ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



Yes, Pakistan’s new National Art Gallery has nudes

Posted: Monday, September 17, 2007 12:58 PM
Filed Under:

There is something of a modern-day bard in Pakistani architect Naeem Pasha, but it’s not just because he writes poetry – it’s more an expression of what he wants his buildings to be.

"It's not that I am concentrating on purely architectural expression," said Pasha, 64, his brown-rimmed glasses perfectly offsetting a head of thick snow-white hair and neat goatee. "All those sketches would have a lot of couplets, the beginning of a poem might be there," he said smiling.

I was intrigued.

VIDEO: Tour Pakistan's National Art Gallery with the architect

Pasha led me on a tour of the spectacular new National Art Gallery in Islamabad, Pakistan's capital. It’s the first national gallery in the country – and Pasha's crowning achievement.  

There is no barrier between architecture, poetry or painting, he explained.

"They understand each other – we might not know their language of understanding, but all these expressions understand each other," he said.

I had never thought of a building in quite that way before.

Contemporary and edgy
The austere, red-brick "fortress-like" exterior grabs one immediately. But the real attention-getter is just off to the side of the main entrance – a "sentry" of six 10-feet tall burqa clad women made out of black fiberglass.

Carol Grisanti / NBC News
Sculptures of burqa clad women welcome visitors to Pakistan’s new National Art Gallery.

The message from the sculptor, Jamil Baloch, seemed to be that though westerners may view the burqa as a form of incarceration for women, in eastern cultures – regardless of how they dress – women are strong and play a larger-than-life role in society.

And that role is certainly evident at the National Art Gallery. Sixty percent of the artists on exhibit are women.

"Pakistan's art world is overwhelmingly female-dominated," said Pasha.

"Parents didn't send their sons to art school; they sent their daughters," he told me. "Art school was considered a sissy thing to do."

But the art inside is far from sissy. It is contemporary and edgy and defies Pakistan's image as a deeply conservative country of religious extremists.

The white painted exhibit halls are light and airy. A combination of interconnecting architectural spaces is accessible from a spiraling light brick ramp walkway. Every gallery looks into each other and, according to Pasha, communicates with each other.

"We are in Gallery Six – the landscapes," he pointed out. "Gallery Six looks down on Gallery One – which is all about love – so love is communicating with landscape."

It was all beginning to make sense – until we reached the nudes in gallery 10. No one seemed to be communicating with them.

Here was an entire room devoted to a raw display of the human form – quite rare in an Islamic country. But just in case someone might be offended, they were all discreetly "tucked away" in one of the top-floor galleries.

We walked past the guard propped up against the ornate wooden double doors. I thought I detected a sort of censorious glance. He looked at me and then at my camera.

"No pictures," he said.

Other spaces, like the sculpture gallery, are two stories high and can be viewed from overhanging balconies offering different perspectives on the works below.

 

Carol Grisanti / NBC News
Inside the sculpture gallery in Pakistan’s new National Art Gallery.

"The idea is that you should go through the whole building in a circular pattern without having missed a single object," Pasha explained. "If you are not successful in doing that, you have failed. Even if you miss one single object you have failed," he said.

Ready for the next project
Light flows through windows of all shapes and sizes, and the glass covered rooftop atrium streams skylight into the spaces below. Large aluminum "scoops" collect and feed indirect light into 14 galleries spread over 91,000 square feet of space. "Scoops" are an architectural gimmick used to bring in lateral light from the roof and redirect it where natural light is not available.

Pasha studied architecture at Penn State. As a student he looked up to and was inspired by Louis Kahn, the man regarded as the "mystic of architecture" and a proponent of brick buildings.

"Brick has humility," said Pasha. "With all its limitations and limited resourcefulness, it is still the most beautiful material."

No surprise then that Pasha built his gallery from brick. Most of the interior accents are also made from exposed red and yellow brick.

"And what will you create next?" I asked.

"I am bidding on the national museum project," he said. "We don't have a museum in Islamabad that chronicles our 5,000 years of sub-continent civilization."

I wondered aloud how long that would take to complete – when the National Art Gallery finally opened last month, it was 17 years after Pasha originally won the design competition for the building. The gallery project had been a saga of "stops and starts" due to national political upheavals and lack of funding.

But even a repeat of that wouldn’t be enough to dampen Pasha's passion for the potential new project.

