ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



Let the sleeping pharaoh be

Posted: Monday, November 05, 2007 12:30 PM
Filed Under:

LUXOR, Egypt – An irreverent and entirely inappropriate thought kept imposing itself as I waited to report live on MSNBC about the first-ever public viewing of the face of King Tutankhamen from his underground tomb in the famed Valley of the Kings in Luxor, Egypt.

There he lay in front of me, his blackened face and empty eye sockets staring upwards, with taut cheeks stretched over small bones, lips pulled back in a sneer and deep wrinkles forming jagged scars in his face. 

And all I kept thinking as I waited for the anchor to ask her first question: Do not kiss the Sleeping Beauty who died more than 3,000 years ago. I imagined that if I did, maybe he would come back to life. And if he did, what would I say?

VIDEO: Revealing King Tut's face

But all went well. King Tut didn't interrupt the live broadcast, and when the lights went out, I was left contemplating these mortal remains of the famous boy-king. 

Fate of the famous boy-king
Tutankhamen was about 8 years old when he became the leader of mighty Egypt, and he is believed to have been 19 when he died. It isn't clear who his father was, what King Tut did as pharaoh or how he died. But he has become the most famous pharaoh, and along with the pyramids and the sphinx, an icon of Egyptian antiquity.

And all because robbers missed his grave. For about 400 years, Egypt buried its kings in the Valley of the Kings, a practice that stopped roughly 3,000 years ago. But within a century or two, the graves had been picked clean, gold statues had been melted down for their ore and carvings of inestimable value had been scattered to the wind.

So when the fabulous treasure of gold and inlaid stones that was buried with Tutankhamen to smooth his transition to the afterlife (pharaohs believed in taking it with them) was first discovered 85 years ago – on Nov. 4, 1922, King Tut was guaranteed his place in history and has fascinated ancient Egypt fans ever since.

Stone sarcophagus containing mummy of Tutankhamun is seen in his underground tomb in the famed Valley of the Kings in Luxor
SLIDESHOW: Take a tour of King Tut's tomb
Not so pretty 3,000 years later
But back to his face. Ugly doesn't begin to describe it. After all, what would any of us look like more than 3,000 years after dying? But whether it was the imposing surroundings in the ancient tomb, the tension of the moment (he could have fallen apart while being moved), or my own response to the face of the pharaoh, I was moved, and left wondering what message he brought from antiquity.  

Tutankhamen is on view in a climate-controlled glass case in the tomb, a modern sarcophagus, his burial place in the Valley of the Kings. Only his small black face and his little black feet can be seen. The rest of his body is covered by a linen cloth – much of his body is broken into 18 pieces. The damage was sustained when the British archaeologist Howard Carter first discovered the mummy in 1922.

Taking in the scene, all I could think of was how weird it all seemed.

The King Tut exhibit will travel to the U.S. in the fall of 2008. But the exhibit will be minus the mummy, as the organizers don't want to disturb him anymore.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

How sad is this? How far are we willing to go to feed our selfishness? This WAS a sacred burial intended to remain undisturbed...for eternity!  
He is the King, we should not allow for his dead body to be exposed to the public in that manner, if scientists need to observe his body they should,but not to everybody. I visted his tomb in luxor fourty years ago,when it was still well preserved and vibrant, when I visited it last year, the colors on the walls were fading..it's human treasure, and it would be a better preserved, without overt exposure.
Please get your facts straight, reporters. This is NOT the first ever viewing of Tut's face. In Howard Carters book, published in the 1930's, there is a photograph of the face, and indeed the entire body!
I've never agreed with this sort of conduct. How arrogant are we that we dig up sacred areas only to satisfy our own interests? The whole subject makes me sick.
He should be left to rest in peace, people are ruining something that is more than sacred!
Good of you to share this with the world.  Thanks!
I think this is pure disrespect.  I know this body is a rare archeological find, and of course piques our morbid interests.  

