ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



IDF soldier's dream to come true, after death

Posted: Thursday, January 18, 2007 10:15 AM
Filed Under:

In August 2002, 19-year-old Sergeant Kevin Cohen was guarding an Israeli settlement in the Gaza Strip. At 7 a.m. he was shot dead by a Palestinian sniper. It was that bullet that killed Kevin and his dream, which he had related to his mother, Rachel Cohen, of one day fathering a child.

But this week, four years after his death, a dramatic ruling by an Israeli court means Kevin Cohen’s dream may very well come true.

A ‘biological will’
After her son’s death, Cohen approached a non-profit organization called "New Family" which is dedicated to advancing family rights.

The organization is trying to convince people to write a "biological will," which in case of death would allow doctors to extract sperm from their bodies," explained Irit Rosenblum, the founder of "New Family" and Cohen’s lawyer.

It was a mother's instinct that led Cohen to request doctors to freeze her dead son’s sperm. Cohen said she had a dream one year after her son died.

"He appeared in my dream and asked me, mom what’s with my child? Please hurry," said Cohen. "I woke up with a big sweat and decided to go ahead, all the way."

Then came the legal battle, which was fought around the ruling permitting only the wife of a deceased man to extract his sperm and to become impregnated by it. The new ruling now recognizes the parent’s right over a dead child’s sperm.

Irit Rosenblum, left, founder of the Israeli non-profit organization “New Family,” and her client Rachel Cohen.

Battle won
Cohen’s cell phone rang with the good news just as she was laying flowers on her son's grave. "I was too nervous and frustrated with the court battle, I decided the best place to be was near Kevin’s grave," said Cohen.

Rosenblum called with the news that her dream of becoming a grandmother was going to come true. "The decision gave me great happiness but still the pain is so huge, I turned to the grave and told the good news to Kevin," said Cohen.

"The ruling represents a light at the end of the tunnel both for a family mourning the loss of a child, and also for a single woman wanting to bring a new life into this world," said Rosenblum.

An unusual appeal
During the course of the legal battle Cohen sent out an emotional appeal to the Israeli public for help. It was a strange request: Would a woman come forward and give birth to Cohen’s dead son's child?

The process of finding a mother for Kevin Cohen’s child took more than two years. Two hundred women were interviewed, medical tests were conducted, meetings with psychologists took place and finally one was chosen. "She won my heart right away," said Cohen.

The 35-year-old woman preferred not to be identified, but Cohen said, "There are a lot of women out there that really want to know the father’s identity, his background, to be able to tell the child who was his father."

Now Cohen is waiting for another phone call, for more good news, that maybe nine months from now she will become a grandmother. At last she will be able to look at her son’s picture and tell him he has a child.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

