ABOUT WORLD BLOG

NBC News World Blog aims to provide a dynamic look at world events and trends -- both big and small -- from NBC News correspondents, producers, and bureaus around the world. Online entries -- from text to video -- will explore news events and how they are shaping our world.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the world and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind NBC News World Blog.



IDF soldier's dream to come true, after death

Posted: Thursday, January 18, 2007 10:15 AM
Filed Under:

In August 2002, 19-year-old Sergeant Kevin Cohen was guarding an Israeli settlement in the Gaza Strip. At 7 a.m. he was shot dead by a Palestinian sniper. It was that bullet that killed Kevin and his dream, which he had related to his mother, Rachel Cohen, of one day fathering a child.

But this week, four years after his death, a dramatic ruling by an Israeli court means Kevin Cohen’s dream may very well come true.

A ‘biological will’
After her son’s death, Cohen approached a non-profit organization called "New Family" which is dedicated to advancing family rights.

The organization is trying to convince people to write a "biological will," which in case of death would allow doctors to extract sperm from their bodies," explained Irit Rosenblum, the founder of "New Family" and Cohen’s lawyer.

It was a mother's instinct that led Cohen to request doctors to freeze her dead son’s sperm. Cohen said she had a dream one year after her son died.

"He appeared in my dream and asked me, mom what’s with my child? Please hurry," said Cohen. "I woke up with a big sweat and decided to go ahead, all the way."

Then came the legal battle, which was fought around the ruling permitting only the wife of a deceased man to extract his sperm and to become impregnated by it. The new ruling now recognizes the parent’s right over a dead child’s sperm.

Irit Rosenblum, left, founder of the Israeli non-profit organization “New Family,” and her client Rachel Cohen.

Battle won
Cohen’s cell phone rang with the good news just as she was laying flowers on her son's grave. "I was too nervous and frustrated with the court battle, I decided the best place to be was near Kevin’s grave," said Cohen.

Rosenblum called with the news that her dream of becoming a grandmother was going to come true. "The decision gave me great happiness but still the pain is so huge, I turned to the grave and told the good news to Kevin," said Cohen.

"The ruling represents a light at the end of the tunnel both for a family mourning the loss of a child, and also for a single woman wanting to bring a new life into this world," said Rosenblum.

An unusual appeal
During the course of the legal battle Cohen sent out an emotional appeal to the Israeli public for help. It was a strange request: Would a woman come forward and give birth to Cohen’s dead son's child?

The process of finding a mother for Kevin Cohen’s child took more than two years. Two hundred women were interviewed, medical tests were conducted, meetings with psychologists took place and finally one was chosen. "She won my heart right away," said Cohen.

The 35-year-old woman preferred not to be identified, but Cohen said, "There are a lot of women out there that really want to know the father’s identity, his background, to be able to tell the child who was his father."

