ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



Losing the anti-pollution battle in Nairobi

Posted: Tuesday, October 02, 2007 11:24 AM
Filed Under:

Here’s what travel books don’t tell you: If you come to Nairobi, bring a surgical mask. It stinks.

Driving bumper to bumper, with your car enveloped by black smoke pouring out of the exhausts of other vehicles, a blue-gray, throat–scratching pall hanging over the traffic, you can almost see your lungs turning black. It feels like smoking four packs of Russian cigarettes a day.

Between the dust and the pollution, I have never coughed, sneezed, cleared my throat and blown my nose so much. My companions quite lost their patience with me. The soundtrack of much of Jeff Riggins’s video sounds as if it was recorded in an infectious diseases ward.

The pollution, which I don’t remember existing at all when I visited Nairobi regularly until about 10 years ago, is in complete contrast with the signs sprinkled through town: "Tree-planting campaign, make your city beautiful."

It must be so frustrating for conservationists and environmentalists, who are doing genuinely great work in reforesting Kenya, to see such a noxious advertisement for their work in the capital.

Trying to recreate a forest with a few trees
About three percent of Kenya is forested, while it is recommended that 10 percent of a country be covered by trees to sustain the land and the air. Wangari Maathai, a Kenyan professor, won the Nobel Peace Prize in 2004 for "her contribution to sustainable development, democracy, and peace."  Her organization, the Green Belt Movement, has planted more than 30 million trees in Kenya. They have an ambitious international goal, too: To plant a billion trees worldwide to protect the planet.

But to a casual motorist in Nairobi, it’s clear who’s winning, and it isn’t the good guys.

Infant trees line the middle of the main road into town from the north. The little saplings stand proudly the whole length of the drive. But pollution-belching trucks, matatu taxis and private cars overwhelm their promise.

And now, because there are so many cars and so many traffic jams, the municipality is planning to turn the four lanes into six lanes. And of course, to make room for the cars, the baby forest in the grass median down the middle will have to go, even though the trees have only just been planted.

The police say they’re cracking down on the worst offenders, the matatu taxi drivers, who charge around the city in their ancient cars causing more pollution than everyone else put together.

But in one police report announcing a crackdown, fines were levied on the drivers for driving vehicles "in poor mechanical condition, overloading, not wearing uniform, tampering with speed governors, lacking licenses, missing seat belts and failing to display drivers photographs and fare." Not a word on smoke-belching exhausts.

But, book soon!
On a separate note:  if you do want to go on a safari, hurry.

It’s already expensive enough to visit a game park: $40 per person per day. But the Kenyan Wildlife Service is planning to increase that to $100 a day.  So that would be about $500 a day for a family of five to look at animals. Admittedly it’s a fabulous adventure, but is it really necessary to charge so much?

Nearby Rwanda certainly thinks so. The little central African country must be home to the world’s most expensive tourist spectacle. Looking at the gorillas in the forest costs $500 an hour. Yes, per hour.

Now Kenya is jealous. "Rwanda charges $500 per hour to see its 13 families of gorillas," the wildlife director thundered in Kenya’s "Daily Nation" newspaper, "while we charge only $40 for a visit to Nakuru National Park, which has many more animals." He attempted to temper any sticker shock by saying that the increase from $40 would be implemented incrementally, reaching $100 a day in 2010. So book your flights soon.

Kenyan citizens, incidentally, pay either $3 a day, or $1.50 a day, depending on which park it is.