However, if this were my relative, and 3000 years from now (if the Earth is still turning)  it MAY be my relative someone digs up, how heartbreaking that would be.
Since when is there is time limit as to when it is OK to dig up a corpse? What would people say if we were to dig up Abraham Lincoln? (Oh it's ok because he died centuries ago) as opposed to say digging up John F. Kennedy which millions of people would have a heart attack over! No matter how much history has been made, bodies should be laid to rest and LEFT THERE! Whatever happened to having respect for the dead??
Dear Mr.Fletcher, When looking upon the face of King Tutankhamen there would never be the right words. You are so very fortunate to have been there when the were moving his body to the glass case. It is truly incredible how the face is preserved. I agree with you Mr.Fletcher I would be wondering what message the young King would bring. How sad he had to die so young. Very moving experience and exciting to see. Thank you for the report and the posting. I hope that King Tutankhamen stays preserved forever. Peace.
What a shame to expose the body of this young King. I truly believe that disturbing his grave to put him on display has no significance at all. The dead should be left alone and given the respect they deserve. I suppose seeing a dark dried up mummy is something we just can't live without!


I agree that revealing the face (or any other part) is completely inappropriate.  This was his sacred burial place.  This of course is all in the name of Anthropology (definitely a significant find).  But also a sacred place.  Anthropologists could have photographed the scene at the time of discovery and re-sealed the tomb.  How unfortunate that the body and paintings are now fading and will never look the same again.

Anthropologists also raided the sacred burial place of 1500 souls at the site of the Titanic.  All the history was known including the pattern of the fine China.  This didn't stop them from looting their final resting place.  What did we learn that wasn't already known and well documented?

Respect should be given to these sacred sites.



Dear Martin,

You made numerous factual misstatements in your video piece on King Tut. To begin with, Howard Carter didn't break the mummy into pieces in a ruthless quest for the jewels wrapped with the mummy. He and his team took great care to preserve the tomb and its contents, including the mummy. They spent years clearing the tomb, and took great care to document, draw in situ, and photograph its contents. A decision was made to unwrap the mummy (the arguement can certainly be made this was a bad idea), but due to the excessive use of resins in the embalming, the bandages were stuck the the mummy, and unfortunately the mummy was subsequently broken in this process. Howard Carter was a man a very high morals, and devoted his life to finding, and preserving antiquities. Your rendering of him is a huge disservice, both to him personally and the many others from his team as well as the Egyptians that worked with the mummy.

Secondly, there IS NO CURSE for God's sake.
The so-called curse was invented by newspapermen to sell newspapers. Howard Carter gave exclusive reports to only one paper, The London Times, and the others were angered by this and invented the curse to have headlines. Lord Carnarvon did not die weeks after the discovery as you claim, but in April of 1923, aprox 5 MONTHS later. And there was nothing mysterious about his death. He was in poor health for many years, hence spending winters in the dry warm climate of Upper Egypt, and he didn't properly take care of an infection, and in those days didn't have access to or use antibiotics, and eventually he died. The lights were always going out in Cairo due to a very unreliable power grid. The story of his favorite Terrier dying at the same time was apocryphal, (ie. untrue), and finally and most glaringly, some simple research on your part would have revealed that Lord Carnarvon was from Highclere Castle, Berkshire, ENGLAND. Not Scotland.......

