ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



‘A pure Masai man’

Posted: Thursday, September 20, 2007 2:25 PM
Filed Under:

 

MASAI MARA, Kenya – One thing that has always bugged me is when people interrupt each other, not letting the other person finish their sentence. Everybody is in such a hurry to say something, we rarely really listen.

So when Kipas, a Masai chief on the edge of the African Rift Valley escarpment in Kenya, gave me his talking stick, I was thrilled. We have a lot to learn from these simple nomadic Masai herdsmen, I thought, and their wonderful respectful customs.

When the men gather, whoever holds the talking stick, speaks. Everyone else listens. If you want to talk, you wait until you are handed the talking stick. It is a narrow piece of smoothed wood about eighteen inches long with a knob on one end, like a small club, decorated with brightly-colored, patterned beads. It is a thing of honor and the chief gave it to me as a present.

NBC News/ Martin Fletcher
Masai Chief Tobias Ole Kipas Manie watches over his herd with local village boys.

I humbly accepted it with my left hand and he grabbed it back. "No," Kipas said, his perpetual happy smile suddenly replaced by a grimace, "Never hold it in the left hand."

"Oh, sorry," I said.

"It is our custom," he explained.

Here, among the Masai, an ancient, proud tribe struggling to fend off the encroachment of the modern era, custom explains everything, but when I asked if women carry talking sticks too, Kipas didn’t smile. For while men gather to talk, to decide, to rest beneath the tree, and in general while away the day delightfully, custom and tradition dictate a different way of life for their womenfolk.

Lots of work, laughter, too
It isn’t for me to criticize or judge, but here is a list of what a typical Masai woman does in her day.

She walks to collect water and then carries it back home – which can be miles away. Then she goes out again to gather and carry wood for the fire. She prepares the food and cares for the children. If the family moves to a new or temporary home, the woman builds the house, mostly of mud and sticks.

NBC News/ Martin Fletcher
Masai boy herding his cows. Masai herders use a lekolulo (a flute) and whistles in the herding process.

A Masai woman can share her husband with a number of other wives, usually depending on how wealthy the man is, which is measured in cows and goats and land. She can be divorced almost at will by her husband, as long as the men of the tribe agree. And certainly the women don’t gather beneath the tree, pass the talking stick, and decide on the affairs of the tribe.

A myriad of other customs confirm the superior role of the man, and the subservient role of the woman, to an extent that may startle an American.

Yet here’s the funny thing. In the days that my NBC team and I spent with the Masai, the dominant sound in the village and around the water spring and in the fields was women laughing.

They chattered happily with each other, stroked the heads of the children and cared for each other – and all the while they smiled and seemed happy. As they toiled and bore the burdens of village life, one word came to mind – acceptance. They accept their lot.

Even so, I thought, I wouldn’t want to be a Masai woman; but I wouldn’t mind being a Masai man at all.

NBC News / Jeff Riggins
NBC's Martin Fletcher with Masai Chief Tobia Ole Kipas Manie.

Not so bad
Take Ben, resplendent in bright Masai red, a color they believe frightens away lions and other predators. He was chatting with a couple of friends by the entrance to the village. Strings of beads and shiny tin dangles hung around his neck and his ears had decorative holes in the lobes. He smiled and was friendly.

"I wear all this decoration because I am a pure Masai man," he said.

"And what do you do all day?" I asked. His English was good.

"I herded my cattle this morning and tend for them, and at the end of the day I will bring them back to the village," he answered.

"Oh," I said. "Where are they?" I peered into the distant rolling, wooded hills of the escarpment, shielding my eyes from the sun, searching for his cattle. The Masai are tall and lean and can walk fast for hours.

"There," he pointed. And there were his cattle, lolling and grazing by the nearest tree, a hundred yards away.

"That’s your day?" I asked in envy.