"The creative process is a fever," he said poetically. "It's like falling in love and when you are newly in love your temperature is always very high."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Dear Carol, I really enjoyed this posting because I was an art major in college and still paint and draw. I understand how he wanted to use the light in the building from outside to fall on the works of art. There are some nice paintings and sculptures in this museum. The black scuptures of the women in burqas sends a statement of how women are seen in the society of the region.  But they have made progress in many ways. The paintings of the soldiers marching on the desert and the water were powerful works. The building is a work of art in itself. I do agree with him that "The creative process is a fever". When you are in love your temperature in higher. That is definitely a really wonderful thing! Thank you Carol for this posting! Peace to all!      
very nice piece. lovely storytelling by both the reporter and the architect.
thank you
See, this is positive news...Congrats to Pakistan! Who is the curator? I want to display my art there. (Seriously)
Where are the naked pics?
Excellent piece!
It's also a story of dedication and persistence, which I appreciate.
More than that, it's a kind of public support for the social commentary that flows from artists and poets to the rest of us.  The lack of intervening walls is symbolic in itself, allowing the free flow of ideas and concepts to intermingle, enhance and compete with one another.
As a poet, writer and activist, I have a special appreciation for these things, especially when they come from an unexpected source!
Another fine example of the countless aesthetic and academic contributions made by the Islamic community. Learning about and appreciating a cultures art leads to a more intimate knowledge of that culture. The more intimate ones knowledge about another culture, the less likely one is to feel fear or hatred based on cultural differences. Art strips us bare
"Architeture is frozen music" I'll never look at a bulding the same way again. Thank you that was beautiful.
Motivated me to go and have a look! By the way objections to the nudes are already making the press. How sad!
 It would be great if a "60 minutes" type program in the US would spend some time there and present such a positive glowing example of their culture.
   You only mentioned one notable artist from Pakistan.  What are the other artists names?  What style of art is predominate in Pakistan?
This is a wonderful story.  Coming from such a conflict stricken area, such beauty takes place. I sincerely hope his dream of a national museum comes to fruition.  The culture is so old and varied, the Pakistani people should have a place to collectively express their feelings about their history.  Our country is so young in comparison.
Finally one positive story in the press about Pakistan, I hope its the begining of change for the better.  
I'm very impressed...Naeem Pasha had a vision and he stuck to it through the years until he saw his vision become reality when the museum finally opened. I want to go see the exhibits now. Thanks for writing this article--pakistani art is far too often ignored in the world today.
The 5,000 years of civilization mentioned, Muslims destroyed much of it and continue to do so.  See Joseph Campbell, the mythologist, Wells, the historian, or Max Weber, the sociologist, all and many more chronicle the sheer enormity of the destruction of Hindu, Buddhist, Jain, and other art and architecture throughout the subcontinent.  What is left is miniscule.  When I see Muslim art built upon the destroyed sacred sites of Hindus, Buddhists, and Jains, upon the burnt areas of ancient libraries and universities, I would gladly trade all that modern "art" in Pakistan for what was once the glorious art of India.  And no one is still safe; Pakistani backed terrorists still blow up Buddhas, destroy Gandharn art in Afghanistan and Pakistan, and still neglect and ruin ancient sites.  What art? Looking for subcontinent non Muslim art is like looking for the remnants of native American villages in Long Island.
Its good to see another side of Pakistan.What we are used to in India is them sending there best(terrorists) and us fighting them and there ISI.If only they could use there man power and mind power to be progressive.Creativity in Pakistan is very very limited albeit thats the bane of Islamist Nations as creativity is stiffled none the less there are artists of all natures there.The only reason Pakistan has this is because it had been a part of India.If not for this it would be the total Crazy islamist state that Muslim nations are.Kudos to the the gentleman who set this up 50 years after Pakistan got independence. Development in pakistan can be viewed in this angle.Pessimist that i am and not a big fan of Islamist nations especially Pakistan which is the Center of all Jehadi idiots. If only Pakistan had no Mullahs.
This shows that Pakistan is not only more modern and advanced, but getting to more educated than some other conservative Islamic countries, lets say Saudi Arabia and Iran. It is portraying modern art with a cultural side, I loved the women in the burqa sculptures, and I think its great.  
Bravo !!! These sculptures of "burqa" are really unique idea and look awesome ...for sure, Its really different than the "western" monotonous idea of nudity.
If pakistanis are really muslims, they should get rid of those statues. if they are hidus and hypocrites, then they will keep them.
great piece..thanks for this piece as it shows the positive side of Pakistan amid a lot of negatives.
To subcontinental islamophobes,
The genius of Islamic art and architecture is the form of fusion. Islam's legacy for accumulating and tranforming the past and the contemporary and transforming the surrounding through inornate geometrics is unparallel. Alhamra in Al Andalus (spain), Taj mahal in Muslim India, Hagia Sophia in Constantinopole (Turkey), Red Fort in Lahore (Pakistan), The Mosque of Omar in Damascus (Syria), The Blue mosque in Isfahan (Iran), The Jama Masjid in Tashkent (Kazakhistan). That all these architectural master pieces were built by the spirituality of a people whose only legacy was one black cube (Kaba) in the center of the vast Arabian peninsula leaves out the narrative of immense creativity and cultural accomodation that is rarely seen in any of the land Muslims once ruled over. From the destruction of Babri mosque in India (1992) to the looting and burning of the Great Museum of Baghdad by US occupation forces are just recent examples of cultural accomodation professed by the two most democratic nations in the world.  
Mr. Pasha's work is really comendable. The light effect and the pieces of art are wonderful. I request Mr. Pasha and other atrtists and architects to build art gallaries like this in other cities of Pakistan also. This will make overseas Pakistanis proud of their country. Thanks Carol.
Excellent Job, ...Sculptures of burqa clad women look gracious and powerful ...Where ever i have been, Muslim art has always impressed me ...from fame of India, one of the most magnificent and wondrous monuments created by the Muslim genius, Taj Mahal, to Islamic Art Section at Modern Art museum Manhattan, NY... or from Uzbekistan, Central Asia to the heart land of Europe, Bosnia ...Muslim art work is really magnificent ...I must admit, its second to none !

