ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



Fighting the Taliban, worrying about Va. Tech

Posted: Thursday, April 19, 2007 3:00 PM


 

 

JALALABAD, Afghanistan -- Col. John Nicholson, commander of Task Force Spartan, has a lot on his mind:

  • He must lead a brigade of some 3,500 U.S. soldiers in the rugged and lethal eastern Afghan mountain ranges near the border with Pakistan.
  •  His tour of duty and that of his men has been extended from one year to 15 months, without prior notice.
  • The winter lull in the war against the Taliban is over and – once again – Taliban fighters and al-Qaida operatives are infiltrating from Pakistan into his “area of operations” in large numbers.

But this is not what was preoccupying this West Point graduate, who has led his brigade through at least three major military offensives in Taliban country during the past year. What was disturbing him, he confided to me after we caught up at Jalalabad Air base on Wednesday, was that his daughter just lost her best girlfriend. Her former high school classmate, Erin Peterson, was one of the 30 killed in Norris Hall, on the Virginia Tech campus.

 

‘’She is calling me and asking how I cope with death here in Afghanistan,’’ said the man who lost several close colleagues, as well as his Pentagon office, on 9/11. ‘’We are working through a lot of pain. It’s hard. What is also tough is that my 12-year-old boy is also asking me about death. Why am I here? Why all the violence?’’

 

Here is a man who, every day, has risked life and limb so that a people as innately alien to America as remote, rural, Afghans can improve their lives.  This has involved building a new road or school or bridge, or clinic, or flushing out Taliban rebels from their villages.

 

'It's just crazy'
But as he spoke, it seemed as if his bedrock of belief in the very system he is trying so hard to bring to Afghans had been shaken by recent events back home. “We are supposed to be bringing a sense of purpose, of democracy and values to these people, and yet, look at how lacking in values we can be ourselves. It’s just crazy,” he said.

 

Nicholson has seen vast improvements in the security and economic situation here in the past 12 months. The Taliban have been uprooted from many of its sanctuaries. Afghan children have returned to school. The elderly are getting help in clinics. Mothers, increasingly, survive childbirth. Most importantly, villagers are beginning to believe in their own local government officials, as well as in the emerging Afghan security forces.  The bullet points rolled off his tongue. The war in Afghanistan, he implied, was there for the winning. But he had no such apparent confidence – at least not this day – when he spoke about his own country’s week of trauma. 

 

Even a warrior like Nicholson, who loves America and all that it represents, seemed to be struggling inside: a confused patriot and father.

 

NBC News correspondent Jim Maceda, who is based in London, is on assignment in Afghanistan.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