"Today, yes, but sometimes I rest."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

The article was presented in a proper way and the feedback from interrested readers was placed along side it in an honest fashion. I enjoyd the heck out of each. Thankyou for the "presentation" and esp. for the way it was handled.
I was fascinated by your story, and by some of the comments I read following it.  Women in America should be so glad that they have a CHOICE in working or not, and for the freedoms they have to pursue life in whatever way they want.  The factthat the NBC group heard "laughter" shows that the people are either happy or resigned.  I think the latter!
Lisa: basically Masai men tend their cattle keep their women pregnant and tending the fire. You go guys! Amanda it is Jambo; not Jumbo.
Very interesting article - enjoyed it.  Had to smile at the last line tho, I know he must be absolutely exhausted!!
get the politicians a talking stick they spend all their time with their mouths open and their ears shut.
Thank you to all the Africans who are pointing out the rediculousness of this article.  Romanticized images of African 'tribes' is an old European racist notion based on the Noble Savage.  Maasai as an identity is not ancient, not in the least.  And the people who claim Maasai identity do not live exactly like people who claimed Maasai identity one hundred years ago.  People everywhere at every time change.  These people are smart, cruel, hard-working, etc.  In short they are just like everyone else, with all of humanity's strenghts and weaknesses.  

And just because there is no long legal process for a divorce doesn't mean that the man can just throw the woman out at will.  I wonder what the divorce rate among Masaai is.  If it's less than the 50% which is common, and increasing, in the West than maybe we should reconsider which people don't value the opposite gender.
I had a birthday party a few years ago and one of the male guests was loudly dominating all conversation.

Finally somebody picked up a banana out of the fruit bowl and started talking into it, like a microphone.  No one talks unless they have the banana!

It worked.

For a little while.

Ultimately it became clear that if a person is that callous towards others, no amount of bananas could inspire their respect for very long.

He had no shame, only the  entitlement of a male ego- that begged to be questioned by everyone there who suffered it.

No matter.

Banana or walking stick aside,
respect is respect is respect.

If the Masai man believes he is entitled to silence, mutilate, prostitute and make slaves of others, it begs the question; does that not matter?

Is he not a sociopath?
Something to keep in mind is that the Maasi are not unchanged.  Their traditional range has been shrunk, some of their activities are no longer possible or are changed to accomodate the outside world.  One of the ways they've chosen to adapt is to accomodate tourists--what Martin Fletcher witnessed was at least partially a tourist attraction.
I spent some time in Kenya, and the Masai culture is unique.  I must say, as a woman, I respect them for not assimilating and changing their customs toward our more western society.  Our society is not necessarily better because that's what we are accustomed to as  a standard.  They do have numerous wives, and their women work extremely hard. I could not imagine working as a Masai woman, and my schedule is hectic enough as a physician.  However, there is piety and a mutual respect amongst them that we lack in our society now.  I do, however, dislike the fact that their women are not allowed to attend higher levels of education.  Ultimately, I respect their culture despite their differences with our own and Masai men were the humblest, nicest, most caring men I met while in Kenya.
As a Kenyan living in the USA, I always feel great and happy to read comments like this from the land i love!!!. But to an average america, Kenya a small coutry only about 583,000 sq Km has about 42 tribes, making a similar 42 of such traditions. I come from North Eastern province of Kenya, My dad is married to 3 wifes and i have 28 sisters and brothers, and my family were the happiest family i have ever met. Therefore as the saying goes, one mans meat is another mans poison, dont dwell much on circumcisions,polygamy etc. We need to get to know other cultures, thats why when we see a muslim women fully covered the western cultures goes to conclusion saying they are been abused, get educated and we will be respected!!!  
In Japan, women are not allowed to go to Sumo Rings, simply they are considered unclean. How about that? That is the culture and tradition!!!.
It is even reported that a female Mayor in one of the cities had to delegate her powers to a male during a presentation ceremony!!!because females are not allowed near the SUMO areas!!
Every society has its own cultural values.
By going out there, my good friend, to mingle with the Massai, you have done what we all Americans should be doing. Global cultural awareness is the key to getting along and respecting one another. Our level of ignorance of other cultures and unwarranted spite for them  is very disturbing. Every culture has it's negative aspects and there is always something positive to learn from every culture as well. Massai is such an example. If you're ever in Greensboro, NC, come and watch the cultural display of Ibos of Africa. You will be thrilled as well.  
Why not do an article on the oddities of American family life, of which there are many?
How sad that so many typical feminists and neutered men are offended by the lifestyle of the Masai. It has endured for eons. I read women on here talking about "waiting on their man hand and foot while he has only one job." Bull! That "one" job often consists of earning an income, doing repairs at home, maintaining the yard and the equipment for it, heavy lifting, pest control, auto maintenance, soundboard for the Mrs. problems of the day without reciprocation and also getting lambasted for not "helping around the house." In the meantime, these "subservient" women are at their own jobs while sticking their children in daycare or turning them into latchkey kids when older and constantly complaining about it.
The Masai culture is an ancient one and it functions. How about stopping the arrogance and assuming you all know what they would prefer or how "demeaning" it is to their women and blah, blah, blah. See to your own life and the second, third or fourth marriage you're in and try to figure out why you can't succeed at a relationship.
I loved your story, I also spent time on the Mara with those Great Masi tribesmen, and being an African American male it was a feeling of LOVE, HOME, and total ENJOYMENT! It is good to hear good news of Africa and not the "usually" bad news of my beloved Homeland! God Bless you Sir.
What the article did not mention is that it is the men who defend the tribe, who are expected to fight and die, if necessary,  to defend the women and children.