Read the rest of Martin Fletcher’s reports from his recent assignment in Kenya and watch his video piece that aired on NBC’s Nightly News with Brian Williams: "LifeStraw battles waterborne disease in Kenya," "Rough riding in Kenya," and "‘A pure Masai man. ’"

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Kenya in general is one of the most beautiful places in the world! And I mean that! I am the third generation of Indian Immigrants here (since 1898!!)and while in the past there was a major move by immigrants to other parts of the western world, many many youngsters who graduate abroad are coming back! This is after having lived in UK, USA, Canada, Australia etc for years on end! Kenya is a very young country and like any developing nation it has it's problems. The lifestyle here though far out-weighs the problems!! Cheerio to Kenya and Nairobi!!
Try Karachi, Pakistan.  You'll think Nairobi is mighty clean.
A clean environment? Thats like saying the earth is clean. This planet is and always has been a chemical soup. Historicaly that fact has brought about new life while extinguishing old. Thats how nature works. Humans will be victims of their own excesses soon enough however the planet will survive unchanged in the long run. It is simply a pity that masses will die either fighting for habitable space or from disease and genetic mutation. In any case it is a savage world and humans have not benefitted from their gift of reason except to manipulate eachother for wealth. The polution is simply a byproduct of the race to become all powerful.
Give credit where it is due. Nairobi has improved quite a lot lately and I am shocked that a foreigner who does not live there to see the changes can comment on its environment. I don't think you're much travelled, otherwise you'd have visited places which are worse than Nairobi. If you were just looking for a story to write, this is not the way to do it. If I were you, I would stop visiting developing countries because you will die soon from polution! Do you know where the ozone layer is mostly destroyed from polution? Not in Nairobi but in developed countries. Finally, Kenya has a right to charge whatever fees they feel like for their services. Take it or leave it.
The whole piece was written for what reason, from start to finish it was pretty muh a dish, there are alot of countries and cities with pollution, or other issues, that make it difficult to live or visit, developing countries have these problems,,,look at london back in the industrial revolution,,,,look at LA 10 yers ago, and look at the efforts to change today... as for how much a safari costs? If you can afford to go to africa you can help support the local economy, I am originally from Key West, and If you visit there you will pay
more for alot of things then me, if I have to pay at all for things like a coffee or internet time, or admissions to certian places. this is totally normal..
and hillarious that in some places in KW  its even written out...tourists pay more...LOL





Mr. Fletcher, I am Kenyan and would like to thank you for complimenting us on our beautiful City Nairobi. I also thank the person that wrote a scathing racist article against Africans and spilt a whole lot of vitriol about them. Lots of thanks to you all. You have done a great job at expressing yourself. Keep it up.
Yes I am Kenyan. I am proud to be Kenyan. I will not insult you back. We have our own rights to live our lives as we please. None has a right to impose their lifestyles on others. If and when we decide to live differently we will do it in our own way. If you keep coming to our polluted city, keep bringing your gas mask and you will be fine.
Our wildlife is our heritage. We will protect it and conserve it. Let us do what we will with the money we collect. It is no longer yours once you have paid it out. You will not have a say in how we use it.
Those who have tried to destroy our wildlife by pushing to be allowed to do game hunting in our country are enemies trying to deplete the beautiful environment that has been so far so well conserved. We will not let you.
We welcome you to come and view our game at a fee. We will decide the amount to charge you. If you can’t afford it, leave it to those who can. It is a supply and demand question. We have so far been undercharging you. I think you would be better placed complaining about the rising prices of crude oil which you cannot do without, rather than complain about the cost of viewing game which is an option you choose.
Kenya is unique in many ways. It is called a land of contrast. You should take the opportunity to tour the whole country from the Indian ocean in Mombasa to the lake Victoria in Kisumu. I guarantee you of enjoyable scenery despite your gas or surgical masks.
Again Karibu Kenya. Kenya yetu, Hakuna Matata. We are proud to be Kenyans. We are proud of our City Nairobi.
And to the racist person, we are proud of our mother Africa. We are proud to be Africans. All the diseases and weapons you have used to try to wipe us out have so far failed. We are a strong people. Insults will not do you any good.
..here it goes again 1st world propaganda...it saddens also that our cities in Africa are growing becoming more like western cities (yes cities full of pollution and crime)...I am surprised that you have the audacity to question how much Kenyans are paying to see wildlife in their own country???...please look into American and European exploitation of the 3rd world populace e.g. Britain's Transit Visa policy which requires most developing countries citizens to pay $92 even if remaining airside or on the plane.
http://www.britainusa.com/visas/articles_show_nt1.asp?i=65025&L1=41000&a=41448

btw Americans and other Europeans are not required to pay..bollocks!!!
 