John Nicholson doesn't HAVE to kill Afghans. He could come back to the U.S. and "help" out here. Or didn't his Westpoint education prepare him for that?
The author writes: "Here is a man who, every day, has risked life and limb so that a people as innately alien to America as remote, rural, Afghans can improve their lives. This has involved building a new road or school or bridge, or clinic, or flushing out Taliban rebels from their villages". With all due respect to Nicholson and his troops, we're not there for these idealistic reasons. We all know that the U.S. is in the Middle East because of the OIL. Can I say that publically? WE'RE THERE BECAUSE OF THE OIL.
Opium production is up, insurgent attacks are up and the death toll is on the rise. This isn't success by any standard of measurement. Yes, the shootings at Virginia Tech was a "crazy" event... but it's even crazier that these "crazy" shootings happen almost daily in Afghanistan... perhaps because our troops are there.
"The bullet points rolled off his tongue." huh. Yes, I bet they did.
As a warrior-patriot who loves America, did John Nicholson have any comments about who and what created those lethal Afghani Taliban fighters in the first place? Uh... could it have been his same beloved America and the former USSR? Perhaps diplomatic statecraft should be taught at Westpoint.
Americans aren't "coping" with the death in Afghanistan, they're CAUSING it. Most of those poor Afghani farmers never even had a chance to go to school. Fighting is all they've known thanks to CIA-backed arms shipments. Now we are there (under the guise of keeping peace) so that we can intimidate Iran, etc. John Nicholson SHOULD be worried about his daughter... because all of these occupations may come back to bit the U.S. in the a**. It's obvious to the world that U.S. statecraft has sought to undermine the Middle East. Now, they're just doing what they can to fight back. Can you blame them?
the man you spoke to is a hero,and better yet he is a concerned father.and you used both of his positions to take a swipe at the U.S. "he had no such apparent confidence-at least not this day"you take the words of a father that is in a low point because he feels bad for his kid and you use it to make the U.S. look like we are lacking morality. you sir have no morals and you don't have the spine to admit that you use a hero to put your stamp on his words. YOU SHOULD BE AHAMED
I was shocked and heartbroken over the events that took place in Monday's shootings at Virgina Tech College. I'm deeply saddened by this because I'm about the same age as most of those students who were slain. I was at work when I heard about it and suddenly, my good mood for the day was gone. I felt as though I'd been punched in the chest and I also felt that since I live in Illinois, there was nothing I could do to help those grieving. I want to express my condolences to those grieving right now and tell them that I know what it feels like to lose someone you love and/or care about. I lost a grandfather I loved very much a couple of years ago, a friend in a drunk driving accident while I was in high school, and many other people I cared about. I want those at Virginia Tech and their families to know that they're in my thoughts and prayers and since I can't make it to the candlelight vigil in Missouri tomorrow night, I'm going to light a candle here at home to honor those who were slain and injured on that fateful day. Again, please express my respects and condolences for the students and families at Virginia Tech. Thanks. With regards, Jennifer
why call it a blog if you wont put up all the comment you get.unless you are not getting the slant you want
Please S-T-O-P airing the horrible VA Tech killer's video!!! I was shocked that you chose to air the video at all, much less your constant hounding of it every new cast! This act is exactly what the killer wanted from you - his big notorious climb to fame with free national television air time thanks to NBC. Evidently broadcasting horrific news casts overcome your sense of sympathy for the many grieving horror stricken students, family and faculty of VA Tech! Why? There is only one person I can possibly imagine that would like to see this video over and over and over again - the killer! Is there some benefit to seeing this video that I am missing? If so, what? Where are you hearts? You censure shows for profanity - why isn't there some sanction against assisting a killer kill the souls of his victims over and over even after the initial blood bath he enacted in person? There our thousands other people in America and across the world in South Korea who wished he was never able to play you so successfully for this free air time of his demonic deed fulfilling the last step of his monsterous plan. Any other deranged could-be killers watching the video may possibly be getting a push toward planning their own day of fame learning how to be guaranteed free worldwide television airing. Others who are deep in shock and striving to make it through painful bereavement from the event are being sickened even worse by the constant reminder. The troops deployed around the world have enough to worry about without constantly viewing this event on American soil. Even the killer's own family I'm sure would wish you to cease airing the video. Please, please, take the video off, return it to the FBI and only air the stories that will help heal the multitudes so adversely affected by this horrific crime. Concerned and former loyal viewer.