I think it is great, so it makes me wonder how long it will last before the Islamists blow it up. The women in Burgas statues out front remind me of restless spirits leading you to a secret.
It is good to see that people all over the world are not much different each other. they all want the freedom to express who they are, without the meddling of religious fanatics that would want to stop them. You may not agree with their form of expression but they should not be held back by some religious idiot.When religion stands in the way of progress and freedoms of the people they serve one should question the religion.As long as people are not being destructive to society in general they should and must express themselves in any way that is available to them.I say leave art to artists and religion to priests. But one has no just cause to stand in the way of the other.People are not sheep and should not be forced to follow each other like sheep.where would we be if we did?we would all still be in the stone age !!Art is just another form of freedom and should be expressed weather you agree with it or not. YOU DON'T LIKE IT DON'T GO TO THE MUSEUM.
What a wonderful and surprising portrait of diverisity in a country often viewed as overly influenced by extremists (such as Aftaab Ahmed, if his comments are to be taken seriously). The human spirit will always find a way to free itself from artificial boundaries imposed by politics and religion and art will always triumph over authority. Bravo to Pakistan and Bravo to Naeem Pasha for defying sterotypes and giving artistic and human beauty a special place where we can come and admire.
This display of nudity is forbidden in Islam. These images should be removed from the musuem immideately.
There is nothing Islamic about having such a deviant instution in muslim country.
Which status Aftaab?  The women in the burqas?  I agree, i find those status ominous, threatening and depressing.
Pak is definitely a creative country and art is one of its better exports.  In India, culture and art from the Islamic world in general – and Pak, Afghan and Mughal art in particular – has always found expression and resonated with the people here.  It has contributed to our poetry, music, architecture, cuisine and culture in general and forms an important part of our history. Some our famous actors, poets, musicians and artists of all forms have had their origins there. So I’m sure any outlet for art in Pak will be a very interesting place to visit.

Friends on the other side of the border tell me that Indian art and culture is just as appreciated there. A majority of us people on both sides of the border each appreciate the other's culture irrespective of issues between us and I think cultural exchanges will go a long way towards better relations for out two countries, so kudos!
Dear Carol: You have created a cool forum for inviting comments. Thanks to most of the comments that have enhanced the forum's capacity to stay cool and thus encourage creativity.
it has given me great pleasure to share the detailed article about Pakistan's National Art gallery with my foreign friends.  I look forward to going back to Islamabad,Pakistan and visit this wonderful and great art gallery.  