What happens to a Masai woman who is devorced?
You showed me dayes of their living conditions, I wonder of their dieing conditions?
Your article and the readers comments caused me to think of my childhood while growing up in N. California 55 years ago.  As the years passed by, our quality of life improved, while becoming so much more complicated.  I've learned through life's experience, and having spent considerable years in Thailand and other S.E. asian countries, that too much western influence,(technology), while improving many aspects of civilized life, is a two edged sword, having negative side effects for some cultures.  If people of other countries are happy with their lives, leave well enough alone.  Ah! as they say, "I miss the good old days".    
For all of you who think we have so much to learn, and those so quick to run down our society in favor of the Masai, buy a plane ticket, go live with them and do as they do.  Be sure to buy a round trip ticket so you can come back to the USA when you need medical help for malaria, and all the other health problems you will encounter.  What we can really learn is that sitting on your a-- all day and making slaves out of women does not get you much in terms of longevity and contibuting to the human race.
The same old americans ignorance. like Njeri said the main thing is to respect humanity  
I have to disagree with someone earlier who said that the Maasai way of life is degrading the landscape and threatening the wildlife.  Having studied human wildlife conflict in Southern Kenya with the Maasai it is not the traditional nomadic herding behavior that is threatening the landscape.  It is that some of the Maasai, but also people other tribes moving into that area that are settling into permanent settlements and growing crops that is threatening the wildlife.  These permanent settlements are threating the natural wildlife migration not the pastoral lifestyle that has coexisted with the wildlife in that area for a very long time.  The problem with this is that the wildlife is so important to the local economies there kenya esp. gets a significant proportion of the GDP from wildlife tourism so it is important that all the people living in that area find some sort of balance to co-exisit with the wildlife.  The Maasai have so far proved to have the most compatiable lifestyle to this balance.
I look forward to the day when I can read one of these articles and the ensuing comments without being repeatedly insulted and belittled for being white or American.  (Njeri, Papa Dallas, etc...)  I find it amusing that the people making these comments are making broad, negative generalizations about people based on the color of their skin.  Guess what that makes you?  Yep!  If you want spout ignorant racist commentary, please find yourself a nice little hate-oriented website and leave me alone.  Thanks!
I think of my friend and colleague Mpeti Ole Surum, who came to Boston from Kenya and earned a living telling school-children about the Maasai way of life. An amazing man with a handshake to be prepared for! He married and had a son with an American woman, and lived in the suburbs and drove a Lexus. We were devastated when on one of his frequent visits to Kenya, he was killed in a car accident outside Nairobi.

It's tempting to think of any group of people as purely anything - Westerners as greedy consumers, hamster-wheeling to keep up with the mortgage and bickering over division of domestic labor, or "tribal people" as simple and basic, got it figured out ages ago and paid for that by not noticing when they're oppressed ane foregoing indoor plumbing.

But wow. Mapping the values of one group of people onto the daily lives of another is bound to yield some some surprises and contradictions, some form of "culture shock," some wistfulness about how "they" have it better, or judgement about things we find alien or even repugnant.