it's ironic that the commander is worried about his daughter (who is safe inside the u.s. and protected from invaders) when thousands die each year in afghanistan because of the fighting between the taliban and the invading u.s. troops. many of the dead are civilians. childrend do not have enough to eat. if you are starving to death and the taliban offers food, it's your only option to accept and fight with them. most of the taliban know very little about the world, they just are taught that the u.s. soldiers are "bad guys". maybe they are? there is no honor in killing poor, starving, uneducated farmers. And the u.s. troops would probably have more fun shooting gophers in wyoming.
I, for one, am happy to hear that others are also wondering how we can hope to "spread democracy" even as we demolish it here at home. It's not just these killings, but the eroding of our precious freedoms, for which my father died in WWII, here at home. In some ways fear seems to be winning, at least as far as the media would have us believe. But then, fear sells papers while love (our other choice) does not. And our government and society seems to be about money now. Just show us the money and we'll declare right and wrong from that prospective. God help us.
What does a westpoint grad-- a product of the industrial-military-complex-- know about the good people at virginia tech? Is he one of cheney's friends, so you thought you'd give him some press? as far as the answer for the 12-year old boy goes, Nicholson is there because during the cold war we screwed them over and made a bunch of people who really hate us... so now we're using guys like Nicholson to try and keep the big mess under control.
Shut up my son is over there. Idiots!
FYI, THERE IS A GOOD ARTICLE ON THE AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL WEBSITE ABOUT HOW THE CITIZENS OF AFGHANISTAN ARE BEARING THE BURDEN FOR THE U.S.- NATO OCCUPATION, SEE BELOW: http://web.amnesty.org/pages/afg-190407-feature-eng WORK FOR PEACE, NOT WAR!
It's nice to see that someone is talking about Afghanistan again!! Good work!!
I lived in Afghanistan for 2 1/2 years in the mid-eighties. I could never prove it, but the poppy (opium) market has to be controlled by the CIA. It's the only way that that degree of internal strife could have been maintained for so long. By nature, the Afghans aren't fighters... they are farmers and herdsmen who have been caught up in geo-political catastrophe.
WHY THE HELL DOES EVEYTHING HAVE TO BE POLITICAL???
I think all of the anti-war nuts should to a quick "tour" of the middle east, and then come back with their drivel...my gut tells me most will quiet down a bit after that. After all, it is easy to sling mud from your living room.
True Patriot: I did two tours in Viet Nam. I was young then and I think I qualify as a patriot. I lived through it, kind of. Viet Nam sucked. Really sucked. I thought we learned something. But here we are, doing it all over again. Do you know what it's like to kill?  Power to the antiwar nuts.  
WE CAN STOP HUNDREDS SOLDIERS BEING KILLED IN IRAQ. TELL YOUR CONGRESS REPRESENTATIVE TO BRING THEM HOME NOW.
I wish that people who feel the need to blame the U.S. for the war in Afganistan would feel the need to study a little history.  WE are not the people who brought violence to this country; WE are not the people who invited the Taliban to rule; WE are not the people who harbored Al Qaida.  Remember 9/11?  Until then WE were not in Afganistan.
A different perspective how dare you say American service men are causing death in Afghnistan, when the only one causing death in Afghanistan are insurgents talibanis and disgruntled brain washed muslims who value death over life Please educate your self maybe you should put your money where your mouth is Go stay in Iran with Ahmedinijiad their are no US service men their and then come back and talk about the Middle East you have no idea what you are talking about so please dont talk Ive been all over the Middle East and you dont have one clue what you are saying people who talk against our soldiers are in my opinion traitors and should be forced to give up their US citizen if you dont like it here leave go live in Afgahanistan and we will bring our soldiers home and then you can talk about whose killing whom
I agree with John florida why call it a blog
you are not entertaining my well thought out coments
People are often contradictory and hypocritical, aren't they?  The twin towers come down, and we demand accountability by eliminating al-Qaida and decentralizing their operations.  Yet here we are now, complaining about how we shouldn't have invaded Afghanistan.  

Has anyone considered what the political and global consequences would have been had we not Afghanistan?  The American public demanded accountability, and our brave men and women gave them such accountability.  Yet as soon as casualties start mounting, we immediately about-face ourselves and scrutinize our own actions.

Islamic fundamentalists are doing a damn good job in eliciting this sort of political backlash from the American public.  The American public has no "stomach" for the rough work which must be done, which is a shame, since our country was built on the foundation of war, strengthened after enduring a civil war, and given a superior, global responsibility after winning two fierce, global conflicts.  

Perhaps Bin Laden was right in calling us paper tigers?        


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=159470

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.