The "gentleman" that wrote this article is obviously not well traveled. Either that or he is just ignorant/arrogant which is far worse. Mr. Fletcher I challenge you to Google statistics on global pollution and you will see that the US ranks #1 and contributes 25% of the earth's pollution. Kenya is currently #87 and contributes to less than 1%. Time to take off the blinders Mr. Fletcher? Or better yet, find a more suitable career because unbiased reporting is clearly not your forte.
Oh and in case you have trouble accessing Google while sneezing, coughing, and hacking from the dusty, choking streets of Nairobi, I have done so for you ... no charge ...

http://www.nationmaster.com/red/pie/env_co2_emi-environment-co2-emissions
The $100 fee is not a price for seeing animals but the rather a contribution to ensure the continuity of the gameparks. There's wildlife conservation costs, security costs and animal care costs. How else do you expect your great grandchildren to see the same rhinos that you saw 10 years ago. Paying your airline and hotel fees to see this beautiful country was a choice you made. You could have gone to Iceland instead - I don't think there's much pollution there.

Kenya, that 583,000 Square Km country has enough land for it's 2.2% population growth. If you honestly think that cars are choking wildlife and tree growth you really need to continue watching soaps and live the real world alone, you're not equipped to handle real issues. If you called for culling of Kenyans, it is symptomatic of abuse suffered as a child, you so need a hug, and some love from mankind, then maybe you'll develop some.

If you really want to make a case for car pollution then the same passion should be engaged urging GM to stop making hummers.
Poor Mr Fletcher! didnt ur country warn you about pollution in Nairobi in their travel advisory? or about the stench? Am sure there is a clone of Nairobi in another galaxy and that is where you were. I have lived and worked in Nairobi for the past 20 years. The city is, for the past few years now, clean, lined with leafy trees everywhere, even the so called downtown matatu terminals are now paved, lit and swept daily. Mr Fletcher when exactly did you last visit Nairobi?
As for KWS charges, what did you expect? to land at JKIA and walk into the Nairobi National Park or wherever it is you wanted to go, for a song? We are a Third World country but that doesnt mean we are stupid. Tourism is a business not a school day out.
Oh and by the way I do use the public transport, as do 2 million other Nairobians and tourists. NO STANDING PASSENGERS are allowed.Can you say the same for TEL AVIV?
Do visit again when your mind is open enough to appreciate something different.
Mr. Fletcher - have you ever been to Los Angeles?  As you exit the airport buildings, the stench in the air hits you hard.  I always have problems breathing for a few minutes until my lungs can get accustomed to the heavy polluted air.  And this is at LAX.  At least Nairobi is only dealing with the exhaust fumes on roads while everywhere else languishes in clean air.  A word of advice - focus on fixing domestic issues before trying to meddle in international affairs.
I was born and raised in Nairobi and I have clean lungs.
does Nairobi stink as bad as Stockton, CA?? is the pollution as bad as San Fran or L.A.?? If not, I think we should worry about our own problems here in America rather than those of another country.
Since you are so alarmed about the pollution you met on the streets of Nairobi then perhaps you should extend that same line of thinking to the game parks.  Those are extremely delicate ecosystems that really do not need millions of cheap tourists roaring around and polluting the place.  Simple logic.  I say hike the rates as high as they can go.  
And the air in Nairobi is hardly as bad as that in New York, Mexico City or parts of China.  I personally developed lung complications when I lived in NYC - in Nairobi, my lungs are free and clear.
As for tree cover - please Google Earth the damn place and see how green (and much greener it will be) it is...
We do have our issues with traffic and housing but which city of over 3 million people doesn't?   Many of the problems stem back to the colonial era - but let's not go there.
In general to all of you who read this piece and agreed with it or didn't - why not take some time out to learn about a place before spewing ignorant comments on the web.  
Get the facts right please.
You couldn't pay me to step foot on ANY 3rd world continent.



SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=390933

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.