THAT IS SO STRANGE. HOPE YOU KNOW WHAT YOU ARE GETTING INTO WHAT IF YOU DO NOT LIVE TO SEE THE CHILD BORN WHAT HAPPENS NEXT?
Was he the last of his line? Will the family name die out with him? Now comes the question of whether or not to abort the child based on the sex the "mother/grandmother" wants. Let go and let God.
I totally disagree with this. It would have been different if he had a wife and was planning on having children. I think the mother is trying to get her son back any way that she can, and I can't blame her for that. There are plenty of kids in this world who could use a adoptive grandma.
Wow, I had no idea that sperm was still alive when somebody dies. However, I think this is absolutely twisted.
Why be so judgmental with a mother trying to complete the dream of her child? Her love didn't die when he did.
you are playing with god this is wrong
The dead son has a child, but the child has a dead father. That works out...?
I can symphathize with this mother's grief of losing a sibling, this is a sad situation indeed however, I do not feel she has the right to fulfill her own needs at the expense of a child.. Being a grandmother of 7 I am very fortunate. I hope she can heal and pray she has done the right thing.
Why can't people mind their own business? Who are you people to hold this woman in contempt?! You obviously have never given birth or know what it is to have dreams of watching your child grow up, attending that child's wedding and seeing your baby with their baby. To all of you who have posted comments of support for this woman, GOOD FOR YOU. To all of you who posted negative remarks, GET A LIFE! She doesn't need a grief counselor, she's not selfish, it's not creepy and it's not wrong. I've raised a child with no father...so freaking what?! Women have kids with no father EVERY DAY in this country. It's people like you that make this world such a terrible place!
I agree with the above. This woman is grief stricken beyond belief. That should be addressed. And my personal thoughts are that in nature: Dead mendon't father children. There is probably a reason for that and I don't think we should mess with that balance. Onthe other hand, if the soldier DID, in fact wish things this way, then I can see no alternative for his mother other than to try to carry out those last wishes. I have my doubts about this being his wishes, however and wonder more if they aren't her own
I think it is ultimatley the families decision on what happens to this mans sperm. Creepy? Maybe to some, but to bring another fatherless child into this world is just selfish and unnessasary. The mans dream of having a child was "his" dream, I dont think this is what he intended. This shouldnt even be an option. The mother needs grief counseling for sure.
WHAT IN THE WORLD!!??!! That is just creepy. If he had a widow that would be one thing, but the mother asking for sperm to create a grandchild with a person her son never knew? WEIRD PEOPLE OUT THERE.
This is sad, She is only being selfish. This is not God,s way. He said husband and wife come together and make a child, Yes this is religious that,s all that matter to chirstians.
Sick, sick, sick. There are lots of poeple that want to be grandpartents, but aren't. Thius is NOT the way to go. She has no real bond with the mother to be, and will have no bond with her "grandchild, should she prove to be a pain to the mother oif that child. She has no legal basis to be called grandmother.
This woman has to be insane! See a grief counselor and GET OVER IT LADY!
So who will raise the child, the mother or the grandmother? Is it wise for a grandmother to assume she will live long enough to raise a grandchild to adulthood? Is it fair to a child to not only not have a father figure but to be raised by a woman ... well... "old enough to be his grandmother"? What kind of emotional baggage does this situation put on the child's slender shoulders? Was ANY thought given to the child that would be born?
How bad do you want to mess up a childs life? Hi I'me little tommy, I have never seen my father because he died 5 years prior to my birth. My mother is from Israeli, and a lady that told me she is my grandmother is from America. This mother needs to give this whole process alot of thought after a few years of counseling.
Is anyone else worried about becoming Dr. Frankenstein?? When we have the capability to artificially create a humanbeing from the cells of another dead humanbeing, where do we draw the line? Is it okay for this woman to do it, but not okay for someone to father a child of say, Hitler or a serial killer. My thanks to the soldier for doing his duty, but at some point we changed the definition of the word DEAD!
Who is this mother to try and play God. If he wasn't meant to have a child in this life then that is how it should have been. This is very wrong and now she has to tell this child that his father is dead and he will never know him. This mother does need therapy and she is being very selfish. I strongly oppose of this. Who are we to play God? Everything happens for a reason. It was her sons time to go and that is how it should be. Yes it is tragic but to go to the extent she did is sick and wrong. She has mental issues that need to be looked at
Sick, sick, sick. There are lots of poeple that want to be grandparents, but aren't. This is NOT the way to go. She has no real bond with the mother to be, and will have no bond with her "grandchild, should she prove to be a pain to the mother oif that child. She has no legal basis to be called grandmother.
gigi: He was an Israeli soldier. He was not defending our country at all. Does that change your outlook? Only American soldiers are heroes right?
totally weird.... why would someone put a child through that? not having a father at all? umm yeah, creepy and weird! I wouldnt want that. Best of luck to them though... whatever floats their boat....
I think no one should knowingly become a single mom. I have 3 children who's father committed suicide and I know how much they go through without a father. They have to explain a lot to kids in school and things like that. It messes with kids heads and should be avoided. I know that grief does weird things to people but you have to grieve and move on and not live in the past.
I just cannot agree with this. A child should be concieved between two people who love each other and want to combine their genes and create a human being. This young man apparently wasn't married to anyone. How selfish of this woman to bring this child into this world just because her son had once stated that he wanted a child some day. Apparently it wasn't God's will that he have one or he would have found his mate and fathered a child before getting killed.
I do feel for this mother at the loss of her son, but this is so wrong. I can't even begin to think of how this will be explained to the child. What will she do if the mother she has chosen at some point cuts all ties with her and refuses to let her see the child. Where the bar fall legally? I agree with the writer above, this mother needs grief counselling. The pressure that is going to be on this child will be hard to live up to. Taking sperm from a dead child, 72 year old women having babies, it is beginning to get weird.
what rights will the carring mother have and what if the birthmother marries or wants nothing to do with the "grandmother"?
This woman is an idiot!
I pray God will give this woman peace over the loss of her son. She cannot bring him back with this potential grandchild. Her attempts might prove in vain if this woman cannot carry the child to term. There are no gaurantees in life. I'm so sorry for this womans loss and pray that she suffers no further loss in this heartbreaking situation.