Sunil Misra and Vikram both represent the extremely narrow mindedness of hindu mentality. They forgot that whatever is build in India is work of Muslims, Taj Mahel is the best example of a Muslim's aspirations of his love life. These people are so narrow minded that they never expect the good things heppening in Pakistani part of subcontinent.
Any attempt to present artwork by Pakistan is a laudable aspiration. Peace and understanding may eventually be achieved if nations can exchange their cultural prizes. Art has been the basis of all civilization and it has created the modern conveniences, medical sciences and advances of man from the days of the Cavemen. The way people express themselves can be the basis of understanding for the entire planet without regard to national identity, race or creed as an obstacle to freedom for all. The destruction of art in Rome was done by a tribe known as Vandals. The word has continued to mean those who have no respect for beauty and human achievement.
Only love and trust. beauty and understanding mingled with the compassion espoused by all the major religions can combat the evils of Apocalyptic marchings. We must act to save the human race now. Art gives us the pride as human beings we need to end bloodshed and tyranny. Hooray Pasha! Keep up the good work and please save as much art as you can. A pity so much has already perished. DH    
Despite some credentials as an artist, I can do without the mystic mumbo-jumbo of "art communicating with art".  What I will say is that it is pleasant, after almost a quarter century of deconstructivist hideousness and post-modernist frou-frou, to see an honest building, which does its job of showcasing art without insisting on calling attention to itself.  Now, all we have to do is to wait for I.M. Pei to die so we can remove that hideous glass pyramid from the courtyard of the Louvre, where it has sat, for too many years, like an infectious chancre on Angelina Jolie's lips.  
Finally a positive article about Islamic art and civilzation that has been ignored for far too long in the mainstream media coverage. And to negative comments from few all I can say that Muslims did not destroy India; they built much of the architectural monuments that present day India is so proud of and adverise in the international media  like Taj Mahal, Qutub Minar, Agra Fort, Red Fort in Delhi, Jama Masjid in Delhi and so many others in all over India that were built during Mughal and earlier Muslim period in India.  
To Jeffrey Sachs,
I guess you are acting as "non-islamo"-phobe while basing your argument with false information. Taj Mahal was built by Hindu architects and labors who were forced to work and later they were rewarded by cuttign their thumb and index fingers so that no one else can hire those talented architects and workers.
Most islamic architecture you see in India echoes the fact that they were built by Hindus and Hindus-converted-to-Islam and they were built after destroying Hindu temples and architectures. The few Hindu temples left were just lucky to evade the eyes of islamic destroyers. Babri masjid was also built upon destruction of a Hindu temple. BTW: if they were so great, why don't we see them building nice architectures like Taj Mahal - oh b'coz they cannot enslave the Hindu or Christian artists any more. Most of the modern architecture you see in the middle east are actually done by US/European contractors and architects. So please... get your facts straight.... and are you talking about destruction? What about destroying the WTC Twin towers, Buddha statue in Afghanistan or Gandharn art destruction? Oh please, you do not want me to start the list... it will be a long long list.
I've always considered Muaslim artwork to be awesome in its ability to capture a feeling without true to form representation of living things. Its the genesis of abstract art.

The burqa clad statues skip past the prohibition on living things by representing the non living matter of the clothing with only the cloaked form to suggest life underneath. Somewhat like the suits of armor standing in european castles and manor houses, or a spacesuit in a NASA exhibit.

John of Damascus wrote a very estute defense of religious icons which explains the manner in which such images focus the minds eye. Worth reading.

While prohibiting certain types of representations of the human form is stiffling to the art world, a look at the Maplethorpe controversy here shows just how the very definition of what constitutes art has become almost meaningless in western society.

