legal drugs there because of the medical that doesn't work in the USA.  And don't forget those drugs that you all use up there in the name of just fun (It isn't hurting anybody) well guess what I would hate to see your party put on hold.  You people when you talk about Mexico you don't have a clue.  It is the richest country in the world per capital.  America doesn't have any laws or rules, just what gets them off at the time.  When was the last time you ever did anything for America.  Or about your laws.  From a person who tires of hearing complaints from dummys and non actavist. what ever on the spell check.  
Some pieces of the wall are in a glass enclosed exhibit in Fatima, Portugal.  I just returned from there and saw it myself.
I was stationed in Berlin from Oct 89 to Dec 90. Seeing the wall come down, Germany reunify, and Germany winning the World Cup were some of the most amazing events. Also Roger Waters on the Wall happened during that time. That was one of the best years of my life. I have 2 pieces of the Wall painted with the Berlin Brigade patch and Swift Strike Battlion crest (and dated). Our platoon went and got pieces during Sgt's time training. Ich Leibt Deutschland und Berlin!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=458057

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.