Could this be any more bizarre? Perhaps she and Cindy Sheehan could get together and exploit their son's deaths to an even wider audience. That child will be in foster care within 9 months, after the mother's inevitible breakdown.
What happens when the grandma eventually dies? The child will be all alone in this world. How can this woman be so selfish in doing this? It's like saying, "Oh, I've always wanted a puppy, and then getting one, then you die and the puppy goes to the animal shelter." The outcome doesn't look so good.
So does this mean that every man who has ever donated sperm is a father, as well? What gives the grandmother the right to decide her son ought to be a father? A dream? Gee, that's reliable. Is this even healthy for the baby (biologically speaking...how long do sperm live after a body's death, and are they really safe to use, or is that baby at greater risk for genetic defects?)? Don't we already have overpopulation problems without dead parents having children too?
As long as there will be love for this child and a proper home why should it be viewed any different then any other IVF. The woman willing to have the child is still like every other woman willing to use IVF to have a child. The major difference in the story is that even with the death of Kevin Cohen all is not lost. There will be love for this child, what else matters more? His Mother now has a memory to be cherished! Good luck to all involved.
what happened to" you were concieved out of love " or" your mommy and daddy were married at the time of conception?" how sad for the child to be!! you know there is life after death, and when a loved one dies you will join him or her in heaven, but to bring and innocent child into this world out of selfishness, the child will feel the pain, now is grandma going to raise this child? or is the woman carrying the child going to keep the child, does grandmother get grandparent rights? what if grandmother doesnt like how the woman is caring for the child in the future? there are alot of pros and cons with this issue, is this actually how god intended for this to be? Is the knowledge he gave us to use in this manner? i agree with some of the responses above i think it is creepy and grandmother to be is being selfish and needs to seek grief counseling, and learn to deal with her loss,
I think that this went to far. I think that she is the one that wanted a child to replace hers. Her son did look forward to having a child and raising it. It is unfair that he didn't get that opportunity to do so. It is unfair that she didn't get to be a Grandmother and see a loving family. But to interview your perspective Mother of your Grandchild seems weird.
This is very sad. It is also a scary sign of what is becoming of the world. How sad to tell a child, "Your father is dead and your mother was the best applicant." Now, is that a heritage to be proud of?
If there is no documentation that her son wanted a child and wanted his sperm frozen in the event of his death, how do we know for sure he wanted his body treated this way when he died? I understand the mother's want to become a grandmother, but how do we know these are his wants and not hers?
i would find it awesome if the mother then takes the child to never be seen again by the stupid/obsessive grandmother.
I agree w/ the majority here--how selfish. She is forcing this child to grow up w/o his father. Good luck explaining that one to the child.
After this baby is born, will there be a custody battle? Does this give the grandmother rights over this child, which will cause more time in the courtroom??
How do you explain to a child that he was conceived AFTER his father's death? Is the donor mother going to be involved with child? How will they explain that? This is just going too far. I can't say that I understand the grief that the soon to be grandmother is going through, but wouldn't she think that playing God is not a good thing? This was his dream, not his mother's. His dream was to be a father. He can't be a father if he's deceased!!! What's wrong with this picture!!!
It was tragic and premature that she lost her son at so young an age, but the fact is that he died without ever fathering a child. Period. He is now gone, and with him went the chance for a grandchild. If an Israeli court recognizes a parent's right to an adult child's genetic material after death, does that now create the possibility for a future precedent whereby a parent could sue to force an adult child to produce a grandchild while that adult child was still living--but he/she did not want children? Do older parents now have the RIGHT to procure grandchildren? This case is all wrong, and was from the very beginning. I agree that this woman desperately needs a grief counselor to help her deal with the loss of her son and the grandchildren that were lost with him the day he died.
This Mom is emotionally unstable and in need of psychological help! This is just plain wrong and sick!!!!
Very scary and very selfish. What is this world comming to? I already feel bad for the kid who isnt even born yet. Lady, you need a shrink!
If she wants so badly to be a grandmother why not "interview" the thousands of children out there that don't have grandparents. It is very wrong to bring a child into the world by a women whom the father NEVER knew. Then to allow the child to be raised with only memories in the version of the grandmother. How selfish can a person be?? I have two brothers that are currently serving in the military and I have full respect for what Kevin did. I am very proud of him and his service to this wonderful country. I do feel sorry for him now to have his name smeared all over the country. Shame on you Mom.
As insane as this story is, I am surprised the mother didn't just impregnate herself with her son's sperm. Afterall, wouldn't that be a lot more meaningful. She is a little twisted.
Will the military end up taking care of this woman and the child because the father was in the military? What about social security benefits?
I work in Child Support and see way too many custody battles and children used as pawns in a relationship. What if this advertised "mom" takes off with this child and is never heard from again? Or what is she finds someone and decides to get married and her spouse adopts this child? Grandma needs help, real help. I feel for this child and the women involved on both ends of this arrangement.
If God had wanted him to be a father his life would have taken a different path. I totally disagree with this process, like the answer above, IT IS WAY TOO CREEPY.
I guess I have mixed feelings. I think that this mother is dealing with alot of grief and perhaps would benefit from a grief counselor. However, maybe she feels that she is doing what she believes her son would have wanted. None of us were there when her son stated to her that he one day would like to father a child. Perhaps, their was alot of emotions tied to how he said it making her think that this would be waht he wanted.
THIS IS A TOUGH ONE. TO BRING A CHILD INTO THE WORLD ALREADY KNOWING THEY WILL NEVER MEET THEIR FATHER SEEMS UNFAIR TO THE CHILD BUT AT THE SAME TIME HAVING A PART OF YOUR CHILD WITH YOU AGAIN WOULD BE AWESOME. ESPECIALLY BECAUSE OF THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF HIS DEATH. GOOD LUCK TO YOU .


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=33735

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.