While Medieval Muslim physicians did great work in tracing the development of the fetus and the digestive tract, their medical texts look like they were scrawled by a six year old. Not for lack of skill but simply because they were afraid to show the human body in a realistic manner.
European Medical texts of the same era are so well drawn that many are still used in modern medical studies.
Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhh Pakistan..the next Palestine
The artchitecture as described is a mode of expression and the reflection of the concepts, mindset and the values of a society or the individual who holds them. Islamic society is based on the values shaped by the Koran and the example of the prophet among them is unity and devotion to Allah, rejection of nudity, adhearance to modesty esp of women, and if all of them if really exist in a society are automatically reflected in architectural expressions. Since burqa in Islam represents a means of modesty attested by Koran so its is not viewed in Islam as suffocating rather its liberating one of physical desires and attrations and focussing on spiritual purity and energy. Nudity is unIslamic western norm of "freedom" of expression entirely opposite to Islam's view. Its symbol of humbleness and piety.  
Great piece! Excellent on all counts.
Those sculptires in front of the museum...did anyone else think of the Nazgul from "The Lord of the Rings"?
Dear Jeffrey,

The Babri Mosque was razed as it was originally built by razing a Hindu temple. What goes around comes around. Has it struck you that the Islamophobes in the subcontinent are wary on account of having seen wonderful Islam in action?
Barely a few kilometers from my town in North India is a beautiful Buddhist monastery, with hundreds of beheaded Buddhas- thanks to your cultural connoisseurs. If one were to catalogue the number of temples, gurudwaras and other places of worship, not to mention cultural artifacts razed by the forces of Islam in the subcontinent, one would lose count.
Lastly, whats amusing is your statement that India bar Islam had little to show in the way of culture- visit the country, and then talk. Islam is but one facet of what ancient India, achieved in terms of art and culture.
I find it interesting that since the burque "in Islam represents a means of modesty attested by Koran so its is not viewed in Islam as suffocating rather its liberating one of physical desires and attrations and focussing on spiritual purity and energy. Nudity is unIslamic western norm of "freedom" of expression entirely opposite to Islam's view. Its symbol of humbleness and piety", women are forced to wear it but the men are not.  
To Ishrat Hyatt Rawalpindi, Pakistan

The objections to the nudes may be sad but, in an Islamic coutry? Totally predictable. There was some of the same air in the United States ( a Christian country) in the 80's coming from right wing Christian/Republican extremists...Religion? The bane of human existence...kill it, ban it, legislate it out of public/political existence
very nice, but go see it now because it will be blown up within a year by you know who. (the usual suspects!)
Folks, here you see clear examples of Hindu minds at work. After reading this beautiful post, a work of art in itself, they have nothing better to say but are jealous and have started their "main na manoon" routine. Pakistan has been a pain in their rear for over half a century and there ain't no cure for that.
Dear Friends:
How different the sculptures expression is compared to the real world!
Bland,  moving, shiftily,  no mystery, while the artist expersses shape it is not defined as male or female in the burgas.  They neither define their shape and or experssion or interpretation of the world. They are like shadows of which Holy things do not have.  They are past, unseen, unspoken, children without love,  without the instinctive experessions of man.  It is like a web of time that has no beginning and no end. The Arabs in my world are seen as more than this.  Feeling,  real and they also had children with experessions not absent.    

I feel for you.  For the men though they not say it are absent in the interactive expression.

A baloon has more than this.  It can be painted on.
In other worlds you wear other cloths and wear a mask much like Shakespear.  Life absent.  

You are not just about oil.  

Abraham had a face and so did his wife and children.

Yet you choose other nations to be schooled at.  

Many years of art and music and emotion.

What is in your biotechnology and nanotechnology the past?
Dear Friends:
Freedom of speech.  Come out of the dark!
I agree with many other commentators- it was very uplifting and a true pleasure to read about and view art from a non-western country.  All the prior images in my head, about Pakistan, involved poverty, pain and suffering.  Thank you for enlarging my concept.  [And thank you particularly for the shot of the sculpture display- I love sculpture!]
to bilabh,
here are some facts about the Taj Mahel,
Many architects have rated it as the most perfect of all buildings standing on earth. Three artists designed it: a Persian, an Italian, and a Frenchman. But the design is completely Mohammedan. Even the skilled artisans who built it were brought in from Baghdad, Constantinople, and other centers of the Muslim faith.
Get your facts right!!!
Great write up. Thanks Pasha for your contributions. As for the pathetic Islamophobic Indians, feel sorry for your inferiority complex and complete ignorance of facts. Go visit the Islamic world and you will learn that besides your country Islamic art has impacted evey continent. Where would India be  without Muslim influence? Be wearing dhoti and eating tastless lentils!  


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=364847

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.