Other than that, great job......
How would you like it if someone dug up your deceased loved one and put him/her on display? Very Sad!
leave the poor kid alone.
Here is one reason I have chosen to be cremated when I pass.  I hate to think that sometime in the future I would be dug up from an eternal rest and put on display like some circus side show freak. I am sure that God would not,and does not aprove of this barbaric practice. Sad In Missouri
How many years must a body be buried before grave robbing becomes archeology?  This applies to anyone, not just royalty.  
How many years must a body be buried before grave robbing becomes archeology?  This applies to anyone, not just royalty.  
I think the pharaoh's should be left untouched, after all this is the ancient Egyptians religion, and how would we feel if in 2,000 years someone came by and dug up our graves?
I agree, I don't see the point of revealing his body to the general public.  I don't think  most of us would want our dead bodies on display, most especially a king.   I find it irreverant and the only purpose I see is that they hope to increase tourist visits.
I agree with Sad in San Diego...this was his sacred burial ground.  Do you want someone to disturb your grave?  Nobody had the right to enter King Tut's grave.  That's what's wrong with society today, we feed into our own greed and selfishness to bring pleasure to our own selves.  You need to leave well enough alone.
For how long must a body be buried before its exhumation goes from sick to acceptable?  We would not think of exposing the face of someone who died last year, or a generation ago, even if it was relatively well preserved.  Does antiquity on the part of the dead really excuse morbidity on the part of the living?
I agree this burial is sacred. I find it very disturbing when graves are opened for the "sake of science". How would we feel if our loved ones were removed from the sites where we layed them to rest. Do the words "rest in peace" mean nothing? Leave these people alone, it doesn't matter how old they are, is this going to change our lives in any way....a future cure for cancer...alzheimers...juvenile diabetes..I doubt it. Do your research without disturbing the dead. Stay off of Holy ground and have some respect!
I think this is just another example of the lack of respect in our society today - somethings were just meant to be left alone.
King Tut looks scary what with his ho.rse teeth and eyes seemingly  prised out and to have died as a teenager beguiles History and perhaps greater glory had he lived a longer and fuller life. What a pity!
It is interesting because of the legend surrounding the famous child king and also for the fact that we would not be able to come across another such find.I say that uttermost care must be excercised to maintain the royal status of the mummy.That should include the control of the number of tourist visitation,taking of pictures and all other necessary steps to maintain the mummy
how wrong it is to disturb someone's final resting place! King or no king, no one should be put on display like some kind of a side show freak. There's no reason for anyone to study his body...the poor guy is dead and has been since long before any of us were here. It doesn't really matter what the cause of death was...it happened over 3000 years ago, what's it matter now? put him back as you found him and let him rest in peace! How disgraceful.
The United Nations should intervene to stop this cruel practise. Would George W. Bush like it if his body is dug up 3,000 years later and taken all over Iraq for public viewing?
All I can think is how would we feel if the world decided to start digging up and displaying some of our past leaders in this manner.  People like Abe Lincoln or George Washington.  I agree with Sad in San Diego, the burial of a person is suppose to be forever.  Digging up ancient cities is one thing, digging up bodies isn't necessary.  
Seeing this reminds me of the scene from 'Indiana Jones and the Raiders of the Lost Ark' where the Nazi's open the 'tomb' of the Ten Commandments and all those who are selfishly feasting their eyes on the sacred artifact, are instantly destroyed by the powers that be. Indeeed, this is a very sad story for the people of Egypt whose heritage and history is slowly fading away at the price of a cheap news story.
CAN WE PLEASE LET THIS MAN REST IN PEACE. WHAT DOES IT SERVE TO SHOW HIS FACE??YOU WANT PEOPLE TO SEE A HISTORY THAT NO ONE TEACHES. THIS IS ALL FOR NOTHING LET HIM BE. WE HAVE LEARNED ALL THERE IS TO LEARN.STOP MAKING MONEY OVER HIS DEAD BODY.ENOUGH ALREADY.
What would have happened if somebody have tried to take out the body of the Tut from his burial place just a month after his death for study? Out of curiosity, I have seen the video. I am feeling as if I have committed  mistake. The golden mask of the boy King is far more beautiful to me.
This is a form of terrorism in name of tourism and archeology.
I.M.H.O. The TOMBS were not raid as people think. I think the Gold & tresures were passed from PHARAOH to PHARAOH. As far as I can find out there was not much GOLD & jewels in Egypt in that time frame. I think they 'MORTICIANS?' were afraid to go into King TUTS tomp to get the treasures. This is because they though he had some kind of illness when in fact he had a birth defect. I do not know if the scientists will be able to do a DNA test to see what he had if anything. It says here that they do not know who his father is. I thought it was ATANAUKIN'?' the Pharaoh that started the worship of the SUN GOD. He built a new capital to worship the sun god. Here is where the religious people started to worship a GOD that they could not see. This is when the PHARAOHS were afraid & banished MOSES from EGYPT. You see there are not many time frames to refer to. If the burials stopped 3000 years ago in the VALLY OF THE KINGS, when did Mummificiation stop? What was the people called that left EGYPT? When was the word JEW coined? Look up when & how was money created. REX
People, people!  We look at the living, why not the dead?  It's not like they will get upset with you - and neither should anyone else if the carcass is thousands of years old.  It isn't terrorism, it's fascination
It would sicken you to see a relative dug up; however, we do not know anything about these pharoahs or what they did. We know about deaths of other people ie abraham lincoln,etc, because it happened so close to now. We could find something incredible to tell others in future centuries or we could possibly forget about it and leave him buried there forever without any knowledge. And you would probably be dead already if someone was so interested to dig up your relative so it really wouldn't matter.  Get over it; it's life.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=448335

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.