What's cool to me right now is the way WE have found to have our say, then pass the stick and listen. Thanks for the article and the discussion.

These people are happy and uncontanimated. They are are organic. They are happy and contented with what they have ( being alive). Westerners whine, complain, always busy, never sleep, and who does not have some pills in the med carbinet. Polygamy is an agreed thing.The first wife always suggests and the man goes for it. As bad as it sounds where this is "purely" practiced there are no single mothers, no abortions, no orphans and by the way what % of Maasai have HIV/AIDS. The food they eat ( Meat,soups and blood), you need two or more...
I may not do what they do but trust me if this keeps them healthy and organic I am visiting...
By the way how many westerners and really happy and contented and not blaiming everything on somebody? By the way, do you know why Americans are never happy? It is because of Bush... Here we go again.
Did you just say say the the chief spoke to you in English? I thought they were living in stone age.. sorry.. somebody said they just stand on those sticks the whole day. Maybe somebody has been going to school.
Lastly, the young boys have to kill a lion armed with only an sharp stick and a spear to be a man. Now lets try that to a Westerner. Okay, gear include a semi Automatic, a telescope, binoculars, a ladder to climb on that tree, a cell phone to call 911, an ambulance in case, a nd a backup pistol if it comes too close plus three months training at $200 /hr.
Who is the real man?
Nice article Fletcher, it occurred to me however that the modern version of your talking stick is displayed below your article here. Hard to interrupt someone elses blog.  
   Enough can't be said about being happy no matter your circumstances. Elie Wiess had it right.  For anyone to determine whether someone elses life is right or good or appropriate is the epitomy of arrogance, welcome to western civilization.  If enough Masai were unhappy with thier lifestyle they would change it.  Thats how it works. since they are obviously happy lets not interfere with a good thing.  Just think of your reaction to them if they came to your house and insisted you should tear it down and build a "nice house" out of cow dung and sticks or that you should quit being a selfish disrespectful woman and quit work and be a good mother and housewife.
In response to Kevin, their medical care is pretty aweful. My sister used to be a nurse in the Rift Valley, and she treated so many Masai women and babies with deformities and diseases that are quite preventable, with better nutrition, pure water, etc. My mom and I went to visit her, when I was twelve, and I still have distinct memories of holding grinning, laughing babies (who stank terribly of urine and sour milk), whoes lips were cleft, or whoes bellies were bloated and sore from infections. But, like the author said, they were generally happy, the children and adults. They thought nothinging of tasks that would totally daunt a Westerner (and they don't have huge problems with stress and depression-go figure). For instance, there were some mothers, who were no older than middleschoolers, who walked for days to get to the hospital, to try and get help for their children.
  So many of them die, when they don't have to. I am all about preserving traditions, but at the same time, more modern medicine would go a very long way towards improving the quality of life. They don't even have such simple things as Advil! I really can't speak for their education, but medically, they're in pretty tough shape.
I don't find this difficult to believe at all, I am the ruler of my house (when my wife isn't around) I make the decisions (when my wife lets me). I like seeing different cultures and how they work. I have travelled this earth extensivly, and I am always amazed at the cultures I encounter. Americans are unique in our own way, we are truly the melting pot of the world and we tend to progress quicker than the rest of the world. We are open to new ideas and inventions. We are constantly striving to reach new hieghts. if these people are content to live how they see fit, so be it. I am going to take one idea from them and I will be constructing my own talking stick, it will most likely be made from a wooden spoon as it is my turn for dinner tonight, but I will parade about my house with my talking stick, barking orders and running the house as I see fit. Of course it will not take long for my wife to remove the walking stick from my grasp and quite possibly whack me on the head with it. She will then be the bearer of the talking stick and I will be back in the kitchen speed dialing Papa Johns....mmmmmmm....paaaapaaaa joooohns...but it will be fun while it lasts. cool article.
One of many challenges about reporting different cultures is gender- many times, when women come in and interview the same people, they'll get a different story.  For instance, if someone were to interview the women, they may have said, "Men say we do what?!".  Seeing as how America constantly struggles with sexism, racism, and colonialism, we certainly seem to look through that lens when learning about indigenous people.  Pastoral people tend to be semi-egalitarian...then you have the issue of what the people were like before western influence, which is something that we probably will never know.

