ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



When will Indonesia’s volcano blow?

Posted: Monday, November 05, 2007 10:29 AM
Filed Under:

SURABAYA, Indonesia – Will it? Won’t it? Has it already erupted? From my vantage point here in Surabaya, guessing what’s going on with Mount Kelud is the most popular game in town. It’s headline news; Indonesia’s television stations reporting regular live updates from somber-faced correspondents camped on the steep slopes of one of country’s deadliest volcanoes.

The brooding volcano sits around fifty miles southwest of us here in Indonesia’s second city. Its alert status has been at the highest level for more than two weeks, and experts say an eruption is imminent.

My driver wasn’t so sure, though.

"Maybe yes, maybe no," he told me, throwing his hands into the air – a sort of resigned, fatalistic gesture that I’ve noticed is very common when it comes to Kelud. My hotel receptionist stuck her neck out a little further: "They always say that," she said of the country’s excitable vulcanologists.

The experts think they have their facts right. Indonesia sits on a belt of intense seismic activity known as the Pacific "Ring of Fire." The country has 70 active volcanoes, more than any other country, so the experts have plenty of hands-on experience.

Evacuation orders
Kelud means "sweeper" in Javanese, because of its historic reputation for sweeping everything away when it erupts. And rather like dealing with a patient in intensive care, the scientists have been monitoring Kelud’s vital signs for weeks, sensors recording every huff, puff and tremor.

And right now, they say, they have the geological equivalent of a life-support machine gone berserk. It could erupt at any minute.

"There’s been a partial lifting of the lava dome at the top, as well as a strong drift of heated winds upwards," they reported Monday – which to you and I means the mountain is about to blow its top.

Orders have gone out to evacuate tens of thousands of people living on the slopes of the 5,700-foot volcano. Officials point out that Kelud killed 30 people when it last erupted in 1990 and more than 5,000 in 1919.

The problem for the experts – and the government – is that not everybody shares their urgency. Many of those in the danger area are refusing to leave their homes, in spite of a compulsory evacuation order, preferring to stay and look after their land and livestock.

And many Indonesians trust age-old mystic traditions, rather than scientists. Last year, when Mount Merapi, one of the most active volcanoes in Indonesia, was rumbling, and experts warned it would erupt at any minute, residents preferred to listen to Maridjan, the 70-year-old "gatekeeper" of the mountain, who has been conversing with its spirits for decades.

To the irritation of the government, the soothsayer told the villagers to stay at home. He said Merapi was merely throwing a tantrum and that nothing would come of it.

He was right.

Banana leaves for protection
It’s not clear whether Kelud has a gatekeeper, but the Jakarta Post today reported that some residents were hiding in the forests, with others placing banana leaves in front of their homes, believing this will protect them from the blazing lava, should it come.

The standing of the experts hasn’t been helped by a false alarm over the weekend, when they announced Kelud had erupted, only to backtrack later. Monday they admitted they were a little baffled as to why it wasn’t behaving as predicted, when their readings were now so strong, they could no longer be measured.

One theory is that hardened lava from previous eruptions could be blocking the release of magma, which could make for an even bigger eruption once sufficient energy has built up. Or the hardened lava could perhaps prevent a major eruption.

Scientists also said today that measuring equipment in the volcano’s crater lake has been damaged. They said they are no longer able to monitor its temperature.

"We are now left with four seismic quake detectors and two deformation detectors," one scientist said. And if they break? I guess there are always the banana leaves and the soothsayer!

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

For those of you suggesting people should leave - of course they should. But where do the people go?  These are mostly very poor with few resources for surviving an extended stay away from there crops and livestock.  Indonesia does not have the support structure to care for them.  A terrible predicament to be in.
There are always humans who will do the wrong thing and we should just leave them alone and let them do it.  They are responsible for their own lives.  They've been warned.  Of course, look at all the housing we've built along the San Andreas Fault in California.  Dumb people everywhere.
This is just a reminder of why you should not live next to a valcano.We just keep making the same mistakes.How many times must people die. we must learn to stay away Or pay the altimate price for our continud mistakes.
I understand that volcanology is not a "perfect" science, but this is not the first time I've read that scientists say the two or three relatively close volcanoes spewing ash and gases are not related. It seems crazy not to think that there is a relation. After all, the movement of one continent may affect another just as a wave crashing on a beach moves the sand.

I must say that they are interconnected and that the earthquakes and tsunamis and volcanic activity that are generated in relative timing are all part of each other. We may even find that major earthquakes, especially under the ocean, may influence the amount of activity during hurricane/typhoon season. We do know that major eruptions from volcanoes can affect world temperatures, which in turn can affect hurricane development as well as glacier production in the arctic.

I understand that scientists do not like to make statements about things which aren't supported by overwhelming proof or evidence, but the interconnection between the events that are happening in Indonesia seems almost "common sense".
Ian Williams really did a nice job with this piece.  His somber/humorous  portrayal of the tensions - volcanic and cultural - is really well done.  
Strange, I have exactly the same apprehension, and I am indeed considering leaving.............not Mt. Kelud, but Neocon America! Perhaps peeling away some of our top bananas would help??
Krakatoa Baby! KRAKATOA!!
As a resident of Washington state USA, I was here when Mt St Helens blew. There were people caught off guard and killed even with all the warnings. Get away from there asap.
If a volcano blows, it blows, period. Many posters are unaware of volcanos and how they blow up and erupt.  Well, folks, I have news for you.  They are dangerous! As for banana leaves/peels, this debate is silly.   In order to protect a grass hut with this material, it would take the production of hundreds of acres of banana plantations for a single home if it was in the direct path of a pyroclastic flow.  Plus, you would be foolish to put them there dry, and it would take enough water to fill an Olympic swimming pool to wet down enough leaves/peels (it makes no difference which) to protect even one hut.  Pity these people who do not even have a volunteer fire department, much less Homeland Security.  One plan could be to plug the opening with cement made from old ground up lava, lime, and sea water.  This mixture would be cheap and could be dumped there by helicopters working around the clock, thereby thwarting the eruption for good and all. Creativity is called for in times of catatrophe.  I am not syaing this is the only way, but a good start in the creativity process.  I am not a professional volcanologist, merely one human being who believes in problem solving to solve problems before they magnify and become serious.  Working together, we can stop this problem before it arises.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=448038

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.