Now Cohen is waiting for another phone call, for more good news, that maybe nine months from now she will become a grandmother. At last she will be able to look at her son’s picture and tell him he has a child.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I think some people don't know hoe to let go. her son wanted a child when he was ALIVE to see him/her grow. She is creating an ORPHAN!!! You can be raised by grandparents, as I was. but you still an orphan.
I think some people don't know hoe to let go. her son wanted a child when he was ALIVE to see him/her grow. She is creating an ORPHAN!!! You can be raised by grandparents, as I was. but you still an orphan.
". . . finely one was chosen"? I think you mean "finally, one was chosen." Perhaps you could use an editor. I'm available, but not cheap. Gary A. Markette --Wordslinger "More than 30 years of quality technical documentation." *************************************** Like detective stories? Read my blog at http://wordslinger01.spaces.live.com/
This woman doesn't need a grandchild, she needs a grief counselor.
How absolutely creepy.
I THINK THIS IS WONDERFUL AND SO SAD THAT THE MOTHER OF A SON SHE WISHED TO HONOR, HAD TO GO THROUGH SO MUCH. THIS IS A PLACE WHERE THE COURTS SHOULDN'T BE INVOLVED,THEY HAVE BETTER THINGS TO DO THAN FIGHT OVER SPERM. THEN AGAIN MAYBE THIS IS A RELIGIOUS THING, I DON'T KNOW. THANK GOD NOW A SON, A MOTHER AND GRANDMOTHER WILL FINALLY COME TO BE.
what purpose does doing this serve? it sounds pretty selfish to me.
So she can tell a picture of her son that he has a child but then she has to tell the child he has no father. And this is right? To me, it's very, very wrong.
I think this is a wonderful result for this poor boys mother. There should have been no reason for this mother to have to fight this in court as her son was defending our country.
This kind of stuff is just wacky. Heavy on the sarcasm, but what's next? A guy having a couple of extra arms sewn on so he can do more at once? Race horses with extra legs so that they can run extra fast? Things should be kept as natural as possible. To go to lengths like this mother/grandmother is getting pretty "out there". I guess I'm kind of happy for her but mostly shocked at the lengths people will go to to avoid a hardship. Then again...if they're a cure or a chance to save someone's life, let's do it. This is a tough one, isn't it?
This is just wrong. To bring a child into this world after the death of the father is placing an un due burden and grief upon an innocent child who will NEVER know its father. It is just plain selfish of the woamn to want to do this.
I understand the heart of a woman, who wants to be a grandmother, my daughter has been married for 9 yrs. and is having trouble conceiving. BUT, isn't there a point when we go to far, trying to be God, to do what only God should do? If my daughter never got pregnant, it would be ok. I understand that this lady doesn't have the privilege of her son being there, but, hopefully she does have great memories.
God bless and good luck. You deserve to be a grandmother and I send all my condolences for you loss of your son, and send all the luck in your future as a grandma!!!!
This is very interesting. I can see where the grandparents are coming from, but then I think of the child & he/she will purposelly never know their father. Hearing stories & living through other peoples memories is not the same as having that person there in the flesh. Also, just because the grandparents pick a certain woman to finish the process does not mean that the son would have chosen that woman. But, good luck to the people who chose to go this route.
Seriously--not only is it wrong since the son is dead, and has been for 4 years, but how do you explain that to the child: "You were born because I froze my son's sperm after his death, then advertised for a woman to carry and deliver you." I know that losing a relative is very difficult, and a child would be the most difficult, but using your dead son's sperm to conceive a grandchild is wrong. Also, how is a parent entitled to the sperm of their child. I own my sperm, not my mother--that would just be weird. Medical science has overtaken nature.
I hope for a happy ending for Mrs. Cohen 9 months from now. A grandchild should provide some comfort to her that, after a fashion, her son still lives on.
This is the strangest thing I've ever heard. Part of me thinks this is really very selfish when so many wait to be adopted. There is another part of me though, and that part is the one that knows that there is a vial of sperm frozen in a clinic belonging to my partner who has cancer. Just this morning I was wondering if I would use any of that sperm if he were to pass away. He signed the paperwork making the sperm mine if he does pass away so legally I could get pregnant. I'm not against single parents, I was a single mother for 6 years and I know children can be healthy and very well adjusted with just one parent. I think the strangest part of this story is that it's the mother of the son wanting the grandchild so badly that she has sperm harvested from her dead son. It makes me uncomfortable, but at the same time, I would do anything to make my son's wishes come true too. But how do we really know it was her son's wishes? I think about how many times my mom says things about me that are so wrong. I wonder if she even knows who I am sometimes. I think it's a tough call and those commenting should just remember both sides of this issue.
I'm reading this at work and I am so overwelmed by this mothers love of her son. I will pray for a healthy and happy grandchild for her as I am a grnadmother of two. I would also think tht I would do the same thing if this happened to me. GOD BLESS.
What happen to love? Is there not enough fatherless children in the world already? Being a father and being a sperm donor are two different things altogether.
Grammar Check. Lots of errors near the end, not necessarily a good thing to see from an NBC Producer.
This has to be one of the weirdest things I've ever read. I sympathize with this woman who has lost her son but I think she has gone too far. It seems as though she is trying to replace her son with a grandchild. And now, another child will have to grow up without a father.
This is not a case of the son wanting a child. It is a mother who cannot let go of her deceased child. The man was 19 yrs old and may have stated he would one day like a child but I doubt that he would've wanted the unreasonable measures taken to ensure that there would one day be another Fatherless child in the world. The deceased man's mother needs professional help.