Maybe the women were laughing because they knew the men were making up stories that the westerners would believe- or maybe they were laughing at the men who have to use a stick to talk when they just figured out how to converse without props.  Or maybe they're laughing at the guy who believes men are making all the decisions....or at the men who believe they're making the decisions...because *if* they're truly the ones doing most of the work, they're also obviously active decision-makers...or maybe they're laughing at the men who think they're the only ones with more than one lover, or that they've fooled him about the paternity of their children the man is supporting...maybe they weren't happy at all, but were being polite...

I've never bought the argument that women in indigenous cultures a) are/were always oppressed and b) like it (which reminds me of the common idea during American slavery that slaves liked or needed slavery). That doesn't make sense- if women weren't stronger and smarter than that, humanity would have died off long ago.  A group within any culture, if oppressed, usually finds a way to challenge it- be it building alliances, overthrowing, bargaining, etc.  The only exception is when that group feels they truly have no way out except death. Unfortunately, people gathering information on these groups often have little or no reference point about oppression, so they'll miss significant subtleties.  Not saying this is what happened- but I do have an anthropological background, and I know this is a consistent problem.  People are people, and we tend to either learn to respect those in our communities & get along or kill each other off...
It is so easy for Westerners to criticize Maasai (Mr. Fletcher should learn to spell the word correctly) culture without understanding both the environment in which they live and the society itself. I've spent quite a bit of time with the Maasai and one thing that people have to experience themselves before they can truly understand it is that these people are 100% dependant on the land and the weather. Their livestock is their life. If they lose even one goat it is a major loss to the family. Thus, the most important job there is to do is to protect the livestock. Like any job in protection, 99% of the time you end up sitting around doing nothing. But you are paid, or in the case of the Maasai men respected, for that time when you have to defend your cattle against a lion, leopard, hyena, or whatever.
I am not in any way condoning some of the practices that the Maasai continue to observe including female genital mutilation, child marraige, etc. Those are things that should be stopped regardless of how they fit into their culture because they are cruel and inhumane. But the idea of a lazy Maasai man is something that is more a result of viewing a culture from an outsiders perspective than the reality of life in Maasailand.
I enjoyed reading all of the comments from other people after the article.  A couple really good comments are Njeri, Sundee, and Betsy Zink.  They know the Maasai and the African culture well it sounds like.  When I visited this tribe, the chief's wife came up to Pat and I.  She was huge--not fat, but extremely tall and powerful looking--and BEAUTIFUL.  She had a regal quality about her and a fierceness to protect the way her tribe was viewed.  Before we began filming their circumcision dance ceremony (tonight was a circumcision for the males) she asked both Pat and I what we were to do with our videos and how we would portray their tribe.  We assured her we only had good intentions with our research and we would not portray their circumcision or customs in a bad light.  Only then were we permitted to continue, but she watched us the whole time, peering down at us--she must have been about 7 feet tall!  I've tried to hold true to my promise to her because she was very upset with those who portrayed their female customs of circumcision and gender roles in a bad light.  The women are a very proud and capable people as are the men and each enjoys their position in their tribe.  One thing that nobody commented on was their religious view of God as a woman.  I believe the Maasai men recognize a woman's great abilities and seeing deity as a female seems to show their respect and love for womanhood.  I don't believe they belittle their women at all and the women take great pride in the responsibilities their men give them.  I really enjoyed the comments on this article because I wasn't sure if the whole translation we got about their tribe came across correct, but it seems, from the comments of Sundee and Betsy, that a lot of what I understood was correct.  Respect their way of life and don't judge their way of love or customs until you've lived with them, speak their language, and are given the "ok" from the main tribal lady.
I'm an ER Nurse who spent several with the Masai last year working in portable clinics. I saw many sick, malnourished women and children, many with large ulcers on their legs who had walked for hours to our make-shift clinics. For most of these Masai, this was the first time they had ever had any type of health care. The young girls (5th grade) were very afraid of their up coming "circumcision" and were NOT looking forward to it in any way!
Did the Masai warriors tell Mr. Fletcher about the young girls who run away to avoid circumcision?  These girls are frequently eaten by lions, or other wild animals on the Mara.  If they make it to a village/town, they must be able to enroll in school, which means finding someone, or a charity organization to sponser them or they will be sent back to their masai village, and to circumcision.  
I am also wondering if Mr. Fletcher was able to visit a Masai market, if so did you notice all of the women selling their goods?  They always looked to their man to make sure that they didn't settle for too little.  If they had sold something for too little, the silent exchange between husband and wife was all telling.  She would bow her head, looking ashamed, and frequently another woman would step up to the table to take her place. Two Masai women told me that they would leave if they could, but there is no where for them to go. These women have not options, so of course they make the best of their situation.
Yes the Masai sang, danced and laughed, as did the people in the horrible slums of Nairobi.
Kenya is rich in culture that is much different than ours, please don't sugar coat the differences or omit them. There is much we can all learn from these differences.



statements appearing here like,
"tough, hardy, masculine men who don,t and never will apologize for being men are still loved and appreciated....
When our women exercized their traditional duties we didn't have so many separations and divorces...
Yes, they are a wonderful simple culture, where the men have a great life, the woman work hard all day and yet are happy...
Good 'ole USA, where the women are women and the men are too...
While warrior spirit is genetic to human males... basically Masai men tend their cattle keep their women pregnant and tending the fire. You go guys!"

Regardless of what is and is not true of this article, American sentiments like this about gender equality or lack thereof are extremely disturbing (and telling). Ugh.
I recently read a book about the Masai. It is called "Ivory". It is a Sci.-Fi. story about the last Masai and the 'greatest' animal trophy ever. In this story there are several statements about the Masai. I wonder how many of them are true:
1. Before foreign goverments took over, the Masai controlled the largest and best piece of grazing land in africa.
2. At that time there were only about 30,000 Masai.
3. They were considered the proudest and most fierce warriors in the land. Nobody crossed the Masai.
4. When the foreign goverments took over they took the Masai's spears and shields. The Masai men could no longer defend themselves or participate in the rite of passage to manhood by killing a lion armed only with a spear.They also lost their own language and spoke Swahili.
"We have alot to learn from these nomadic hedsmen". Do you all know that if we adopted masai culture of sharing wives and husbands (a masai woman is allowed to share her husband with other wives and a masai man is allowed to share other masai's wives through placement of a spear in front of their doorways) we would put cheaters program out of business?
I just implore everyone to learn from this story. Don't judge, don't impose your western feminist or mysogynist views on this story. It sickens me to read the men who say things like "know your place," but it also disgusts me the way certain people post feminist comments about the women laughing at the men, or that the women could be a matriarchal society and that they could learn things from our western women. I am not saying I am against women's rights but to impose a western view of how women should act or be in a society on another culture is both ignorant and presumptuous. One must learn to appreciate cultures and people as they are. It is a habbitual error westerners make when they presume they know best and that their view is the correct one. Does anyone ever wonder why divorce and separation is so high here in the US? Does anyone ever wonder why the "richest nation with the most opportunities" produces so many unhappy people? I am not suggesting we emulate other cultures to be happy, although it is true that we could learn from them. To ignore wisdom from another source is idiotic. Now I am rambling...the point is we ought to evaluate ourselves before we presume to judge other people and their cultures. Don't be so sure we are "the smart ones."
While some may claim that the lifestyle of the Masai is very convenient for the men, would you believe that we in the West are just as sexist? Just the fact that we believe the Masai's lifestyle to be wrong speaks volumes on it. If real, true feminists are so proud to be as powerful as men, wouldn't they cherish the responsibility of a man, a responsibility taken from an era when men ruled? To be the sole provider, to be the bread-winner/home-builder/whatever-doer?

I just find that interesting that we are so sexist in every way, we feel the need for everyone to be totally 'equal'. There is never equality in the universe. That is called entropy, and while all systems run towards it, there are always natural forces opposed.

I'm done ranting. Flame away, but I think we all can admit, at least us Westerners, that we have an unrealistic view on life, and are WAY too concerned with equality and material and monetary gains.
A man is as happy as he or she feels. Proper medical health care, a good job, a fancy car and big house house does not stop one from committing suicide. Hats off the Masai man.
In the tears of a shadow.