Ok now that's creepy. And not far to the child. The child will be confused. His/Her father passed four to five years before His/Her birth. I think that is very selfish of the mother of the young man. And I am truely sorry for her loss and thank her son for his service. My heart feels for her.
After this baby is born, will there be a custody battle? Does this give the grandmother rights over this child, which will cause more time in the courtroom??
There are already too many people on this earth........I think she's crazy and so are the Israeli courts. Just idiots.
its cool!
That's alot to handle for a child that isn't born yet. Where is the protection for the childs rights?
Sure, and now there will be yet another boy raised without a father with all the "issues" that go with it.
Where is the consent from the actual father? He didn't consent to having his sperm extracted for this use, nor to the choice of mother for his unborn child. Creepy.
Will the son's mother be a part of the grandchild's life. Or is the woman free to raise the child on her own as in the case of anonymous donations. Basically the mother is looking for a daughter in law for her dead son.......cause that is what would have to happen in order for the grandmother to see her son's child.
There are so many children in this world without any parents at all. I think adoption would be a better way to give a grandchild to this woman.
VERY TOUCHY AND BRAVE WOMAN,IN MY CASE I WILL DO THE SAME TO PRESERVE THAT WISH.NEVER COME TO THIS CLOSE ABOUT THIS ONE.
There are already too many people on this earth........I think she's crazy and so are the Israeli courts. Just idiots.
This is beyond creepy. I am surprised she didn't decide to be impregnated by her son's sperm. How can a 19-year old wish to continue his legacy with a child? This is all the mother's decision and will. She just wants a semi-clone of her son. Poor soldier just had his privates vandalized after an honorable death to extract the sperm for his mother. I cannot imagine saying to my mother - "Mom, if something happens to me, please extract my eggs and hatch them as you deem feasible." Very disturbing.
I don't think we should change the course of nature. If we are suppose to have children, it will happen in our lifetime. God has his plan for all of us, with or without children.
This is so bad...absolutely unthinkable. It is as bad as the people who clone their pets. Aren't there enough children in the world already who are waiting for adoption?
This is SO stupid; I can't believe that a court of ANY kind would allow this to happen; where do we draw the line for ethics?
wow how freakish is it to have a dead man s sperm used to inseminat a embryo. we are a desprate sick cruel unusal society bent on our own self serving in dulgences
I think this is just weird.
I admit it is a little weird, but who are we to judge? And for all the comments about the child not having a father, that's just rubbish. How many kids in the world don't have a mother/father? Woman go to sperm banks and fertility clinics all the time. Plus, there are kids who have parents who aren't worth a crap, at least this kid will have a grandmother who cherishes he or she.
Creepy. I could understand a wife wanting to but a mother? Who would ever volunteer for the job of carrying that child. Yuck.
I think that's just plain weird. Only in Israel, could something so bizare happen. Maybe if he wasn't guarding an illegal settlement on occupied land, he could've lived and fathered a child like normal human beings
This is absolutely disgusting. If one of my daughters were to pass away, I wouldn't harvest their ovaries for eggs. This brings up other issues such as child support, custody, death benefits -- will the child be entitled since the father was dead years before the child was born? As a Mother, I would not do this. It's immoral, perverse and unethical. This woman clearly needs mental & grief counseling...This should have been the courts verdict.
He "supposedly" told his mother that he wanted to have a child. I am sure he mentioned it in conversation but did not say "if I die, extract my sperm and make me a daddy" I think mom needs emotional help with the loss. Poor child that may be born from this.
Maybe I'm just being closed minded, but this is one of the most ridiculous things I've heard. I am all for people's wishes being carried out after their passing, but a child? I would imagine that the man wanted a child to raise, love, and be a part of his/her life. All that this process does is have him be involved in the conceivement of the child, only the physical. Why doesn't the mother (grandmother to be) adopt a child in his memory instead? Just my opinion, for what it's worth.
So this child will be born in Israel?? Will she get to see her grandchild??? If I am incorrect on this and they will be living in America, will this child get social security for their dead parent? It would seem ok if it were the mans wife and they had discussed this prior, but this sounds like a classic case of some one needing to cut the umbilical cord to mommy.. how sad for this child!!!
Sounds like a good start to a plot of a Van Damme movie or something.Next the kids grows up and gets revenge 25 years later for his father's death....
I agree with Sara B. and Esme. The whole situation is very sad, and totally creepy. I think children deserve to have two parents. If it was so important to him to have a child, he should have found a woman to do that with while he was alive. I think there are a lot of questions beyond who has control of biological/reproductive fluids of a dead person. Does the "finely" chosen woman get to keep the baby and raise it by herself, or does the grandmother have plans to raise the baby by herself? What kind of therapy are does this kid have in his/her future? Why do all weird stories about dead people involve a family member and a dream? It's a little too Sylvia Brown for me.
I have 3 children and those children need me to be there as a Dad. Bringing a child into the world without a father is downright wrong. This woman is being extremely selfish in denying this future child a patriarchial figure. She is treating the child as a object or an objective in and of itself and not like the divine child of God he or she would be.
This is absolutely disturbing.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=33735

Syndicate This Site

Add World Blog to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

Interactive

Fight for Iraq
Learn more about the ethnic, religious and political power plays in and around Iraq during a briefing of the region led by NBC’s Richard Engel.