Near the streamlet,
and where a rustic
fireplace remembers
the sound of a
countryside, I see
a timid and innocent
care; and besides,
like the scent
of a swallow, a
tender bell-finger
discovers a faith.
well, well i've read every fact from every writer but you failed to acknowledge things keep changing like weather but reality gonna stand and judge you with the things happening now and the things which happenened at the past.For me personally i don't agree with you for that kind of a cultural and customs applied by masai as a tool to be honored by their culture is awkleward  and living in a past life which does not benefit the whole society they should join with others to acquire knowledge because its' not sold in gourd in ablack market period.Leave about the past, history gonna remind you about the past.my point is ,can we leave like masai? ok if yes how are we going to shape our history?
another sad example were we try to impose our standards on other people.
I like the modern tribes.  I wake each morning and herd my code on the internet. When people "talk" to me, we take turns, each with email or chat. Tis a simple life, but rewarding.
While contentment and simplicity can always be achieved regardless of where one lives,is it not "our" business to educate others on how to promote "our" health? Mr Flethcher, did you ask Kipas if the Masai men and women are aware of the Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV)?
If we learn to respect each other and listen, we can learn a lot from each other. Family values and the family unit have been and is the strength that helped humanity survived to date. Where the future is going, I can not tell you.
Maybe you'd be less eager to be a Maasai man if you realized that killing a lion single-handedly (which is seldom done today due to governmental regulations)is only one of the prerequisites.  If you think you're able to kill enough songbirds with a rungu (throwing stick/club)to make yourself a full headdress or able to stand the pain of an unanesthetized circumcision without showing ANY sign of pain, by all means go for it.  Ati, I hate the way people here blather on about things they have no understanding of.
‘If the Masai man believes he is entitled to silence, mutilate, prostitute and make slaves of others, it begs the question; does that not matter?
Is he not a sociopath?’
C., South Carolina (Sent Friday, September 21, 2007 8:52 AM)

Now if that’s not an absurd conclusion, I don’t know what is. The Maasai maybe chauvinistic but so are men in many other countries, including this one. Drop the feminist rhetoric, it gets old and produces nothing positive.

For sean fitzpatrick, Dallas, TX, as you said it was a sci-fi book. People are changing with the influence of Westernization of the world so of course language and customs are dying away.
The Maasai like everyone else had skirmishes with others including their Kikuyu neighbours e.g. raiding for women and cattle.

Bottom-line for me is that whereas the Maasai have been able to sustain their traditional practices for a lot longer that many of us have, let us neither romanticize nor demonize the reasons for that or their way of life with no real understanding of whom they are. It would be good to see a travel article that does not advance either the ‘noble savage’ or the ‘poor backward African’ stereotypes. It’s patronizing and ultimately quite demeaning.


just remember my people,learning and teching is the spirit of the future.
i have taken the time to read all the above comments plus the story ! i am a tanzanian and we have massai s too contrary to popular belief that they are kenyan they are actually a nomadic tribe. most of the comments come from western minded people who can never say anything good about an african and always go attacking ower culture. the nbc guy says the cows were a hundred yards away i wonder if he asked from what time the man started sheparding them and how far they go each day to search for food and water and where they are located ( in the middle of the bush) .alot of masais also exist in towns and there u will find most of the woman busy doing business while the guys are usually night watchman this is how they live the man are trained warriors and the woman hold the people together making them the strong culture u seee today! so please before being critical try and understand the right way of living is certainly not the american way (western). i for one am so dissapointed when i try to get african news i only see DARFUR, SOMALIA and the rest is iraq
When I visited the Masai about 12 years ago I didn't think the women laughed anymore or less than a group of women anywhere else.  What I did go away wondering was why some cultures don't change over time and others do.  I keep reading comments that the Masai live with nature, accept their surroundings, maintain their traditions and way of life...but where is their inventiveness, their art, their urge to create, and explore?  When day to day life is a struggle just to feed your self and you children there is no opportunity for anything else.  There were a few more things I noticed on my visit: the oldest person in the village couldn't have been more than 40, half the children had conjuntivitis, and many of the adults (most in their 20s & 30s) had knee and joint problems, and a few had cataracts.        


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=371336

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.